StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Pelagian Culture: Pro et Contra - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
As the paper "Pelagian Culture: Pro et Contra" tells, free will is one of the key ideas of Pelagianism. This idea is not about absolute free will declared in conceptions of voluntarism (Schopenhauer) and nihilism (Nietzsche). Rather this is a manifestation of human self-sufficiency towards God. …
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER92.3% of users find it useful
Pelagian Culture: Pro et Contra
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Pelagian Culture: Pro et Contra"

Pelagian Culture: Pro et Contra Free will is one of the key ideas of Pelagianism. This idea is not about an absolute free will declared in conceptions of voluntarism (Schopenhauer) and nihilism (Nietzsche). Rather this is manifestation of human self-sufficiency towards God. How to be independent from God Is it possible at all Is it necessary What are typical results of such independence, namely results for person and results for society Let us try to find some answers. Augustine in his "Confessions" says to God: "Give me what You command and command what You will." Traditional Pelagianism was a reaction upon such turning man into a mere automaton. Pelagius declared that such "slavery" is in contrary to Christian understandings of God's grace and human's free will. Original sin and overemphasized necessity in Divine aid were considered as the fetters for human. Therefore, the essence of traditional Pelagianism was in negation of original sin influence upon human nature and in neglecting of Divine aid role for human salvation. Promptly these ideas were transformed into several moral principles, namely that human will is capable of choosing good or evil without Divine aid, and that humanity has full control and responsibility for its own salvation in addition to full responsibility for every sin. These old ideas are in a heart of modern society. Indeed, most of us live inspired by ideas of independence, self-sufficiency, and also responsibility for our free choice. However, allegorically some of us build our houses upon the sand. "And every one that heareth these sayings of mine, and doeth them not, shall be likened unto a foolish man, which built his house upon the sand. And the rain descended, and the floods came, and the winds blew, and beat upon that house; and it fell: and great was the fall of it." (Matthew 7:26-27). Are we strong enough to make the right choice between good and evil without God's will inside of us Are we so wise to disclose consequences of our actions hidden in future Last questions are contra-Pelagian for the "no" answers. It is interesting that these questions will become pro-Pelagian rhetoric for the "yes" answers assumed. It seems that psychologically Pelagian culture is a culture of self-confident and active individuals. And vice versa, non-Pelagian culture is "suited" for submission and confidence in God's will. For instance, Pelagius places free will at the basis of all turning to God for grace; see St. Augustine's critique in (Book I, chapter24). Then, doctrine of Pelagius somewhat conflicts with the words of Christ: "Without me ye can do nothing" (John 15:5); see details in St. Augustine (Book I, chapter 30). It seems that for modern human being non-Pelagian culture is too passive and internal oriented. However, I suppose that this is essential feature of true Christianity. Of course, both Pelagian and non-Pelagian cultures have positive and negative aspects. To disclose these ones, let us consider the case of real person which tried to balance between own freedom and responsibility. This is the case of Albert Speer, the first architect of the Third Reich. He was talented designer having numerous architectural ideas. And he wished to realize them all. This was the case when individual wants to be self-fulfilled, but self-fulfilled at any price. It is important that this is a typical case for Pelagian (sic!) culture. Moreover, Speer was capable to understand and then realize monstrous architectural visions of Hitler. Therefore, he had access for almost all intellectual, financial and human resources of Nazi Germany. In other words, his free will was supported by external forces. And Speer worked. He felt oneself as a creator of beautiful, perfect and immense constructions. But simultaneously he agreed with the forced evictions of Jews from their houses to make room for his plans, and also agreed with usage of the slave labour to build his constructions. After years, Speer acknowledged his own guilt, but as guilt of blinded creator with "see no evil" attitude towards the Nazi atrocities (see details in Pollard). Is it real guilt Is it real responsibility for own actions This example allows us to disclose essential differences between Pelagian and non-Pelagian cultures. It seems that for Pelagian culture we have following scheme: Free will actions responsibility (incl. guilt). This scheme is used by modern society for its efficiency. Indeed, there are no any stop-factors (excl. corporeal) between free will of individual and his actions. This feature allows us to concentrate upon realization of own ideas without wearisome hesitations due to ethical causes. Here, responsibility and guilty are secondary towards an action. Therefore, Pelagian culture is "more suited" for active individuals which often prefer to neglect ethics. This will be an exaggeration, but it seems that our Pelagian culture (rather post-Pelagian) is a culture of blinded creators like Albert Speer. Also, I suggest that scheme above is a scheme suited for non-religious technocratic society. For non-Pelagian culture we have quite different scheme: Free will mental responsibility actions or inactivity. Here, there is stop-factor between free will and possible actions. It was named conditionally as 'mental responsibility' (rather ethical term) but we can also replace this factor by 'God's grace' (theological term). Such displacement is item for more deep discussion; see appropriate suggestions in Tertullian's "On repentance" (chapter 3). Also, 'free will' in this scheme is in fact non-free due to stop-factor. It seems that Pelagius suggested this stop-factor as the cause which can turn man into a mere automaton. But this factor was absolutely necessary for theological constructions of St.Augustine which caused severe confrontation between St.Augustine and Pelagius. Then, it is obvious that this scheme is less effective than previous one. For modern individuals this scheme seems to be inactive because of stop-factor before any action. I suppose that the case of Albert Speer is unthinkable for pure non-Pelagian culture. It is difficult to say what practical implications follow from such conclusions. Maybe, these schemes will be useful for studies of legality and studies of history of human motivation. Works Cited St. Augustine. On the grace of Christ, and on original sin. Book I (selections). Pollard, Miriam. The other face of love: dialogues with the prison experience of Albert Speer. New York: The Crossroad Publishing Company (selections). Tertullian. On repentance (selections). Translated by the Rev. S. Thelwall. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Pelagian Culture Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 words”, n.d.)
Pelagian Culture Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 words. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1512254-pelagian-culture
(Pelagian Culture Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 Words)
Pelagian Culture Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 Words. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1512254-pelagian-culture.
“Pelagian Culture Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1512254-pelagian-culture.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Pelagian Culture: Pro et Contra

