StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...

Irish Historiography - Essay Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
Summary
Irish historiography, just as is Irish history, is an arena replete with debate, often contentious, regarding the validity of historical date, the objectivity of perspectives and the role that nationalistically-fuelled myths have played skewing the truth.' The stated is not intended as an argument for the invalidation of popular history but as a remark on that literary, cum mythological, treasure trove which Irish nationalistic history is comprised of and with which Irish historiography must contend…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER94.2% of users find it useful
Irish Historiography
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "Irish Historiography"

Download file to see previous pages The Irish Potato Famine and Revolution comprise the twin pillars of the Irish nationalism's post-1923 ideal of the Republic. The two disparate events were celebrated, recalled and made into mythology for very different reasons. The Great Hunger was seen, within nationalist circles, as a largely avoidable food crisis, precipitated and subsequently exacerbated by British ineptitude and an attitude that saw the Irish as expendable quasi-citizens. The Revolution, on the other hand, was portrayed as a glorious event which successfully liberated an oppressed people, while making heroes and martyrs of men such as Michael Collins who, "in a span of six short years brought a country from bondage to a position where she could win her freedom." (Conlon & Barter, 2003, p.20). Both events would likewise serve as the twin axis upon which revisionism was to flourish - the backlash against nationalism both from within and outside of Eire.
Fuelled by frustrated patriotism and the deep-rooted influence of the Irish Diaspora in the New World, post-Famine Irish Nationalism espoused an interpretive view of history which conflicted with reality. Furthermore, the practice of history in Ireland has traditionally been merged with oral tales of the past, endowing Irish historiography with a romanticised view of the real life narratives which inspired it. The combination of these two external factors produced a history that was, following the mid-nineteenth century, a potent mix of literature, folklore and propaganda with the result that fact often made way for a more apt form of fiction, unchallenged until the advent of revisionism after 1930. As expressed by R.F. Foster, "rather like generals always fighting the previous battle, cultural revolutionaries rarely get the revolution they expected" (Foster, 2001, p.20).
Inspired by romantic writers such as Yeats, turn of the century Irish historians were highly critical of the British Government's sluggish relief tactics in response to the failure of the potato crops in 1845. 'Famine' was renamed 'starvation', with emphasis on the allegedly deliberate nature of the event, and it was taught in republican schools as the only correct version of events. Moreover, nationalist academic research appeared to prove the most damning charge levelled against the British, namely that there was indeed large food stocks available in England and withheld from the starving Irish. The selective use of primary sources determined that revisionist theory, following its emergence in the 1930's, be more concerned with evaluating all of the source material, rather than concentrating only on those facts that underpinned the nationalist republican political ideology. Throughout the dissection of modern Irish history, even after the 1930's, voices that dared to question the validity of the term 'starvation' were denounced as traitors or British sympathisers. Indeed, for many years, only those historians who shared the Nationalist viewpoint would receive patronage for their work: this was the historical compromise that mirrored the North/South, Protestant/Catholic divide in Ireland during the twentieth century.
Apart from a ...Download file to see next pagesRead More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Irish Historiography Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 3750 words”, n.d.)
Retrieved de https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1507362-irish-historiography
(Irish Historiography Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 3750 Words)
https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1507362-irish-historiography.
“Irish Historiography Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 3750 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1507362-irish-historiography.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Irish Historiography

Irish History A Brief Historiography

...Irish History A Brief Historiography From whatever perspective you choose to view Irish history, whether from a nationalist viewpoint advocating the ultimate break from Britain and all she stood for, or from a unionist or British perspective where you might see Ireland’s role as an integral part of the largest and most powerful empire the world had ever known, there are no clear arguments to justify one sides perspective at the expense of the other. No one side has a monopoly of rights on their side and to view Irish history or any other nation’s history from just one perspective is to do an injustice to the subject. From a nationalist point of view its very much a case of unfinished business as the ultimate goal of a thirty-two county...
21 Pages(5250 words)Essay

