Nobody downloaded yet

Analysis of Jane Eyre similarities between Bertha and Jane - Essay Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
Summary
To attempt an extensive comparative study of similarities between Jane Eyre and Bertha is like searching for a needle in a haystack because on the physical, emotional and intellectual level, they are poles apart. Perhaps one can attempt this from an entirely psychological point of view and clutch at Jane's childhood days as the straw - a slightly weighty straw, however.
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER93.1% of users find it useful
Analysis of Jane Eyre similarities between Bertha and Jane
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "Analysis of Jane Eyre similarities between Bertha and Jane"

Download file to see previous pages While Jane dominates the whole novel, it is only towards the third part of the novel that we are exposed to Bertha in person. Physically there is no comparison whatsoever, as there are no grounds at all. Jane is plain but not ugly; Bertha is grotesque. A comparison is possible only between the deeply subconscious state of Bertha and Jane's childhood misery, where she is confined to the frightful hole and wallows in terror.
In the second chapter, the little child Jane gets scared and screams " Miss Jane screamed so loud Madam" (Bronte 12), pleads Bessie. Mrs. Reed condemns her as a "precocious actress in the eyes, a compound of virulent passions, mean spirit and dangerous duplicity" (Bronte 12). Jane is a creature of circumstances. She is unable "to bear the doctrine of endurance."
Perhaps one may attempt a comparison to Bertha in this context, far fetched though it is likely to be. Chapter 3 talks of Jane being "wretched of mind" (Bronte 14). There is wretchedness in her heart. It is there in Bertha too. Why else would a mentally deranged woman rip the wedding veil apart and crush it underfoot
Rochester in the guise of the fortune teller talks of Jane's "melancholy arising from loneliness" (Bronte 176) as reflected in her eye. Bertha is mad. Is her madness melancholy Bertha's reaction to the veil creates such a doubt in the reader, though one tends to squash it and attribute the action to her madness. Jane speaks of herself as "passionate but not vindictive" (Bronte 211) to her dying aunt. Bertha also is passionate - capable of intense feeling. Grace Poole calls her 'tolerable', 'snappish', 'not 'rageous today' (Bronte 259)
Only the child Jane who mentions that she was beside herself or rather out of herself and is referred to as a "mad cat" can help bring comparisons to the forefront.
"Dear dear ! What a fury to fly at Master John!
Did ever anybody see such a picture of passion!" (Bronte 7)
She is said to be an underhand little thing with so much cover. Abigail says, "It was always in her" and that "I have told Missus often my opinion about the child, and Missus agreed with me. She is an underhand little thing. I never saw a girl of her age with so much cover" (Bronte 8).The little Jane revolts against injustice vigorously. Her reason screams "Unjust! Unjust!". Mr. Lloyd talks to himself and says that her nerves are not in a good state. In Chapter 6, Jane, on a wave of introspection attributes her lack of good home and parents to her abnormal reasoning - wishing the wind to howl more wildly and "the confusion to rise to clamour" (Bronte 46). The first that we hear of Bertha is her laugh "mirthless, curious, distinct" (Bronte 92)
As Dr. Sally Minogue states (Minogue, XVIII), "Sandra Gilbert and Susan Gubar, in their groundbreaking study of nineteenth century fiction talk about psychoanalytic rather than realist terms. Following this, we can be persuaded that " Bertha's Gothic disruptions are Jane's rebellions writ large. Both threaten social stability, and both are contained, Bertha physically, Jane by self restraint. The red room is deliberately recalled in Bertha's incarceration in the third storey, and the she-devil called Mrs. Reed sees in the ten year old Jane, 'all fire and violence' (p. 211), prefigures Bertha's ...Download file to see next pagesRead More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Analysis of Jane Eyre similarities between Bertha and Jane Essay”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1534794-analysis-of-jane-eyre-similarities-between-bertha-and-jane
(Analysis of Jane Eyre Similarities Between Bertha and Jane Essay)
https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1534794-analysis-of-jane-eyre-similarities-between-bertha-and-jane.
“Analysis of Jane Eyre Similarities Between Bertha and Jane Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1534794-analysis-of-jane-eyre-similarities-between-bertha-and-jane.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Analysis of Jane Eyre similarities between Bertha and Jane

Victorian literature Jane Eyre, Tess of the D'Urbervilles and The Tenant of Wildfell Hall

...a happy life thereafter – Jane and Rochester marry, Jane bears Rochester a son, and Adele becomes a helpful companion to Jane. Diana and Mary, her cousins, are also happily married, and St. John achieved his dream of becoming a missionary. Although this novel is different than Tess in tone and in the ending, it bears many similarities to Tess as well. For instance, both novels deal with heroines who rebel against societal mores and strictures, and attempt to gain independence from male patriarchy. Tess in Hardy's novel does this by killing Alec, although Tess does this act not to live life on her own, but, rather, to live life on her terms with Angel....
29 Pages(7250 words)Dissertation

