Nobody downloaded yet

Comparative Analysis of John Rawls Justice as Fairness and Irving Kristols A Capitalist Conception of Justice - Essay Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
The purpose of this essay analyzes two articles of writers John Rawls and Irving Kristol and to measure their strengths and weaknesses. Both John Rawls and Irving Kristol employ reason and common sense in arriving solution for the problem of social injustices…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER97.9% of users find it useful
Comparative Analysis of John Rawls Justice as Fairness and Irving Kristols A Capitalist Conception of Justice
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "Comparative Analysis of John Rawls Justice as Fairness and Irving Kristols A Capitalist Conception of Justice"

Download file to see previous pages The flaw with this argument is that an individual gets economically rewarded for those attributes of his personality that he did not cultivate, evolve or learn of his own industry and enterprise. In other words, talents in rendering music, mathematical ability and good looks, etc are to a large extent genetically determined. So what we see here is a subtle form of Eugenics. There are also shades of Social Darwinism attached to Kristol’s hypothesis, wherein the capitalist system will eliminate those individuals who are unable to contribute to the economy. It is also impetuous of Kristol to state that “luck” is a valid determinant of human dignity. To imply that the indignation suffered by those living in absolute poverty is a matter of bad fortune while the luxuries enjoyed by the rich minority are attributable to an element of good luck is too simplistic an argument to make. In making a comparison between “social justice” and “capitalism” Kristol mentions how capitalism is neither egalitarian nor authoritarian. One gets an impression that there is no virtue in aspiring for an egalitarian society and that authoritarianism is inherently defective. Both the conceptions are false. Secondly, authoritarianism is not a decadent concept as the author would have us believe. There are objections to this line of argument. First of all, isn’t it a universal principle of justice and decency that no section of humanity should be living in absolute poverty? ...Download file to see next pagesRead More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
(“Comparative Analysis of John Rawls Justice as Fairness and Irving Essay - 15”, n.d.)
Retrieved from
(Comparative Analysis of John Rawls Justice As Fairness and Irving Essay - 15)
“Comparative Analysis of John Rawls Justice As Fairness and Irving Essay - 15”, n.d.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Comparative Analysis of John Rawls Justice as Fairness and Irving Kristols A Capitalist Conception of Justice

John Rawls: A Theory of Justice

...If you were one of the people given the job of designing a "conception of Justice" for a society in which you would choose to live, what would you expect of that society in terms of fairness and justice? Can you possibly construct an ideal society without factoring in your own special circumstances, such as your gender, race, ethnicity, social status, level of privilege, of level of education? Rawls wants to factor those issues out of the process. Can you do that? Can anyone? If not, can any system of justice be fair? Given the rare privilege of designing a “conception of justice”, I...
2 Pages(500 words)Term Paper

The Conception of International Justice utilization of the social contract. This theory results in the formation of another theory known as Justice as Fairness, which deals with the difference principle and liberty principle (Freeman 2007, p. 10). Justice as Fairness is John Rawls’ political conception of justice. It encompasses two main principles of Equality and Liberty (Rawls 2001, p. 73). The principle of Equality is further divided into the Difference Principle and Fair Equality of Opportunity. He organized them in a prioritizing order as from the Liberty Principle to Fair Equality of...
7 Pages(1750 words)Essay

In A Theory of Justice, John Rawls

...?A Theory of Justice The nature of justice has been considered since at least Greek antiquity. Philosophers such as Plato and Aristotle contributed significantly to this area of investigation. Throughout the centuries other thinkers have added insights. Notably, John Stuart Mille advanced the notion of utilitarianism where the proper approach is to advance one’s happiness, while refraining from doing harm. Emmanuel Kant considered the categorical imperative wherein one should only engage in actions as long as they could be extended to all members of society. John Rawls, in his Theory of Justice, proposed the idea of the veil of ignorance....
6 Pages(1500 words)Essay

Critically evaluate John Rawls claim in political liberalism to justify Justice as Fairness as a political conception

