StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...

Critique of a qualitative study - Essay Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
Summary
The phenomenon of interest in this study is that they are striving to discover whether African-Americans utilize the support of their family, friends and available resources when attempting to survive their diseases. In this particular study, it was breast cancer for African-American women and prostate cancer for African-American men.
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER93.1% of users find it useful
Critique of a qualitative study
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "Critique of a qualitative study"

Download file to see previous pages They will be better handle to handle the situations and help them and give them support in areas that will be most beneficial to their recovery.
Moreover, the method used to collect data is compatible with the purpose of the research. The method is also adequate to address the phenomenon of interest, to document and follow whether African-American men and women utilize their support network and resources when coping with their illnesses.
The type of sampling used is that 28 African-American men and women were selected from 291 men and women who had completed Health-funded studies for three National Institutes: Managing Uncertainty: Self-Help in Breast Cancer Study funded to Principal Investigator (PI) Merle Mishel, Phd, RN, FAAN; Promoting Self-Help: Underserved Women with Breast Cancer Study to PI Carrie Braden, Phd, RN, FAAN, and Managing Uncertainty in Stage B or Early Stage C Prostate Cancer Study to Mischel.
The informants who were chosen were appropriate to inform the research because the 28 African men and women that were selected did not receive any type of intervention for their conditions. Some of the men were in control groups, resulting in them having to deal with their condition full-force. They would be better able to study whether they might be affected by support in coping with their illnesses because they didn't have any interventions to stop or alter the full affects of the illnesses.
Additionally, the data collection is focused on human experience, and the researcher does describe the data collections used such as interviews, observation and discussion. The protection of human participants is addressed, and the saturation of the data is described in that the support findings and interviews with the participants are described in detail.
The procedure for collecting data was open-interviewed with the participants, mostly in their home, in a place where they would feel comfortable. It was also stated that the interviews were began very casually, "Tell me more about your experience." This helped the interviewee relax more knowing that their experience was important enough to be heard. Another procedure used was data analysis of the participants. This helped to know what backgrounds, social status, or other areas the participants were contained within.
Additionally, the researcher does address the credibility, auditability, and fittingness of the data in this research. The researcher does address that these findings are important to the welfare of the participant, thereby making it fitting for the welfare of others that are African-American men and women as well.
The participants did recognize the experience as their own, and they were given ample time to fully understand the phenomenon of their cancer. Furthermore, the reader can document the researcher's experience as they read through the experiment.
The researcher does document the research process very well by separating the experiences of the individuals into labeled categories, there again better enabling the ...Download file to see next pagesRead More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Critique of a qualitative study Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 words”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1502797-critique-of-a-qualitative-study
(Critique of a Qualitative Study Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words)
https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1502797-critique-of-a-qualitative-study.
“Critique of a Qualitative Study Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1502797-critique-of-a-qualitative-study.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Critique of a qualitative study

Qualitative research critique

... bеing vеry cost-еffеctivе to thе rеsеarchеr and giving quality rеsults. Although survеys havе thеir drawbacks, in tеrms of falsе rеports, sеlf-rеport bias, and othеr issuеs, such as participants putting down or saying wrong answеrs on purposе, survеys and intеrviеws can shеd a lot of light on issuеs, particularly in a qualitativе study that sееks to mеasurе attitudеs and bеliеfs in a givеn population or populations, as notеd abovе. “Survеys can bе classifiеd by thеir mеthod of data collеction. Mail, tеlеphonе intеrviеw, and in-pеrson intеrviеw survеys arе thе most common. Еxtracting data from samplеs of mеdical and othеr rеcords is also frеquеntly donе. In nеwеr mеthods of data collеction, information is еntеrеd dirеctly into computеrs...
6 Pages(1500 words)Essay

Qualitative Critique

...? QUALITATIVE STUDY CRITIQUE SUBMITTED BY: SUBMITTED INSTITUTE: SUBMISISON INTRODUCTION This paper attempts to critique a research article titled: ‘First generation Korean American parents’ perceptions of discipline’ by Kim and Hong (2007). The research article, cited in Journal of Professional Nursing (23:1), describes an exploratory study conducted to have a deeper understanding of perceptions and use of American versus Korean discipline strategies used by Korean American parents. This critique is intended to evaluate the study, highlighting its strengths and weaknesses. 1.1 Research aims, purpose and rationale The twofold aim and purpose of this study have been clearly stated by the researcher. The main aim of this research was to study...
4 Pages(1000 words)Book Report/Review

Qualitative critique

...? Qualitative Research Critique Qualitative Research Ploughman, M., Austin, M. W., Murdoch, M., Kearney, A., Godwin, M., & Stefanelli, M. (2012). The Path to Self-Management. A Qualitative Study Involving Older People with Multiple Sclerosis, 6-17. The title ‘The Path to Self-Management: Qualitative Study Involving Older People with Multiple Sclerosis’ describes the study clearly and concisely. The title indicates that the study is qualitative in nature, with the topic being the path to self-management. The study population is well defined; old people with multiple sclerosis (Ploughman et al., 2012). The abstract outlines the purposes, methods used to conduct the study, the results of the data collected, and the conclusions. The abstract...
5 Pages(1250 words)Essay

Qualitative Critique: A qualitative study of nursing student experiences of clinical practice

