StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...

Police Discretion Position - Essay Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
Summary
When asked whether full enforcement is constantly practiced, police usually answer in the affirmative, citing "policy" as the reason. The main ingredient of all law enforcement policies is a commitment to enforce all laws. Even though a shortfall exists in the resources needed to enforce all laws and police officers' perceptions about prosecutors, judges, and the entire court system may influence their decisions to enforce all laws, police still fail to acknowledge the lack of full enforcement…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER91.7% of users find it useful
Police Discretion Position
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "Police Discretion Position"

Download file to see previous pages One will find that it is very common throughout the country that virtually all of police work involves discretion, with the exclusion of mandatory arrests. Furthermore, it is not just the police officer who has to use discretion, but it is also the prosecutor deciding what charges to file or how the offender should be sentenced, and the judge who has the most discretion of all when it comes to setting the ultimate punishment at the culmination of the case. Therefore, it is unlikely that discretion is a myth. It simply must exist for the criminal justice system to function as is. Laws cannot be passed to cover every possible scenario, which makes the practice of using discretion necessary in law enforcement.
According to Maggs (1992, pg. 1), "Few issues in criminal justice presently arouse the public's attention more than how much flexibility and discretion the police should have. Police departments and their officers traditionally have had broad authority to decide how to perform their work, and most people simply have trusted that they will exercise their powers in a professional manner. Yet, acceptance of the traditional arrangement has diminished, perhaps more in the past year than ever before. Disturbing incidents of misconduct, incompetence, and unresponsiveness have suggested to many a need for closer control over individual officers and for external constraints on departmental policy-making."
There are a number of causes of discretion that should be taken into consideration. They are commonly grouped into three categories: offender variables, situation variables, and system variables. There are stern but true facts that surround each of these variables (APSU, 2007).
The first group is offender variables. Juvenile complaints are taken less seriously than those made by adults. African Americans are more likely to receive excessive force or be arrested than other races. People who are polite and cooperative with police are treated better by them. Better police service is given to individuals with middle to upper income levels than other those in lower income brackets. Police also tend to handle situations involving individuals suffering from mental illnesses differently. Gender plays a role in how individuals are treated by police. Only some offenders are lectured and sympathized with by police (APSU, 2007).
The second group is situation variables. Matters involving crime are taken more seriously by police than matters not involving crime. Police often overact to the presence of weapons or to resistance by an offender. Police actions are also affected by the type of property that is involved in a property crime and their decision whether or not to pursue any investigation on that crime. If a police officer initiates an act versus a citizen, it is more likely to be acted upon. When it comes to vice enforcement, visibility of the vice is the major factor in acting upon it. When the media, an audience, or witnesses are present, the police are far more likely to behave more bureaucratically than they would otherwise (ASPU, 2007).
The final category is system variables. ...Download file to see next pagesRead More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Police Discretion Position Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 words”, n.d.)
Police Discretion Position Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 words. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1506975-police-discretion-position
(Police Discretion Position Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 Words)
Police Discretion Position Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 Words. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1506975-police-discretion-position.
“Police Discretion Position Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1506975-police-discretion-position.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Police Discretion Position

Critically analyse the problems involved in Police use of discretion

...?Critically analyse the problems involved in Police use of discretion? Introduction In simple terms the use of discretion by police refers to their action and ability to choose when to intervene and when not to intervene in the enforcement of law. Reiner regarded discretion as a particular tool in police organisation to be used by officers at the very ground level who are operating away from the immediate supervision of management1. This paper shall critically analyse the problems involved in the police use of discretion. It shall specifically discuss the practice of ethnic and other subjective considerations in routine stops and searches, the evaluation of domestic violence incidents, and similar police activities. The use of discretion...
14 Pages(3500 words)Essay

Administrative Discretion

...? Administrative Discretion (College) Administrative Discretion Introduction Public employees constitute the of people who work at the public sector under the direct control and administration of government. Although, public employees get comparatively attractive remuneration for their services, they are always vulnerable to salary-cut and other compensations in times of national contingencies. Since the public sector employees play a vital role in the economic growth of a nation, every nation normally formulates special policies for preserving the interests of public employees. However, it seems that various organizational practices and other developments impinge on the worksite interests of public employees. With intent to discuss...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay

Police Discretion

...?PD <Police Discretion> and Section # of Police Discretion In the fast growing world, the crimerate is ever rising, hence the police officers in charge of daily civilian peace face a variety of situations which they have to deal with in order to maintain public law and order. It rarely happens that the same incident takes place in the very same manner as every incident or crime has a specific signature attached to it. Usually the police officer facing the situation is the judge at the precise moment of action and a slight error of judgment can cause massive loss of either the officer himself or public property and order. This is the soul essence of the report, the police officer and his judgment actions at the spot, in the field...
4 Pages(1000 words)Research Paper