Charlotte Bronte Jane Eyre

...?Is Bertha (Mr Rochester's wife) the only crazy woman in the house? In what way Jane is insane? Besides Bertha, Jane can also be considered as an insane person for reasons that can be well understood from a philosophical point of view. When somebody passionately wants to stay isolated, this is insanity. We see in Jane’s personality that she is most of the time feeling comfortable in solitude. When she comes to know about Bertha, she leaves Rochester even she was madly in love with him. Bertha can be considered as a metaphorical character representing Jane’s rage towards the society that has been...
1 Pages(250 words)Essay

Jane Eyre

...?Analyse the role of childhood in Jane Eyre. The novel Jane Eyre tells the story of a young woman from the age of about ten until her marriage in adult life to Mr Rochester. There are two contrasting views of childhood in the book, and they are the childhood of orphaned and impoverished Jane herself, along with the children in Lowood school on the one hand and the childhood of her cousins, the Reeds, and of her own pupil, Adele, on the other hand, who all come from an upper class background. The book explores the pros and cons of growing up in both of these social classes and this is one of the main themes of the novel. This paper considers the...
4 Pages(1000 words)Coursework

Jane Eyre: Gender Roles

...that Jane Eyre undergoes all the bad experiences in her life due to her childishness, but that is far from the truth. Critics may attribute Mrs. Reed’s humiliation towards Jane Eyre as a consequence of the age difference between the two, specifically when Jane Eyre asks Mrs. Reed why her behavior with her is so rude and Mrs. Reed retorts that she is not fond of addressing others’ queries. She tells Jane Eyre that being younger to her, she is not supposed to question her and that she is supposed to conform to the norms while talking or remain quiet. But an in-depth...
6 Pages(1500 words)Research Paper

Jane eyre

...Jane Eyre Jane Eyre is one of a kind story about women in that Victorian Period. The main character, Jane Eyre, growing as a humble, polite, orphan girl who was always under oppression from her guardian, Mrs. Reed and school teacher, Mr. Brocklehurst, managed to become an autonomous lady. In a society where women always became oppressed and their voices could not be heard, the author, Jane Eyre, tried to bring out the plight of women by the use of the character, Bertha Mason. Jane Eyre, by using Bertha Mason, present her own plight and...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay

Jane Eyre

...that when they talked. Rochester also considers Jane Eyre to be strict and holds back issues nonetheless; he thinks this is as a result of her being a student and a leader and for quiet some while and hence with another company she would relax a little. The ending in “Jane Eyre” is not a traditional love story but a non-conformist in the sense that, as the story ends, in the beginning of the last chapter the narrator say tells us that she married him. This makes us happy as we see a wedding happen yet it had been stopped earlier. A man breaks up the wedding ceremony by telling a large number of people that the bridegroom, Rochester in this case had a wife who was still...
8 Pages(2000 words)Essay

Jane Eyre

...Jane Eyre Jane Eyre tries to preserve her self-respect, independence and self-sufficiency at every stage of her life, both in struggling with socialpressure and in resisting the temptation of passion. This statement was innovation in the literally world of the 19th century. The novel "Jane Eyre" written by Charlotte Bronte greatly influences the reader and gives another vision of society and world in the whole. The novel was published in 1847. And it is a matter of fact that this novel made the author famous all over the world. The main reason for this is that this novel became an innovation in world literature. It was unusual for that...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay

Script for Jane Eyre

...and build up Jane Eyre’s story towards a climax through the use of suggestion and context. The screen adaptation cannot be as exhaustive as the written book due to the limitations of screen time; however the project is similar to the book “Rebecca”, in that the opening pages of the book which describe a dream are like a composite of the entire story. The screen version of the Jane Eyre story achieves the same objective of providing a capsule of the entire storyline, through a focus upon specific scenes which are important, while other less important scenes are shown in the form of a montage or a rapid flash of several scenes which give a general idea...
8 Pages(2000 words)Essay

This an assignment regarding a retirement community in arizona named sun lake. It is a group projject below is my part

1 Pages(250 words)Essay

Jane Eyre

... to be unpleasant, harsh and cruel. Miss scratched treats harshly Helen. Miss Temple has a good attitude towards others. She believes the story of Jane and offers her seed cake and tea together with Helen. She does not give in the idea of cutting the girls’ hair. She appears to Jane as being compassionate and reverent which is not the case to Miss Scatched. . Work cited Fisher, Clarice. The Narration and Structure of Charlotte Bronte's Novels. , 1980. Print Bronte, Charlotte. Jane Eyre Summary and Analysis. 1999. 06 05 2014. Jane Eyre › Study Guide‎>.... Jane Eyre In the novel Jane Eyre, Jane the main character goes through several people and experiences that help to...
1 Pages(250 words)Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Essay on topic Analysis of Jane Eyre similarities between Bertha and Jane for FREE!

Contact Us