Historiography

...The "Great Man" theory tries to explain histories and events in it by the impact of "great men" or heroes- highly influential people, who due to their charisma, intelligence, wisdom, Machiavellianism, used power in a way that had a decisive impact on history. This theory is commonly associated with the main events of the 20th century, in which both world wars occurred, the nuclear bombs were dropped in Hiroshima and Nagasaki, millions of Jewish people and other ethnic and social groups were brutally killed during the Holocaust, and many atrocities took place and challenged human conception about people, humanity and mankind in general. Trying to connect atrocities and brutal, ferocious events such as conquests and annihilation... "Great Man"...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

The Growth of Irish Historiography and Historical Debate

...The growth of Irish Historiography and Historical debate There has been without a doubt a growth in Irish historiography and historical debate since the 1960’s. This trend has focused on the relationship between England (and later Britain) and Ireland with its consequences for both countries’ developments and history. Such interest was brought about by the troubles in Northern Ireland, underscored by the contemporary emergence of the IRA and policies in relation to its neighboring Britain. There are different sides trying to justify their cause and historians trying to explain and interpret with their own personal biases. Traditional historical debate usually tries to argue in favour of one perspective rather than another, against looking...
38 Pages(9500 words)Dissertation

Mythology and Symbolism in Irish Literature

...Dreaming and Mythologizing as a Peculiarly Irish Phenomenon The present work is the synoptic essay, discussing the question of mythology and symbolism in Irish literature. According to Elmer Andrews, the disposition for dreaming and mythologizing is a peculiarly Irish phenomenon. (Andrews 1995, p. 10 ) The work is aimed to prove, that it is often used in Irish literature, using parallels with Celtic mythology and other national symbols. The three literary works to be analyzed and used to prove the statement will be: W.B. Yeasts Selected Poems, Brian Friels Dancing at Lughasa, and Michael Longleys Selected Poems. All three have common lines in relation to symbolism and mythologizing. To start with, the mechanism of mythologizing...
13 Pages(3250 words)Essay

The Results of the Irish Economy

... and United Kingdom. Country Enterprise Boards are established for the promotion of an enterprise culture at the local level and the creation of a range of enterprise-related projects at micro level. For job creation, the ‘social dialogue’ approach is adopted. The Irish culture has taken thousands of years to develop, so the people of Ireland cherish every moment of the cultural discovery. They are proud of their cultural traditions and make sincere efforts to maintain and develop it. The Department of Irish Folklore at University College Dublin has over 100,000 tales, myths and legends on record. This is the single largest collection of its kind in the world. The policy environment: The results of the Irish economy are encouraging...
8 Pages(2000 words)Term Paper

Scottish Irish and Welsh Nationalism

...Running Head: Nationalism Nationalism of Nationalism The definition of nationalism has haunted researchers since the nineteenth century. It is an ever changing subject that cannot be pinned down within one nation or person. Nationalism roughly refers to the sense of pride and caring which a people share for the particular culture, language, and history within a specific geographical area. The people see themselves as a nation with specific characteristics that form its identity. This paper studies the similarities and differences between Irish, Scottish and Welsh nationalism. Nationalism arose in the nineteenth century in Europe because of several influences. During the Enlightenment, many intellectuals discussed the idea of individualism...
8 Pages(2000 words)Assignment

The Irish Government's Reach E-Government Initiative Is a Threat to Individual Liberties

...IRISH GOVERNMENTS REACH E-GOVERNMENT INITIATIVE IS A THREAT TO INDIVIDUAL LIBERTIES Introduction The increase wave of globalization that has been taking place in the world has been changing in many fronts in the world. It has not only changed the business world but there has also been a change in the social life as well the change is social life has been attributed by increasing interaction of people from all parts of the world. This has contributed to polarized world culture where all standards of life are judged by one global accepted standard. There has also been a change in the landscape of governance in the world. In this regard there has been changing nature of governance where the governments have become more open...
7 Pages(1750 words)Coursework

An Understanding of the Irish Economy from 2005 through 2008

According to the voxeu.org website, the economy and social Research Institute prospected a -0.4% GDP growth in 2008. While compared to the 2007’s growth of 5.3% and the previously reported growth rates since the 1990s, this would be a huge decline. Also going in line with these trends were the terms of trade movement leading to a real income rate of -2.6% in the year 2008. Recovery of the real income rates was projected and 2009’s rate would stand at 20%.

