StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...

Police Discretion Position Paper - Essay Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
Summary
The issue of police discretion, while a seemingly natural aspect of the duties of a law enforcement officer, is a topic which generates much debate. A more modern view posits that police discretion is a valuable and necessary part of police work. To this end, calls for the elimination of police discretion have been replaced by proposals to more carefully define when and how police officers should use discretion…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER92% of users find it useful
Police Discretion Position Paper
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "Police Discretion Position Paper"

Download file to see previous pages Several myths, such as an inevitable abuse of power, are unsupported by the research. The main causes of police discretion are offender variables, situational variables, and systemic variables. The exercise of police discretion arises in many situations, such as domestic violence and juvenile delinquency, and can often lead to positive resolutions. Discretion is a valuable part of police work.
The issue of police discretion, while a seemingly natural aspect of the duties of a law enforcement officer, is a topic which generates much debate. Historically, the concept of police discretion was thought to be associated with police corruption and with an "extralegal" use of police power (O'Connor, 2005: np). Indeed, the recognition of police discretion as a legitimate aspect of police duties was not formally recognized until 1956 when it was formally identified and discussed by an American Bar Association study. This revelation, that the police did in fact use discretion in the course of their duties, generated a substantial amount of controversy: "When it was finally exposed, people like the American Friends Service Committee (1971) called for its abolishment, and police administrators sought a clampdown on discretion (administrative rulemaking)" (O'Connor, 2005: np). In the beginning, though police discretion was an integral part of daily police work, it was viewed with suspicion.
A more modern view posits that police discretion is a valuable and necessary part of police work. To this end, calls for the elimination of police discretion have been replaced by proposals to more carefully define when and how police officers should use discretion. This modern view operates on the assumption that police work is often complex, that situations are rarely neat and simple, and that discretion results in better police work than a mechanistic application of the law. As noted by a National Institute of Justice Research Report, "Each tactical choice by the police, each citizen's response, counter responses by each, and changes in other variables in the context (for instance,
intervention of strangers) create a fluid, ever-changing encounter" (1997: pg.35). This essay will define what is meant by "police discretion", a number of common myths associated with the concept, and the real-life sources of the need for police discretion. The essay will then present ten practical illustrations of police discretion in operation in order to compare situations in which discretion is used appropriately and situations in which discretion very well might be abused.
Police Discretion: Definitions, Myths, and Sources
Discretion means many things and encompasses a tremendous variety of different situations. From a theoretical point of view, it has been referred to as the making of decisions where the law is not clear, where the police officer has alternative courses of action, and where a cost-benefit analysis cautions against the rigid application of the law. Some scholars have defined police discretion as judgments made within the realm of a "regulated autonomy" (De Lint, 1998: pg. 2) and others have characterized discretion as a police officer's role as a public servant whom is sworn to balance the intent of the law against the interests of ...Download file to see next pagesRead More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Police Discretion Position Paper Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 words”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1534486-police-discretion-position-paper
(Police Discretion Position Paper Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 Words)
https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1534486-police-discretion-position-paper.
“Police Discretion Position Paper Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1534486-police-discretion-position-paper.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Police Discretion Position Paper

Police Discretion

This is the soul essence of the report, the police officer and his judgment actions at the spot, in the field at a particular instance; a fact that differentiates a good officer from an average one. Definition Discretion can be described as a police officers’ will to act upon a certain situation or not and in what way. That is for example whether to stop a speeding motorist, book him or leave him with a gentle warning. The definition may be true but more often than not discretion is associated with use of force in the field. This discretion can be in either deciding to see force and if using so, how much and to what extent (Hunt 1985). Another school of thought preaches that the discretion of a police officer is with regard to th...
4 Pages(1000 words)Research Paper

Police Discretion in Domestic Violence

Most police officers feel that a domestic dispute is a private matter that should be handled by both parties. However, police officers mostly rely on their experience as police officers to handle the situation as they think appropriate. Police Discretion in Domestic Violence Introduction Family problems which breed domestic violence are universal issues which affect all members of the family including parents and children. Domestic violence can be fatal, but it can be effectively controlled with the proper implementation of law and timely and appropriate intervention by the police. Police reactions to incidents of domestic violence have usually depended upon the attitude and discretion of the officer involved in investigating the...
8 Pages(2000 words)Research Paper