The Influence of the European Culture

However, all these are influenced by factors such as the immediate as well as external environment, the structure of the organisation or institution, business culture and the relationships which exist between the management and the subordinates (Marcus et al, 2003).... Democratic, laissez faire and participative management leadership styles involve staff while autocratic style is purely based on the management making decisions for the business or company (Marcus et al, 2003)....
8 Pages (2000 words) Research Paper

Nixon's Counterterrorism Policies

Nixon's counterterrorism policies Instructor University Nixon's Counterterrorism Policies A Cabinet Committee to Combat Terrorism was established in September 1972 by President Nixon in order to consider the most effectual methods to prevent terrorism in the United States.... ... ... ... The Committee's task was to excel in the procedural work to ensure that the federal government was taking prompt action against any act of terrorism....
3 Pages (750 words) Essay

Challenging Leopold

Challenging Leopold Name of Student Class, Subject Name of Professor Dec 5, 2013 Challenging Leopold Introduction Edmund Dene Morel was a British politician.... Earlier in his life, he started off as a clerk of a shipping firm in Liverpool.... Later on, he began part time journalist, writing exclusively based on information he received from information supplied by shipmen and other merchants who visited the shipping office especially regarding the British trade in Africa....
10 Pages (2500 words) Essay

The Revolt of the Netherlands

The "Spanish answer was an armed one; the new stadholder Parma arrived with an army and began to take control of the southern territories, "representants" of which in 1579 established the Union of Arras, a pro-Catholic and pro-Spanish federation, the remaining rebelling provinces formed the Union of Utrecht (1579).... The "peace of Munster, signed between the Catholic Monarchy and the United Provinces in 1648, went, at least apparently, against the political culture of both polities....
11 Pages (2750 words) Essay

Critique on European Imperialism in Heart of Darkness by Joseph Conrad

et during the era of the heightened competition for all the imperial territories that most of the historians have termed the New Imperialism, the Heart of Darkness was loosely based on the Conrad's observations and experience during a six-month stint, in the year 1890, in the Congo as being an employee of a Belgian company.... When published originally as a series in pro-imperialism journal, Blackwood's Magazine, Heart of Darkness has also been cited as an unabashedly pro-imperialist and also as an even racist on the one hand; it has also been seen as scathingly anti-imperialist on the other hand....
8 Pages (2000 words) Term Paper

Newly Established Nations in World Wars

The establishment of new nations that were colonies during the Imperial Period is closely connected with politics and international relations dominated during the first half of the XX century.... The world's fate hinged on the outcome of this massive effort to meet the Axis threat of world conquest and restore balance of power....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Refugee and Migration Movements Throughout the History

Since the Arab bona fides were questioning the loyalty of the Arab Shia, problems related to politics and religion among the Arab Shia and pro-Iranian Shia community remain unsolved (Global Security). ... Over the years, Tutsi people were able to adopt with the culture of Hutu people.... culture and customs of Rwanda.... "Peoples and culture....
10 Pages (2500 words) Research Paper

Far Right and Green Politics in European Countries

Die Grünen advocated for the rights of immigrants but another party, the Freedom Party, which later coalesced with ŐVP, likewise entered the Austrian landscape at the same time and opposed the pro-immigrant position of the die Grünen.... ‘Activist culture and Practices in a Constraining Environment' Green Parties in Transition: The End of Grass Roots Democracy?...
14 Pages (3500 words) Term Paper
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us