Distributive Justice: Access; Rationing; Futility - Essay Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
Nowadays many hospitals provide facilities for transplanting organs. Most of the organs of humans can now be transplanted, thanks to the vast development in medical sciences. The most common transplant is the…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER94% of users find it useful
Distributive Justice: Access; Rationing; Futility
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "Distributive Justice: Access; Rationing; Futility"

DISTRIBUTIVE JUSTICE: ACCESS, RATIONING, FUTILITY Organ Transplantation is no more an impossible or tedious work. Nowadays many hospitals provide facilities for transplanting organs. Most of the organs of humans can now be transplanted, thanks to the vast development in medical sciences. The most common transplant is the process of transplanting the heart. Generally if a patient is diagnosed with an organ failure, the concerned hospital then decides whether that organ could be replaced. If it is found to be possible, the hospital then takes the further step of helping the patient for a transplant. The doctors will try and inform other hospitals and some service organizations to locate people who are willing to donate the organ. If they have found a suitable donor, all the required tests are taken to make sure that the organ can be successfully transplanted. Then they proceed with the transplantation.
In the year 2004, an American, Todd Krampitz was suffering from cancer and he had to undergo a liver transplantation. He thought of a new method by which the possibility of getting the organ was easier without waiting for a longer time. His family decided to place hoardings at some of the main places in America, describing the need of an organ for transplantation. (Tutt 2004) The board carried information that he has to undergo liver transplantation and requested for donors. It had the name of a website which had the complete details regarding his requirement. This idea of placing boards had a very good response and it grabbed the attention of many. His method was successful in finding a person who was willing to donate. The operation was successful. (Caplan, 2004). But the real question that rises is that whether his method was ethical. According to a study, at the time when he got the organ transplantation, 17000 people were waiting for the organ.
The method he adopted was very effective that it gained so much attention and popularity. It could reach people easily as many people would definitely come to know the need of an organ. This was successful because it doesn’t take much time in searching for a donor. I feel that this method is an easier and effective way in finding donors. As this proved to be successful the hospitals can come forward and adopt this to help a patient who is in need of an organ transplant. They can set up boards, give advertisements in newspapers and magazines, and telecast the need through television so that it can reach more number of people in a short span of time. This will reduce the time that a patient generally waits to get a donor.
If there are two people who are waiting for same organ transplantation, the organ can be transplanted to a person who will definitely survive for a longer period instead of giving it to a person who is sicker and not sure of having a good life span after the transplantation. The person who is willing to donate should be free from any sort of medical complaints and should not be an alcoholic as it will affect the patient. Transplanting kidney from a living donor is not ethical as he may face some problems at a later stage. It will enable in solving the problem of patient waiting for a longer time. The hospital can make use of this approach whenever a patient is found to undergo a transplant so that it makes sure that the patient is benefited easily and quickly. The Todd Krampitz’s approach to find a donor is more successful and hospitals can follow it to serve people better.
Caplan, A. (2004). Journal Article on Cutting In line For Organ Transplants.Retrieved from:
Tutt, B (2004). Journal Article on Organ Transplant provides Second Chance. Retrieved from: Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
(“Distributive Justice: Access; Rationing; Futility Essay”, n.d.)
Distributive Justice: Access; Rationing; Futility Essay. Retrieved from
(Distributive Justice: Access; Rationing; Futility Essay)
Distributive Justice: Access; Rationing; Futility Essay.
“Distributive Justice: Access; Rationing; Futility Essay”, n.d.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Distributive Justice: Access; Rationing; Futility


...?Distributive Justice Cutting in line for Organ Transplants The case of Todd Krampitz begs the application of ethical concern in matters of organ donation. Todd Krampitz was diagnosed with liver cancer in 2004. The cancer had already spread throughout his body when he was diagnosed therefore his disease was rendered incurable; the only way out seemed to be a liver transplant. Owing to the stage of cancer and unfortunate diagnosis, Todd Krampitz was given a low ranking on the UNOS wait list. Since Krampitz was a successful businessman, his family and friends were able to launch a nationwide media campaign to find a suitable liver donor (Vogel, 2007). After pulling some strings, his family was able to...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay

Distributive Justice

...?Nozicks principles and individual property rights, are they in line? America has been d the land of opportunity throughout much of its history. The ability of the average man or woman to buy property, work for oneself, save money and be a voice of change within the system that exists through the use of physical voting or civil obedience or disobedience has long been seen by many in other nations as a shining example of freedom. However, with the use of distributive justice are we truly free, does the use of distributive justice within both legal and social approaches allow for us to be free. Property rights are tenuous when the possibility of losing it at the behest of...
4 Pages(1000 words)Term Paper

