Research, Evaluation & Policy Analysis - Essay Example

Running Head: RESEARCH, EVALUATION & POLICY ANALYSIS Research, Evaluation & Policy Analysis Date:421463Research, Evaluation & Policy AnalysisResearch on Re-Introduction of Capital Punishment in AustraliaResearch QuestionsCapital Punishment had been used in Australia up to 1967. Since then Humanitarian has provided the conception of a person in prison as one who needs to be reformed and punished. It is believed that the vindictive penalties have been done away with (Walton, 2003). It is being debated on the media: if its introduction is called for 1.

Do you support the re-introduction as on the media If yes, what reasons to you have for supporting it 2. It has been perceived as a barbarism and illogical as well as a second rate deterrent. Do you believe that its re-introduction would diminish the value set on human life and would hanging mean that the government sees it cheap3. Capital punishment has still been reserved in the contemporary world as the criminals designedly and willfully take away the lives of innocent people.

Do you think that it would be justifiable and ethical to use death as a possible punishment for such capital crimes If you think so, why Prior to Ryan's execution the states of New South Wales and Queensland had brought the practice to an end. Walton (2003) indicates that death penalty had been part of the Australian legal system since the settlement by British in the 19th century. Crimes which had the potential of carrying capital punishment included forgery, burglary, stealing of sheep, sexual assault, manslaughter and murder as well as robbery with violence.

Other crimes included piracy, treason and arson of naval dockyards.4. Which crimes if any do you think, deserve capital punishment 5. Will this re-introduction of death penalty for such crimes reduce the level of such crimes committed in all states In what ways do you think it will perfect this6. The strategy to re-introduce the practice in Australia would have different reactions from various citizens of different caliber. What do you think would be the feeling of the majority of the citizens7.

If life has been perceived as so secret that no where on earth where a murderer would escape the extradition laws, then how, can the authorities be justified in taking away life 8. Moreover, if punishment can prevent the incarceration in such a lunatic asylum as well as the objective of the natural life, is not it more appealing to have punishment than just be summoned to face a quick and sudden as well as an awful death Do you think a big number would support it and why Would this create emotional reaction to a crime which is against the people of Australia instead of the real desire to abolish the anti-death penalty standard The death sentences were conducted under Aboriginal customary law through sorcery or directly.

The victims were denied mortuary rites. The initial executions were conducted when the authorities then in Australia did hanging of mutineers of the Batavia.9. If the practice is re-introduced back, which means and criteria do you think would be appropriate to use in doing away with the condemned ones10. Do you think it would be appropriate and ethical to deny such individuals their ritual rites after hanging in mortuary as they were treated before How do you think the condemned needs to be treated after hanging 11 It is appropriate to have capital punishment re-introduced on a state-to state basis Would it be appropriate for each state to have its own criminal laws and ways of punishment rather than being applied country wide 12 Since its abolishment, death penalty has been replaced by life imprisonment as the maximum applicable punishment.

Is it sufficient for as punishment for such crimes Does it help combat the crimes that were punishable by dearth sentence13. According to Law Reform Commission of Western Australia (2003), hangings were done at several places including the site of the committed offense. In 1888, the Imperial Convict Establishment at Fremantle used employed for all hangings in the state. Is it appropriate to have such hanging centers rather than the practice being done any where If yes which places are most appropriate14.

If hanging to death has to be used how should it be conducted 15. Should be in public or in private and should the relatives of the body be allowed to burry their loved ones or should it be laid down to rest in a public cemetery ReferencesLaw Reform Commission of Western Australia. 2003. Traditional Aboriginal Law and Punishment: Aboriginal Customary Law and the Criminal Justice System. Retrieved on March 12, 2010 from http://www.lrc.justice.wa.gov.au/2publications/reports/ACL/DP/Part_05B.

pdf Walton, M. 2003. Australian Policy on the Death Policy: Australian Position on the Death Penalty. Retrieved on March 12, 2010 from http://wwww.nswccl.org.au/issues/death_penalty/aust_policy.php