Police Discretion Position

...Police Discretion Position According to Davis (1975, pg When asked whether full enforcement is constantly practiced, police usually answer in theaffirmative, citing "policy" as the reason. The main ingredient of all law enforcement policies is a commitment to enforce all laws. Even though a shortfall exists in the resources needed to enforce all laws and police officers' perceptions about prosecutors, judges, and the entire court system may influence their decisions to enforce all laws, police still fail to acknowledge the lack of full enforcement. Nevertheless, the citizen who has been stopped for a traffic violation and been given a warning instead of a citation knows that discretion in enforcement exists. Even when confronted...
6 Pages(1500 words)Essay

Police discretion postion

...POLICE DISCRETION Position Paper Introduction: The exercise of police discretion in enforcing criminal laws is a very important aspect of police work. Discretion is considered to be one of the most important tools used by the police because of the vastness, complexity and vagueness which are inherent characteristics of both policing and parts of the law. Dantzker (2005) states that according to Black’s Law Dictionary police discretion can be defined as “the power to act in an official capacity in a manner which appears to be just and proper under the circumstances”. Discretion denotes the power or freedom to judge and decide what needs to be done in a particular situation. It is the action that a police officer takes, according to personal...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay

(Criminal Justice) Police Discretion & Corruption

...Criminal Justice Ethics - Police Discretion and Corruption Criminal Justice Ethics - Police Discretion and Corruption There ismore corruption in the police force today than there was in the past. The extension of the influence of police departments is responsible for increased corruption. For instance, if more branches of departments such as those responsible for preventing the drug trade are created, there will be more opportunity for police officers to be offered bribes, or even kickbacks from professionals who are proposed as potential leaders of drug programs and task forces. The fact that many more people than was the case in the past are seeking police protection for their businesses also means there is more opportunity for extortion...
1 Pages(250 words)Assignment

Equity Issues in the City Police Department

The front-line activities are carried out by the Department of Operations, and its functions are distributed under the following sections of the Department:

1. Patrolling and Support: The city area has been divided into several zones like central, north, south, east, southeast, northeast, northwest, etc. to efficiently extend these services to every part of the city.

This department, in its mission statement, has declared that it is committed to improving the quality of the life of citizens, by having problem-solving partnerships with various communities, government agencies, and members of the community, so as to achieve a high degree of fairness, integrity, respect, transparency and equitable distribution o...
6 Pages(1500 words)Case Study

Police and Society: Post 9/11

The paper then takes note of a number of initiatives that have attempted to combine local policing with intelligence work. This shift from crime-prevention to counter-terrorism has had a profound effect upon these local law enforcement divisions; lack of proper funding has also undermined these projects, leaving local officers with the ability to prevent terrorists, but either lacking in resources or risking becoming dependant upon intelligence divisions. The paper will then turn to a consideration of two local communities, Dearborn, Michigan, and Las Vegas, Nevada, that have been involved in these initiatives, and considers the impact of counter-terrorism policing upon the wider local law enforcement of the region.

By...
12 Pages(3000 words)Case Study

James Madison's 51st Federalist Paper

If this theory was seriously followed, it would suggest that the citizens must opt for the president, the legislators, as well as the judges. However, the framers identified certain realistic problems in making all the offices elective. Especially, the judicial branch would face problems because the typical person does not have knowledge about what qualifications judges ought to have. Judges must have great capability, but also not have any political pressures. While federal judges are selected for life, their philosophy will not be inclined via the president who appoints them or the senators whose permission the president will take.