Does Police Discretion Amount to a Miscarriage of Justice

...?Does Police Discretion Amount to a Miscarriage of Justice? Introduction It is only in the recent decades that scholars have shifted their focus fromoffenders to the police. One of the issues that scholars discovered, when looking at law enforcement, which appears to have brought about a certain level of controversy was ‘police discretion’. Police discretion, according to Scraton (1985 as cited in Pond 1999, 94), implies that “Police officers necessarily use their personal judgment to weigh up a situation and enforce the law” (Pond 1999, 94). Basically, the police do not implement the law at all times and an undeniable proof of an unlawful act does not constantly lead to criminal trials. In truth, as stated by some criminologists, when...
9 Pages(2250 words)Literature review

Police Discretion in Domestic Violence

Most police officers feel that a domestic dispute is a private matter that should be handled by both parties. However, police officers mostly rely on their experience as police officers to handle the situation as they think appropriate. Police Discretion in Domestic Violence Introduction Family problems which breed domestic violence are universal issues which affect all members of the family including parents and children. Domestic violence can be fatal, but it can be effectively controlled with the proper implementation of law and timely and appropriate intervention by the police. Police reactions to incidents of domestic violence have usually depended upon the attitude and discretion of the officer involved in investigating the...
8 Pages(2000 words)Research Paper

Police Discretion Position Paper

... The issue of police discretion, while a seemingly natural aspect of the duties of a law enforcement officer, is a topic which generates much debate. A more modern view posits that police discretion is a valuable and necessary part of police work. To this end, calls for the elimination of police discretion have been replaced by proposals to more carefully define when and how police officers should use discretion. This modern view operates on the assumption that police work is often complex, that situations are rarely neat and simple, and that discretion results in better police work than a mechanistic application of the law. Police discretion can best be characterized as the use of judgment in fluid situations and settings. Several...
5 Pages(1250 words)Essay

Police discretion postion

...POLICE DISCRETION Position Paper Introduction: The exercise of police discretion in enforcing criminal laws is a very important aspect of police work. Discretion is considered to be one of the most important tools used by the police because of the vastness, complexity and vagueness which are inherent characteristics of both policing and parts of the law. Dantzker (2005) states that according to Black’s Law Dictionary police discretion can be defined as “the power to act in an official capacity in a manner which appears to be just and proper under the circumstances”. Discretion denotes the power or freedom to judge and decide what needs to be done in a particular situation. It is the action that a police officer takes, according to personal...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay

(Criminal Justice) Police Discretion & Corruption

...Criminal Justice Ethics - Police Discretion and Corruption Criminal Justice Ethics - Police Discretion and Corruption There ismore corruption in the police force today than there was in the past. The extension of the influence of police departments is responsible for increased corruption. For instance, if more branches of departments such as those responsible for preventing the drug trade are created, there will be more opportunity for police officers to be offered bribes, or even kickbacks from professionals who are proposed as potential leaders of drug programs and task forces. The fact that many more people than was the case in the past are seeking police protection for their businesses also means there is more opportunity for extortion...
1 Pages(250 words)Assignment

Equity Issues in the City Police Department

The front-line activities are carried out by the Department of Operations, and its functions are distributed under the following sections of the Department:

1. Patrolling and Support: The city area has been divided into several zones like central, north, south, east, southeast, northeast, northwest, etc. to efficiently extend these services to every part of the city.

This department, in its mission statement, has declared that it is committed to improving the quality of the life of citizens, by having problem-solving partnerships with various communities, government agencies, and members of the community, so as to achieve a high degree of fairness, integrity, respect, transparency and equitable distribution o...
6 Pages(1500 words)Case Study

Police and Society: Post 9/11

The paper then takes note of a number of initiatives that have attempted to combine local policing with intelligence work. This shift from crime-prevention to counter-terrorism has had a profound effect upon these local law enforcement divisions; lack of proper funding has also undermined these projects, leaving local officers with the ability to prevent terrorists, but either lacking in resources or risking becoming dependant upon intelligence divisions. The paper will then turn to a consideration of two local communities, Dearborn, Michigan, and Las Vegas, Nevada, that have been involved in these initiatives, and considers the impact of counter-terrorism policing upon the wider local law enforcement of the region.

By...
12 Pages(3000 words)Case Study

Pros and Cons of Police Discretion in Domestic Violence Situations

Flaws have been raised as to why the full discretion rests on the hands of the police officers, now if there is the need to deal with the situation and as much as possible eliminate cases like these, then why let the police defined justice on matters like these? We need to weigh between the advantages and disadvantages of letting the police adjudicate domestic violence for us to establish a point to modify or to enforce the legislation. This paper has thus presented some of the pros and cons as according to some concerned social services, apparently because they have more accurate listings other than those who have the authority.
Domestic Violence. Domestic violence emerges as one of the most predominant crime usually commit...
12 Pages(3000 words)Research Paper

Why Police Officers Killed in the Line of Duty

3. Rationale: It is quite ambiguous to discover the exact reasons why police officers are targeted to be killed by criminals. Many of the bogus reasons for this heinous crime have been that of self-defense on the part of the culprits, or it occurred in the course of fending off racial maltreatment common to some over-ambitious police officers.

4. Objective: The crucial objective of this research is to explore the core of this subject matter and argue critically why such an occurrence happens in the first instance, and how it could be constructively prevented.

