Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Go to advanced search...

The Meaning of Meaning - Essay Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
The traditional study of natural language leaves much to be desired in the philosophical realm. While they have discovered certain universal features which appear to be species-specific, and have some idea about the structure of language…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER92.1% of users find it useful
The Meaning of Meaning
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "The Meaning of Meaning"

The Meaning of Meaning The traditional study of natural language leaves much to be desired in the philosophical realm. While they have discovered certain universal features which appear to be species-specific, and have some idea about the structure of language, it remains to be seen as to whether any of this is actually naturistic of language, or more associated with actual cognitive learning approaches and syntax. The question raised most often by philosophy is what about the meaning of words; where does it originate. It’s not that meanings don’t exist per se, but rather that they take a different form than what we usually intend when we say meaning. Word meanings are more inaccurate than sentence meanings. For this reason we often have to gain the meaning of words through their contextual surroundings. Previous philosophers have postulated that sentence meanings should be addressed first in attempting to discover the meaning of words; however, if the word has different connotations between societies, then no amount of studying the meaning of a sentence will bring one closer to the real meaning of a term. Traditional philosophers postulated that there are two applications of words; one in the actual term, and the other in its significance or sense. The actual term has been thought of as the extension of a descriptive concept; the actuality of everything belonging to that one descriptive set and whatever is true for that set. The significance or sense of a term involves whatever is intentioned by that term. Words cannot be defined concretely as there are always variances of significance despite the terms used. For this reason, the dictionary also has many different connotations describing one word and its usage. The extension form of a term is fairly precise; however the intension form can often be vague conceptually. The problem is that traditional philosophers treat the intensions of words as mental entities. Modern philosophers postulate that because meanings are held uniformly across groups of people, they are in actuality abstract entities dependent upon psychological cognitive events applied individualistically in order to derive accurate intentionality of a term. By this, it has been theorized that two identical terms cannot differ to intension with the same extension. They postulate that intension is considered a criterion for recognition of belonging to the extension set. Therefore, the theory of meaning is based on two assumptions: 1) that defining a term is based on the psychological state of a person, and 2) that the intension of a term signifies its extension. Putnam argues that this bases the meaning of words on inaccurate theory. For one thing, traditional philosophers held that psychological states were individualistic; that no two people could be in the same psychological state simultaneously. These psychological states were limited by and unique to the individual. In this mode of thinking, there are no global circumstances of awareness. This philosophy restricts the psychological nature to fit preconceived and idealistic reconstructions of the world and knowledge; that beliefs and knowledge are individualistic across time and cultures. Yet, in reality, there are two approaches to determining psychological state. In the broad sense, it is a globally applicable condition which many individuals may share at any given moment. People can possibly grasp intentionality of a term regardless of its extension. The concept of a word has a widely held common understanding. However, the point of contention arises with the belief that the intension determines the extension. In traditional theory, meanings are thought to be platonic entities as opposed to mental entities; understanding the difference between them is considered an example of the methodological solipsism viewpoint, where what one determines to be true is the only truth. Taking the global view of psychological state, it’s a case of using mental particulars to define and identify concepts, as opposed to using mental entities. The traditional view holds that if two people have differing concepts of a term, then they must be in different psychological states as the psychological state of the communicator determines the intension and extension of that term. Putnam argues that if this were true, one must consider which is affected by the psychological state; the intentionality or the extension of the term. She postulates that only sometimes does the psychological state of the communicator have a bearing on the extension of a term. Different speakers of the same language sometimes have different intensions for the same term. This accounts for confusion between similar linguistic communities. While speakers across a large area may be in the same psychological state and have identical terms for expressing the extension of those terms, the conceptual intentionality isn’t always identical. Therefore, the extension of a term isn’t dependent upon psychological state or its intension. Putnam goes on to explain a plausible theory which holds more credibility and may have more to do with the socio-linguistic connotations of a term; the social or commonly held beliefs about a term as used by a group of L1 speakers. These terms evolve over time, involving culture adaptations to vary the intention while retaining the extension of the term. This would also account for blended languages that include slang terms, and adopt terms from other languages to express interpreted intensions, which may vary from the actual intentionality of the L1 term. Bibliography Putnam, H. How Not to Talk About Meaning. R. Cohen, M. Wartofsky, eds., Boston Studies in the Philosophy of Science, vol.2 ( New York: Humanities Press, 1965) Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
(“The Meaning of Meaning Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 words”, n.d.)
Retrieved from
(The Meaning of Meaning Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words)
“The Meaning of Meaning Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words”, n.d.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF The Meaning of Meaning

Meaning and Types of Money, the Federal Reserve System

...First Last Dr. First Last 3 May 2008 Monetary Policy Money is a form of exchange of value in an economy and a regulatory policy that controls the supply of money is termed as “Monetary Policy”. However, before discussing the nuances of a monetary policy and what it constitutes, it is essential to understand the nature of money, what role it plays in an economy, the role of a banking system and then, finally, how money supply can be controlled. These aspects presented here are a summary of Mankiw’s discussion on the subject (641-660). Meaning and Types of Money: Money is the form of asset used and accepted regularly to buy and sell products and services. This definition is in contrast to wealth, where even though a person may have...
10 Pages(2500 words)Coursework

Meaning and Characteristics of Contract

Even as it is almost certainly not viable to give one total and generally correct definition of a contract, the most normally admitted definition is: 'a promise or set of promises which the law will enforce' (Pollock Principles of Contract (13th Edn) 1). The key considerations for the enforcement of a contract against a promisor are economic meaning the economic obligation of gripping the adherence of bargains and moral meaning moral reason that the guarantee was freely given.

