Evaluate for a case - Essay Example

In addition, the reason for locating new blood donors, while taking help of medical consultants, was the loss in business, which Plasma International could foresee, due to the above-mentioned reason. However, Plasma tried to exploit the new donors, which were innocent tribal people who wanted to sell their blood for money. The whole issue came to surface due to discovery of the scam by a Tampa paper. According to its reports, Plasma made millions of Dollars in little time, by buying cheap blood and selling the same to needy patients in United States at exorbitant prices.

The treatment of blood as a commodity in United States is vastly different from the system of blood supply followed in Britain, where the National Health Service entirely depends on voluntary donors. According to theory of Capitalism, capitalist theories stress on the fundamental issue of profit motivation in any business venture. Although the theory of capitalism may apply to the business style of Plasma International, it goes beyond doubt that the whole business did not follow any moral ethics.

According to theory of Utilitarianism, the business motive should be to bring maximum good to optimum number of people. However, in this case, the benefit has gone only to Plasma International and none else, as both blood donors and receivers were cheated by the company. Kantian theory has application for British model of treating blood as a human need, instead of trading it as any other commodity. Hence, system followed in Britain certainly has several advantages, over the American system, particularly since human blood and lives are involved.

This theory relates to getting satisfactory fulfillment of human needs by employing voluntary means. At the same time, the theory underlines the fact that one’s actions or thinking should not interfere in the freedom of others. Human needs, for this