StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

You Can Blog but You Cannot Hide - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
This essay "You Can Blog but You Cannot Hide" discusses the issue of a journalist’s privilege and considers that if there are such privileges, how far should they extend and by whom, and concludes by stating that once determined then such privileges should be extended to all journalists…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER96.8% of users find it useful
You Can Blog but You Cannot Hide
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "You Can Blog but You Cannot Hide"

       In his article “You Can Blog but You Can’t Hide” Eugene Volokh discusses the issue of a journalist’s privilege and considers that if there are such privileges, how far should they extend and by whom, and concludes by stating that once determined then such privileges should be extended to all journalists.

       Volokh begins his article by creating a hypothetical scenario wherein an “I.R.S. agent” (1) commits a “federal felony” (2) by disclosing “a politician’s income tax” (1) information “to a newspaper reporter” (1). While the reporter has a right to make this information public according to the First Amendment, the government is also “entitled to punish the agent” (4) in the protection of a citizen’s rights to privacy.  By providing this scenario, he invokes a ‘catch twenty-two’ type situation in the mind of his reader and a sense of absurdity.  He then further stimulates this sense of the bizarre by stating that in order “to punish the agent” (4), the government must first attain the name of the informant from the reporter and if the journalist chooses not to provide such information under privilege, the informant “may never be caught” (8). At this point, Volokh gains the interest of his reader, enough to induce him/her to read further.

     Having gained the reader’s attention, Volokh then moves from the hypothetical to reality by introducing the Plame Affair, an incident with which most readers would be familiar and would probably have views on, and a more recent incident in Providence, R.I where a reporter “was convicted of criminal contempt” (13) for not naming the person who “gave him a tape of a city official accepting a bribe” (14). By referring to these actual cases, the reader is more likely to agree with his questions: “Should there be a journalist’s privilege? What should its scope be? And who exactly qualifies as a journalist?” (16/17). In other words, he sets the scene and lays the groundwork first before moving to his real contention.

     At this point in his article, Volokh supports his logic with reference to the inconsistencies in government rulings and the fact that the “courts are now split on whether the privileges exist” (25) and that states are divided on the issue with some acknowledging a journalist’s privilege to different degrees, while others “and the federal government” (27) are not. This inference of authority being in such disarray, and his poignant use of language, such as “a cryptic three-paragraph concurrence” (20), “should try to strike a proper balance” (23),  and “the situation is a mess” (29), help to stimulate the reader’s sense of helplessness and vulnerability.

      Volokh then broadens his line of reasoning from a discussion on whether there should be a journalist’s privilege and its scope to who “qualifies as a journalist?” (17) and further expounds the problem by raising the issue of the “hundreds of thousands” (31) of bloggers who write on the internet, “some of which come with a condition of confidentiality” (32/33). By appealing to the First Amendment once again, he asserts that “freedom of the press should apply to people equally” (35) including bloggers.

     This, however, creates another problem, suggests Volokh, because if “everyone is a journalist” (37) and these privileges are granted to everyone, the “mainstream journalists” (39) will suffer. Informants will be able to bypass any risk of reprisal by publishing through “a friend who has a blog and a political ax to grind” (40), rather than a conventional reporter, who “may turn him in” (39). “On the one hand” (43), he claims information from informants assists reporters to “uncover crime and misconduct” (44), and if the journalists had to disclose the names of their informants, the source of information would disappear. “On the other hand” (45), however, he claims that some information is “rightly made legal” (46).

     The “best solution” (47) to this paradox, according to Volokh, may be to adopt the same laws that are acknowledged by “lawyers, psychotherapists, and spouses” (48), which have an appreciation for the safeguarding of confidentiality. He then appears to counteract his own suggestion by claiming that these laws, however, control the privilege by not protecting exchanges that may lead to “crime or fraud” (51) and are, therefore “limited” (51). At this point, the reader may feel confused and not quite sure where Volokh is heading in terms of the answer but he then proposes that if the privileges given to journalists were also limited and laws protected legal disclosure of information but not illegal exposure of information, then it would be the unlawful informants who would be deterred “from coming forward” (59).