All the arguments were generated due to his past life as he was in an aristocratic fami...
6 Pages(1500 words)Term Paper

Role of the Police and Private Security

... terrorism. Hence understanding the criminal justice system is extremely important so that it may be implemented effectively and impartially. Hence, this report will also cover the following areas namely, the three levels of law enforcement in United States, the interaction between those agencies, the role of the police and private security personnel in homeland security, the role of this group in intelligence gathering and federal funding. Three levels of law enforcement: The three levels of law enforcement in the United States cover national, state and local security. This task of homeland security is the responsibility of the Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI), the state police forces, and the local police force. Each of them has...
8 Pages(2000 words)Case Study

The Purpose and Effectiveness of Police Patrol

...Running Head: Police Patrolling The Purpose and Effectiveness of Police Patrolling The main purpose of this paper is to discuss the reasons why police patrollers are needed in the country, and why they have proven to be useful towards the development of peace and order throughout the nation. The researcher has also presented information that would show that the police patrol system is not without flaws. In other words, the system still requires plenty of improvement- one of them being the collaboration of the community members themselves. Clearly, it is important that for any system to work, there should be trust and cooperation between all involved parties. The same holds true with the police patrol system. The researcher has also...
9 Pages(2250 words)Literature review

Police Power of Search and Seizure

...POLICE POWER OF SEARCH AND SEIZURE Police Power of Search and Seizure Searches and seizures are necessary exercises in the contemporary society, in their assistance in the pursuit of criminals. They are used in order to provide evidence to assist in the prosecution of alleged criminals. The police are granted the powers of search and seizure but the public, particularly at the personal individual level, are protected against unreasonable and arbitrary police intrusions. In order to guard against arbitrary intrusions by police enforcement officers, there was a ratification of the Fourth Amendment of the American Constitution, which states; “the right of the people to be secure in their persons, houses, papers, and effects against...
6 Pages(1500 words)Term Paper

Analysis of the Documentary about Police Investigation

...Police Investigation Before I started to watch this film I gathered a book and pen and resolved to try and lay aside my own views and keep an open mind to the material that is presented to me. As the film began, I was immediately impressed by its slick presentation, with an authoritative narrator and frequent shots moving from photographs to sound bites to sections of interview. It seemed to be a quality production and it laid out an intriguing set of circumstances that made for good television entertainment: a violent rape and murder, a set of suspects, police investigations, court scenes and a twisting track of investigation that raised a number of mysteries that needed to be resolved. Overall, therefore, my first impressions were...
6 Pages(1500 words)Essay

The Position of Women in Islam

...Status of Women under Islam by Introduction Muslim society is traditionally critiqued for the position of women in Islam. Islamic religious law, Sharia, presupposes differences between men and women rights and obligations. The differences can be seen in the questions of marriage, divorce, education, law, and clothes. Western society considers any limitation and restrictions to be blameworthy. However, it is impossible not to take in the account the fact that men and women are not the same, and treating them in similar way is illogical. Men and women want different things in life and are destined for different things in life. Thus, basing on the long-term observation of men and women nature Islam offers a separate way of treating women...
6 Pages(1500 words)Term Paper

National Database for Police Killings

... National Database for Police Killings The proposed essay will be based on Censored Story #18; National Database of Police Killings Aims for Accountability. The topic identified for further analysis in the proposed essay involves the lack of a national database, which tracks the death of civilians as a result of lethal use of force by the police in the United States. The death of Michael Brown at the hands of police was an incident that I found unacceptable and tragic, especially when it emerged that this has been a pattern in black neighborhoods all over the United States. Indeed, the number of black civilians killed by the police is shocking because I believe in human rights for all, which I also believe is what the US constitution...
7 Pages(1750 words)Essay

Reasonable Force Use by Police

Some of the cons include breaching of people’s right to freedom, officers misusing this power, corruption and needless killing among others.
This section will conclude which side outweighs the other and recommend what should be done about the use of force. The advantages outweigh the disadvantages, but the people found out that it is best that officers try to use their power in a proper way that protects the public.

The "professional era" of policing started in the 60s after the Omnibus Crime Control and Safe Streets Act came into law, in 1968. The law passed that federal resources and funds would be offered to local agencies to improve their equipment and training (Tyler 84). This concurred with the peak o...
14 Pages(3500 words)Case Study
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Essay on topic Police Discretion Position Paper for FREE!

Contact Us