Argument rehearsal for multiple realizability of mental states (contra the identity theory) - Essay Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
A common example is pain. Effort has been made by numerous physicalists to identify mental states with physical states, usually with brain…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER98.2% of users find it useful
Argument rehearsal for multiple realizability of mental states (contra the identity theory)
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "Argument rehearsal for multiple realizability of mental states (contra the identity theory)"

Download file to see previous pages This follows from property identity: if X = Y, you can’t have X without Y, or Y without X. For example, you can never ask for six bottles under the condition that you will not be given half a dozen bottles. This is because six is just the same as half a dozen. This is true of the identity of mental and physical states. For example, if the physical realization of pain is C-fiber firing, then it cannot be anything else but C-fiber firing. This is property identity theory. But the multiple realizibility of mental states opposes this claim. If pain is related to both C-fiber firing and D-fiber firing, you can have pain without C-fiber firing (given that you have D-fiber firing), and you can have pain without D-fiber firing (given that you have C-fiber firing). What this also implies is pain is not identical to either one – you cannot have six bottles without having half a dozen. Therefore, I ask myself the following question, is there valid reason to think that mental states are in fact multiply realizable? I believe so.
Alien beings are often conceived as having similar mental attributes to humans, albeit physically different. Intelligent beings develop the capacity to select advantageous mental states to sustain life force. For example, if I am unable to feel pain (which is a mental state), it won’t be possible for me to recognise any physical experience which is life threatening. Resultantly, I would cease to exist, thus failing to reproduce and pass on my legacy. Likewise, my cognitive capacities such as intuition and decision making abilities enhance my awareness about surroundings and help me do the right things at the right time. Without these traits, I wouldn’t have been able to sense danger and would expose myself to potentially harmful situations, which, again, would make me susceptible to extinction. Therefore, one can rationalise that an intelligent alien creature living somewhere in the universe would have ...Download file to see next pagesRead More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
(“Argument rehearsal for multiple realizability of mental states (contra Essay”, n.d.)
Retrieved from
(Argument Rehearsal for Multiple Realizability of Mental States (contra Essay)
“Argument Rehearsal for Multiple Realizability of Mental States (contra Essay”, n.d.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Argument rehearsal for multiple realizability of mental states (contra the identity theory)

Professional Project - Rehearsal Studio

...?Literature Review The capability of opening a rehearsal studio in the UK is one which requires looking at a variety of perspectives. The rehearsal space is different than any other form of business, specifically because it is based on socio-cultural movements and the needs of artists within the community. The question of opening a studio is also dependent on the changes in the economy and how this affects the different values and needs that are a part of artists and the community. Defining the various perspectives of using a rehearsal space and understanding whether it is feasible to do is one that can then promote and change the alternatives available to musicians while determining if...
6 Pages(1500 words)Literature review

Professional Project - Rehearsal Studio

...?Methodology There are two objectives which need to be achieved when examining rehearsal studios and the implementation of these studios within a given climate. The first is based on the financial viability of starting a rehearsal studio in the United Kingdom. Examining the financial conditions, economic conditions and the responses which would come from the target market is necessary to make the right investment for today’s needs. The second question asks if it is feasible to run a studio in today’s climate. This is inclusive of the sociocultural conditions and other economic situations that are now a part of the UK. This also includes the trends and conditions which are in the current environment and...
5 Pages(1250 words)Dissertation

Theory of Multiple Intelligences

...? Theory of Multiple intelligences Theory of Multiple Intelligences First postulated by Dr Howard Gardner in 1983, the theory of multiple intelligences suggests that there are eight different intelligences the influence the learning potential of children and adults, as well. The theory holds that the tradition understanding of intelligence which is based on I.Q. testing is limited in describing the intelligence of individuals. According to Gardner (2006) the multiple intelligence theory is a diversion form tradition I.Q. view of intelligence which is psychometric and defines intelligence as a person’s ability to provide accurate answers to intelligence tests. Such test scores would then be inferred against a predetermined rating... feelings,...
3 Pages(750 words)Research Paper

