StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Solving The Moral Dilemma Of Janet Moore - Essay Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
Summary
This essay discusses that Janet Moore is torn between her need to find her first job and the ethical and moral dilemma that the job presents. In addition, Janet has to take cognizance of the Kantian Philosophy of treating men as means to achieve an end…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER94.3% of users find it useful
Solving The Moral Dilemma Of Janet Moore
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "Solving The Moral Dilemma Of Janet Moore"


Solving the moral dilemma of Janet Moore.
Janet Moore is torn between her need to find her first job and the ethical and moral dilemma that the job presents. I would decide to join the firm of Union Tobacco Inc. since there is no other job available. Further, when I join up and draw salary and wages, I would ensure that my duty of increasing the market share, finding new markets and increasing revenues are met. When a job is offered and salary is drawn, then the first allegiance is to the company and meeting its goals and targets. The role of a traitor who would subtly act against the best interests of the tobacco firm is not ethical. If there are any misgivings about the firm or if I don’t like the product and goals, then I should not join the firm. This reasoning applies for manufacturers of alcohol products and arms.
As per the case, the firm aggressively targets younger children with low-nicotine mint and cherry-flavoured products so that they would graduate to the two much stronger and best selling brands. The issue that arises now but which has not been mentioned in the case is how does the snuff product compare with cigarettes. The case does not mention the comparison between the two products for addiction and harm done to the body and it is further assumed that the two products have the same levels. Cigarette marketing and branding is widely accepted and if the addiction and harm levels are same, then the marketing job that Janet is exploring should be acceptable.
However, Janet has to take cognisance of the Kantian Philosophy of treating men as means to achieve an end. This attitude is callous as Kant argues that while men can be used as a means, they must be also treated as an end in themselves (Seidler, 1986). Therefore Janet has to realise that what her senior Karen says is also true, that they can use the job as a means to improve the firms image and to save peoples lives. There are a number of lawsuits being files about the dangers of the tobacco product. Soon the firm would be in serious trouble. Janet and Karen can use their training and education to modify the marketing campaign to bring in the principle of utility. A balance can be struck between obtaining the required sales revenues yet prevent younger age children from being targeted by the Ad campaigns.
Janet should take up the job more as a challenge and because she believes in the good that she can bring to kids. She could explore the concept of corporate social responsibility and ensure that the product carries enough health warnings and that people are aware of the dangers the product would cause. She could even target parents about the ill effects of the product and if kids still wanted to try the products, then she has tried all that she could do. Janet should work in the job for a couple of years and the lessons she learns should help her in her role in the future to be more responsible in the marketing functions. However, as long as she is drawing wages from the company, she should ensure that her main role and function of increasing the firms revenues and market share are met. She should also ensure that the negative publicity and negative image of the firm is reduced through the use of proper advertisements.
References
Seidler. Victor. J. 1986. Kant, Respect and Injustice, The limits of liberal moral theory. Routledge & Kegan Paul Plc. England. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Solving The Moral Dilemma Of Janet Moore Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 words - 7”, n.d.)
Solving The Moral Dilemma Of Janet Moore Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 words - 7. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1557924-case-study
(Solving The Moral Dilemma Of Janet Moore Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words - 7)
Solving The Moral Dilemma Of Janet Moore Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words - 7. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1557924-case-study.
“Solving The Moral Dilemma Of Janet Moore Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words - 7”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1557924-case-study.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Solving The Moral Dilemma Of Janet Moore

Final Moral Dilemma Case Analysis

...? Final Moral Dilemma Case Analysis Gathering Data and Identifying Conflicting Moral Claims The patient arrived from a psychiatric organization. He is in this organization because of the murder. The patient's lawyers and attorneys defended him basing on the notion that he was mentally disturbed. The patient was transferred to the current hospital since he had been diagnosed with having crucial lung cancer that meets the spine. The patient was admitted while with a weak condition of bilateral lower extremities. The patient as well had no capability to walk because of cord compression. The patient vocally rejects all prescriptions and treatments. Moreover, the patient is struggling physically and rejects blood withdrawals and intravenous...
4 Pages(1000 words)Assignment

