StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...

Defensive Communication - Essay Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
Summary
In 1962, J L Austin put forth 'an understanding of language as a medium for actions or deeds' (Kenaan 66). The notion of language as behaviour found further expression as 'linguistic acts' and 'speech acts' (Searle). What is more, as a type of behaviour, defensive communication is a social phenomenon that occurs when a person in a group feels threatened (Gibb 14)…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER93.4% of users find it useful
Defensive Communication
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Defensive Communication"

Download file to see previous pages By examining these forms of messages in the context of interpersonal communication, I shall reaffirm previous research findings that defensive communication results in 'losses in efficiency in communication' (Gibb 14).
The strategy of defensive communication has various tactics and in the limited space afforded by this paper I will separately analyse in the following order only control messages, dogmatic messages, messages of indifference, and messages of superiority.
Control messages predominantly operate as imperatives, commands, and instructions. Control messages therefore imply authority, that is, the 'right to give orders or make decisions' (Lewis). Authority, however, implies varying degrees of power. 'A power relation is a causal relation between the preferences of an actor regarding an outcome and the outcome itself' (Pettigrew 188). For example, a police officer has authority to issue commands and power to enforce those commands. In contrast, a teacher has authority to issue commands and instruction but less power to enforce those commands. Parents like teachers have authority and a limited degree of power. What is more, as the context of one's communication becomes more personal authority and power wan, so that no real power relations exist between friends. For instance, in intimate relations defensive communication can occur when 'individuals are sensitive about their own flaws as well as the flaws of others close to them' (Becker, Ellevold and Stamp 95). Complicating the matter is that not all communication is verbal - body language for instance. So that, without explicit messages or in fact any intent, one may communicate irritation or annoyance. Furthermore, control is not simply the directing of action; 'information may become an instrument for advancing, attacking, or defending status' (Burns and Stalker cited in Pettigrew 189). For example, one may use control messages to avoid a topic of discussion, as in family secrets (see for example Caughlin et al.).
Dogmatic messages fall within the compass of defensive communication by virtue of the denotation of dogma; 'a doctrine or code of beliefs accepted as authoritative' (Lewis). In contrast to control messages, that expose authority and power, dogmatic messages expose censorship. Defensive communication in general, and dogmatic messages in particular, involve 'a self-perceived flaw that an individual refuses to admit to another person' (Becker, Halbesleben and O'Hair 144). Resisting the model of a dialogue (Pope 173), dogmatic messages rely on the monologue. For, 'every word is directed towards an answer and cannot escape the profound influence of the answering word that it anticipates' (Bakhtin cited in Pope 235). We may think of a dialogue as the collaboration between people to come to a mutual understanding. Yet in contrast, dogmatic messages attempt to curtail the give-and-take of communication. Such messages contain a deep irony; for, despite the effort to avoid a topic or point via an assertion of strength, the effort itself communicates a defensive attitude grounded on weakness. Dogmatic messages, therefore, undermine any authority or power asserted by a conversational partner. Furthermore, because a dogmatic message ...Download file to see next pages Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Defensive Communication Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 words”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/people/1501162-defensive-communication
(Defensive Communication Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words)
https://studentshare.org/people/1501162-defensive-communication.
“Defensive Communication Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/people/1501162-defensive-communication.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Defensive Communication

Concept Mapping of Social Communication and it's HIstorical Contexts

Communication being a complex social phenomenon relies on a number of related phenomena and processes, particularly history and traditions in communities or human groups, cultural determinants in a certain society, the political context in which a community or group exists, yet, gender and ethnical variables that also play significant role in the processes of information exchange.
There is no doubt that a researcher attempting not only to define the nets of informational exchange in a social group (whether it is a community of organizational environment) but also to provide a solid analysis of communication, needs to evaluate all of the above-outlined variables. Knowledge and past experience, for example, determine both the q...
7 Pages (1750 words) Case Study

Implications of Mobile Communication on Society

Lifestyle has changed and the mobile phone is gradually becoming a part of the culture of modern societies (Hulme & Peters).
Voice transmission is no longer the only way that mobile phones are used. It is a multi-purpose device. Mobile phone networks have become a new platform through which data, information and transactions are exchanged. It serves as an alarm clock, an address book, an entertainment device through games, and to a text message.
At the end of 2003, there were 1.35 billion mobile subscribers worldwide compared to 1.2 billion fixed line users (Shaping the Future Mobile Information Society). It has undoubtedly changed the lives of the people and the biggest factor which induces the purchase of mobile ph...
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

The Widespread Use of Information Communication Technology

An increasing number of frauds is an example of an alarming situation. All these have a far-reaching impact on the employees, on businesses and on people. 

