Liberal and Academic Approaches to US Immigration Policy - Essay Example

Stoll does not think that immigrants have any contribution to the country rather than providing cheap labor. Well, this is not agreeable as many respectful jobs are done by immigrants.

Mead however has a different view than Stoll and thinks immigrants have shaped America as we see it today. I agree with Mead in this approach as he calls America has been known as the “melting pot” of assimilation of cultures and has given new opportunities to immigrants throughout history. Mead argues that coming to the country without following the right jurisdiction is never encouraged, forgiving this act and allowing individuals to have new opportunities. Mead is a person who wants to protect immigrants. Stoll suggests that poor immigrants can adversely affect American workers. However, Stoll thinks these poor people can be allowed to live in the country but he does not think it is the responsibility of America to help poor people.

Mead does not think these immigrants have to rush to America but these poor people need to give shelter and facilities by their respective countries. He believes that the entry of people from all around the world to Europe and the US will disrupt the wealth and moral values of these countries. This is a fact; actually, there are many illegal immigrants in America and the UK which damages the socio and economic infrastructure of these countries. It also steals the opportunity of the citizens and put pressure on the country’s population. Mead argues that r while coming to the country without following the right jurisdiction is never encouraged, forgiving this act and allowing individuals to have new opportunities represent the true face of America itself. The government in essence must take additional steps to increase border patrol security.

Mead thinks that elite people do need immigrants but normal citizens do not want them. So we can see that Western nations need immigrants for their benefit but not as they want to improve the lives of these unfortunate people. So both Stoll and Mead do think that immigrants are only needed by rich people. This is a fact as many people who work in low-paid jobs are illegal immigrants from Pakistan, Bangladesh, and India. Illegal immigrants are a social evil and the Western countries need to bring about a comprehensive strategy that can bring less suffering to illegal people and their citizens. Read More