Moral Dilemma

... PSY-238-001 4 December Dishonoring a Person’s Moral Rights The question of moral rights is a long-debated issue. Many have argued about the extent of moral rights but the issue still remains as a moral and ethical dilemma in the present society. When a dying person’s chance to live is almost gone and hospital bills keep running without assurance that the patient can be revived, it is good to consider whether family members can request doctors to end the patient’s misery, thus exempt them from the agony of paying a high hospital cost. Dishonoring the right to live in lieu of practical reasons, the situation presents both moral and ethical dilemmas. Moral dilemma is directed toward the family, while ethical considerations are credited...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay

Evaluation of Janet Holmess

... Evaluation of Janet Holmes’s Essay The difference in communication between sexes has been a major talking point in society. Women have been labeled as “talking too much” while men have been seen or viewed as potential or good listeners. However, the article by Janet Holmes discusses the issue in detail while offering an understanding of the various issues associated with ‘talking too much’. Across the world, women have been believed to talk too much even in situations that do not require communication. In view of the developed ideology, Holmes evaluates and conducts analysis on the issues and gives a clearer view of the problem than initially presented (Holmes). She addresses the diverse situations and the contribution of women...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay

Moral Dilemma

...Order 116949 Moral Dilemma What exactly is a 'moral dilemma', and does one face it in everyday life A 'moral dilemma' is a situation where here is conflict and where an agent regards himself as being completely morally justified in doing what he is doing, while at the same time, carrying out the second option of the situation where he is in may not be possible. The most crucial factor of a moral dilemma is therefore that the agent is required to carry out each of the two actions, the agent can carry out each of the actions, and the agent cannot perform both the actions. Therefore, the agent seems to be condemned to moral failure, no matter what he may do eventually, whatever he does, he would have failed to do something else right...
16 Pages(4000 words)Essay

Moral Dilemma: Culture vs. Heroism

...Moral Dilemma: Culture vs. Heroism YOUR FULL THE OF YOUR SCHOOL OR Moral Dilemma: Culture vs. Heroism The fundamental nature of any individual's moral conflict is the innate question of "what is the right thing to do" The question must be honestly and sincerely posed outside of the conflict of any particular personal desire, i.e., knowing what the right thing is and simply not wanting to do it does not constitute a moral dilemma. The question must also present choices having equally valid conditions with significant consequences regardless of the choice made. For example, the decision to remove the feeding tube of a suffering relative in a painful, vegetative state rather than preserve their life on the unlikely-but-not-impossible hope...
5 Pages(1250 words)Essay

Ethical Dilemma paper-second moral language

...SECOND MORAL LANGUAGE PAPER ETHICAL DILLEMA Ethical dilemma refers to the perplexed situation in which performing an act that is morally good and ethically refined one results in bad outcome and ends an inappropriate effect on the one hand, and a morally wrong act produces a pleasant state of mind and circumstances on the other. In the ups and downs of life, such moments come when it becomes really hard to take decision without partiality, keeping in view the ethical duties and moral obligation, having no care of one’s own priorities and interests at all. Robert J Nash (2002) has presented the model of the Second Moral Language, in which he has described the ethical dilemma and moral conflict arising in man’s mind as an outcome of his...
5 Pages(1250 words)Essay

Moral Dilemma

...Moral Dilemma The question of ethics and morality is one that has been debated since at least Greek antiquity. Philosophers and thinkers have debated what constitutes moral action and whether humans innately tend towards moral actions. With the advent of psychology, theories of development emerged that explored aspects of morality and intellectual understanding. Two prominent theorists in these regards were Jean Piaget, who seminally presented a theory of cognitive development, and Lawrence Kohlberg, who established a theory of moral development. Today these theories remain prevalent tools in understanding human psychology. This essay implements both of these theorists’ perspectives, in characterizing the moral development of am eleven...
2 Pages(500 words)Research Paper

