StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...

Sexual Offence - Case Study Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
Summary
In R. v. Scott Redgrave1, the appellant was charged with continually persisting for an immoral purpose contrary to section 32 of the Sexual Offences Act2. This section of the law states "It is an offence for a man persistently to solicit or importune in a public place for immoral purposes3."
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER95.8% of users find it useful
Sexual Offence
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "Sexual Offence"

Download file to see previous pages It was held that the judge ruled that the evidence was inadmissible and the appellant was convicted on a majority verdict5. The appellant was consequently fined 50 and ordered to pay 100 for the fees of prosecution. He later appealed inter alia, that the judge's ruling was incorrect.
On November 13, 1979, between the hours of 4:45 and 5 p.m., five officers of the law from the South East Area Vice Squad kept plain clothes observation on a public convenience store in Portsmouth6. For the duration of this time, the appellant, aged 22, entered and exited the shop on four occasions. Two times he followed two officers inside the restroom of the store where the plaintiff masturbated for approximately one minute near the urinal. Both officers reported that the appellant masturbated openly, noisily and violently and while staring at them for the duration of the episode7. The appellant was asked to leave the store and was then cautioned outside. The officers reported that the appellant stated that he had been satisfying his lust due to the fact that his girl friend was away. The officers reported that the appellant then denied that he was attempting to attract other men and explained that he felt the urge to masturbate as he passed the convenience store. The appellant could neither explain the reason why he failed to go to his house nor why he had failed to use a stall. He conceded to the officers that his actions looked bad and he later repeated this defense at his trial8.
The jury failed to reach a consensus at the appellant's first trial and on the re-trial, the appellant sought to tender comprehensive evidence regarding his heterosexual relationships with females in order to refute inferences from witnesses9.
The appellant appealed via a certificate of the trial judge under section 1 (2) of the Criminal Appeal Act 196810. His appeal was based on terms of whether on a trial for persistently importuning for an immoral purpose, if evidence regarding the appellant's heterosexual disposition would be admissible. Also, if this is the case, whether this evidence should be limited to general evidence of reputation or whether it could include specific evidence regarding heterosexual relationships11.
It was held that though a defendant would be able to call evidence to show that he did not commit the acts alleged against him, he is not allowed to call evidence that he was of a disposition that brings about the unlikelihood that he would have committed the offence charged12. Applying the case of Rowton (1865), the trial judge ruled as he did arguing that the construction of the type of evidence in the present case would have been inadmissible and undesirable, and in addition to this, the appeal would be dismissed13.
History
The appellant had originally been tried on March 31, 1980 and the present trial was a retrial. During the first trial, under his Honor Judge Brodrick, the appellant produced five bundles of documents described as love letters14. Included in the documents were images of the plaintiff with five girls. The images were taken in contexts to suggest that the plaintiff was on intimate terms with the girls. During the first trial, the appellant alluded to the fact that he had had sexual intercourse ...Download file to see next pagesRead More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Sexual Offence Case Study Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 2750 words”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1507055-sexual-offence
(Sexual Offence Case Study Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 2750 Words)
https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1507055-sexual-offence.
“Sexual Offence Case Study Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 2750 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1507055-sexual-offence.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Sexual Offence

Sexual prosperity

...? The establishment and maintenance of sexual propriety are important things for almost any society, especially in the adolescent stage between childhood and adulthood when sexual behavior is in an especially grey area. Both the !Kung people and the Mehinaku, studied by Marjorie Shostak and Thomas Gregor respectively, have vastly different sexual structures from our own. In both these societies there is a greater acceptance and openness about sexuality during the childhood years, which narrows near the early years of marriage only to re-open later in life once partners are in more mature and stable marriages. One of the main differences between the !Kung and the Mehinaku and our own practice of sexuality is the age at which children...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay

The Sexual Response Cycle: Sexual hormones

...?Sexual hormones play a number of roles in the human body, upon conception they play a role in determining the sex of the embryo as well as later in life estrogen levels, help regulate menstruation and ovulation in females. In humans the sexual response cycle is much more complex where psychological and physiological factors play a major role, although human sex hormones do play an organizing and activating effects (Buchanan, 1992, pg. 439). Human sex hormones play also a vital part in the sexual behavior and response cycle of both sexes since levels of testosterone (male human hormone) have direct effects on both sexes by stimulating sex drive and facilitating response to sexual stimuli an activating effect. According to Masters...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay

Sexual Harassment & Sexual Consent

...? SEXUAL HARASSMENT SEXUAL HARASSMENT With the rapid grow in the way technology is consumed in recent times, one is aware of the maximum amount of the mishaps and instances that take place I this world, it is alarming that the cases that deal with sexual harassment are increasing on every day basis. This gives a vivid picture so as to why the ratio of such cases is increasing. One of the most prominent reason is that the individuals who are in power are not giving the required attention on this topic or merely not even considering it to be a problem after all hence no measure to prevention is being taken. Those individuals who commit such action deserve serious punishment. This gives a vivid reason so as to why such incidents are occurring...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay

Workforce Offence

...Workplace crimes are in general offences that cause an identifiable loss to an employer. One constituent of such crimes is what is usually termed as employee theft, internal theft or pilferage. It is important to remember that internal theft comprises merely one of a range of misbehaviours indulged in by recalcitrant employees. In addition to this crime there exist five other forms of misdeeds, which are adopted by undesirable employees, these are, disobeying the rules, indulging in destructive practices, resorting to non-cooperative practices, adopting disruptive practices and the misuse of facilities1. The variety of such deviant practices found at the workplace illustrates the reason as to why there is no recognized and unanimously...
12 Pages(3000 words)Assignment

Sexual Abuse and Sexual Dysfunction/

...Running Head: Sexual Abuse & Sexual Dysfunction/Addiction Sexual Abuse & Sexual Dysfunction/Addiction of the of the Institution Sexual Abuse & Sexual Dysfunction/Addiction Introduction The term 'abuse' has a Latin root abusare but it is not until early modern times that it has found its way into European languages in its present sense as misuse, disuse, ill-treat, violate, defile or pervert. Sexual abuse and harassment are relatively recent legal and moral concerns. They both involve sexual advances or actions that occur against the wishes of the person toward whom they are directed or in situations in which that person is either incompetent to consent or where consent was given under conditions that are reasonably seen as coercive...
14 Pages(3500 words)Essay

LAW OF EVIDENCE examine critically the rules regarding sexual history of the complainant in relation to prosecutions for sexual offence in the light of the cou

.... Harder to bear, when you’ve got family sitting watching, it’s not something that you want to broadcast all over. (C9: current partner, acquittal) The Youth Justice and Criminal Evidence Act (YJCEA) 1999 introduced a new regime for the conduct of sexual offence trials. Section 41 of the Act, which came into force on 4 December 2000, brought about dramatic changes to the rules on the admissibility of evidence of complainant’s sexual behavior, severely restricting the discretion of trial judges to introduce such evidence or to allow questioning concerning it. Responses to section 41 are divided given the extremely sensitive nature of this area of the law of evidence and the complex set of...
6 Pages(1500 words)Essay

Sexual offence Investigation

... will be evaluated. According to the statistics, 20-40% of girls and 1 out of 6 boys become victims of undesirable sexual contacts until they become 18. The so-called “rule of silence” around the theme of sexual offence allows to assume that such cases happen much more often. Sexual violence takes place when a personality, a child or an adult, is used by an older or stronger individual for the satisfaction of his own sexual desires. There are many kinds of violence: verbal, visual and physical contact without victim’s consent. In order to understand the nature and the consequences of sexual aggression in relation to children, it is essential to realize that the offence happens in the context of relations with a adult, who was supposed...
8 Pages(2000 words)Assignment