According to the present law of contract, claim for money is either for ‘payment of an agreed sum’, or for damages for breach of contract. In the 19th century, these two ideas made the common law to sanction full freedom and purity of...
6 Pages(1500 words)Coursework

The Meaning of Globalization

...The Meaning of Globalization The term globalization admittedly has been used in such diverse contexts and broad applications that theorists have taken up diametrically opposed views not only as to its benefits or evils, but even as to whether it exists in actuality or only as myth. For this discussion, three articles from among the required readings have been selected with this issue in mind: the existence, or non-existence, of globalization. This discussion will be undertaken by examining each author’s claims, comparing them one against the other, and in the end harmonizing the different viewpoints to create, if possible, one cogent synthesis. The first article chosen is that by Hirst and Thompson (2000) entitled Globalisation...
6 Pages(1500 words)Assignment

Explaining the Meaning of Team and the Stages Involved in Group Formation

...From the experience gained working in a group as well as a team while still a and at my workplace, I have realised that theories of groups and teams are very crucial to know in as far as understanding of behaviour is concerned. The notion of group dynamics is very important because of its great influence on human behaviour in the workplace. Schultz (2003), suggests that there are always factors that influence as well as shape the group hence this reflective essay seeks to critically evaluate the usefulness of the theories of groups and teams to understanding behaviour. This essay begins by explaining the meaning of group and team then goes on to illustrate the various stages involved in group formation and how the knowledge... the experience...
9 Pages(2250 words)Essay

Definition and Meaning of Workplace Safety

...Definition and Meaning of Workplace Safety Introduction Workplace safety generally refers to the protection of employees while they are on job. Workplace safety has been one of the major concerns for employees, as well as for managers. Almost every country has made significant laws to improve and ensure workplace safety because of increased concerns of media personnel, employees, and public about this issue. However, the cases of hazardous workplace injuries are still caching the attention of public. Occupational Safety and Health Act (OSHA) is the American employee safety act which also deals with workplace safety issues. In this paper we will discuss whether OSHA is proving successful in dealing with workplace safety issues... and Meaning ...
8 Pages(2000 words)Research Paper

Meaning of Modernity According to Modern Political Theorists

...Meaning of Modernity According to Modern Political Theorists Introduction Modernity has been defined differently by different theorists and commentators. The definition of modernity as it applies in the social, political, and philosophical arenas has been subject to change over time. While in sociology, modernity is often associated with industrial revolution (Eyerman and Jamison 1991, p. 74), politically, it has a lot to do with the shift from feudalism to nation-state. Further, modernity in philosophical terms is associated with the loss of certainty and the impossibility of establishing certainty ultimately. In lay terms, modernity is associated with modernism and the modern era. In consideration of the above definitions, it may be well...
6 Pages(1500 words)Term Paper

History of the Word Nationalism and How Its Meaning Has Changed

... full Kenneth J. Tiller ENG 1010 - Nationalism (An extended definition) 24 November (word count = 2,067 of text only) Introduction English is a widely-used language in the world today, especially in the academe and in business by which people can communicate and understand each other. Globalization made the mastery of English language skills a requirement for success in many fields of endeavor. It is expected of people to have at least a minimum knowledge of the English language for them to get along with most other people in the world as English is the virtual lingua franca today. If a language like English is termed as a lingua franca, it means it is used as a bridge language by which two persons who are speaking entirely in two...
8 Pages(2000 words)Assignment

The Meaning of an Art Piece

... Meaning of Art piece Art is a means of imitating nature and a means by which individuals can express emotions. There are many elements contributing to the art and this makes it difficult to define art. Art is one of the conditions of human life. There is integration of art in most communities. Each community has their own unique art and ways that they communicate the message of the art. Painters are artists who take the responsibility of shaping materials, techniques, ideas, and feelings to express their feelings (Beckett and Wright, 12). There are things in the world today that relates to art. Posters, portraits, paintings are a few of the elements that indicate that art is important to the lives of most individuals. Art is in different...
6 Pages(1500 words)Essay

The Meaning of Struggle in Human Life

... The Meaning of Struggle in Human Life It has never been a surprise that any human life is a story of constant struggle for anything: good living conditions, well-paid job, a family to be proud of and many other things that are definitely worth fighting for. The point of concern here is that some people take any efforts to reach the goals – they sacrifice all the time and resources they have, and at the end, they reasonably win and gain everything they want, whereas some prefer to do it in a usual way knowing that it is impossible to gain the ultimate results anyway. The fact which is proved by the life itself is that struggle definitely deserves many efforts and much time, even though the results may be not that good or even...
8 Pages(2000 words)Essay

Coordinated Management of Meaning Theory And How It Improves Effective Communication

...The Coordinated Management of Meaning Theory al Affiliations (Word Count: 3539). The Coordinated Management of Meaning Theory Introduction The process of communication, whether written, spoken, non-verbal or visual, is done to ensure that certain information has reached an audience (Cronen & Pearce, 1982). However, for mass communication, it is essential that the message is conveyed in such a way that the intended meaning reaches the audience. It is through the mass media that important issues affecting a particular country or region are addressed; hence there is the need to pass information in a way that will be effectively interpreted (Yamaguchi, 2005). Therefore, this creates criticism to the known definition of communication...
14 Pages(3500 words)Research Paper
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Essay on topic The Meaning of Meaning for FREE!

Contact Us