Nobody downloaded yet

To what extent is it still true to say that legal justice in England and Wales rests upon adversarialism - Essay Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
The legal system obtaining in England and Wales is based upon the adversarial system of justice this is in marked contrast to the system prevalent in the Netherlands and Germany, which is inquisitorial. In an adversarial system the trial is reminiscent of a combat between two…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER96.6% of users find it useful
To what extent is it still true to say that legal justice in England and Wales rests upon adversarialism
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "To what extent is it still true to say that legal justice in England and Wales rests upon adversarialism"

Download file to see previous pages In such a system a decision is arrived at by a neutral decision maker on the basis of the details furnished by the parties. In respect of criminal cases two decision makers will be present, namely the judge and the jury; the duty of the former is to decide on the legal aspects whereas the duty of the latter is confined to factual issues.2
Moreover, the large number of legal commentators has designated the Australian and American legal systems as being adversarial legal systems. “Such classification is made because the primary and dominant legal procedure in this system is adjudication on legal disputes defined by the parties who bring those disputes to court for adjudication”3.
The adoption of an adversarial system in England has been attributed to first, the practice of compurgation. This practice was an Anglo-Saxon defence in which several persons were made to testify in respect of a person’s innocence and second, the culmination of the extant English legal procedures like trial by jury and private prosecution4.
I believe strongly that our adversarial process is the most effective way of trying criminal issues. However, the legal system has begun to recognise that pure adversarialism does not always produce justice, and more effort is now going into establishing areas of consensus between prosecution and defence. For example, judges are reining in needless, destructive cross-examination which puts people such as rape victims on trial, and procedures are being invented to prevent ambush tactics which involve one side taking the other completely by surprise5.
The English legal system is primarily adversarial in composition. In this system resolution of issues is achieved by means of argument between the disputing parties in the presence of the presiding judge. This organization is methodical but costly and a considerable amount of time is taken in deciding ...Download file to see next pagesRead More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
(“To what extent is it still true to say that legal justice in England Essay - 1”, n.d.)
Retrieved from
(To What Extent Is It Still True to Say That Legal Justice in England Essay - 1)
“To What Extent Is It Still True to Say That Legal Justice in England Essay - 1”, n.d.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF To what extent is it still true to say that legal justice in England and Wales rests upon adversarialism

LLB Company Law England and Wales

...actual omission involving default, negligence, breach of trust or breach of duty. Under this, as exclusion to the rule laid down in Foss v Harbottle, a statutory derivative claim can be initiated by a shareholder against the company directors, and this section does not complement the rule laid down in Foss v Harbottle but simply offers a legal procedure for a derivative action.(Hicks & Goo 2008:430). In this case, Brian can make a derivative action against the directors to reimburse the loss sustained by the company. Further , board has kept silent even after finding the lapse and Brain has every right to sue the directors of the company, including Marcus for their act of negligence . Issue II “Duty to promote the...
10 Pages(2500 words)Essay

Homicide in England and Wales

...?Homicide in England and Wales Based on traditions, the legal system in England and Wales can be considered distinct from those followed by the othertwo countries of the United Kingdom (Institute of Legal Executives 2011, Section “How criminal law is enforced in the England and Wales”). This is possibly the reason why in the documentation of the crime and offence statistics by His Majesty’s Home Office, the documentation for England and Wales are separated from Northern Ireland and Scotland. In this analytical paper, we focus on the offence of manslaughter. Table 1....
6 Pages(1500 words)Essay

ADR in England and Wales

...offering by the government after the shift in the provision of legal services, currently, has been the Community Legal Service (CLS) – binding sectors, services and funding through a thin thread. Potential in the mechanism and working of CLS can be measured by ___________________________ 4University of London, P. 63. selecting certain regions to know the role of these services in meeting the legal needs of the local people besides discussing the problems of widening gaps between the demand and supply of justice because of the under-nourished and divided CLS infrastructure, threatening the presence of CLS from the huge layer of unwanted bureaucracy. In the context of...
12 Pages(3000 words)Essay

