Comparing and Contrasting Poetry - Essay Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
The choice of vocabulary is also primary to setting the mood. Both of them talk about how things appear, but allow the reader to discern the real truth. While poetry often…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER91.4% of users find it useful
Comparing and Contrasting Poetry
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "Comparing and Contrasting Poetry"

Revealing the Undercoat Both of these poems use a strong iambic rhythm to set up the mood and then to deal the reader a surprise. The choice of vocabulary is also primary to setting the mood. Both of them talk about how things appear, but allow the reader to discern the real truth. While poetry often uses the reader’s reaction to the words to convey its message, these two poems are more straightforward about what the poet thinks. The major differences between the two poems are in the use of imagery and the ease with which the reader participates. The poem by Robinson is easier to access and, in some ways, lighter, and the distance of the poet from the subject creates an atmosphere within which we can observe what is really going on. Both poems illustrate strong emotions: envy and love.
The strong iambic trimeter of Papa’s Waltz is made slightly uneven by the extra unstressed syllable on the even lines, suggesting that, perhaps, the steps of the waltz are not exactly even either. However, in Richard Cory, we have iambic pentameter and the quatrain structure rhyming every other line, suggestive of a sonnet, which is only changed by adding the last two lines. The slightly uneven meter of Roethke’s poem creates a certain image of a stumbling dance, while Robinson’s keeps its perfect structure throughout, mirroring the poem’s statement of the perfection of Richard Cory.
While there is a lot of imagery and symbolism in Papa’s Waltz, the poem Richard Cory is a symbol in itself, almost a painting in words, representing everything we dream about and everyone we envy. We hear description of things like he was “imperially slim”, or he “glittered when he walked”. Robinson uses words that hint of royalty: crown, king and imperially, but contrasts these with the meagerness of saying that “we” (the narrator’s group) “went without the meat, and cursed the bread”.
Roethke is a bit more subtle with his poem, first allowing us to peek in at the scene, watching the boy and his drunken father stomp about. We know that the household is not rich, and that the father is a manual laborer, or maybe a farmer, from the dirt caked rough hands. The language is plain and driect, using words like “romped” and “scraped” while the language in Richard Cory is quite formal, increasing the mood of quiet admiration which bordered upon envy, and increasing the power of the simply stated ending.
We suspect that the father in Roethkes poem is, at least a little, abusive. However, there is also a certain relationship shown between the man and the boy as the poet tells us that “mother’s countenance could not unfrown itself”. This word may be the strongest image in the poem, because the poet chose to take the extreme of saying that she could not stop it, but she also could not stop them. The man and the boy are in their very own world, further strengthened by the use of Papa for the father and the more formal “mother” for Mama. They are both defying the mother’s idea of proper decorum, partners in crime, and this is a bond between them. Even though the boy was probably abused, he “held on like death” to his father and clung to his shirt as Papa waltzed him off to bed. He respected many things in his father and was willing to overlook the roughness, because he loved him deeply. It was interesting to note the disagreement among scholars concerning the interpretation of this poem, and John McKenna points out that Rhoetke’s revisions increased the ambiguity of the poem. (McKenna, John 1998)
Both poems depend upon contrast and surprise for their main impact, but My Papa’s Waltz” rather sneaks up on the wonderful realization of this family and their love, while Richard Cory sets us up with exciting description and then delivers the smacking blow at the end.
McKenna, John J., 1998,ANQ; Spring98, Vol. 11 Issue 2, p34, 5p,
*Add your citations for your versions of the poems. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
(“Comparing and Contrasting Poetry Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 words”, n.d.)
Comparing and Contrasting Poetry Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 words. Retrieved from
(Comparing and Contrasting Poetry Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words)
Comparing and Contrasting Poetry Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words.
“Comparing and Contrasting Poetry Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words”, n.d.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Comparing and Contrasting Poetry

Comparing And Contrasting Wireless Security

...discussing secured public networks while the latter is discussing unsecured public networks (or “hotspots”) like one might find in a coffee shop. That might explain the greater pessimism of Potter (2006) in comparison to the other authors. He compares the “hotspot” network to a storm in which all users are simply searching for any port that will lead them to the internet (p. 53). He goes on to comment that system administrators of an unsecured public network are always more concerned with protecting the security of their systems, rather than the security of their users, which means that “users of wireless hotspots are ultimately responsible for their own security” (Potter, 2006, p. 54). This sounds very similar to the...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay

Comparing and contrasting

...? Running head: Compare and Contrast Compare and Contrast: A Long Way Gone with Hotel Rwanda First and Name Abstract The book, A Long Way Gone, and movie Hotel Rwanda, both tell of civil unrest in Africa. The purpose of this paper is to compare and contrast the similarities and differences in the situations and characters presented. Also as a part of this, a personal opinion will be given as to which character is more identifiable. Compare and Contrast: A Long Way Gone with Hotel Rwanda Africa has undergone much turmoil over the past few decades. Lack of descent healthcare, food, and shelter, combined...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay

