StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...

The Plight of the Insured: Fact or Fraud - Case Study Example

Cite this document
Summary
The paper “The Plight of the Insured: Fact or Fraud?” looks at the case of the insured who purchased a house, converted it to two apartments and left Cape Breton to find work in British Columbia. The house remained vacant for a period of time before a tenant moved in…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER94.6% of users find it useful
The Plight of the Insured: Fact or Fraud
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "The Plight of the Insured: Fact or Fraud"

Download file to see previous pages

Did it operate as an inducement to the insurer to enter into the policy In order to be entitled to avoid a contract of insurance or reinsurance on the ground of non-disclosure the insurer must show both that the fact not disclosed was material, and that its non-disclosure induced the contract? To be material a fact did not have to have a decisive influence on the mind of the prudent underwriter. The test is as stated in subsections 18(2) and 20(2) which relate to non-disclosure and misrepresentation respectively and which set out the common law principles relevant to non-marine (as well as marine) insurance.

The material non-disclosure or misrepresentation must induce the contract. It is not sufficient that the non-disclosure or misrepresentation is material. ". . . there is to be implied in the Act of 1906 a qualification that a material representation will not entitle the underwriter to avoid the policy unless the misrepresentation induced the making of the contract, using "induced" in the sense in which it is used in the general law of contract" and "in practice the line between misrepresentation and non-disclosure is often imperceptible.

"The claimants insured their yacht with the defendants for value as certified by an independent valuer. The defendants claimed he had misrepresented the value in the proposal. The words 'sum insured' indicated a ceiling on a claim on an unvalued policy. There was no indication from the insurers on the proposal form that they would agree with the value, but rather they asked only for the value to be insured. The policy was, therefore, an unvalued policy.HIH Casualty and General Insurance Ltd and Others -v- Chase Manhattan Bank and Others [2001] 1 Lloyd's Rep 30Disclosure law in other countries is possibly more tilted in favor of the insured than in the UK.

  The Canadian case of Marche –v- Halifax Insurance Company (2005) involved an insured who purchased a house, insured it, but then left it vacant before its first tenant moved in.  After the tenant moved in, the house was destroyed by fire, but the insurer attempted to avoid liability because the period of vacancy had caused a significant change in the condition of the house, according to the “statutory” condition of the contract.  While the defendant prevailed in a lower court, the appeal court found that Part VII of the Insurance Act applied only to contractual conditions – not statutory conditions – and so the plaintiff won the appellate judgment (Marche).

 A similar reversal occurred in a US case involving non-disclosure and liability.  Wilson –v- 21st Century Insurance Company (2006) was an action claiming “breach of contract and tortious bad faith” in adjusting the plaintiff’s claim of damages in an accident with an uninsured motorist.  The summary judgment initially awarded to the defendant was overturned, because the plaintiff had not been given sufficient time to complete discovery, specifically in the area of the defendant’s investigation of the plaintiff’s accident (Wilson).

Initially, it may appear that UK law seems to have a more even balance between insured and insurer, but it would be difficult, on the basis of case law, to urge reform in laws governing liability and disclosure.

...Download file to see next pages Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(The Plight of the Insured: Fact or Fraud Case Study, n.d.)
The Plight of the Insured: Fact or Fraud Case Study. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/law/1504676-principles-of-international-insurance-law
(The Plight of the Insured: Fact or Fraud Case Study)
The Plight of the Insured: Fact or Fraud Case Study. https://studentshare.org/law/1504676-principles-of-international-insurance-law.
“The Plight of the Insured: Fact or Fraud Case Study”. https://studentshare.org/law/1504676-principles-of-international-insurance-law.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF The Plight of the Insured: Fact or Fraud

Sick Around America directed by Jon Palfreman

Failure to disclose anything material is regarded as fraud and the insurers employ this opportunity to recede retrospectively coverage of persons after they have become sick.... This is compounded by the fact that the insurers have access to all the medical records ever developed about any person.... Indeed, the documentary points to the fact that some insurers actually paid bonuses to their employees who were in charge of rescission based on how many rescissions the carried out in a given year....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Sustainable Marketing of Emirates Airline

Sustainable Marketing (Name) (Institution) (Course) (Tutor) (Date) Table of Contents 1Introduction 3 2Stakeholder Analysis 4 3Customer Analysis 4 4Competitor Analysis 5 5Company Analysis 6 6Community Analysis 7 7Brand Positioning Analysis 7 8Bibliography: 10 1 Introduction Emirates Airline is a long-haul airline which is ranked second to Singapore Airlines in terms of profitability....
7 Pages (1750 words) Essay

How Well Does Insurance Contract Regulation Work

hellip; There are two parties involved, the insurer which is the insurance company proffering or selling the insurance and the insured, widely known as policyholder, an entity or a person buying the insurance policy.... The payment settled out for the insurance policy according to the An insurance policy is documented properly and the insured is handed over a contract which signifies the terms and conditions under which the insurance policy will be processed and the circumstances under which the financial compensation will be carried out1....
11 Pages (2750 words) Research Paper

Teresa Reifs Insurance Fraud Case

The paper “Teresa Reif's Insurance fraud Case” analyzes fraud as one of the biggest challenges that many organizations face today.... Findings show that organizations loss billions of dollars in the form of fraud.... hellip; The paper will provide recommendations on how best a fraud of this type may be prevented in the future.... Report also shows that occupational fraud is the most common.... Nevertheless, white-collar fraud is also reported being on the rise....
7 Pages (1750 words) Research Paper

Written Modified Duty Program

In any organization, productivity and hence profitability is based on making sure that injured workers return to work safely and early enough after a workplace injury or disease.... The longer an injured employee has to wait for help the less likely it is to be operative and the… The intent of this paper is to discuss return to work program after an employee in the company has been injured. It is factual that the finest habitation to rehabilitate most wounded workers is in the job Apart from promoting a faster recovery, activities undertaken at work have proved to be more therapeutic than long rest or only receiving treatment in a hospital away from the workplace....
12 Pages (3000 words) Essay

The Duty of Utmost Good Faith in the Contract of Insurance

The doctrine requires the insured party to such contract to disclose all vital and relevant information that could reinforce the insurer's knowledge of the incoming client.... Consequently, the… The doctrine of utmost good faith has limited to no applicability outside the insurance sector....
17 Pages (4250 words) Research Paper

Economic Change Effect Frauds

Even though both judgment and knowledge inform us so as to the risk of fraud could be keen in the current economy, it is almost unfeasible to measure the factual quantity of fraud.... Therefore, no precise calculation of the height of fraud throughout the contemporary recession could subsist.... To obtain a pulsation on how the economy is touching fraud tendencies, the ACFE left to the professionals who are in the ditches hostility fraud on an everyday basis....
16 Pages (4000 words) Research Paper

What The Government Should Do About Whiplash Claims

As a result, rampant cases of fraud, lack of discipline on the road and heavy cost of motoring have led to an increase in the number of such cases.... An author of the essay "What The Government Should Do About Whiplash Claims" reports in the UK whiplash damages have become too common among victims of accidents to an extent that local insurance companies are now facing problems expending the damages....
7 Pages (1750 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us