...?RawlsJustice as Fairness: A Political Conception Introduction Questions germane to issues of justice, human nature, and the political have longbeen part of the ongoing discourse pertinent to understanding human predicament (Barak, 2012). In modern society, there is a seeming consensus that pluralism is an integral characterization of modern democracy (Gaus, 1999; Gutmann, 1994; Lehning 1998). This characterization re-enforces two ideologies that are commonly connected with each other and yet different from one another – democracy and liberalism (Baier 1989). It appears that the factor connecting these two ideologies is the similarity in which the nature of the human person is ascertained. In liberalism, the individual... . The second part...
19 Pages(4750 words)Term Paper

Rawls A theory of Justice

...Rawl's, A theory of Justice Equality of opportunity provides individuals to compete against each other on equivalent terms to achieve their place in a social setup. Compared to caste system where the assumption is that society contains hierarchy, and superior and inferior status is determined by birth, equality of opportunity is a unique theory, which promises competition on equal terms. Rawls's in his book A Theory of Justice has constructed a hypothetical theory which is system based on equality that he calls "Justice as Fairness". Rawls's social theory discusses the role of institutions in a society,...
5 Pages(1250 words)Essay

Conception of Justice it might be the selection of place, type of business or business strategy and if you did a little mistake in making right decisions you have to face loss no matter whatever business you are running .if you opened a sweat shop in a place where people are unable to buy it because of poor living standard then what And if you opened the shop and are unable to fill it with quality products then how would it be successful So for me Ciulla's theory is much better then the second one. Just opening a sweat shop doesn't assure that it will be good for you References Irving Kristol, "A capitalist conception of justice," from DeGeorge and Pichler,...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay

Rawls Theory of Justice

...John Rawls was an American philosopher (February 21, 1921 - November 24, 2002), he wrote one of the most famous books in the 1971 also it widely reading of political philosopher and this book is a Theory of justices in this book Rawls tries to address the real meaning of distributive justice through the classical philosopher model of social contract and other philosopher tries to do this is Kant. However, Rawls in concept of distributive justice goes further in hypothesizing the justice theory under the justice as fairness. The justice as fairness has two principle to drive the following Rawlsian principles of justice the first one is that the liberty principle and the second is the difference principle. Furthermore, in the theory... of...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay

John Rawls' Theory of Justice

...& Number: John Rawls Theory of Justice (Moral Decision Making) 10 August (word count - 334) John Rawls had his theory of justice based on the concept of a social contract. Social contract is an intellectual or philosophical construct in which originally free individuals agree to give up some of their natural rights in favor of a social system or a political organization. It will help the individuals being governed to live in a society that is bound by common laws for the protection and benefit of each individual. Each individual therefore agrees to be bound by commonly-accepted rules and conventions in the society in...
1 Pages(250 words)Essay

Comparative criminal justice

...Comparative Criminal Justice Corruption continues to be a serious crime that affects several countries in the world. However, since Transparency International started ranking countries using corruption perception index, the rate of crimes has decreased considerably. However, countries facing persistent poverty, political volatility, as well as high crime rates continue to portray high rates of corruption. The Transparency International uses Corruption Perception Index, which communicates the rate of corruption as perceived by businesspersons as well analysts in a country. In the 2007, Denmark, Bolivia, and Myanmar the countries whose crime rates will be compared in this paper were ranked at position 1, 105, and 179 respectively... . The...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

Comparative Justice

...Comparative Justice of the Law of the Concerned June 22, Comparative Law In a strictly Western context, law means aformal codification of the essential values, mores and expectations of a society. Yet, in a catholic context, this definition of law happens to be apt for all the societies, are they affiliated to any legal system. All legal systems tend to use the tool of law to shape, regulate and discipline their respective societies in consonance with the values and ethics that are sacrosanct and dear to them. In that context there are many similarities and differences between the Islamic law and the US legal system If one tries to delve into the basis of the US legal system, it becomes...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Essay on topic Comparative Analysis of John Rawls Justice as Fairness and Irving Kristols A Capitalist Conception of Justice for FREE!

Contact Us