A key issue for the courts when deciding on the legal status of a comfort letter is whether or not the party proffering the comfort letter intended to create legal relations - Essay Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
Summary
In order to determine whether the party proffering the comfort letter intended to create legal relations between themselves and the other party it is necessary to discuss the relevance of comfort letters.
Comfort letters came into usage due to the difficulty in finding someone…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER98.9% of users find it useful
A key issue for the courts when deciding on the legal status of a comfort letter is whether or not the party proffering the comfort letter intended to create legal relations
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "A key issue for the courts when deciding on the legal status of a comfort letter is whether or not the party proffering the comfort letter intended to create legal relations"

Download file to see previous pages Comfort letters are common in loan agreements, as an alternative from asking the lender to obtain a guarantor for the loan. In order for a claimant to be able to rely on the letter of comfort as a guarantee of payment, the claimant has to prove that the person issuing the letter intended to create legal relations between themselves and the claimant.
According to Ellinger (1989) comfort letters can be identified into 3 specific types, and can include undertakings from a parent company to meet the financial commitments of the subsidiary company. Less stringent comfort letters identify that the parent company knows of the intention of the subsidiary company to enter into a contract with the other party, but makes no express guarantee to honour the agreement of the subsidiary or to actively intervene to ensure that the subsidiary company fulfils the contract.
These letters can have legal effect despite the fact that they cannot be relied upon as a guarantee that the party will fulfil their part of the contract. One of the first cases to consider the effect of comfort letters was Banque Brussels Lambert S A v Australian National Industries Ltd1 in which the defendant averred that the letter should not be regarded as a binding contract. In this case, the bank insisted on a letter of comfort as a condition of the loan agreement between the parties. The bank had originally tried to force the defendant to guarantee the payments on the loan, which the defendant had refused to do. The claimant attempted to aver that the letter of comfort contained promissory paragraphs with regard to the conduct of the defendant and that the defendant had breached these promises. One such paragraph stated
We take this opportunity to confirm that it is our practice to ensure that our affiliate [the borrower] will at all times be in a position to meet its financial obligations as they fall due. These ...Download file to see next pagesRead More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“A key issue for the courts when deciding on the legal status of a Essay”, n.d.)
A key issue for the courts when deciding on the legal status of a Essay. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1561650-a-key-issue-for-the-courts-when-deciding-on-the-legal-status-of-a-comfort-letter-is-whether-or-not-the-party-proffering-the-comfort-letter-intended-to-create-legal-relations
(A Key Issue for the Courts When Deciding on the Legal Status of a Essay)
A Key Issue for the Courts When Deciding on the Legal Status of a Essay. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1561650-a-key-issue-for-the-courts-when-deciding-on-the-legal-status-of-a-comfort-letter-is-whether-or-not-the-party-proffering-the-comfort-letter-intended-to-create-legal-relations.
“A Key Issue for the Courts When Deciding on the Legal Status of a Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1561650-a-key-issue-for-the-courts-when-deciding-on-the-legal-status-of-a-comfort-letter-is-whether-or-not-the-party-proffering-the-comfort-letter-intended-to-create-legal-relations.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF A key issue for the courts when deciding on the legal status of a comfort letter is whether or not the party proffering the comfort letter intended to create legal relations

MBA Exam: Comfort Homes

...give them a cooler factor but will make their ‘connect with the customer’ simpler and more advantageous for the customer as well as Comfort Homes. Another thing that they need to focus on is to build a strategy for the long term growth of the organization. This will happen only if they first solve all the existing problems they are facing in relation to production, marketing and employment. Comfort Homes seems to be having a few issues internally and solving these is the key to a better, smarter organization. Once they are free of the major issues internally, they will be stable and can thus focus on working towards eliminating the...
8 Pages(2000 words)Essay

Usefulness of Comfort Theory

...and a sense of strength. Moreover, it provides a conceptual framework for nursing care (Kolcaba K. , 2003). According to Kolcaba, comfort exists in three forms; relief, ease and transcendence, which can again occur in four contexts; physical, psychospiritual, environmental and sociocultural. (Kolcaba K. , 2010) Relief comfort is a result of pain management through use of medications. For example, if a patient feels pain, a prescription drug is administered to relieve the pain. Ease comfort places more emphasis on the environment and state of mind of the patient. Kolcaba suggests that if issues of anxiety are exhaustively addressed a person feels at ease. The last form of...
9 Pages(2250 words)Research Paper

