Nobody downloaded yet

Comparison of the Scientific Philosophies of Kuhn, Duhen and Lauden - Essay Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
Summary
Name Class Teacher Date Comparison of the scientific philosophies of Kuhn, Duhem and Lauden Thomas Kuhn, Pierre Duhem, and Larry Lauden each contributed valuable information regarding the philosophy of science and the issues which beleaguer it. Foremost for all of them was the question: How can scientific process be more accurate?…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER97.2% of users find it useful
Comparison of the Scientific Philosophies of Kuhn, Duhen and Lauden
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "Comparison of the Scientific Philosophies of Kuhn, Duhen and Lauden"

Download file to see previous pages Therefore, his philosophy will be examined first. Duhem posits that “hypotheses are not straightforwardly refuted by experiment and that there are no crucial experiments in science.” (Wikipedia, 10/19/11) This means that a hypothesis cannot be directly disproved by being part of an experiment. There are several possible reasons which support this theory. First, Duhem works on the presumption that experiments are conducted by humans, who are fallible. Therefore, the results they produce will not be perfect. This means that experiments in science are inherently flawed, which devalues the results of said experiments. Duhem would go on to set the stage for the theories of Kuhn and Lauden, because Duhem presents the idea that hypothesis, experiment, and fact are not inextricably linked. Kuhn and Lauden dig deeper to consider the reasons why. Thomas Kuhn makes the point that “science has included bodies of belief quite incompatible with the ones we hold today.” (Kuhn, 238) The premise here is that one generation’s science is another generation’s bunk. Certainly, history is full of examples of past beliefs which have fallen out of fashion with the advent of scientific knowledge and the technology which helps to uncover it. For example, scientific beliefs since the time of the Egyptians have changed irrevocably over the centuries, but Kuhn’s point is that at the time those discoveries were made, they were the newest (and therefore most valid) sources of scientific information. Kuhn further posits that what scientists and scientific historians should be concerning themselves with is to “ask new sorts of questions and to trace different, and often less than cumulative, developmental lines for the sciences. Rather than seeking the permanent contributions of an older science to our present vantage, they [should] attempt to display the historical integrity of that science in its own time.” (Kuhn, 238) By contrast, Larry Laudan challenges us to re-consider the entire purpose of science. He believes it is “to ask…whether science through time brings us closer to achieving our cognitive aims or goals.” (Laudan, 145) Does scientific knowledge bring us closer to those? Laudan presents a valuable point, which is that “principals of testing, comparison, and evaluation of theories seem to vary significantly from level to level.” (Laudan, 144) This seems to say that there are a number of variables present which cannot be reconciled from level to level or from scientist to scientist. These variables can manifest themselves as simply as the fact that all people interpret results slightly differently. Take, for example, a doctor who views a patient’s X-ray on which there is evidence of carcinoma. A general practitioner would have a different interpretation of this than would a pulmonary specialist. They both see cancer, but only the pulmonary physician can properly assess which treatments would be most appropriate in attempting to eradicate the cancer. Now, suppose the patient can only afford to see his general practitioner because that is all his insurance will pay for – he never gets to see the lung specialist, and is relying entirely on the scientific opinion of only one scientist to assess his chances of survival. This is only one example of the flaw in scientific method: suppose the pulmonary physician was more well-read on the latest techniques of eradicating lung carcinoma, and the general ...Download file to see next pagesRead More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Comparison of the Scientific Philosophies of Kuhn, Duhen and Lauden Essay”, n.d.)
Comparison of the Scientific Philosophies of Kuhn, Duhen and Lauden Essay. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1434123-philosophy-of-science
(Comparison of the Scientific Philosophies of Kuhn, Duhen and Lauden Essay)
Comparison of the Scientific Philosophies of Kuhn, Duhen and Lauden Essay. https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1434123-philosophy-of-science.
“Comparison of the Scientific Philosophies of Kuhn, Duhen and Lauden Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1434123-philosophy-of-science.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Comparison of the Scientific Philosophies of Kuhn, Duhen and Lauden

Thomas Kuhn`s Pradigm theory

...?Key words: paradigm, incommensurability, normal science, digital, surveying and mapping This paper describes Thomas Kuhn’s Paradigm theory and the existence of paradigm shifts in scientific disciplines, resulting from technological and theoretical advancements. Thomas Kuhn introduced the concept of incommensurability and paradigm changes in the philosophy of science. A paradigm is described as a pattern or model, and a paradigm shift occurs when there are changes in the old paradigm, bringing in a new paradigm. Kuhn states that the evolution of paradigms in scientific disciplines occurs in patterns or cycles, beginning with a prescience period, followed by a period of crisis, then a scientific revolution and then the development... of...
11 Pages(2750 words)Essay

