Should Intelligent Design be taught in Public School - Assignment Example

Summary

The people who support ID stipulate that it should be treated as an alternative to the field of evolution. The people who support this concept are normally members of the Discovery Institute…

Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing

GRAB THE BEST PAPER96% of users find it useful

Should Intelligent Design be taught in Public School

Read Text Preview

Subject: Philosophy
Type: Assignment
Level: High School
Pages: 1 (250 words)
Downloads: 2
Author: mmckenzie

Extract of sample "Should Intelligent Design be taught in Public School"

Intelligent Design Intelligent Design (ID) is an argument regarding the existence of a creator on earth. The people who support ID stipulate that it should be treated as an alternative to the field of evolution. The people who support this concept are normally members of the Discovery Institute. However, the scientific community stipulates that ID cannot be regarded as a science. In this case, the US National Academy of Sciences stipulates that ID is not a science and it should therefore not be taught in schools.

This body stipulates that ID does not generate any hypothesis which can be tested by any experiments. Moreover, ID does not provide a basis whereby its claims can be tested. Since ID does not know how something works, it usually associates it with a higher power (Goodman, n.d). Therefore, if schools adopt ID as a science, then the children who are in schools today would not be adequately prepared to handle fields such as medicine or biology. There is a major controversy surrounding the teaching of ID in schools.

For example, in 2005, a school in Pennsylvania was sued because it allowed its students to present ID as an alternative to creation as well as in explaining how life came to be. Research reveals that ID normally violates the rules of science that are centuries old. For example, ID invokes supernatural connection and it also attacks evolution negatively. As a result, ID has been entirely disproved by the scientific community (Ruse, 2012). In this perspective therefore, scientific experts argue that if ID is to be taught in schools, it should be taught in fields such as philosophy, religion and politics (Goodman, n.d). However, it should not be taught in any science course.

This is because it would confuse the students especially regarding the various scientific concepts that are normally applied in biology and medicine. ReferencesGoodman, R. (n.d). Should Inteligent Education be Taught in Schools? Retrieved from http://eeb.bio.utk.edu/darwin/images/Handout_ID_in_schools.pdfRuse, M. (2012). Keep Intelligent Design Out of Science Classes. Retrieved from http://www.beliefnet.com/News/Science-Religion/2005/08/Keep-Intelligent-Design-Out-Of-Science-Classes.aspx#

Cite this document

APA
MLA
CHICAGO

(“Should Intelligent Design be taught in Public School Assignment”, n.d.)
Should Intelligent Design be taught in Public School Assignment. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1615223-should-intelligent-design-be-taught-in-public-school

(Should Intelligent Design Be Taught in Public School Assignment)
Should Intelligent Design Be Taught in Public School Assignment. https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1615223-should-intelligent-design-be-taught-in-public-school.

“Should Intelligent Design Be Taught in Public School Assignment”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1615223-should-intelligent-design-be-taught-in-public-school.

Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Should Intelligent Design be taught in Public School

Intelligent Design and Natural Selection

Dennett recounts that there are plenty of scientific controversies that are not yet in public knowledge as the scientists and biologists are first trying to get acceptance from their peers.... intelligent design (ID) according to Dennett is not a legitimate… The proponents of ID assert that the process of evolution and features of the living things can be explained through intelligence cause and not through the process of natural selection.... intelligent design (ID) according to Dennett is not a legitimate school of thought as it fails to explain what it seeks to explain....

2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Should Evolution Be Taught In Public Schools

Teaching the creation story in public schools only serves to fulfill the role of defending particular religious beliefs.... If kids are to be taught, it is exclusively the responsibility of the church and parents because teaching the religious stories including creation in public schools violates constitutional principle.... Teaching the creation story in public schools only serves to fulfill the role of defending particular religious beliefs....

7 Pages (1750 words) Essay

Should Evolution Be Taught in the Public Schools

The theory of evolution, which states that species have evolved over time, is a theory which must be taught in public schools.... They feel that evolutionary theory would undermine their While both sides have valid arguments, the argument for teaching evolution in public schools clearly trumps, because parents have a right to ensure that their child gets the best education possible, and a failure to instruct on evolutionary theory in the public schools clearly undermines this basic right....

10 Pages (2500 words) Essay

Art And Design And The Acquisition Of Knowledge In Other Subjects

The paper "Art And design And The Acquisition Of Knowledge In Other Subjects" explores the effectiveness of art and design in teaching other subjects, in schools.... The introduction of art and design culture in the education system is one of President Obama's proposals for the transformation of the U.... This paper explores the effectiveness of art and design in teaching other subjects, in schools.... education system should enhance the ability of students to think creatively through meaningful arts education (Seidel 2005, P....

8 Pages (2000 words) Essay

Religion and Spirituality

Constitution including their own religious belief of creation, but it forbids these suppositions to be taught in public school science courses.... It analyses attempts to establish religious beliefs into public school systems which would certainly cause some teachers and students to be offended and, although Christianity is the predominant religion in the U.... This essay discusses religious beliefs in public schools.... hellip; If creation is to be taught, it is solely the responsibility of parents and the church because teaching the religious theories of creation in schools not only violates constitutional precepts, it also has the unintended effect of damaging the integrity of the religious point of view....

5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Creation versus Evolution

rofessor Morreale of Walden University once said in the class, “If too many people are involved in public policymaking, it will create tremendous trouble to the government.... The teaching of God is banned from school because people cannot comprehend God.... Many consider the public policy as individual interests (Denhardt, Denhardt & Aristigueta, 2002).... Each person is eager to promote his or her interests because they thought it was public policy....

5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

The Teaching of Creation in Public Schools Underling Religious Beliefs

The First Amendment begins with “Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof…”… The teaching of creation in public schools simply fulfils the purpose of protecting specific underlying religious beliefs.... If creation is to be taught, it is solely the responsibility of parents and the church because teaching the religious theories of creation in schools not only violates constitutional precepts....

7 Pages (1750 words) Research Paper

Why Evolution should be Taught in Schools

This work called "Why Evolution should be taught in Schools" describes evolution as a key Biological theory that seeks to explain the origin of man.... Hence, from these concepts of evolution, this essay seeks to argue in support of the thesis that evolution should be taught in schools.... This is one reason why it should be taught in schools.... Hence, if evolution is proven by fossils, it gives and avails a reason as to why it should be taught in schools because it is n not only alleged but also supported by material evidence (Neuman, First Land – Walking Fish Looks Like It Had 'All – Wheel Drive')....

14 Pages (3500 words) Essay