Comparing and Contrasting Diverse Roles

...?Comparing and Contrasting Diverse Roles A project manager plays different roles during the of the project. These roles depend on the nature of the project and the qualification of the project manager. The more skilled or educated a project manager the more diverse roles the manager has to deal with. Particular roles are associated with particular project management tasks. For instance, for a financial or IT related project, the project manager will probably be mainly concerned with testing various systems for ensuring their usability and efficiency. However, there are common sets of duties and responsibilities that all project managers, regardless of their qualification and project’s nature, have to fulfill. These common roles... requires...
3 Pages(750 words)Research Paper

Comparing & Contrasting Authorities

...YAO Xinyu No: YAXIC51 QCA1208 Modernism & Postmodernism Semester: Semester 2006 Assignment: Assignment Assignment 1 Pablo Picasso has made tremendous contributions towards the improvement of the global economy that influences our society today. Having passed away in 1973, his paintings are some of the most famous & sought-after masterpieces that are definitely priceless & irreplaceable due to their uniqueness & rich content. Apart from his works being displayed in most major museums of great importance around the world, anyone belonging to the elite & rich would unarguably love to have an original collected. On the basis of this argument, the three articles that I will be comparing as part of this paper are...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay

Comparing and contrasting poems

...A Comparison between Morales’ “Child of the Americas” and McKay’s “America” “Child of the Americas”by Aurora Levins Morales and “America” by Claude McKay are two of the many poems that revolve around the complications and the achievements of immigrants in the land of opportunity. Morales, born in 1954, is a Puerto Rican Jewish writer and poet. She is a very proactive lady, largely interested in protecting women’s rights which is apparent in her poetry. She is most famous among the circles of Latina Feminism. She has been part of many projects regarding the third world feminism other than the several other justice movements that she was part of. On the other hand, Claude McKay was born in another century, in 1890. He was...
5 Pages(1250 words)Essay

Poetry Comparing and Contrasting

...Aviva Kopolovitz Marotta English 165W 10/23/14 Comparing and Contrasting Poems The poem To His Coy Mistress by Andrew Marvell depicts a young lady who has been slow with respect to responding to sexual advances of a young man. The young man spends a lot of time admiring each body part of the young women despite the resistance she directs towards his advances. In Those Winter Sundays by Robert Hayden, we see an adult speaker who depicts the ways in which his father expresses love and concern towards him based on the actions he engaged in. Both of these poems To His Coy Mistress and Those Winter Sundays contain common elements that will show the similarities and differences of their content. From the two...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay

Comparing and Contrasting

...brighter colors, the end result is the same, the color brings out the form. Looking at the Kooning, you notice the similarity with Portuguese in the way that space has been utilized, there are other spots on the painting that have not been painted. We could agree that De Kooning painted women more than any other subject but that is not what he is known for. The difference that is so obvious between these paintings is the vigorous way that De Kooning used his paint strokes. They are dominant as compared to the delicate strokes of George in the Portuguese. The color is subdued with the Portuguese while in the Woman it is the first aspect of the painting that speaks to you. There is more sensuality in the Woman painting...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay

Comparing and contrasting

...Comparing and Contrasting USA and Australian Constitution Comparing and Contrasting USA and Australian Constitution Introduction The paper compares and contrasts the Constitution of Australia with that of United States of America. The analysis is based on the methods of limitation of state power as provided for in the two constitutions of the two countries. The paper makes a critical examination of Federalism, separation of powers and parliamentary sovereignty in the two countries. Moreover, the contrast and comparison focus on the Bicameralism, bills of rights and heads of power as reflected in the each country’s...
6 Pages(1500 words)Essay

Comparing and contrasting

...Compare and Contrast The Law Battles There are two cases and a legal text to be examined in this paper, there will e a comparison of the facts and judgment given as follows. In the Botha case there were four complaints lodged against the appellant, while in the Davey case there was only one complaint. After a thorough investigation the law society came to the conclusion that the appellant had not deposited all the monies that he had received for the transfer into his trust account and the deposited monies was not done in a prompt manner, the appellant records of accounts did not reflect all the transactions of the practice and the accounting records were not updated. The appellant was not accountable to...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay

Comparing and contrasting

...Comparing and Contrasting Comparing and Contrasting Constitutions tend to vary from one nation to another. This is because the provisions of any constitution are guided by the laws of a country. Since the laws might be different between nations, then the constitutions might also be different. However, in some instances, constitutions can have similarities. The United States Constitution and the Australian Constitution have some similarities and differences. This paper will compare and contrast the United States and Australian Constitution. In the comparison, the factor to be considered is the limitation of state power. More specifically,...
6 Pages(1500 words)Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Essay on topic Comparing and Contrasting Poetry for FREE!

Contact Us