    Whatever the outcome or solution, however, Volokh contends that the “rules should be the same” (61) for all – mainstream journalists and bloggers. Whatever the journalist privileges are he reasons, they “should extend to every journalist” (62).

     In his article, Volokh effectively manages to persuade the reader to either take a stance in terms of a journalist’s privilege or at least to become much more informed about the situation.

(words: 830)

Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Analysis Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 words - 7”, n.d.)
Analysis Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 words - 7. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1529283-analysis
(Analysis Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 Words - 7)
Analysis Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 Words - 7. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1529283-analysis.
“Analysis Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 Words - 7”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1529283-analysis.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF You Can Blog but You Cannot Hide

New Forms of Advertising in Digital Age and Social Media

you can post a blog even on the move.... Gone are the days when you had to switch on your PC for every little thing.... They are however not only restricted to businesses, the “blog” is the 21st century alternative to a website.... What makes a blog so appealing is the fact that anyone can create his a blog about any topic they want, free of cost.... In the blogging world fashion blogging leads a very competitive environment between independent fashion bloggers and fully funded fashion blog networks (Heathcote, 2010)....
17 Pages (4250 words) Research Paper

Developing Website and Blog for Caf Cuisine

The document provides justification for selection of the web contents as well as the contents published over the blog for attracting the customers.... The document provides justification for selection of the web contents as well as the contents published over the blog for attracting the customers.... After completing the design of the website in the Dreamweaver, we started to write the contents of the website, as well as planned the contents of the blog (Calhoun, 2003)....
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay

Globalization through Cyberspace

The United Nations Committee on Economic, Social, and Cultural Rights profoundly stated that 'globalization is a phenomenon which has wrought fundamental changes within every society' ('Statement on Globalization').... Moreover, we live in an era of globalization.... .... ... ... From our waking moments to sleeping hours, our lives are unconsciously and inexorably linked to someone somewhere across the globe....
7 Pages (1750 words) Essay

4 Blog Posts for Business Website

Not only do you get to spend the most meaningful day of your life with the important person in your life but you get an opportunity to throw a gorgeous party as well.... he best part is that you can choose any paper that works for you.... you can either get the announcement published in the paper in your local hometown even if you haven't been there in a while or you can even get it printed in the local paper which delivers right to your door....
10 Pages (2500 words) Essay

Consumer buying behaviour blogs and portfolio

In the research paper 'Consumer buying behaviour blogs and portfolio' the author tries to answer the question: What is a brand?... Brand is a name, symbol, term or design that helps to distinguish product of one seller from another.... ... ... ... The author says that at times he feels that there is no need for purchasing branded products....
11 Pages (2750 words) Essay

Teaching English With the Aid of Technology

Noteworthy, Evernote and Studyblue cannot be said to be impeccable in meeting the TEFL needs in contemporary society.... The objective of the present assignment "Teaching English With the Aid of Technology" is to provide a comprehensive summary of several information technology tools that can be applied in the classroom in order to enhance the effectiveness of the learning process.... Moreover, students can work with their friends and colleagues simultaneously and can even share their notes....
8 Pages (2000 words) Assignment

Social Media Activities - Blogging for Passion, Profit, and to Create Community

In this blog, ideas and comments from readers and writers will be used to gather more information on financial issues.... In addition, the blog will be used to keep track of the changes in prices of basic commodities; through which the interests of everyone can be tracked.... Being that the social backgrounds of the readers vary, different opinions from them will be necessary for creating realistic and accurate posts on the blog.... It is also through creativity and the development of accurate posts that more readers will be attracted to the blog....
6 Pages (1500 words) Assignment

Azez the Wonder Boy - Site's Target Audience and Competitive Analysis

This means the visitors cannot just visit once and cover the whole site.... The site shall also have a blog for Aziz's fan base to follow him and keep find out about his endeavors.... They are all about young people doing life the best they can.... This case study "Azez the Wonder Boy - Site's Target Audience and Competitive Analysis" discusses Azez the Wonder Boy that is a website about Azez....
6 Pages (1500 words) Case Study
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us