StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...

Does Zero Tolerance Policing 'work' - Essay Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
Summary
Borrowed from the Reagan-era war on drugs, the phrase "zero tolerance" is now being applied as a judicial model by universities and government agencies in investigation and prosecution of charges of harassment and discrimination. The principle of zero tolerance is that once an accusation is made of, say, sexual abuse, violence against women, or profanity in the schools, it should be followed by immediate arrest of the alleged perpetrator, even if the accusation was made anonymously…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER98.1% of users find it useful
Does Zero Tolerance Policing work
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "Does Zero Tolerance Policing 'work'"

Download file to see previous pages The administrators objected to having to enforce the principle of zero tolerance on the grounds that they would have to go in with a police escort, even on the basis of a sliver of a rumour about a picture you don't like. Defenders of the policy reply that it indicates a greater willingness to take such complaints seriously.
This type of policy of reversing the burden of proof is a species of argumentum ad ignorantiam of the following form: if you can't prove that you are not guilty, then it is presumed that you are guilty. Normally, the burden is on the accuser to provide evidence or corroboration of the charge. Admittedly, where an event took place privately between two people, with no physical evidence of harm, it is generally hard to prove such objective corroboration. The solution advocated by the zero tolerance principle is to shift the burden of disproof of the charge onto the side of the accused party. If he can't furnish such evidence, the conclusion we should draw by the ad ignorantiam argument is that he is guilty.
Is this a reasonable or fallacious use of the argument from ignorance This is a hotly disputed question at the moment. Defenders of zero tolerance argue that the application of the argument from ignorance, as a reasonable argument in this instance, is justified by argument from consequences: namely, those women are at present suffering from abuse to such a degree that anyone who opposes zero tolerance is causing the deaths of women. Opponents of the principle also base their opposition on the argument from consequences. They argue that the policy of zero tolerance is producing many innocent victims of false charges of abuse, and having a disastrous effect on families.
Opponents of the policy also argue that the advocates of zero tolerance are focusing only on the consequences as they affect one group, and ignoring the impact on anyone who is not a member of this group. They see this as a form of self-interested bargaining or advocacy dialogue taking the place of a more rational and objective type of deliberation or critical discussion that takes all points of view into account.
At any rate, on this controversial issue, the central question directly relates to the argumentum ad ignorantiam as a type of argument. Is it reasonable or fallacious in this case And what are the grounds for justifying one opinion or the other
Significantly, zero tolerance policing, with its more assertive and control oriented message, seems to have struck a chord in recent years.
An increasing number of public-initiated police contacts are crime-related, especially in inner-city areas and in a time of stretched resources many have argued that police duties should be more closely restricted to crime-work. This was the dominant message behind the setting up inquiry into core policing tasks, which, despite denials, was envisaged as clearing the way towards the privatization of alleged 'peripheral' police-work. While the conclusions of the ...Download file to see next pagesRead More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Does Zero Tolerance Policing 'work' Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 3750 words”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1503678-does-zero-tolerance-policing-work
(Does Zero Tolerance Policing 'Work' Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 3750 Words)
https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1503678-does-zero-tolerance-policing-work.
“Does Zero Tolerance Policing 'Work' Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 3750 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1503678-does-zero-tolerance-policing-work.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Does Zero Tolerance Policing 'work'

Zero Tolerance

In Simon’s case, he had participated in contravening a company’s internet policy (Gerson, Parker, Volokh, Halloran, Cherkasky, 2006). Simon had utilized the company’s intranet to communicate with an unauthorized personality out of the network. The violation was gross since the company had sculptured clear conditions about the policy. This included clear indication of the relevant consequences. The management had notable controls in the same situation. To begin with, it laid a clear policy. This policy indicated that it banned use of the company’s internet and intranet in communication under unstated uses. The company also stated that unwarranted internet use and e-mailing could result into the termination of employment. In additi...
8 Pages(2000 words)Essay