Property offence

...PROPERTY OFFENCE by The of the The of the School The and where it is located The Date Property Offences Question 1 a) Petty theft When Fred changed the price tag on the shirt, he became a suspect in a petty theft or shoplifting accusation. According to the U.K law, any actions that one may take to avoid paying the full purchase price on an item could make them guilty of shoplifting. This includes acts such as altering price tags, changing price tags between items, and swapping the goods in containers that have different prices. An attempt or intent to pay less than you should have paid excluding a cashier’s mistake can result in a shoplifting charge. The charges may be treated as a petty theft case, which falls in section 22...
8 Pages(2000 words)Assignment

Criminal Law Doctrines of Sexual and Person Offences

The criterion that is used is by assessing whether a reasonable man would have been able to assess the risk inherent in his actions that caused harm, which will be sufficient to establish men's rea3. However, the road accident has occurred through no fault of James and it is only after the incident that James discovered that the man killed happened to be Hugh. Therefore, the underlying intent to cause bodily harm with malice afterthought will not be established. Despite the fact that James had set out with murderous intentions which indicate the existence of men's rea he did not actually carry them out which means the absence of actus rea and the accident was not the result of malice afterthought. Therefore he should not be charge...
7 Pages(1750 words)Assignment

Essential Elements of a Criminal Offence

...Introduction The two essential elements of a criminal offence are the actus rea and the mens rea. While the actus rea which encompasses the actual conduct constituting the crime is straight forward, mens rea is a bit more complicated. Both intention and recklessness can be used to substantiate the existence of mens rea. The definition and application of the doctrine of recklessness has developed into a confusing and contradictory exercise and the recent House of Lords decision in R v Gemmell and Richards (2003) was an attempt to remove the previous confusions and contradictions. Whether or not the House of Lords achieved this goal can only be determined by an examination of the case law that preceded this decision. R v Cunningham...
9 Pages(2250 words)Term Paper

Sexual Abuse & Sexual Dysfunction or Addiction

...Running Head: Sexual Abuse & Sexual Dysfunction/Addiction Sexual Abuse & Sexual Dysfunction/Addiction of the of the Sexual Abuse & Sexual Dysfunction/Addiction Introduction The term ‘abuse’ has a Latin root abusare but it is not until early modern times that it has found its way into European languages in its present sense as misuse, disuse, ill-treat, violate, defile or pervert. Sexual abuse and harassment are relatively recent legal and moral concerns. They both involve sexual advances or actions that occur against the wishes of the person toward whom they are directed or in situations in which that person is either incompetent to consent or where consent was given under conditions that are reasonably seen as coercive. The recent...
14 Pages(3500 words)Case Study

Sexual Harassment in the Workplace

...Introduction: The major ethical issue that any organization is facing today is sexual harassment. Sexual harassment in the workplace is one of the main reasons of employee turnover. Sexual harassment is seen in many ways and is the unwelcome sexual advances or physical conduct of sexual nature. This is known to public in rare cases due to fear, unawareness, and employee turnover itself. Many of the workers are unaware of the rules against sexual harassment. Therefore, management should take a well-defined policy to fight against sexual harassment. Management has the duty to ensure safe and comfortable working environment for achieving the company’s target. It is important to enforce the policy adopted against sexual harassment and clear...
8 Pages(2000 words)Report

The Problematic Offence of Terrorism

...1 Introduction The factual scenario raises complex issues of potential liability under criminal law and in particular the problematic offence of terrorism. It is evident that the post-September 11 socio-political climate has heightened the international community’s attention on the growing problem of terrorism (Williamson, 2009). In addition to acknowledging the global nature of terrorism, a central problem has been the ability to define what constitutes terrorism within the international legal framework in particular (Bianchi & Naqvi, 2004). For example, previous United Nations Security General Kofi Annan commented that whilst governments differed on their stance regarding the definition of terrorism at state level, what is clear...
8 Pages(2000 words)Assignment