Rawls's Theory of Distributive Justice

...addresses a state of nature that describes the content of a social contract which is an agreement to enter civil society. Distributive justice deals with the questions of distribution of liberties, wealth, and income (Rawls, 2003) According to Rawls there are two principles that are supposed to govern the basic makeup of a just society are the parties to the original position: an imaginary circumstance which specially constructed by a rational individual. The principles are (a) the principle of equal liberty and social justice where each individual has equal claim to adequate basic rights and liberties. In this system there are equal political liberties...
5 Pages(1250 words)Essay

Distributive Justice - Health Insurance

...declarations and the sanctification of finances and economic wellbeing in place of human health. In addition, charging more for the same services in health care provision is unethical as it blatantly violates federal policies and regulations. Such policies are such as the Patient Protection and affordable Care Act which is meant to ascertain the implementation of universal health insurance coverage (Lance, 2011.). This is done by denying uninsured patients access to quality healthcare by making it expensive. In turn, this beats the entire concept of having a universal health insurance policy to improve the overall health of the nation. Although the idea of having insurance is to finance once health in tough times,...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay

Distributive Justice CS4

...? Distributive justice cs4 Medical ethics refer to a set of guidelines that are supposed to govern functionality of the entire system and ought to be applied both practically and theoretically. Recently, those in the field of health have adopted a conceptual framework referred to commonly as bio-ethics (Miller & Truog, 2008). Bio-ethics entirely talks about beneficence and non-malfeasance. The guidelines are aimed to helping distinguish between right and wrong. Todd Kramptiz had been battling with cancer for quite a long time. It was not long before his liver also failed and had a tumor developing inside (Miller & Truog, 2008). Todd’s family was very concerning about his health and vowed to do anything...
3 Pages(750 words)Case Study

Distributive Justice

... that one deserves on the virtue of being human. 3. This distributive justice that everyone deserves can be justified in purely secular and rational terms and is independent of religious, cultural, or any other beliefs. 4. The concept and practice of the distribution of this share of goods is a practical project and is not something unattainable or useless. Putting in our efforts to achieve this distribution of goods will not go futile since it is an attainable project. It is not even like attempting to enforce friendship, since that would undermine the very goal of what one seeks to achieve. 5. It is also the duty of the state, not just private individuals or organizations to guarantee the distribution of goods.... from what Aristotle...
6 Pages(1500 words)Essay

Distributive Justice ( healthcare ethics)

...Titus R Manickam Order No. 173412 13 June 2007 Distributive Justice healthcare ethics) Todd Krampitz did not adhere to ethical standards The healthcare ethics brought to bear by the Todd Krampitz episode raises a number of issues. To begin with, let us take the issue of propriety. The issue of propriety is being taken up because of the patient and his doctor's method of getting a liver donor by the use of ads, while there were 17000 other similar patients some of whom may have required the transplant more urgently than Krampitz did. It also raises the issue of a level playing field where the recipient who needed the transplant more, becomes automatically entitled to the first available donor organ. In the light of the above...
4 Pages(1000 words)Case Study

Distributive Justice for Medical Care Systems

...Distributive Justice (M4C) It is improper for medical care systems to discriminatively charge patients for medical procedures on basis of medical insurance coverage on the patients. While it is not ethical for any system to appear to rob the rich and reward the poor, it is not in line with proper medical conduct for a hospital to charge the uninsured more than the insured for the same medical procedure. Ethics in the medical profession revolves around the health of the patient, but with the contradiction occasioned by the need to maintain productivity in the sector, it has become remotely practical for practitioners to exercise due ethical compliance. However reasonable this might appear in the light of...
1 Pages(250 words)Essay

Distributive Justice in Physical Therapy

...Distributive justice in Physical Therapy By Distributive Justice in Physical Therapy Distributive justice demands equity and justice in the allocation or distribution of goods or services in the society; distributive justice demands that goods and services should be distributed in the society according to people’s needs, i.e. in proportion to the needs of the people (Distributive Justice, web). The principle of distributive justice is applicable in solving ethical dilemmas that involve...
4 Pages(1000 words)Case Study

Distributive Justice and Ownership Rights

...Distributive Justice and Ownership Rights The issue of distributive justice has sparked a lot of controversy within the public domain with many scholars investigation the possible implication of this statement. Nozick is among scholars who have found fault in the application of distributive justice within the society. In his note, he identifies the legal ways that a person may acquire property either by acquisition or by transfer. However, there is evidence there are many ways in which people may acquire property either by fraud or by redistribution. The role of liberty in ownership of properties is to give every person the right to use...
4 Pages(1000 words)Coursework
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Essay on topic Distributive Justice: Access; Rationing; Futility for FREE!

Contact Us