UK Zero Tolerance Policing

... or rather develop into the high profile crimes. The criminal statistics of England and Wales indicate that, in a period of fifty decades (1950-2000), recorded criminal cases rose from 500-5500. Further reports in (Newburn, 2003, p.3) show that there was a 23% decline in public confidence with the police from 1992-2000 (Newburn, 2003, p.3).This new direction that zero tolerance policing has taken must therefore factor in these two concerns and work towards improving the relationship. This research paper will look at how the government of UK has faired so far with its strategy of zero tolerance policing since its inception, and what the government has so far achieved. The paper will also go further to analyze the viability of the concept...
8 Pages(2000 words)Essay

Evaluating the Impact of Zero Tolerance Policing

Attention will be given to what zero tolerance policing encompasses and the theoretical context underlining the topic. The project will also touch upon the several aspects where the strategy is acclaimed, for instance the first application in New York, United States and its effectiveness in reducing crimes, also the approach widespread to the United Kingdom. Nevertheless, in order to, effectively discuss the impact of the approach if it is implemented by the Metropolis Police Service, questionable results of its application in New York and other relevant areas will be discussed. Presented will be a critical review on the effectiveness of the Zero Tolerance Policing using the available research and literature guide, also a theoreti...
11 Pages(2750 words)Essay

How Does Branding Affect Buyers Purchase Decision

The scope of the study covers all kinds of buyers with different behaviours making buying decisions with regard to different brands. There is also a detailed study of the Consumer Decision Process. There is a good enough introduction on consumer buying process besides an extended and detailed introduction on Branding and Marketing emphasizing the difference between the two and how the concepts are different from each and in what way there can be a delineation between the two. There is an explanation on the different stages of Consumer Buying Behaviour, namely Need Awareness, Information Search, Checking Options, Purchase Decision, and Post Purchase Behaviour. There is also a detailed explanation on Types of Consumer Buying Behavio...
44 Pages(11000 words)Research Paper

Does Terrorism Work as a Means of Changing World Policies

That is the dilemma associated with terrorism--- the double-edged weapon. The old saying that one man's terrorist is another man's freedom fighter, is still in vogue. A man belonging to Al-Qaeda can be a so-called freedom fighter for Bin-Laden but for President George Bush Government, he is simply a terrorist, who spills the blood of the innocents.

The basic and the debatable question here is whether terrorism really works in the present scenario in changing the Governments and their opinions? There appears to be a number of instances across the globe wherein it has been felt that terrorists, except killing innocents and making media headings and stories, have generally failed in their deadly mission in toppling the dem...
7 Pages(1750 words)Report

Does Game Violence Make Teens Aggressive

All those teens showed great changes in their behavior, which was not in a positive manner. (Vorderer, pp. 69-72)
Furthermore, a number of studies (Kirsh, pp. 11-13) have shown that worse academic results are shown by the teens that play violent video games according to the National Institute on Media and Family. It is indicated by the researches (Kirsh, pp. 17-22) that violent games are preferred by more than seventy-five percent of teens that are interested in playing video games. One of the schools in Texas carried out a study of teens that play video games, and it found out that teachers complained of frequent arguments from the students that were involved in playing violent video games at home. In some cases, teens were...
8 Pages(2000 words)Essay

Frustration at Work

Personal life is pretty different from professional undertakings.  An employee who knows how to take his personal life along with his professional life is considered as a balanced individual. He is a person who comprehends what his responsibilities are and how best he can deliver in the line of duty – both at the domestic front as well as on the side of the organization. Personal life must not influence his professional agenda and a similarly professional angle should remain within the four walls of the office and official issues must never be discussed in the luxury of his home. He must dedicate his energies towards work when he is at the office and remain loyal and fully devoted to his family when he is at home. Th...