Ethical And Moral Dilemma Case Studies

...ETHICAL AND MORAL DILEMMA CASE STUDIES The parole board As a matter of defining, a panel of persons sit andconsider whether a person in offense and serving in prison should be released having served over the minimum term prescribed and be monitored under parole explains a ‘parole board’ (Ward, 2012). These boards are currently in use within many jurisdictions across the globe and have the main challenge in determining the suitability of an inmate to have freedom to be back within the society. The deliberation is often on the likelihood of the prisoner to reform as against committing more crimes or offenses as were committed before conviction. It is therefore in such a framework that Robert is shown to serve as the leader to such a board...
9 Pages(2250 words)Case Study

Ethical Dilemma, Professional Organizations Issue Rules and Regulations

The Samaritan in the Holy Bible was also just another passer-by like the trekkers in SADHU but he behaved unlike these trekkers and also did not ignore his duties as a human being. The priest and the temple assistant are supposed to be in service of the Lord but they did not understand that to serve another human being is the biggest service to the lord. The Samaritan, despite his schedules, spent time and effort in providing comfort to a dying man. He fulfilled his duty by bringing him back to the inn on his own donkey, and while departing ensured that the Jew was fully taken care of. The actors in SADHU did show some concern but only to the extent, their schedules were not hampered.

Being ethical is to be dutiful and...
6 Pages(1500 words)Assignment

Critique of Research Article Moral Problems Among Dutch Nurses: A Survey by Arie JG van der Arend

... philosophies, and the reality of nurses’ moral problem experiences in practice. The description quoted from Jameton (1984) helped to clarify meanings when examining the researchers’ findings. His distinctions of three levels of a moral problem; “moral uncertainty (as a result of ignorance); moral dilemma (a choice from opposite principles or activities); and moral distress (the impossibility of carrying out a right choice)” may be applied respectively to the following realities experience by nurses; mistakes being made, following instructions from families or physicians against personal beliefs, and watching physicians continuing treatment instead of letting a person die in peace. The researchers contended that “some moral problems...
12 Pages(3000 words)Term Paper

IAEA's Development on Solving Proliferation of Nuclear Material and Weapons Trafficking In Former USSR & Current Russia

International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA) has developed various measures to report and control the illicit movement of radioactive materials in the former Soviet Union and present Russia. There has been an unprecedented increase in the smuggling of radioactive materials in the region since 2000.

IAEA maintains the Illicit Trafficking Database (ITDB) in collaboration with 81 nations that voluntarily offer details about unauthorized purchase and sale of radioactive and nuclear materials. Between 1993 and 2004, the ITDB report maintained by IAEA has found 662 incidents of nuclear smuggling. Most of these incidents involved the trafficking of low-grade materials which cannot be used to make weapons. However, there have been...
13 Pages(3250 words)Case Study

Googles HR Dilemma

Even big organizations sometimes failed to adopt the right HRM strategies because of the complex structure of HR management. Google, arguably the world’s best internet search company has also met with difficulties in its recruiting process. At the end of the tests, most of the candidates were rejected citing various reasons. Even some brilliant talents identified were also not selected because of their failure in the background checkups. Later the recruitment process has been limited to a seven stage process in order to reduce the complexity, but still, the hiring process creates a lot of problems for Google which needs to be rectified. (Verma, p.3, p.4)
Being the most heavily used search engine, Google in a very...
6 Pages(1500 words)Assignment