Tablet Devices and Comfort

We have the slate tablet which is also referred to as the iPad.It has a touchscreen unit which and does not have a keyboard. Lastly, there is the rugged tablet that can stand all the rough handling by the students. They have hard drives that are usually shock protected. Some people argue that the tablet devices should replace the books that learners use in their classrooms. Using the tablets may have various disadvantages to the learners like the costs. Some of them are expensive and not each parent can afford to buy for their children. Background The tablet devices may have their advantages but some people choose to be against it. In the world today, the education system has been in the recent years become technological. Many lea...
5 Pages(1250 words)Essay

Client legal advice letter

...?Client legal advice letter LAW OFFICE GEORGE MERO & ASSOCIATES 123 Federal Street, Andover, MA 1234 Telephone: (978) 111-2222 Facsimile: (978) 125-6666 April 17, 2013 BY REGISTERED MAIL PRIVILEGED ATTORNEY/ CLIENT COMMUNICATION Dr. Karen Wallaby 1234 Hyland Avenue Boston, MA 4000 Re: Potential Claims against Hospital Dear Dr. Wallaby, I enjoyed meeting with you on Monday, April 14th in spite of the events that compelled you to look for our professional assistance. In fact, I acknowledge your honesty and transparent nature when we met. Ordinarily, dealing with issues such as this is usually challenging. However, such discussions must always take place to pave way for...
5 Pages(1250 words)Essay

Legal Issue

...Diversity Issue The legal issue is whether or not "interacting with others" is a major life activity under the ADA. - that is a common term for this legal issueLegal Analysis/Thoughts The ADA (Title I) protects individuals with disabilities from discrimination in the employment context.[1] - its fully referenced. The - common English word individuals with disabilities from discrimination in - too common To be entitled to such protection a person must: (i) be employed by an entity covered by the ADA, (ii) be disabled within the meaning of the ADA, (iii) be otherwise qualified to perform the essential functions of her...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay

Comfort Letter

...it was stated that it was the policy of the company (Malaysia Mining) to ensure that Metals would always be in a capacity to pay back what was borrowed from KB. The carefully worded correspondence is now the so-called comfort letter at issue. When Metals became troubled with insolvency owing to the predicaments of the tin industry because of the problematic world market, KB claimed payment from Malaysia Mining for the obligation of Metals. KB charged that Malaysia Mining had made a promise to prevent going into a situation where it could not pay its debts. The question now is whether or not Malaysia Mining is liable to KB on the basis of the language...
4 Pages(1000 words)Case Study

Holistic Comfort

...on the environment they set up for their patients. There are two key considerations to be made when analyzing intervention and they include the greatness of the unmet needs of patient and degree of needs as seen in nursing literature (Katherine, 1992. pp 4). Once these are established, the nurse is in a position to decide the actual measures to take in order to assist the ailing person. Purpose of the analysis. The purpose of analyzing the concept of holistic comfort is to bring to light the great role comfort plays in lives of the sick people. It also seeks to bring to limelight to the comfort gauging mechanism thus precipitating...
5 Pages(1250 words)Essay

Legal Status of Comfort Letters in South Africa

...). The Banque Brussels’ decision took a more liberal approach by saying that in addition to the terms of the letter, one must consider the factual matrix surrounding the creation of the comfort letter (Gurney, et. al). Simply stated, if the maker or issuer does not intend to be binded by the comfort letter, he or she must include a disclaimer or a clear statement on the face of the letter that he or she does not intend to give rise to any legal obligation whatsoever. Otherwise, in the absence of the disclaimer, the comfort letter is...
5 Pages(1250 words)Essay

LETTER OF LEGAL ADVICE

..., it can be better interpreted as “when party does some act as being intended by the offeror, it amounts to implied acceptance” (Moshal, 2008). Implied acceptance is an informal kind of acceptance, where there are no scenario legal procedures. For instance, this kind of scenario is observed in the case of Brogden v Metropolitan Railway Company, where there was no formal contract and the Metropolitan Railway Company thought that Brogden had accepted the contract and hence, Brogden continued to supply the coal to the Railway Company. Moreover, this kind of scene was also witnessed in the case of Masters v Cameron (1954) 91 CLR 353, where there is no scenario of formal or...
7 Pages(1750 words)Essay

LETTER OF LEGAL ADVICE

.... The offeree may decide to send an electronic mail to the offeror. As long as the letter of acceptance is received by the offeror, the acceptance from the offeree will then be complete. e) Conclusion It is therefore, clear that there is need to consider many factors when dealing with contractual acceptance in the company. The different forms of contractual acceptance ant their legalities should always be well understood to avoid any issues or misunderstandings arising among partners later after signing legal a contract. I therefore, hope that this legal advice concerning contractual acceptance will be useful in any...
7 Pages(1750 words)Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Essay on topic A key issue for the courts when deciding on the legal status of a comfort letter is whether or not the party proffering the comfort letter intended to create legal relations for FREE!

Contact Us