The Case Against Tipping - Essay Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
The focal point of the article highlights the negativity of tipping in the present times. While many people believe that tipping is a way of ensuring continued good service (Obringer), Lewis finds the growing appeals for tips as disturbing. The author's opening statement (1) is valid only on undue practice of gratuity…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER94.3% of users find it useful
The Case Against Tipping
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "The Case Against Tipping"

The Case Against Tipping In his article, Michael Lewis voices his bold view opposing obligatory gratuity or tipping. The points out the downbeat surface of tipping. The main argument seems to go like this:
(1) Growing appeals for gratuities are disturbing and taxing.
(2) Tipping must be inhibited.
The focal point of the article highlights the negativity of tipping in the present times. While many people believe that tipping is a way of ensuring continued good service (Obringer), Lewis finds the growing appeals for tips as disturbing. The author's opening statement (1) is valid only on undue practice of gratuity. His premise is arguable considering that he failed to substantiate the real value of gratuity as being completely lost. He overlooks that argument as he himself gives the benefit of the doubt that some people really tip out of generosity.
That tipping must be ignored (2) would significantly affect employees who rely on this extra source of income to alleviate themselves of poverty which is not improved by their meager salary. Although there are undeniably benefits and advantages of gratuity on server and patron alike, he dismisses that tipping puts the economy in an unfavorable baksheesh shape. In this point he is correct, taking into account that the government is losing an estimated $7 to $10 billion of earnings in tips that go unreported (Snyder). Moreover, there is the possibility that aside from cabs and restaurants, other sectors of the society will adapt this practice. Lewis suggests that reticence or silence on the matter may worsen the issue in the future. He concludes that standing up against the unwarranted custom may be advantageous.
That the essence of gratuity has vanished in the modern times is most compelling. Now, waiters and waitresses believe that it is their right to be tipped (Shaw). Nowadays, tipping is expected even if the quality of service is not significantly worthy of an extra favor coming from the customer. Although Lewis also explicate that tipping is an aristocratic conceit, what really prompts a tip seems to be missing. It is very much logical that the workers are but rendering the service that they are already salaried to do. What was once a tradition of the customer's demonstration of sincere generosity is crudely replaced by a superfluous inconvenience to the patron as it becomes obligatory. Instead of this act of kindness being unreservedly awarded by the customer, the patron is pressured to tip. Although not punishable by law, not tipping is prejudiced as rudeness when it is not even compulsion, in the first place. Even undertipping instigate discrimination in society. Ironically, in other nations like Japan, the custom of tipping is regarded as impolite and a slap in the face to the server.
Customary tipping must be avoided. It is an optional act and it must be non-compulsory in this democratic times. The times have surely changed this act of appreciation to an obligatory burden. It should be kept in mind that gratuity is simply a form of generosity or token of appreciation for a noteworthy act of service; a monetary recognition rendered to a deserving employee. Employees should perform their duties without demanding or being expectant of the extra favor. In the same manner, their service is not supposed to be dependent on the tip they are receiving. Good service motivates a tip and must not be the other way around. The supposed symbiotic relationship between employee and customer must be guarded so as not to turn into a parasitic one. Patrons must not be compelled to tip when they feel that it is unnecessary or undeserved. But the advantages of tipping-in the truest sense of the practice-must equally be taken into consideration. We must not discount the benefits of practicing gratuity. In one way it promotes both sides valuing the role of the other in each other's subsistence. In the case of employees desperately relying on tips, that dilemma can be cured by the management itself by giving its employees a fair salary that they deserve and should instead present a reasonable service charge instead of augmenting the deficiency through tips.
The Consequences of "Carnage as Entertainment"
John Ellis posted in this article various cases involving minors in shootouts. He states that violence depicted on television affects the actions of these children. His main argument seems to go like this:
(1) There is correlation between violence depicted in the media and the violence in American life.
(2) Violent behavior is also incited by the idea of earning a reputation.
While it is true that there is linkage between violence in television and violence in society particularly in the United States, the author failed to consider other channels by which violence is promoted. Websites and mature computer games also play a significant role in violence. In (2), his claim is unsubstantiated and speculative. But it is true that television networks compete with each other to get the exclusive right of the instant celebrity's story. News at it is, news broadcast display violence as well and contributing to the chain of violence depicted in media.
That media's great influence particularly in children's emotion and behavior is undeniable. What worsens the issue is the fact that children have their own entertainment equipment. According to the Annenberg Public Policy Center, 57 percent of kids aged 8 to 16 have TVs in their bedrooms, and 39 per cent have gaming equipment (Media Awareness).
It is pertinent to assess how children process media content and what effect that processing experience has on their thoughts, feelings, and actions (Impact). Violence is even evident in cartoons that very young children can freely watch. Researchers observed that the children who watched the violent cartoon were much more likely to hit other children and break toys (Media Awareness).
Exposure to media violence heightens the level of violent behavior among minors. But because it is virtually impossible to totally eliminate the demonstration violence in media, it is now the responsibility of the immediate family and the society to instill the necessary values and morals to shelter the children from the harsh realities and gradually train them on how to react and handle the inevitable depiction of violence in the surroundings.
Works Cited
Lewis, Michael. "The Case Against Tipping" The New York Times Magazine
21 September 1997
Obringer, Lee Ann. "How Tipping Works" How Stuff Works 20 June 2006
Shaw, Steven A. "Tipped Off" The New York Times 10 August 2005. 20 June 2006
Snyder, Lynn. "No Tips, Please" Washington Free Press 22 June 2006
Ellis, John. "The Consequences of "Carnage as Entertainment" " Boston Globe
19 May 1998
"Violence in Media Entertainment" Media Awareness Network
"The Impact of Entertainment Media Violence on Children and Families"
Iowa State University, University Extension
Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
(“The Case Against Tipping Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 words”, n.d.)
Retrieved from
(The Case Against Tipping Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words)
“The Case Against Tipping Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words”, n.d.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF The Case Against Tipping

