We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Nobody downloaded yet

Irish Historiography - Essay Example

Comments (0)
Irish historiography, just as is Irish history, is an arena replete with debate, often contentious, regarding the validity of historical date, the objectivity of perspectives and the role that nationalistically-fuelled myths have played skewing the truth.' The stated is not intended as an argument for the invalidation of popular history but as a remark on that literary, cum mythological, treasure trove which Irish nationalistic history is comprised of and with which Irish historiography must contend…
Download full paper

Extract of sample
Irish Historiography

Download file to see previous pages... The Irish Potato Famine and Revolution comprise the twin pillars of the Irish nationalism's post-1923 ideal of the Republic. The two disparate events were celebrated, recalled and made into mythology for very different reasons. The Great Hunger was seen, within nationalist circles, as a largely avoidable food crisis, precipitated and subsequently exacerbated by British ineptitude and an attitude that saw the Irish as expendable quasi-citizens. The Revolution, on the other hand, was portrayed as a glorious event which successfully liberated an oppressed people, while making heroes and martyrs of men such as Michael Collins who, "in a span of six short years brought a country from bondage to a position where she could win her freedom." (Conlon & Barter, 2003, p.20). Both events would likewise serve as the twin axis upon which revisionism was to flourish - the backlash against nationalism both from within and outside of Eire.
Fuelled by frustrated patriotism and the deep-rooted influence of the Irish Diaspora in the New World, post-Famine Irish Nationalism espoused an interpretive view of history which conflicted with reality. Furthermore, the practice of history in Ireland has traditionally been merged with oral tales of the past, endowing Irish historiography with a romanticised view of the real life narratives which inspired it. The combination of these two external factors produced a history that was, following the mid-nineteenth century, a potent mix of literature, folklore and propaganda with the result that fact often made way for a more apt form of fiction, unchallenged until the advent of revisionism after 1930. As expressed by R.F. Foster, "rather like generals always fighting the previous battle, cultural revolutionaries rarely get the revolution they expected" (Foster, 2001, p.20).
Inspired by romantic writers such as Yeats, turn of the century Irish historians were highly critical of the British Government's sluggish relief tactics in response to the failure of the potato crops in 1845. 'Famine' was renamed 'starvation', with emphasis on the allegedly deliberate nature of the event, and it was taught in republican schools as the only correct version of events. Moreover, nationalist academic research appeared to prove the most damning charge levelled against the British, namely that there was indeed large food stocks available in England and withheld from the starving Irish. The selective use of primary sources determined that revisionist theory, following its emergence in the 1930's, be more concerned with evaluating all of the source material, rather than concentrating only on those facts that underpinned the nationalist republican political ideology. Throughout the dissection of modern Irish history, even after the 1930's, voices that dared to question the validity of the term 'starvation' were denounced as traitors or British sympathisers. Indeed, for many years, only those historians who shared the Nationalist viewpoint would receive patronage for their work: this was the historical compromise that mirrored the North/South, Protestant/Catholic divide in Ireland during the twentieth century.
Apart from a ...Download file to see next pagesRead More
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment
Irish economy
The author analyzes the case when the Irish nation experiences a recession first, which is followed by a short lived period of recovery and lastly, a recession once again, so that there are in all two recessions that the economy experiences. He suggests that a positive shift in aggregate demand is possible when an economy follows a stringent budget regime.
5 Pages(1250 words)Essay
Historiography and Memory Essay
Historiography for instance, analyses how the historical studies have changed over time, from concentrating on traditional, political, and economic aspects of the society, to the current study of the cultural and the social aspect of people. Memory on the other hand refers to how information is received, coded, stored, and then retrieved when the need for such information arises (Schwartz, 1997).
3 Pages(750 words)Essay
Comparing History and Historiography
Comparing History and Historiography Name Professor University/Institution Location May 15th 2013 History is the most difficult education subject to delineate precisely since various disciplines persuade and contribute to it; as such students consider it to be tedious and difficult to comprehend.
3 Pages(750 words)Essay
Irish revolution
Therefore, revolutionary conflict may mean the emphasis of the condition of dual sovereignty. The occurrence of dual sovereignty means that an occurrence of revolution follows. On the other hand, it may become very difficult to establish the result of the conflict whether it brings about a positive or a negative change especially when the revolutionaries succeed and the challenging parties fail.
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay
Irish revolution
a complete sudden change of rulers and the political system of a nation. ‘Revolutionary conflict’ indirectly refers to the causes of a revolution. A revolution is a consequence of several major events leading to the ultimate result. Those consequences are a result of conflicts between two or more powerful groups.
5 Pages(1250 words)Essay
History and Historiography
However, the humans have not been able to know all the past events that have occurred since the advent of human on this planet. Thus, the known past has been considered as the proper and realistic definition of the term history by most of the historians. Moreover, some more terms have been originated from the term history, such as historiography, which represents the human lives, as well as, civilizations that have been known by the humans in the form of records, it may be written, as well as, in verbal form.
6 Pages(1500 words)Essay
Irish History A Brief Historiography
From whatever perspective you choose to view Irish history, whether from a nationalist viewpoint advocating the ultimate break from Britain and all she stood for, or from a unionist or British perspective where you might see Ireland’s role as an integral part of the largest and most powerful empire the world had ever known.
21 Pages(2250 words)Essay
Irish Literature
Catholics were treated like second-class populace in their native home. Centuries of oppression churned in the hearts of the Irish and came to a simmer in the writings and literature of the sons and daughters of Ireland. The Literary Renaissance of Ireland produced some of the greatest writers the world has seen.
6 Pages(1500 words)Essay
Why Were Women In Ireland Excluded From The Public Exercise Of Power Over Men
Women in Irish history have generally appeared as the oppressed “other”. There has been little examination of the position of women in general in the nationalist movement, or the relation between the nationalist movement and struggle for women’s rights.
8 Pages(2000 words)Essay
Historiography Paper II
American history is filled with many antagonistic events engineered by the American government to further its interests. As the nation announced itself on the world stage, it faced
3 Pages(750 words)Essay
Let us find you another Essay on topic Irish Historiography for FREE!
Contact us:
Contact Us Now
FREE Mobile Apps:
  • About StudentShare
  • Testimonials
  • FAQ
  • Blog
  • Free Essays
  • New Essays
  • Essays
  • The Newest Essay Topics
  • Index samples by all dates
Join us:
Contact Us