The basic cause for the economic decline was mostly attributed to the housing sector’s contraction resulting in a prospected fall of total investment by around 15% in the year 2008 and a further, decline of 4.5% in the following year. Despite this...

8 Pages(2000 words)Term Paper

Irish State towards Residential Child Welfare Policy

...Irish State towards Residential Child Welfare Policy and Practice Table of Contents Introduction 2 The Kennedy Report and the Implications 3 Implications of Children Act, 2001 5 The Ryan Report and its Implications 8 Conclusions 11 References 12 Bibliography 14 Introduction The Republic of Ireland has a population of about 3.9 million and among this 29% of the total population is under the age of 20 and 37% are below 25 years according to the Central Statistics Office 2002. It is quite evident from the data that the Republic of Ireland is a young country (in age of the populace) which has got that sufficient youth population to bank upon. Therefore, a lot has to be done for the youth and the children of the country and the state...
9 Pages(2250 words)Assignment

Amendment to Irish Constitution Granting More Rights to Children

...Amendment To Irish Constitution – Granting More Rights To Children – An Analysis Introduction Irish Constitution was drafted as early as in 1937 and children till they attain the age of seventeen, they are under the control and care of their parents. Today, society is of the view that children do have privileges and they should be allowed to exercise their individual decision when they feel necessary. The Irish constitution through its Article 40 guarantees that Irish children have imprescriptible and irrefutable rights, which safeguard their individual privileges. However, the Irish Government having considered in the background of the “undeniable right and responsibility of parents” mentioned in Article 42.1, it has come to a conclusion...
8 Pages(2000 words)Case Study

The Irish Economy

...The Irish Economy The Irish economy has been an ideal case of a country which roller-costered from being a country labelled as “Poorest of Rich” to being saluted as “Europe’s shining light”, in a period of 10 years (Murphy, 2000, “The ‘Celtic Tiger’ – An Analysis of Ireland’s Economic Growth Performance”). During the period of mid nineteen nineties till 2007, the country had an exceptional run, with near perfect economic indicators. It was believed that an era of low-tax (Independent, 2004, “Low-tax policies created the Tiger”) coupled with the positive influence of globalization spurred the growth which many countries are now trying to replicate. The spectacular growth in GDP from $81.214 billion in 1997 to $260.08 billion in 2007...
8 Pages(2000 words)Essay

Irish Economy from April 2008 to April 2010

...Irish Economy April 2008 to April The Irish economy has urguably undergone a metamorphosis from how it used to be around 20 years ago. There aremany factors that can be credited with the success of the Irish economy over the years. The Irish government has done quite a lot to ensure that the economy of Ireland does not crumble completely in the midst of the ongoing financial crisis which has rocked many countries across the globe. Though the economy of Ireland can be said to be more secure than the countrys counterparts in Europe, a lot has happened over the last two years to affect the countrys economic situation in a big way. This paper sets to assess how successful the Irish government and the European Central Bank have been in running...
8 Pages(2000 words)Case Study

Critical Analysis of A Global History of Modern Historiography by Georg Iggers and Edward Wang

... A critical response paper on a global history of modern historiography by Georg Iggers and Edward Wang World history needs to be written within the global context and avoid copy pasting the historical approaches from the west to the modern historical writing. The systems of interaction in place between the local and global historical development have acted as central forces driving world history. These two historians have made certain truths based on evidence provided and have made us accept most of these claims. The ideas of evidence, standards of reasoning and rigor that has been applied in their historical inquiry forms a major histographical analysis of this paper. This school of thought, Georg Iggers and Edward Wang, have used...
6 Pages(1500 words)Book Report/Review
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Essay on topic Irish Historiography for FREE!

Contact Us