Examination of the Tipping Point

...Examination of the Tipping Point Introduction The concept of drastic and dramatic changes is usually a component to modern thinking, both in the ideology of society and biology. However, this is often overlooked in terms of evolution and how various processes take place over time. The defining point which is created between change and staying the same occurs with a tipping point, which begins to rebalance and define various aspects in a different manner. The tipping point is one that is not only responsible for creating a sense of change both biologically and within society. It also becomes important because it creates a dynamic in social analysis while creating an understanding of a...
10 Pages(2500 words)Essay

The Case against Happiness

...? The Case against Happiness number number Teacher’s Due The Case against Happiness The story, The Lady with the Dog, by Anton Chekhov, is one that talks of the impossibility of finding love in modern life. Chekhov’s works, like those of Tolstoy, talk of the futility of attempting to find love and happiness through conjugal relations between a man and a woman. This futility is at once nihilistic and also a result of the historical forces that shaped the work of these writers. This paper shall attempt to explore this celebration of sorrow through an analysis of the short story, The Lady with the Dog, by Anton Chekhov. The paper shall seek to highlight the social and...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay

The Tipping Point

...? The Tipping Point Although a great many factors help to define the current world in which we live, one of the realities that has been definitively proven is with regards to the rapid pace and development of new ideas. One of the main contributing factors to the way in which ideas are rapidly generated, engaged with, and either accepted or thrown by the wayside is with regards to the increasing level of technological dependence that has been evidenced over the past several decades. In seeking to understand and analyze the means by which ideas are adopted, championed, and either accepted or disregarded, the book, The Tipping Point seeks to categorize the means by which this process takes place. Far more than endeavoring to define... ; as was...
3 Pages(750 words)Book Report/Review

The Case Against Evolution

...The Case Against Evolution This essay addresses whether evolution ought to be taught in public schools. In my view, the answer is that there is no valid basis for including evolution in public school curriculums. My arguments are not based on the Culture Wars commonly presented in the mass media. Rather, my arguments are based on the observation that evolution is an unproven concept, as it pertains to the origins of life on Earth, and that it is too often manipulated by people with a political agenda. To this end, this essay will discuss the nature of the evolution argument, why it should not be taught in public schools, and the implications if it were included in public school curriculums. In order to...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

Major Assignment 1

...The Case against Tipping by Michael Lewis Yes, tip jars can seem pointless when not much service is performed like “merely [handing] you a $2 muffin and perhaps a ruinous cup of coffee and then [ringing] them up on the register (Lewis),” but the word tip means to insure prompt service according to the Webster dictionary and should be done if service is prompt and friendly. Yes, “people who serve you are more likely to do it well and promptly if they will be rewarded (Lewis),” but it is the server’s job to serve you promptly for the weekly paycheck and expecting a tip should not affect service. Yes, “if you fail to tip the...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay

Case against death penalty

...Case against death penalty Death penalty has attracted a lot of debate from society, with some people arguing against it, while others supporting it. As a form of punishment, some justice systems death penalty punishes a collective number of capital offenders who are guilty. Whereas, the definition of capital offenders differs, many offenders who are guilty of taking the life of others fall into the category of capital offenders. Despite that fact that capital offenders attract capital judgment decisions such as the death penalty, there are strong arguments that people have raised against this practice. Some people view that the death penalty is barbaric, expensive, and...
7 Pages(1750 words)Essay

The Case against Marriage

...The Case against Marriage Marriage has been considered as an important social institution since time immemorial. According to many people, tying the knot is the surest way to ensure social stability, bring up children and avoid sexual anarchy. Thus, changes in the nature of marriage in the form of higher divorce rates and cohabitation without marriage are often portrayed as an indication of social decay. However, Bennett and Ellison claim that due to the changed social situation, it is no more necessary to tie the nuptial knot legally to ensure its stability. In other words, getting into a legal marriage does not increase the stability of the union anymore. The authors claim, “legally tying down unions...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

Tipping Points

...of individuals, which could then affect the stability of well established institutions. In the case of the government, it can lead to the rise and fall of regimes. Knowing the anatomy of tipping points is important because it helps governments to control the direction of change, which is really at the heart of public risk management. Tipping points are inevitable but unpredictable occurrences (Nathan 20); it has the potential to introduce new innovations that benefit citizens, or if it not managed properly, could lead a country to chaos. The danger of tipping points was aptly summarized by Deepak Chopra in his article: Is Egypt a Tipping Point or a “Now...
2 Pages(500 words)Admission/Application Essay

Violence Against Women (CASE)

...against women emphasizes all members within the community play a role in ensuring violence against women does not occur. A bystander is the person who witnesses a situation and is neither the victim nor the perpetrator but in someway the person could make a difference if involved in the situation (Postmus, 2013). In many different cases, the bystander program has been found to prevent possible cases of different forms of possible violence. However, in prevention of violence against women, the bystander program has not produced effective results. Most cases of violence against women mainly occur at family level and...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

Tipping point

...The Tipping Point and my personality type Products and ideas, behaviors and messages spread like infections and for someone to understand why things happen this way, they must be well-acquainted with memetics. In The Tipping Point, using engagingly demonstrative anecdotes and clear explanations, Gladwell exemplifies three dominant personality types where each of us can at least find a category where they fit. These are the Connectors, Mavens, and Salesman, three closely related, but different categories of personality that have significantly helped in understanding of people in the business stream. Connectors are perceived to be the trendsetters because of their rich network of acquaintances and...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Essay on topic The Case Against Tipping for FREE!

Contact Us