7 Pages(1750 words)Term Paper

The Work Breakdown Structure and its Advantages in Project Planning

A typical construction project involves a WBS that evolves from an initial task that is successively subdivided into smaller work blocks until the lowest level is reached, indicating a tree-like structure. Subdividing the project breaks down the project work effort into packages that are both manageable and independent. It connotes that the lowest level of the package corresponds to the smallest project work, which requires the shortest completion time periods. As WBS shows the relationship of all elements of a project, a sound basis for cost and schedule control is provided.

Some lists of project activities involved in WBS include budgeting, cost allocation, time allocation and management, and quality assurance. These...
11 Pages(2750 words)Report

The Person and the Work of the Holy Spirit in John's Gospel

Prior to the real time events of the New Testament, the Old Testament revisited an idea which simply dictated that God was an entity and the only God was Ruah. The New Testament came with a series of events which changed everything from the cessation to offerings and sacrifices to an ideology of the Holy Trinity. Jesus is noted as being “anointed with the Holy Spirit” in John 1 32-34. This stands to reason that ther is a differentiation and somewhat autonomy between the three facets of the Holy Trinity. The Holy Trinity is of course, God, Jesus and the Holy Spirit. This is essentially a three in one or a unification of the elements of God. In John’s gospel, he seemingly avoids the dramatic details of the Holy Spi...
14 Pages(3500 words)Essay

How Does the US Media Effects Evolve in Singapores Current Media

Lewis and Slade (2000, p. 223) in their critical evaluation of the effects of media communication on the audience argue that media effect is achieved incongruent with social context. Their study recounts the experiment on the influence of television on identity in Singapore indicates that US social values and Singaporean values greatly differ from each other. The sharp differences in program content have a negative influence on the audience because Chinese raised Singaporeans value marriage, social values, and collectivism whereas US social culture involves career, family and the struggle to balance the two. Therefore the question of US media's influence to destabilize Singaporean national identity is limited. This view is emphasi...
6 Pages(1500 words)Assignment

Death Penalty: Does it Serve as a Deterrent to Future Crime

Animal instincts are directed towards self-preservation and it is the law of nature that a stronger and healthier individual has more chances of living than his weaker counterpart. The survival of the fittest has now been established as a ground reality according to Darwinian philosophy. If we eliminate our civilized thought process, it emerges as a stark reality that we would not desist from attacking another living person or animal when we are overcome by the basic needs of food, shelter, and clothing. In times of natural disasters like earthquakes, wars and floods, and manmade disasters like war, it is not uncommon to witness ravaged populations shedding the façade of civilization and resorting to violence in order to fu...
9 Pages(2250 words)Case Study

The Hard Work of UNHCR

Towards this direction, in the study of Atlani (2000) it is noticed that ‘there is a growing sense of urgency within international humanitarian aid agencies to intervene quickly when faced with organized violence stemming from war or armed conflict; from this perspective, the rape of refugees calls for prompt psychological intervention’ (Atlani, 2000, 435). In accordance with the above study, the provision of humanitarian aid has to be multidimensional. Apart from food, drugs and clothing, people in developing countries need to be supported psychologically – in many countries around the world, strong military conflicts are being developed on a daily basis. United Nations – an organization that serves the in...
9 Pages(2250 words)Case Study

What Is the Hybrid Warfare and What Challenges Does It Present

...The term HYBRID warfare is increasingly used to describe current and future conflict; what is it and what challenges does it present? The end of theCold War and the events of 9/11 have provided a catalyst for unprecedented challenges to the international order and national security policy. Arguably the most important challenge has been the appropriate and most efficacious method to combat a transient and intangible enemy, which transcends borders and the conventional notion of an organised army that “yet has shown a remarkable resilience against traditional military firepower”1. Moreover, Mahmood’s observations highlight the changing nature of conflict and the fact that the contemporary international framework has removed pre-existing...
7 Pages(1750 words)Article
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Essay on topic Does Zero Tolerance Policing 'work' for FREE!

Contact Us