Nobody downloaded yet

The evolution of the law on the anonymity of witnesses: the governments provisions fail to provide a balance with anonymity and a defendants' rights - Essay Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
Summary
Witnesses fear intimidation especially in cases where the defendant is accused of involvement in heinous crimes. Prosecution, too, is of the opinion that many criminals escape justice because witnesses…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER93.8% of users find it useful
The evolution of the law on the anonymity of witnesses: the governments provisions fail to provide a balance with anonymity and a defendants rights
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "The evolution of the law on the anonymity of witnesses: the governments provisions fail to provide a balance with anonymity and a defendants' rights"

Download file to see previous pages This concealment of identity is not only from the defendant but also from the public and pseudonym is used during the hearing. To conceal this identity common methods such as placing of sight screen and distortion of voices by electronic media are used.
However, the method’s frequent use had raised concern and this practice was challenged. On the other hand, courts held that in absence of any solid reason to contradict the assumption of fair and just trail and where the evidence of anonymous witness could be tested in the adversarial process, admission of evidence in anonymity is allowed.
The criminal evidence (witness anonymity) Act, 2008 was introduced soon after the house of lords allowed appeal by Ian Davis in the case of R Vs Davis. Davis was accused of murdering two men in 2002 and his conviction was set aside on the plea of non-admissibility of anonymous evidence in common law as it prevented the defendant to cross examine the witness to determine or establish malafied on their part. This decision created a sudden vacuum and a lot of pending trails collapsed. To fill this gap, Mr. Jack Straw, introduced the bill on 4th of July 2008 which become an Act of parliament on 8th of July 2008.
In this paper our main focus will be an analysis of law prevailing before the enactment of Criminal Evidence (Witness Anonymity) Act, 2008, the factors which lead towards the promulgation of the Act, case of R Vs Davis (Lain) 2008 and its contribution in enactment of this Act.
Furthermore, a critical compassion of this law with Evidence (Witness Anonymity) Amendment Act 1997 of New Zealand will be made to understand special measures and balance between anonymity and defendant’s right to fair trail.
R Vs Davis (Lain) has proved to be a landmark case which initiated a series of events including promulgation of criminal evidence (witness Anonymity) Act, 2008. This ...Download file to see next pagesRead More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“The evolution of the law on the anonymity of witnesses: the Essay”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1561103-the-evolution-of-the-law-on-the-anonymity-of-witnesses-the-governments-provisions-fail-to-provide-a-balance-with-anonymity-and-a-defendants-rights
(The Evolution of the Law on the Anonymity of Witnesses: The Essay)
https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1561103-the-evolution-of-the-law-on-the-anonymity-of-witnesses-the-governments-provisions-fail-to-provide-a-balance-with-anonymity-and-a-defendants-rights.
“The Evolution of the Law on the Anonymity of Witnesses: The Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1561103-the-evolution-of-the-law-on-the-anonymity-of-witnesses-the-governments-provisions-fail-to-provide-a-balance-with-anonymity-and-a-defendants-rights.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF The evolution of the law on the anonymity of witnesses: the governments provisions fail to provide a balance with anonymity and a defendants' rights

IS INTERNET ANONYMITY A MYTH OR REALITY

...require that the customers need to purchase the debit cards out of the band. 2.5. Legal issues: One important question that needs to be thought of is whether Internet anonymity is right or wrong? From legal perspective, US court protects the right to receive anonymous communication. The law reasons that if the readers are required to identify themselves, to read information from an entity, then the reader may refrain from that communication. With respect to usage of anonymity tools, it was suggested that government agencies should not shut down the operations of these tools. Also a government agency...
103 Pages(25750 words)Thesis

In your opinion, can a criminal trial be fair if witnesses are granted anonymity

...and controversial issues related with the criminal justice. The laws related with the anonymity of the witnesses have been developed under the common law and there has been a large standing principal that the defendant to be confronted with his accuser in the court of law. (The Crown Prosecution Service) The case of R Davis however, brought forward new challenges when it was decided by the House of Lords that the anonymity of the witnesses may render the overall trial as unfair. This case is considered as one of the leading examples of ignoring the achievement of a delicate balance...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay

Governments Balance Law and Order with Individual Freedom

...the rights with the interests underlying the maintenance of law and order. Means of balancing law and order with individual freedoms The Government outlines the individual rights and freedoms in the constitution, which comprise a set of guidelines to govern the people. Thus, individual liberty needs a basis in law, but additionally, it must integrate the requirements of social order. This means that maintenance of law and order balances with individual freedom to guard and define the sphere of liberty of the individual and promote order in the society (Schnarrer, 2004)....
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

EVOLUTION OF PATIENT RIGHTS

...? Evolution of Patient Rights Id: Abuses in human s in biomedical practices were reported which drew public attention particularly after Second World War. Nuremberg code and Belmont report revolve around single purpose of empowering human beings in deciding the matters of day-to-day life. During and after the Second World War certain abuses on human subjects in biomedical experiments were reported that drew great human attention to the matter. Nuremburg code clearly stated 10 standards for doctors to follow while carrying out research about human subjects. Human respect is the main pillar of basic ethical principles. Beneficence dilates upon not harming the individual at all or minimizing the harm and...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay

Jehovah's Witnesses

...? Jehovah’s Witnesses Jehovah’s Witnesses Jehovah’s Witnesses is a religious denomination that has its beliefs, which are far, distinct from mainstream Christianity. The denominational group was formed in the late 1870’s by a man known as Charles Taze Russell. The group has been well known for their house to house preaching methods that are believed to help non-believers understand their doctrine. Some of their principles advocate for the refusal of military service and blood transfusions. They believe that the use of the name of Jehovah is a vital key in proper worship. Some of the principles that the group advocate for is the rejection of Trinitarianism. This is the belief in God being...
3 Pages(750 words)Research Paper

Collective Bargaining Assignment

5 Pages(1250 words)Assignment

Anonymity and Abuse on the Internet

...the Internet remains a problematic area that must be understood within the proper contexts (Cowan 2004). If this is not done in the most righteous way, there could be serious consequences for the people who matter the most within the related settings. These could include the users who are browsing over the Internet, the ones who frequent social networking websites, blogs and so on and so forth. These social networking websites have played their due role at bringing people closer and by this; one does not really mean that these are coming together for all the right reasons. There are negativities as well which have come to the fore as these have been at the forefront of starting debates and discussions which are related...
6 Pages(1500 words)Essay

Anonymity and exclusion

...Anonymity and exclusion Task: ANONYMITY AND EXCLUSION Introduction The paper gives a brief summary of anonymity and exclusion together with a few examples as pertaining legal terms. The two terms are mostly used as legal terms to mean two different viewpoints . AnonymityAnonymity typically means a state of an individual hiding his or her personal identity hence publicly unknown. There are several reasons as to why people prefer being anonymous or to withhold identity. People prefer taking charity acts so that benefactors are not easily identified. Witnesses who appear in court cases are usually nowhere to be seen in a...
1 Pages(250 words)Essay

Anonymity: Morals, Ethics, Responsibilities

... How Are Ones Morals, Ethics, And Responsibilities Affected By Anonymity? Anonymity has the potential to affect ethics, morals and the responsibilities of an individual. Anonymity gives an individual the freedom to live in disguise. Being anonymous affects the morals, ethics and responsibilities of an individual because the individual is faced with a situation of competing obligations, duties and conflicts of interests. These individuals are also needed to make explicit and implicit choices between the interests and values of different groups and individuals. During a research, an anonymous participant has the right to confidentiality and privacy. However, the researcher is challenged by legal and cultural variations. In this case... . For...
7 Pages(1750 words)Essay

Jehovah's witnesses

.../fetus to be aborted should be considered as an independent life, which should also have the right to determine its fate (Beckwith, 22). According to the ruling under Case Treatment of Jehovahs witnesses in relation to the blood transfusion of the first sextuplets ever born in Canada, the BC Supreme Chief Justice Donald observed that; the rights of the parents to determine the medical treatment of their children could trump on the charter rights of the infants to receive medical treatment, which may prevent personal injury or death of the infants. Thus, the application of this provision of the law simply means that an infant has the...
3 Pages(750 words)Case Study
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Essay on topic The evolution of the law on the anonymity of witnesses: the governments provisions fail to provide a balance with anonymity and a defendants' rights for FREE!

Contact Us