Nobody downloaded yet

Plato and Descartes: Comparing their Thoughts on Knowledge and Learning - Essay Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
Summary
From a philosophical perspective, the idea of learning can fall under the heading of epistemology, which refers to the study of the origin, nature, limits, and methods of knowledge.1 How can we know How can we learn something new What is the source of knowledge The complexity of how humans learn is illustrated in the following excerpt from Plato's Meno (427-347 B.C.):
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER93.2% of users find it useful
Plato and Descartes: Comparing their Thoughts on Knowledge and Learning
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "Plato and Descartes: Comparing their Thoughts on Knowledge and Learning"

Download file to see previous pages Actually, there are two positions on the origin of knowledge and its relationship to the environment: rationalism and empiricism. In varying degrees these positions are recognizable in our present learning theories. Rationalism is connected with the idea that knowledge derives from reason without aid of the senses. The distinction between mind and matter, which figures prominently in rationalist views of human knowledge, can be traced to Plato, who distinguished knowledge acquired via the senses from that gained by reason.3 Plato believed that things (e.g., houses, trees) are revealed to people via the senses, whereas individuals acquire ideas by reasoning or thinking about what they know. People have ideas about the world, and they learn (discover) these ideas by reflecting upon them. Reason is the highest mental faculty, because through reason people learn abstract ideas. The true nature of houses and trees can be known only by reflecting upon the ideas of houses and trees.4
Plato escaped the dilemma in Meno by assuming that true knowledge, or the knowledge of ideas, is innate and is brought into awareness through reflection. Learning is recalling what exists in the mind. Information acquired with the senses by observing, listening, tasting, smelling, or touching constitutes raw materials rather than ideas. The mind is innately structured to reason and provide meaning to incoming sensory information. On the other hand, empiricism refers to the idea that experience is the only source of knowledge. This position derives from Aristotle (384-322 B.C.), who was Plato's student and successor. Aristotle drew no sharp distinction between mind and matter. The external world is the basis for human sense impressions, which in turn are interpreted as lawful (consistent, unchanging) by the mind. The laws of nature cannot be discovered through sensory impressions. Rather, they are discovered through reason as the mind takes in data from the environment. Unlike Plato, Aristotle believed that ideas do not exist independently of the external world. The latter is the source of all knowledge.5
However, it is on the emphasis of the idea of the Self, as something primary in experience and providing the basis of ontology, may be said to be the keynote of modern as contrasted with ancient and medieval philosophy. It was this that Descartes had the merit of being the first to bring into prominence, and thereby of making "the greatest philosophical discovery since the age of Plato and Aristotle".6
More likely, the rationalist doctrine is evident in the writings of Ren Descartes (1596-1650), a French philosopher and mathematician. Descartes employed doubt as a method of inquiry. By doubting, he arrived at conclusions that were absolute truths and not subject to doubt. The fact that he could doubt led him to believe that the mind (thought) exists, as reflected in his dictum, "I think, therefore I am." Through deductive reasoning from general premises to specific instances, he proved that God exists and concluded that ideas arrived at through reason must be true. The major premise "whatever thinks exists" might be learned from our own case. One possibility is that our own case serves as a single piece of evidence that supports the premise by inductive enumeration, in the way that an observer might try to form a generalization ...Download file to see next pagesRead More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Plato and Descartes: Comparing their Thoughts on Knowledge and Essay”, n.d.)
Plato and Descartes: Comparing their Thoughts on Knowledge and Essay. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1515233-plato-and-descartes-comparing-their-thoughts-on-knowledge-and-learning
(Plato and Descartes: Comparing Their Thoughts on Knowledge and Essay)
Plato and Descartes: Comparing Their Thoughts on Knowledge and Essay. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1515233-plato-and-descartes-comparing-their-thoughts-on-knowledge-and-learning.
“Plato and Descartes: Comparing Their Thoughts on Knowledge and Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1515233-plato-and-descartes-comparing-their-thoughts-on-knowledge-and-learning.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Plato and Descartes: Comparing their Thoughts on Knowledge and Learning

Plato and Descartes on the Soul

...or can we tell where it has gone or what happens to it when we know its demise. However, although the issue has never been quite resolved, enlightenment on the issue have been initiated by such great philosophers like Plato and Descartes whose thoughts would be the main sources of this paper, seeing where they meet and where they contrast. Plato is the well known student of Socrates who carried with him most of his mentor’s philosophies and brought them to the existence it enjoys until this day. The son of wealthy Athenians, he sought education from well known philosophers during his time and has learned a great deal from them, taking his education...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay

Plato, Descartes, and Freud's Take on

...? Running head: Posture of Reason Plato, Descartes, and Freud’s Take on The Posture of Reason First and University Name Abstract By taking an in-depth look into several philosophical theories and theorists this paper attempts to uncover the posture of reason that exists behind philosophical thought. The three theorists and theories included are: Plato’s Divided Line Theory, Descartes Method of Doubt, and Freud’s Psychoanalysis. The similarities and differences are demonstrated, as well as the reasoning that was used in creating each theory. Plato, Descartes, and Freud’s Take on the Posture of Reason Philosophy was birthed out of the innate longing of human nature to understand the interworking of human thought, action, and purpose... truth,...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay

Plato through Descartes: Main Problems of Philosophy

...to brainwash away all his pre-conceptions, transforming his knowledge and accepting as true only those claims that are utterly deemed to be certain. All that the philosopher had recently thought that he had knowledge about them came to him via his senses. By a process of methodological doubt, Descartes succeeds in withdrawing completely from the senses. Any moment that he could be in a dream, or his senses either being deceived by either God or some evil spirits, he would conclude that no more that he would ever trust his own senses. Eventually, he arrives at a conclusion that there is no way that he would ever doubt his own existence. In order for one to either think or...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay

Plato, Descartes, and The Matrix

...The Matrix with the reading from Plato and Descartes The most apparent similarity between the film The Matrix, Descartes’ Meditation, and the cave analogy of Plato is that all these works doubt the reality of the world enveloping us and call into question the soundness of our sense perceptions. Nevertheless, although the three sources attempt to ask analogous questions, it is essentially their manner of answering these questions that differentiate them from each other. Plato examines the notion that the real world represents an illusion within the allegory of the cave presented in The Republic. Similarly, Neo is pulled from a form of the cave in the...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay

Locke and Descartes source of knowledge

...and hypotheses need to be tested against natural world observations and not simply relying on intuition or reasoning. The empirical theory is a better theory in discussing the source of knowledge because all that man knows has its basis on experience, while innate knowledge can be corrected with time following observation. Comparison Locke’s notion in the empiricism theory of an idea was borrowed from, the discussions by Descartes. According to Locke, the mind is the immediate object of understanding, thought, or perception by the mind (Scheibe & Falkenburg 2011). This is similar to what Descartes considers an idea to be, contending that it is what the...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay

Essay : Plato, Descartes, and The Matrix

...Compare and contrast The Matrix with the readings from Plato and Descartes. What are some similarities and differences? The Matrix is a new adaptation of “Republic” by Plato as both reveals about the truth of reality. Just like the people in the cave, the hero of the movie “Matrix” is chained to the walls where machines work on his body’s heat to power themselves. Same like the prisoners in the cave, the hero does not realize he is a prisoner. Both the parties are unaware of the reality and are living under a false perception. He like the people in the cave is born under bondage where he cannot smell or taste or touch. It is the prison of the mind. However in movie, the...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay

Plato, St.Thomas, Descartes

...to be the cage in which the soul gets locked. Plato has justified the comment of soul to gain eternal knowledge. At the point where one finds out that soul is the sole player of the power then knowledge is gained likewise. However, the fact remains that souls are merely imprisoned by the body that makes soul to undertake learning in a customized manner. Soul imprisoned within the body tends to create possibilities of learning other things as well. It is evident from the following quotation as well, “The lovers of learning know that when philosophy gets hold of their soul, it is imprisoned in and clinging to the body, and that it is...
6 Pages(1500 words)Essay

Dualism by Plato and Descartes

...that soul can think better when it is separated from the body. Whereas for Descartes, soul has to be integrated with the body for it to function while Plato thought that the soul ought to be separated from the body so that it can think better. For Plato, the soul has already a “pure and perfect” knowledge even before the birth of the body and it is at its thinking best when it is in this condition without the distraction of everyday life. While Descartes thought the soul is necessary to animate the body, Plato thought that the soul is in its “ideal” condition when it is separated from...
1 Pages(1000 words)Assignment

Plato and Descartes theories

...Topic: Lecturer: Presentation: Plato and Descartes Plato and Descartes are associated with the rationalistictheory of knowledge. Many philosophers try to explain how knowledge is acquired, the extent of our knowledge and how reliability of the knowledge can be judged. Some claim that we cannot be certain of what we know but Plato and Descartes went a long way to explore and evaluate various ways in which certainty of knowledge can be gained. They therefore came up with a rationalistic theory of knowledge which declares that absolutely...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

Comparing the ideas of Plato and Aristotle

... Comparing the ideas of Plato and Aristotle Plato was a philosopher and mathematician in ical Greece. In relationto politics, Plato’s politics was based on a study of human nature where he was a proponent of an orderly society that was based on a logic and reason. Plato says, “Cherishes the soul of him who lives in justice and holiness and is the nurse of his age and the companion of his journey (Plato, 46)”. Plato’s ideal city comprised of four virtues that included moderation, courage, wisdom and justice. Aristotle, on the other hand, was a Greek philosopher, as well as, a scientist. His ideas of politics and the government considered a city as a natural community that gave more importance to the family. He covered politics... capacity...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Essay on topic Plato and Descartes: Comparing their Thoughts on Knowledge and Learning for FREE!

Contact Us