On the work front, the advantages of ICT cannot be overlooked in maintaining and implementing successful quality programs. Customer-driven standards, customer-supplier links, the prevention of error, quality at the source, and continuous improvement are some of the principles that are put into practice (Laudon & Laudon, 2000 cited by Iles & Healy, 2004). IC T facilitates the production process, helps meet benchmarking standards, make constant upgradation based on customer demands. The internet has revolutionized not just the selling of goods and services...
9 Pages (2250 words) Essay

Description of a General Communication Diagram

Communication as such, is a dynamic process of exchanging thoughts, ideas, information, feelings, messages, attitude or knowledge amongst two or more persons through a predefined set of symbols, icons and signs called language. The language in itself is not made of a set of units alone. It is the spaces spanned by a set of units like semantic associations with words, human behavior, group behavior, social attitudes that make language. Radio, television, print, Internet, Advertising, Public Relations form part of the communication process. Effective communication is one in which this exchange achieves the intended goals of the communicating ends. A human being communicates his message with the help of spoken words or sign language....
8 Pages (2000 words) Term Paper

Billing System Upgrade with Web-Based Version Project of Rick Auto Enterprises: A Communication Plan

The project is envisioned to involve changes to existing business processes, changes to existing jobs, and/or the creation of new positions. With the new web-based version, customers and auto brokers will be able to view and pay their bills online, as well as access a billing customer service agent is required. This change will affect the billing, sales, and customer service departments but it is expected to reduce costs, improve customer satisfaction, and reduce the number of days for outstanding accounts receivable.
Ownership of the existing system rests with the Billing Department. However, with the benefits projected to be derived from the upgraded system, especially with the implantation of the web-based version, the Cus...
12 Pages (3000 words) Case Study

Teaching Language and Communication Skills

“Language occurs through an interaction among genes (which hold innate tendencies to communicate and be sociable), environment, and the child’s own thinking abilities” (Genishi, 2006). But just how does this happen? How do children learn to use sounds to communicate and then to place those sounds in the correct order to make themselves understood? While some of this behavior can be attributed to the imitation of the caregivers, there remain aspects to the development of language and communication that cannot be so easily explained. To provide a more complete understanding of how language and communication develop in the young child, it is necessary to understand not only the primary terms that are applied, but al...
12 Pages (3000 words) Case Study

Business Communication for Degree Access: Olympic Volunteering Consultancy

The London Organising Committee for 2012 is headed by Lord Coe but we would need to contact the Minister for the Olympics who is Tessa Jowell to place the Bid. The Olympic Games are said to need 70,000 employees with large land development in London.

To beat out the competitors with an excellent business strategy (Wikipedia) an excellent marketing strategy must be used! 26,400 pounds, of the 1 million pounds on Flyers and radio ads this company can inform the residents of Greenwich of the career training opportunity. Using Radio ads that are up to date we can gain a young volunteer base. Flyers handed out to community centers and welfare offices this company will gain other targeted volunteers.

The Census Bur...
6 Pages (1500 words) Assignment

Cultural Communication

...CULTURAL COMMUNICATION SELF-ASSESSMENT PAPER Cultural communication is a very interesting to analyze in light of globalization and the interconnectedness of different cultural communities throughout the world. Evaluating one’s own cultural background is difficult to do from an objective standpoint. It is also even more difficult to understand how one’s cultural background affects our communication styles with people from our own culture as well as with people from other cultures. With the aim of understanding cultural communication fully, the following will provide a nice overview of my own cultural background. Following this, I will explain the communication style of my culture and then look at how my cultural background influences...
7 Pages (1750 words) Essay

Communication Role at the Workplace

Internal communication in any organization has been found to play a significant role in regard to role achievement in any business venture. When the internal communication department closely works with the top management, it has been found that job satisfaction levels rise which in effect translates to higher individual and group output from the workers (HRM guide, 2009). It is the role of the internal communication department to ensure that the strategic organizational direction is passed on to all employees and followed as planned so as to guarantee the achievement of intended outcomes.
With the current developments towards globalization, knowledge availability has become more readily available and the economy has approache...
9 Pages (2250 words) Assignment

Analyzing a Communication Situation

Communication is part of everyday life. It is not limited to adults or learned individuals. Babies communicate with their mothers as they cry when they are hungry, the mute use sign language to express what they want to say, while the mentally disabled laugh when they are happy or excited. The forms of communication people use may vary but common elements are usually present. These include the message and the communicators or the participants who play the role of either the sender or receiver of the message. In the communication situation, I had with my friend, these common features were present along with others namely, feedback, noise, context, and mutual agreement/negotiation. These elements affected the outcome of the conversa...
12 Pages (3000 words) Case Study
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Essay on topic Defensive Communication for FREE!

Contact Us