5. Statement and significance of the problem: This social problem has robbed the Police of the lives and services of some energetic police officers. And...
6 Pages(1500 words)Research Paper

Role of the Police and Private Security

... terrorism. Hence understanding the criminal justice system is extremely important so that it may be implemented effectively and impartially. Hence, this report will also cover the following areas namely, the three levels of law enforcement in United States, the interaction between those agencies, the role of the police and private security personnel in homeland security, the role of this group in intelligence gathering and federal funding. Three levels of law enforcement: The three levels of law enforcement in the United States cover national, state and local security. This task of homeland security is the responsibility of the Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI), the state police forces, and the local police force. Each of them has...
8 Pages(2000 words)Case Study

The Purpose and Effectiveness of Police Patrol

... good relationships with the members of the community, then they can use these networks to make sure that crimes are solved before they even occur or the occurrence of crime is decreased. Once trust is established between both the members of the community and the police, perceptions on the legitimacy of the police is increased, and this has been known to have a direct effect on the crime rate in a particular area. The main reason for this is that the legitimacy of the police fosters an increase in the willingness to actually obey the law. In addition, when the police is viewed as concerned individuals, who respect the law and the public, and when they are seen to possess legitimate authority, there is a significant increase in the positive...
9 Pages(2250 words)Literature review

Police Discretion: Issues of Decision Making

After making a decision, the officer must then ensure both uniformity and agreement with decrees and prosecutorial policies set by the authority, police policies and any orders. This leaves the police officer with very hard decisions to make. Since the officer knows that he/she will be accountable for all the decisions that he/she makes, it becomes hard to make certain decisions. The officer is compelled to follow the policies set by the higher authorities as well as the interests of the society (Atherton, 3).
Police are given the use of discretion specifically since we believe that allowing the use of judgment in some circumstances can lead to improved results than setting up a rigid set of rules, strategies, and measures that...
15 Pages(3750 words)Term Paper

Police Power of Search and Seizure

... affecting civil life (Dempsey & Forst, 2009). Through these expanded authority and reach of the police, there has been an increase in use of surveillance; for gathering information, especially on persons believed to be criminals or terrorists. President Obama’s amendment of the Executive Order 12425, that designated Interpol as being a public international organization that is entitled to enjoyment of certain privileges, immunities and exemptions, elevated Interpol and its activities above the American Constitution and Local enforcement agencies (Dempsey & Forst, 2009). In conclusion, in view of the above, it is critical to note that there are positive outcomes to this power of the police in that there is increased security, especially...
6 Pages(1500 words)Term Paper

Analysis of the Documentary about Police Investigation

...Police Investigation Before I started to watch this film I gathered a book and pen and resolved to try and lay aside my own views and keep an open mind to the material that is presented to me. As the film began, I was immediately impressed by its slick presentation, with an authoritative narrator and frequent shots moving from photographs to sound bites to sections of interview. It seemed to be a quality production and it laid out an intriguing set of circumstances that made for good television entertainment: a violent rape and murder, a set of suspects, police investigations, court scenes and a twisting track of investigation that raised a number of mysteries that needed to be resolved. Overall, therefore, my first impressions were...
6 Pages(1500 words)Essay

The Position of Women in Islam

...Status of Women under Islam by Introduction Muslim society is traditionally critiqued for the position of women in Islam. Islamic religious law, Sharia, presupposes differences between men and women rights and obligations. The differences can be seen in the questions of marriage, divorce, education, law, and clothes. Western society considers any limitation and restrictions to be blameworthy. However, it is impossible not to take in the account the fact that men and women are not the same, and treating them in similar way is illogical. Men and women want different things in life and are destined for different things in life. Thus, basing on the long-term observation of men and women nature Islam offers a separate way of treating women...
6 Pages(1500 words)Term Paper

National Database for Police Killings

... National Database for Police Killings The proposed essay will be based on Censored Story #18; National Database of Police Killings Aims for Accountability. The topic identified for further analysis in the proposed essay involves the lack of a national database, which tracks the death of civilians as a result of lethal use of force by the police in the United States. The death of Michael Brown at the hands of police was an incident that I found unacceptable and tragic, especially when it emerged that this has been a pattern in black neighborhoods all over the United States. Indeed, the number of black civilians killed by the police is shocking because I believe in human rights for all, which I also believe is what the US constitution...
7 Pages(1750 words)Essay

Reasonable Force Use by Police

... to permanent and temporary wound cavitations, the suspect might still be in a position of harming not only the officer, but also the general public. Only a few police reports have confirmed that in some scenarios, even if multiple shots were fired, only a few of them strike their aimed targets (Arend and Robert 67). During life and death gunfight, a police officer will know if he or she is making effective shots on the threat because in most cases, the threat ends up falling or giving up and they cannot advance in the fight. In other cases, it is essential for police officers to depend on partial information when making a lethal force decision. At times, the significance of circumstances is gauged in a split second wherein an officer...
14 Pages(3500 words)Case Study
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Essay on topic Police Discretion Position for FREE!

Contact Us