StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Composite Role Rating - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
The faculty evaluation process is routinely adopted by universities for evaluating performance and improving the teaching effectiveness of its faculty members. A successful evaluation system commonly involves obtaining valid and reliable inputs from students, peers and…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER97.9% of users find it useful
Composite Role Rating
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Composite Role Rating"

Composite Role Rating The faculty evaluation process is routinely adopted by universities for evaluating performance and improving the teaching effectiveness of its faculty members. A successful evaluation system commonly involves obtaining valid and reliable inputs from students, peers and department chair. However, according to Arreola (2007), the evaluation process is necessarily subjective but, for consistency of conclusions, it needs to be made objective through the strategy of controlled subjectivity.

The evaluation procedure essentially consists of a numerical rating provided by the sources in several pre-defined areas (roles and components) of teacher performance. Measurement tools viz., rating forms, observational checklists or questionnaires are used to obtain measures (numbers) that are valid and reliable (Arreola, 2007). In the hypothetical Impact Matrix (Appendix A) that I have prepared, I have used typical activities that university teachers engage in namely, Teaching, Scholarly Activity, and Service as the 3 major roles to evaluate faculty performance.

Under ‘Teaching’, the role components identified are ‘instructional delivery’, ‘instructional design’, ‘content expertise’ and ‘course management.’ In my impact matrix, students, being the target entity, will be the sole judge for instructional delivery skills. This component is best evaluated through the following list of desirable attributes of faculty teaching performance whereby “the instructor creates an intellectually stimulating environment by : demonstrating interest and enthusiasm in the student learning process; demonstrating effective communication skills: writing, speaking and listening; eliciting responsible student participation; …being available to students outside of class time to discuss course materials; …and returning student work in a timely manner” (Clarke University Faculty Evaluation Manual, 2008, pp 4-5).

These are qualities in a teacher that are especially needed for effective guidance of students in their academic course work; therefore, I have assigned 35% as the source impact. With an arbitrary source rating of 4, the weighted rating works out to 1.4 (as shown in Appendix A). The ratings are based on a 5-point performance scale which is: 1 (Unacceptable); 2 (Satisfactory); 3 (Good); 4 (Very Good); and 5 (Excellent). For the instructional design component, students (source impact weight, 10%); peers (15%); self (10%) all contribute the data.

The weighted rating from all these sources adds up to an arbitrary value of 1.25. The content expertise component is evaluated by peers and department head, besides self. Content expertise is “the formally recognized knowledge, skills, and abilities a faculty member possesses in a chosen field by virtue of advanced training, education, or experience” (Clarke University Faculty Evaluation Manual, 2008, p 4) which is judged by peer evaluators and department head on the following criteria: the faculty member “possesses an appropriate degree, ongoing professional experience, and licensure or certifications when applicable; is knowledgeable about recent trends, findings and value issues within his/her discipline and incorporates this information in the teaching-learning experience; and, develops a breadth of knowledge that enriches his/her teaching by making connections to other areas within the field of expertise or in other fields” (Clarke University Faculty Evaluation Manual, 2008, p 4) .

The ‘course management’ component of teaching is evaluated by only one source that is, the department head since it includes all the “organizational and administrative tasks involved in maintaining and operating a course” (Clarke University Faculty Evaluation Manual, 2008, p 5) Under the faculty role of ‘scholarship’, “the development of personal professional skills or standing”, “the development of knowledge (research) or of creative work or of professional practice” and the dissemination of knowledge in the professional community through publishing research papers, monographs, text books etc.

(Clarke University Faculty Evaluation Manual, 2008, pp 5-6) are considered suitable for evaluation by self, peers and department head. And, the faculty role, ‘service’ that includes those activities of a faculty member in which (s)he assumes responsibilities relating to the academic and support services of the college besides participating in community service activities are evaluated by only self and department head. According to Elmore (2008), the evaluation system has to be so designed as to “encourage faculty to take all aspects of the faculty workload seriously, decreasing the tendency among those who perform well in highly visible areas to regard mundane aspects of faculty work as beneath them”.

I have tried to do just that in the rating system that I have proposed in Appendix A. In summary, the hypothetical impact matrix presented here represents a format to evaluate the various roles and their components proposed by me earlier as the faculty role model. The evaluations are weighted in direct proportion to the pre-determined emphasis placed on those activities. Reference List Arreola, R.A. (2007). Developing a comprehensive faculty evaluation system: A handbook for college faculty and administrators on designing and operating a comprehensive faculty evaluations system (3rd ed.).  Bolton, MA: Anker Publishing Company, Inc.

ISBN: 978-1-933371-11-5Clarke University Faculty Evaluation Manual. (2008). http://www.clarke.edu/media/files/Academic_Affairs/Faculty_Evaluation/ facultyevaluationmanual_2008.pdf. Retrieved on February 18, 2009.Elmore, H. W. (2008). Toward Objectivity in Faculty Evaluation. Academe Online. http://www.aaup.org/AAUP/pubsres/academe/2008/MJ/Feat/elmo.htm. Retrieved on February 19, 2009 StudentsPeersTeachingY/NSource WeightSource Impact WeightSource RatingY/NSource WeightSource Impact WeightSource RatingInstructional DeliveryY100%35%4 x 35%N0%0% Instructional DesignY25%10%4 x 10%Y50%15%3 x 15%Content ExpertiseN0%0% Y40%10%4 x 10%Course ManagementN0%0% N0%0%    45%   25% Scholarship        Personal DevelopmentN0%0% N0%0% Original ResearchN0%0% Y30%10%4 x 10%Publication, Poster etc.