Marketing Environment

8 Pages(2000 words)Essay

Comparison of Quality Philosophies

...?Comparison of Quality Philosophies Dimension Deming Juran Crosby PMI Quality Definition Fulfilling expectations ‘Fitness for use’ of the end product Conformance to requirements Conformance to requirements Quality System Produce qualitative products, do not rely on inspections Improving communication, adapting to new technology and enhancing accountability Improve attention and knowledge to minimize errors Prevention Performance Standard Substitute management based on numerical assessment of goals Relative effects of individual tasks in the overall process Zero Defects Zero Defects Quality Measure Productivity per unit cost Identify most effective tasks through pareto analysis Cost of non-conformance Cost...
3 Pages(750 words)Research Paper

Comparison of Quality Philosophies

...? Comparison of Quality Philosophies Comparison of Quality Philosophies Introduction Modern management environment is faced with numerous challenges and expectations due to increased competition, competition, customers’ and shareholders’ expectations and rapid technological advancements (Rose, 2005). Quality management has emerged as one of the approaches that are able to help management of any organization navigate through the challenges and attain organizational objectives and goals. Quality management is an organization approach that seeks to precisely understand what customers need and to consistently deliver accurate solutions on time, and within budget and in a way...
3 Pages(750 words)Research Paper

Educational Philosophies

...? Education models and their impacts in lives al Affiliation Since its invention by Greeks many years ago, education remains to be the most fundamental tool and aspect in life. Success in education is like a key to a better life. Every human being strives to be successful by pursuing education to the top ranked institutions. However, education is a journey faced with a handle of challenges that begin from childhood exodus in school all the way to tertiary institutions or universities. It’s a process that requires good parental support and financial stability. Systems of education vary in many parts of the world and they keep changing with the trends as the world advances at a very high speed. People have reevaluated the old ways... Education...
3 Pages(750 words)Article

Philosophy: The Structure of Scientific Revolutions by Thomas S. Kuhn

...Kuhn’s scientific revolutions According to Kuhn, scientific development constitutes a piecemeal process whereby scientific methods as described through observations, laws and theories have been added, either singly or in combination to the growing stockpile that constitutes scientific technique and knowledge (Kuhn 2). But with the development of additional research, many earlier conclusions are being questioned. Kuhn is of the view that science is based upon the assumption that the scientific community knows what the world is like and is also prepared to defend those assumptions. Some of...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay

The Structure of Scientific Revolution (Kuhn) and Varieties of Religious Experience: (James): An Analytical Review

.... This is a very fundamental concept which has shaped the way science has been understood ever since this book came out. Sankey, remarking on Kuhn’s contribution, says that post-Kuhn, science is viewed to be a “developing process” which is undergone and practiced by society, adding, reworking and discarding ideas in light of “shifting historical and social circumstances” (821). Kuhn is of the opinion that science works on a very ‘dynamic model’ where “relatively long periods of stability, dominated by one theory, alternate with short periods of so-called scientific revolutions, dominated by free competition among theories” (Spariosu 305). Kuhn gives a...
5 Pages(1250 words)Essay

Thomas Kuhn The Structure of Scientific Revolutions

...Thomas Kuhn: The Structure of Scientific Revolutions Thomas Kuhn: The Structure of Scientific Revolutions Introduction Kuhn’s philosophy of science derives inspiration from the history of science and pursues to describe how science develops. Kuhn asserts that an immature science is that which is yet to attain a paradigm. An immature science progresses to mature science with the adoption of its first paradigm. Stage two details the process of normal science comprising processes directed by, and essential for, maintaining scientific paradigms. Scientific revolutions are in direct conflict with normal science and emanate from some crisis amid the scientific field. Pre-Paradigm Stage The first stage, “pre-paradigm science,” details... ...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay

A comparison between western and east Asian philosophies

...Teacher Law and Justice: A Comparison Between Western and East Asian Philosophies Throughout human civilization, cultures have largely dealt with issues of law and justice in various ways. Some resort to strict laws with rigid levels of punishments associated with violators, while others resort to more spiritual or philosophical approaches. In the end, the various cultures of the world have not developed in a linear fashion when it comes to the development of a conception of law and justice. There is perhaps no more stark example of this than to compare and contrast the Western and East Asian conceptions of law and justice. Upon just taking a cursory look at this topic, one will immediately be struck...
7 Pages(1750 words)Essay

Scientific

...Recombinant DNA technology Recombinant DNA technology In obtaining the three plasmid DNA including A2-F, pFR-Luc, and Gal4, the study employed use of Luria broth and plasmid cloning techniques. Essentially, Luria broth defines a a bacteria culture media that with high nutrients used in laboratories. In addition, isolation of specific DNA sequences from complexes of varied sequences of DNA relates to DNA cloning (Walker and Rapley, 2009, p. 115). Plasmid or highly modified phage acts as vectors for replication of DNA fragment during cloning in a host cell. The inherent plasmid vector consists of three elements including cloning site, drug-resistance gene, and a replication origin (Stuttard and Rozee, 2013, p. 180). The latter... DNA technology ...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Essay on topic Comparison of the Scientific Philosophies of Kuhn, Duhen and Lauden for FREE!

Contact Us