Equity and Trusts (England and Wales)

...” will be regarded as establishing the settlor’s intention to create a trust.3 On the facts of the case for discussion, Sir Clarence specifically instructed his friend Tilda to hold both 200,000 pounds and his seaside cottage upon “trust” for his daughter Davina and her children in equal shares. Thus there can be no doubt that Sir Clarence intended to create a trust out of the transfer of the property/gifts to Tilda. In order to give effect to Sir Clarence’s intention to create a trust, certainty of subject and object must be satisfactorily established.4 In this regard, certainty of subject matter is sufficiently established if the property transferred or to be transferred to the trust can be identified and...
8 Pages(2000 words)Essay

Models of Criminal Justice System in England and Wales

...1 MODELS OF CRIMINAL JUSTICE IN ENGLAND AND WALES While England and Wales are trying to weather the economic recession, it had been noticed that there is a surge of crimes such as burglary, theft, shoplifting, forgery, fraud and sexual violence. Thus, Chris Huhne had been quoted as saying that such statistics were eloquent proof that "crime increases as the recession bites". In 2008 alone, 284,000 domestic burglaries had been recorded. Likewise, there were 38,082 crimes involving violent and sexual knife offences (Edwards, 2009, England and Wales try to cope with this...
6 Pages(1500 words)Essay

The criminal justice system in England and Wales

...Running Head: CRIMINAL JUSTICE SYSTEM Criminal Justice System [The [The of the The Criminal Justice System In England And Wales Is In A State Of Almost Continuous Change Introduction A comparative learn of two media forms such as newspapers is conducted by means of a simple systematic move toward. This approach occupied taking sections of the articles inside the newspaper and analysing them on a variety of factors such as images, context, lexis, syntax and linguistics. We appreciate images to be any form of graphical in order, context as the major story and the standard ideas it represents, lexis as the actual language used, grammar as the agreement of the lexis and linguistics as verbal communication devices such as influential... ...
8 Pages(2000 words)Essay

The Criminal Justice System of England and Wales

.... Such legislations may be contested by the parliament which is composed of the Monarch and the House of Commons. This is because the acts of the Parliament can override common law provisions. Moreover, its membership in the European Union requires it to follow the European community law. The World Factbook of Criminal Justice Systems also said that the legal system in England and Wales is "adversarial" in all courts, including the juvenile courts. Its criminal justice is the "historical pioneer" of the common law type of legal system. More often than not, the law evolves through the decisions made in previous...
7 Pages(1750 words)Essay

Consumer law in england and wales

...The evolution of the Internet and online growth has facilitated novel business opportunities through the ad hoc evolution of electronic commerce, thereby creating a new business model (Reed, 2004). Directly correlated to the internet business model is the EU driven wave of legislative proposals geared towards consumer protection to address the challenges of the digital trading medium, which has directly impacted consumer law in England and Wales. The focus of this analysis is to critically evaluate the impact of European legislation on consumer law in England and Wales. It is submitted at the outset that the nature of consumer driven measures from the EU has been...
13 Pages(3250 words)Article

Business Law: Courts in England and Wales

...explicitly in law. In some cases, English court’s interpretations of statutory provisions reflect the intention of parliament, while in other cases they do not. This is especially true in cases which do not comport with European Law (Nourse 70). The Principal Rules In England and Wales, judges normally adopt certain presumptions in an effort to interpret a statute (Rakoff 1560). Firstly, a presumption is something that is held to be true unless a factual argument voids it. These assumptions are: that the law remains the same unless the statutory provision in question shows a precise intention to alter it; the doctrine of Mens Rea or guilty mind required to support...
5 Pages(1250 words)Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Essay on topic To what extent is it still true to say that legal justice in England and Wales rests upon adversarialism for FREE!

Contact Us