N0%0% Y30%10%3 x 10%   0%   20% Service        InstitutionalN0%0% N0%0% CommunityN0%0% N0%0% OtherN0%0% N0%0%    0%   0% SelfDept. ChairY/NSource WeightSource Impact WeightSource RatingY/NSource WeightSource Impact WeightSource RatingN0%0% N0%0% Y25%10%4 x 10%N0%0% Y20%5%4 x 5%Y40%10%4 x 10%Y0%0% Y100%5%3 x 5%  15%   15%         Y50%25% 3 x 25%Y50%25%3 x 25%Y30%5%4 x 5%Y40%10%4 x 10%Y40%5%3 x 5%Y30%10%3 x 10%  35%   45%         Y35%10%4 x 10%Y65%50%3 x 50%Y35%10%3 x 10%Y65%15%2 x 15%Y35%5%2 x 5%Y65%10%2 x10%  25%   75% Total Source Impact WeightRole Component Weight (Must Add up to 100%)Final Weighted Rating 35%1.4 35%1.25 25%1 5%0.

15100%100%3.8    50%1.5 25%1 25%0.75100%100%3.25    60%1.9 25%0.6 15%0.3100%100%2.8

Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Composite Role Rating Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 words”, n.d.)
Retrieved de https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1552046-composite-role-rating
(Composite Role Rating Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words)
https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1552046-composite-role-rating.
“Composite Role Rating Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1552046-composite-role-rating.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Composite Role Rating

Specificity of Children Play Therapy

The paper "Specificity of Children Play Therapy" underlines that child-centred play therapy plays a significant role in understanding the underlying troubles leading to the development of behavioural problems.... It is a tool that can help to deal with difficult behaviours with patient and empathy....
7 Pages (1750 words) Research Paper

Psychological Factors on Eating Disorders

This essay presents the psychological factors of eating disorders which have become a big issue over the past few decades.... Much of this has to do with movies, advertisements and what is considered socially acceptable as regards what the Western culture thinks women should look like.... nbsp;… As the paper, Psychological Factors on Eating Disorders, stresses ballerinas, models, film actresses, any women whose appearance is part of making a living, suffer from the image that being rail-thin is essential to success....
6 Pages (1500 words) Research Paper

How Do We Select Our Life Mates

Abstract Social researchers study numerous human behaviors.... One of them is the selection of ideal life mate.... Both researchers and ordinary people pay paramount importance to this issue.... … Abstract Social researchers study numerous human behaviors.... One of them is the selection of ideal life mate....
9 Pages (2250 words) Research Paper

Motivational Behavior

The participants included 48 college students (24 females and 24 males) who each filled out the questionnaire rating the partner of the opposite sex in terms of physical attractiveness on a scale from 1 to 10 where 10 is the highest rating of attractiveness.... The participants were given an attractiveness rating based on a panel of judges.... In addition to this, the researcher found that there was a high correlation between similar levels of attractiveness and the happier the couple's rating in degrees of physical intimacy (Silverman, 1971)....
16 Pages (4000 words) Essay

Article Abstract 03

The negative shows increase in the fan rating.... The role of uncertainty of outcome and scoring in the determination of fan satisfaction in National Football League is the title name for journal article.... Fans also enjoyed high scoring games against low scoring games and they prefer seeing the two top rated teams together in a match instead of two Article and The role of uncertainty of outcome and scoring in the determination of fan satisfaction in National Football League is the title name for journal article....
1 Pages (250 words) Essay

Psychological Factors on Eating Disorder Symptom and Diet Induced Emotional Reaction

Much of this has to do with movies, advertisements and what is considered socially acceptable as regards what the Western culture thinks women should… Ballerinas, models, film actresses, any women whose appearance is part of making a living, suffer from the image that being rail-thin is essential to success....
6 Pages (1500 words) Research Paper

How Do We Select Our Life Mates

"How Do We Select Our Life Mates" paper conducts a survey to determine self-portraits of 190 respondents through a set of questionnaires.... Questionnaires were tailored to characterize respondents per the Big-five model theory.... The respondents described the portrait of their expected life partners....
10 Pages (2500 words) Research Paper

Unemployed Challenging Gender Roles

This literature review "Unemployed Challenging Gender Roles" discusses changes in the current working environment where, for a number of factors, men and women are entering jobs that have been associated with the opposite sex.... The article gives examples including Mike Oczkowski.... hellip; The decision for Mike Oczkowski to register and enter into a new profession, nursing, is according to him, “I wanted something that would give me security, but also a sense of fulfillment,"....
9 Pages (2250 words) Literature review
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us