Ethical Dilemma in Nursing

As a practitioner, the nurse attends to all the medical needs of the patient and as a leader, she takes decisions that relate to, influence and facilitate the actions of others with an aim to achieve a particular goal. As a researcher, the nurse aims to implement studies to determine the actual effects of nursing care and to work towards further improvement in nursing care (Nettina, 2006). In order to impart these duties in the most appropriate manner, nurses must not only possess sound knowledge of the subject, but they must also be aware of ethical laws and legislations and how to handle ethical dilemmas. This is because, through their career, nurses encounter many situations that are tangled in ethical complexities. As Hall (19...
9 Pages(2250 words)Article

Issues of Moral Philosophy

After the stimulus of the sensation has passed, there will remain a fleeting image or “fading relics of sensation” (Oakeshott, 1981: 249); these fading relics of sensation are called images or ideas. When we become conscious of images, it is called imagination. And when we try to recollect these images it is called memory. Being such, the whole gamut of human experience is made up of his/her entire memories. The succession of images in the mind is called mental discourse and it may be haphazard or regulated. Prudence is the recollection of past memories combined with present experience, thereby allowing human persons to associate, predict or anticipate others or even events. In this sense, prudence is natural wisdom an...
8 Pages(2000 words)Assignment

Decision Making and Problem Solving Skills

The Emerald article Developing Competent Managers, written by Tom Kilcourse argued that competences of managers are specific to organizational culture, and the individual needs to develop in parallel with the organization (Kilcourse, 1994). Decision Problem Solving, Interpersonal Skills, Performance Management, Personal Organisation, Stress Management, etc are generally accepted as the necessary skills for a competent manager. This paper is focussing only on the decision making and problem-solving skills of a manager in order to analyze the competencies of a manager.

Management is a process that requires rapid decision-making abilities. Logical and effective decisions making abilities are essential for an effective mana...
5 Pages(1250 words)Assignment

The Social Dilemma Encountered by the Elderly

...Social Dilemmas Encountered by the Elderly A variety of problems are usually encountered by people belonging to diverse agegroups including the elderly. The elderly is confronted by different dilemmas which can be attributed to a variety of aspects and contributing factors. One of the problems faced by the elderly is the social problems of specific sorts. To better understand this, one must address and explore the problem to gain a better insight on this predicament that could have an impact not only on the individual alone but also the society. Keywords: social problem, dilemmas, predicament, elderly The Social Dilemma Encountered by the Elderly Introduction A variety of problems are usually encountered by people belonging to diverse...
9 Pages(2250 words)Term Paper

Omnivores Dilemma (Industrial Corn)

...Omnivore’s Dilemma (Industrial Corn) Introduction The book, “The Omnivore’s Dilemma: A Natural History of Four Meals” is an enlightening literary piece by Michael Pollan. The book appeared before its readers in the year 2006 and the book captivates a huge volley of inquisitions on the selection of the meals owing to the unselective nature of omnivores who tend to have almost anything and everything for their breakfasts, lunches and dinners. This tendency in human beings gives rise to dilemma for the choice of food and time of taking them. To justify these dilemmas in human nature and choice of meals, Pollan investigates the entire food habits of Americans or American way of eating. To investigate and analyze the entire food chains of human...
10 Pages(2500 words)Coursework

Moral and Legal Status of Abortion

...Moral and Legal Status of Abortion 1. True (Reading 10, Page 168, paragraph 2) Rosalinda Hurst uses virtue theory in reading 10 of page 168. She postulates the feeling women get of being bearers of new life within them. Therefore, she postulates that the virtue of life underlies within the sole responsibility of child bearers (Warren 168) 2. C ( Reading 10, Page 166, paragraph 1) The understanding of the beliefs and rights of the growing fetus can only be based on rightness or wrongness through understanding the wisdom of the fetus as a virtuous person. One therefore has to develop the correct attitude on the correct undertakings relative to a rowing fetus. (Warren 117) 3. A (Reading 10 Page 166, paragraph 6) An establishment...
7 Pages(1750 words)Assignment
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Essay on topic Solving The Moral Dilemma Of Janet Moore for FREE!

Contact Us