Avoiding Sexual Harassment Problems

... How to curb Sexual Harassment Sexual harassment may be termed as any repeated act that is conducted without the consent of one party (Tatiana 1). The derogatory acts may entail sexually abusing or invoking remarks uttered by a workmate at a workplace or in classrooms in colleges. Francis (3) adds that such statements are commonly offensive and objectionable on the side of the recipient and may result in discomfort and mental trauma. The most disgusting part of the entire act of sexual harassment is that it is gender biased since the female person is the most vulnerable in most of the cases (Linda & Hajdin 11). The responsibilities and caution requisite for the achievement of an environment favorable for work and studies is one...
8 Pages(2000 words)Coursework

Staff Sexual Misconduct in Community Corrections: A Negation of Justice

...Staff Sexual Misconduct in Community Corrections: A Negation of Justice Full The historical development of community corrections has illustrated that its emergence is in response to the society’s call for a compassionate and more humane criminal justice grounded on the belief that not all offenders are evils and thus can be rehabilitated to be successfully reintegrated into the community. However, this noble purpose of community corrections is proven complex to achieve as there are various obstacles to its achievement. One of which is the increasing reports on staff sexual misconduct. Due to the manipulative and coercive nature of SSM exacerbated by the culture of silence, fear and shame predominating community corrections, the prevalence...
11 Pages(2750 words)Thesis

Human Rights Violations and the Possibility for Change Introduction: Sexual Abuse in India

... cultural traditions that make it difficult for rape victims to come out. Consequently the police ask for more support from the government and society to help them cope with the problems of sexual violence. The judiciary is another arm of the government that deals with provision of justice to victims of rape through the courts. Over the decades the institution has shown considerable weakness in its duty to provide justice to victims through punishment of perpetrators. However, the judiciary claims that with the current laws as they are, it is difficult to avail justice when the threshold of evidence required for convicting violators in sexual offence cases being very high (Law Commission of India 15). According to the judiciary, rape...
12 Pages(3000 words)Term Paper

Goblin Market - Sexual Imagery

...Goblin Market: Sexual Imagery Rossetti, Christina G. The Complete Poems of Christina Rossetti. Ed. R.W. Crump and Betty S. Flowers. London: Penguin, 2001. Purpose The purpose of the article is to thwart down her critiques misleading interpretations of the poem biased on sexual overtones. She is vowed to help explain that the poem is children-based and can be used to teach children as we saw the two sisters in the later years using their experience top teach their children of the evil goblin market. Summary As pointed out by Rossetti (1962), the global market is a narrative poem composed by Christina Rossetti in April 1859 while its publishing was in 1862. According to the author, in her attempt to counteract her critiques to whom she...
6 Pages(1500 words)Annotated Bibliography

Sexual Interest in Children

...Results and discussion al affiliation: Introduction The purpose of the research was to determine the different facets of sexual harassment on children. The use of children for sexual gratification is a worldwide problem (Greytak, 2003). Apparently, the reality surrounding harassment on children cannot be overlooked. Its recognition in the society as major problem-affecting children remains anonymous. Child abuse involves stimulation of children sexually either through pornographic materials or physically. In this respect, sexual child abuse remains one of the major problems parents have to deal with. Many cases go unreported while others reach into the light. Additionally, many cases do not end into prosecution of perpetrators (Strauss...
7 Pages(1750 words)Assignment

Sexual Harassment at Workplace

...Sexual Harassment in the Workplace Outline Fahad Alrasheed HDL 625 Murray April 29, Table of Contents Introduction 3 Legal Description of Sexual Harassment at Workplace 3 Statutory Basis of Sexual Harassment at Workplace 3 Societal Description of Sexual Harassment at Workplace 3 Literal Description of Sexual Harassment at Workplace 4 Legal Issues Surrounding Sexual Abuse at Workplace 4 Literature Review 5 Legal Description of Work Place Sexual Harassment 5 Types of Sexual Harassment 6 Quid Pro Quo 6 Hostile Work Environment Harassment 7 Elements of Sexual Abuse at Workplace 7 Characteristics of Sexual Harassment in the Workplace 7 Causes of Sexual Harassment in the Workplace 7 Evaluating the Organizational Environment 8...
13 Pages(3250 words)Term Paper
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Case Study on topic Sexual Offence for FREE!

Contact Us