Gardner's Multiple-Intelligences Theory

...Gardners Multiple-Intelligences Theory: Overview: Howard Gardner came up with the Multiple-Intelligences Theory in the twentieth century in an attempt to explain the term “intelligence.” Gardner basis his theory on the argument that the traditional definition of psychometrics as in the IQ tests lacks the representation of all the cognitive skills humans are naturally blessed with. Gardner’s theory renders the conventional means of judging an individual’s intelligence by means of specific IQ tests meaningless in that they are only a tool to measure one or two of the numerous shades of intelligence people retain. The...
2 Pages(500 words)Research Paper

Dissociative Identity Disorder (Mental Disorders)

...Multiple personality disorder is a serious condition that many use to protect themselves. This use of different personalities allows the individual to set aside one person and allow another to deal with the bad. In a way multiple personality disorder is somewhat of a defense mechanism the brain and body use to protect itself from harm. Karen, who faced an extremely terrible childhood, had multiple personalities that she chose to handle certain events. Karen would do this by assigning a new person to each aspect of her life. One person would deal with acting normal while another person would handle the abuse and sexual assault. Since Karen was doing this at such a young age, Karen began...
1 Pages(250 words)Essay

Gardners Theory of Multiple Intelligences

...Gardner’s Theory of Multiple Intelligences ‎ Gardner’s Theory of Multiple Intelligences ‎ The theory of multiple intelligenceswas developed by Howard Gardner, a Harvard psychologist (Plotnik and Kouyoumdjian, 2010, p.23). The initial theory stated seven different intelligences that people use to perceive or understand this world. He suggested that these intelligences existed in everyone; this challenged the traditional view that there were only two types of intelligences, and this has given a new perspective to cognitive sciences. Gardner referred to intelligence as the capacity to solve problems or to fashion products that are valued in one or more cultural setting (Gardner and Hatch, 1989, p.5) Following are his seven proposed... the...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

Human Mental States

...Mental States I would contend that the patient has mental states. On this view, I would back the position taken by Doctor 2. I base my argument on two main points. First, I dispute the argument that an organic brain is necessary for the existence of mental states. Secondly, I challenge the view that the absence of an organic brain necessarily implies the absence of a non-material soul. The patient lacks an organic brain but has a computer in its place. From the observations of the doctors and from my own assessment of the patient, I would quickly argue that the computer fulfills all the roles that an...
5 Pages(1250 words)Essay

Multiple Culture Identity: Comparison of Two Stories

...Multiple Culture Identity: Comparison of Two Stories 1. Introduction: 1.1: Overview Cultural identity is the most overwhelming thing for a human being. The stories under consideration are A Good Fall and Brave We Are by Jin and Naqvi respectively. Both of these tales have a similarity which draws them together. In both stories a metamorphosis of identity is revealed. In Jin’s story the life and adjustment issues of an immigrant are discussed. The immense inferiority complex of immigrants is portrayed which help in understanding the dilemma of identity crisis. The enormous misery of identity catastrophe is discussed by the fact that...
9 Pages(2250 words)Essay

Constructing an Argument from Multiple Sources

...Constructing an Argument from Multiple Sources There are various challenges that are present in this world. From global warming, to constraints in resources to high population growth, all these are challenges that need to be fixed. Despite the fact that the solutions are right in front of us, we have failed to utilize our abilities to fix our issues. We have resulted to shifting blames to each other instead of seeking ways through which these challenges can be resolved. This paper argues that it takes individual effort for an environment to be cleaner, more livable and sustainable. For the environment to be sustainable, clean and lively, individual efforts must be invested. The environment comprises of...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay

Social Identity Theory

...Social Identity Theory Social Identity Theory Social identity is what people perceive themselves to be in terms of theirgroup membership. When students choose group members for coursework, presentation and group assignments, there is always a tendency of such groups being composed of people who feel that they belong to the same social group (Haslam, 2001). The composition of such groups, when the responsibility to form is left to students, is always not well balanced. One will find that students come together based on factors such as race, culture, social class or even religion to form a coursework group. Such group formation is discriminative and full...
1 Pages(250 words)Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Essay on topic Argument rehearsal for multiple realizability of mental states (contra the identity theory) for FREE!

Contact Us