Nobody downloaded yet

Defensive Communication - Essay Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
Summary
In 1962, J L Austin put forth 'an understanding of language as a medium for actions or deeds' (Kenaan 66). The notion of language as behaviour found further expression as 'linguistic acts' and 'speech acts' (Searle). What is more, as a type of behaviour, defensive communication is a social phenomenon that occurs when a person in a group feels threatened (Gibb 14)…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER97.1% of users find it useful
Defensive Communication
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "Defensive Communication"

Download file to see previous pages By examining these forms of messages in the context of interpersonal communication, I shall reaffirm previous research findings that defensive communication results in 'losses in efficiency in communication' (Gibb 14).
The strategy of defensive communication has various tactics and in the limited space afforded by this paper I will separately analyse in the following order only control messages, dogmatic messages, messages of indifference, and messages of superiority.
Control messages predominantly operate as imperatives, commands, and instructions. Control messages therefore imply authority, that is, the 'right to give orders or make decisions' (Lewis). Authority, however, implies varying degrees of power. 'A power relation is a causal relation between the preferences of an actor regarding an outcome and the outcome itself' (Pettigrew 188). For example, a police officer has authority to issue commands and power to enforce those commands. In contrast, a teacher has authority to issue commands and instruction but less power to enforce those commands. Parents like teachers have authority and a limited degree of power. What is more, as the context of one's communication becomes more personal authority and power wan, so that no real power relations exist between friends. For instance, in intimate relations defensive communication can occur when 'individuals are sensitive about their own flaws as well as the flaws of others close to them' (Becker, Ellevold and Stamp 95). Complicating the matter is that not all communication is verbal - body language for instance. So that, without explicit messages or in fact any intent, one may communicate irritation or annoyance. Furthermore, control is not simply the directing of action; 'information may become an instrument for advancing, attacking, or defending status' (Burns and Stalker cited in Pettigrew 189). For example, one may use control messages to avoid a topic of discussion, as in family secrets (see for example Caughlin et al.).
Dogmatic messages fall within the compass of defensive communication by virtue of the denotation of dogma; 'a doctrine or code of beliefs accepted as authoritative' (Lewis). In contrast to control messages, that expose authority and power, dogmatic messages expose censorship. Defensive communication in general, and dogmatic messages in particular, involve 'a self-perceived flaw that an individual refuses to admit to another person' (Becker, Halbesleben and O'Hair 144). Resisting the model of a dialogue (Pope 173), dogmatic messages rely on the monologue. For, 'every word is directed towards an answer and cannot escape the profound influence of the answering word that it anticipates' (Bakhtin cited in Pope 235). We may think of a dialogue as the collaboration between people to come to a mutual understanding. Yet in contrast, dogmatic messages attempt to curtail the give-and-take of communication. Such messages contain a deep irony; for, despite the effort to avoid a topic or point via an assertion of strength, the effort itself communicates a defensive attitude grounded on weakness. Dogmatic messages, therefore, undermine any authority or power asserted by a conversational partner. Furthermore, because a dogmatic message ...Download file to see next pagesRead More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Defensive Communication Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 words”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/people/1501162-defensive-communication
(Defensive Communication Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words)
https://studentshare.org/people/1501162-defensive-communication.
“Defensive Communication Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/people/1501162-defensive-communication.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Defensive Communication

Statistics on Defensive efficiancy for NBA Basketball

... NBA Standings Introduction Statistics revolves around data collection, organizing or processing, analyzing, understanding and interpretation. It also includes the plans involved in data collection, planning individual surveys, and the subsequent experiments. All this processes are conducted by statisticians. This is an economic data analysis project that has incorporated different items in statistics. The data used is for NBA defensive team, it keeps the national basket ball records annually. This data are for the years 2009 and 2010, both home and away games. The records are for 30 top defensive teams. The first team attains two points after a vote while the second team attains a vote following a vote. Test hypothesis... the completion of...
5 Pages(1250 words)Research Paper

Communication

...?Communication While theorists and researchers speak of effective communication, one of the most important considerations within these analyses is the context in which the communication occurs. Indeed, one could argue that it is impossible to speak of effective or ineffective communication without consideration of the context. One prominent context where communication occurs is in retail environments. While there are a number of universal best practices for customer service, communication may differ markedly between different retail environments. This essay examines communication in three Philadelphia retail environments:...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay

Defensive Developmentalism

...in military and economic factors, which served as a threat ton the Middle East and North African nations (Kia, 2011). Therefore, the challenged regimes assumed that the best way to stand unchallenged against the rival European nations would be through the implementation of the same policies of leadership. Ottoman Empire and North African communities imply the earliest adapters to the system (Quataert, 2005). Their idea revolved on militarization with a stiff maintenance or improvement to the nations’ economic performance. Third world countries and the Middle East regimes met a range of obstacles associated to the system of defensive developmentalism. At the long run, they suffered victims of the system...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay

Communication

...? Communication: The Positive and the Negative Sides Details: al Affiliation: Communication: The Positive and the Negative Sides Communication is a vital element in the s survival of every species in existence on the earth surface. To be sure, all animals employ some mode of communication in ways that are impressively unique and proficient to the functioning of a species. However, none rivals the precision and flexibility that comes with the interactive mediums of human communication. Clear and effective communication is but the life blood of a good working relationship in any given society; for any misdirected/confusing communication automatically results in piling up of unresolved problems (Stuart, Sarow and Stuart, 2007, p. 108... ). It is...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay

COMMUNICATION

...? Communication of the Communication In a social situation, do I prefer to talk to others or do I prefer to listen? I prefer to be a listener. I admit, I do not possess the gift of the gab and I lack spontaneity. Some people have the ability to say something interesting instantaneously, but I need time to recollect and answer the question. As such, I like to listen more and talk less and study the responses with the one with whom I converse. In social situations, when a friend needs my specific advice, I will listen to him in detail, instead of giving on-the-spot solutions. The very process of talking and unburdening the pent up feelings may lighten the stress of the person with whom I am engaged in...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay

Insider Trading: Offensive and Defensive Causes

...Insider Trading: Offensive and Defensive Causes This essay addresses the concept and the causes of insider trading. Insider trading is consideredan issue of immense importance to the business and legal communities. The issue, in effect, is one of honesty and transparency in the conduct of corporate affairs. It is considered so important because this type of security transaction, insider trading, can potentially harm individual investors, industries, and a country’s business reputation. This is a truly global issue. Insider trading is defined by the United States Securities and Exchange Commission as “buying or selling a security, in breach of a fiduciary duty or other relationship of trust and confidence, while in possession... providing...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

Communication

...new gown. Bella: And who decides whether wearing each other’s old clothes is right or new clothes? Even though you tend to wear my old clothes, but they are as dear to me as my new ones. Kelly: My clothes smell foul after you have worn them. You never take a bath! Bella: What? What did you just say? I don’t take a bath? YOU don’t take a bath. You smell foul. You filthy evil! (Kelly and Bella start abusing each other. First they call each other names and then break into a physical fight. Kelly pulls Bella’s hair, while Bella tends to protect herself and in self-defense, slaps Kelly. Mom comes running from the kitchen into the lounge). Mom: Aey, why are you fighting like cats. Ae, Kelly, leave Bella’s hair. (Mom comes in...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

Communication

... A review: Lights (1931) Introduction lights, a film produced in 1931 and directed by Charles Chaplin generated captivating performances with an ending that seemed more open than conventional films. The gist of the storyline, involved the Tramp falling in love with a blind flower girl and his attempts to empathize with her condition. The films was written by Charles Chaplin, Harry Clive and Harry Crocker and featured in the cast were Virginia Cherrill, Florence Lee, harry Myers, Al Ernest Garcia, Hank Mann and Charles Chaplin. The film produced during the ominous era of the great depression and the advancement in film production, particularly the talkies, were prominently intertwined, albeit humorously in the film. the film’s... A review:...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay

Communication climate supportive defensive

... from the same level of understanding and we approached the presentation from a problem solving perspective. Besides, we appreciated positive criticism from the committee and we took to their recommendations on improving on our initial idea. I would therefore have no support to a proposal of a change in the communication climate that we adopted for the presentation process. Works cited Larsen, Svein, and Ingebjorg S. Folgero. "Supportive and Defensive Communication." International Journal of Contemporary Hospitality Management 5.3 (1993): 22. ProQuest. Web. 23 June 2014.... Supportive communication environment Introduction I happen to have worked as a secretary to an investment group where as a team; we came up with...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

Defensive versus Offensive Realism

...Defensive versus Offensive Realism: Differences and Strengths Ferguson described that Frederick the Great is a better ruler than Machiavellian leaders because the former supports preventive war that can better ensure the former’s powerful status in international political systems, while the latter will lose in an anarchic international political system by only waging wars as defense strategies. A preventive war maintains the balance of power through averting the rise to authority of other nations, which could, in the long run, weaken powerful states (Ferguson, 2011). The concept of preventive war fits offensive realism’s assumption of a state’s insatiable appetite for power and security (Ferguson, 2011)....
4 Pages(1000 words)Research Paper
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Essay on topic Defensive Communication for FREE!

Contact Us