...? Qualitative Critique on Nursing Clinical Practice Sharif, Farkhondeh and Masoumi, S. (2005). A qualitative study of nursing experiences of Clinical Practice, Open Access, US: BMC Nursing , pp 1-7. Name of the Student University Name of Professor Date of Submission Number of words 2,977 Abstract This is a critic of the research conducted by Farkhondeh Sharif and Masoumi, S. in 2005 which was titled as A qualitative study of nursing student experiences of Clinical Practice. In the study, the researchers provided, in its abstract, brief disclosure of the background, methodology undertaken in the study, the outcome of research and the conclusion derived thereof. They explicated that the study was basically delving about the knowledge...
11 Pages(2750 words)Assignment

Qualitative Research Critique

...Qualitative Research Critique Instructions: Critique the qualitative research paper pertaining to this order based on the following headings:Introduction In order to properly asses, thereby criticizing the research paper "The Lived Experience of Having a Chronic Wound: A Phenomenologic Study," (Beitz & Goldberg, 2005) it is necessary to establish what qualitative research is Phenomenology. Phenomenology, as stated in the paper was "described as the study of essences, a philosophy that puts essences back into existence" as referenced by Beitz and Goldberg (2005) to Burns and Groove (2001). It was further defined as "the rational investigation of meaning rather than empirical investigation of things or events" thereby everyday life...
5 Pages(1250 words)Essay

Qualitative Article Critique

...Qualitative Research Critique Burns: Understanding Nursing Research, 4th Edition Critiquing Exercise Williams, ML. and Payne, S., (2003). A qualitative study of clinical nurse specialists' views on depression in palliative care patients. Palliative Medicine; 17: 334 - 338. STANDARDS/EVALUATION CRITERIA CRITIQUE Research Problem and Purpose 1. What are the study problem and purpose Is the problem sufficiently narrow in scope without being trivial Does the purpose narrow and clarify the focus or aim of the study and identify the research variables, population, and setting 2. Is the problem significant and relevant to nursing 3. Was the study feasible to conduct in terms of money commitment; the researchers' expertise; availability...
6 Pages(1500 words)Essay

Qualitative critique

...Qualitative Research Critique Qualitative Research Michelle, P., Mark, W., Michelle, M., K., A., Marshall, G., & Mark, S. .The Path to Self-Management. A Qualitative Study Involving Older People with Multiple Sclerosis, 6-7. The title ‘The Path to Self-Management: Qualitative Study Involving Older People with Multiple Sclerosis’ describes the study clearly and concisely. The title indicates that the study is qualitative in nature, with the topic being the path to self management. The study population is well defined; old people with multiple sclerosis (Michelle, Mark, Michelle, Marshall, & Mark, 2012). The abstract outlines the purposes, methods used to conduct the study, the results of the data collected, and the conclusions. The abstract...
5 Pages(1250 words)Essay

Critique qualitative

... Qualitative Research Critique The Aim of this paper is to critique the article written by M. Persson andJ. Martensson entitled, “Journal of Nursing Management: Situations influencing habits in diet and exercise among nurses working night shift”. The main goal of conducting the research was to find out all the situations that are significant to healthy diet and exercise habits of nurses working night shift. The researchers had a concern because most of the ill heaths related to lifestyle of individual are a global menace causing many losses of lives. Lifestyle of individuals contributes to unhealthy diets and poor exercising habits. Unhealthy diets are the consumption of foods containing low levels of nutrients. In the article...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay

Welfare to Work and Social Policy: Comparative Study of Various Nations' Approaches

The social policy varies differently by the needs of individual nations and can include assistance to youth unemployment in an attempt to provide temporary aid until an individual is able to sustain a regular income through work incentives. One of the main theories regarding welfare to work programs is that working parents contribute to the economy and are less likely to rely solely on the state for their welfare (Walling, 2005). With this concept being one of the primary motivators for welfare to work policies, different nations adopt a policy to provide an allotment of skills training, aid with transportation issues, financial support, and even child care as an incentive to drive the welfare recipient back into full-time work. T...
9 Pages(2250 words)Report

Quality Systems in the Public Sector: A Study of Quality Initiatives in the NHS, Scotland

The disintegration of some service provisions covered by the public sector is the cause of concern. In some cases where services, earlier provided by public sector organizations, were privatized led to the dramatic change in the quality and cost of service. This makes a study of concepts of quality management in the context of the public sector necessary to understand the reasons behind the ‘market failure’ of public sector service providers.

The problems that assail these services are inherent in any government enterprise such as lack of coordination, slow decision making, inflexibility, lack of incentive to perform and so on. Consider the following observation of Joseph Stiglitz (1998).

"Making...
55 Pages(13750 words)Dissertation

Critique of Statistical Methods for the Social Sciences Research by Agresti and Finlay

It was expected that the discussion would be about the costs associated with shrunken class size.  That it is impractical to decrease the number of students to 30 since it will not improve their academic proficiency, but would only increase costs.  Or if it does boost academic performance, it is too little to match the costs associated with that kind of class set-up. Simply stated, the cost of reducing class size to 30 is greater than the expected benefit. However, the proposal mainly dwelt on the ineffectiveness of reducing the class size, with no or minimal discussion on costs. The introduction creates a first impression on a written piece. That is why, short as it may be, the introduction should still brief and prepar...
6 Pages(1500 words)Assignment

Critique of Technological Innovations, Activity Based Costing and Satisfaction Article by Davood Askarany

Many of the innovations have been introduced as early as 1980, such as “activity-based costing (ABC); activity management (AM) and activity-based management (ABM); local information system (LS); balanced scorecard (BS); life cycle costing (LCC) and target costing (TC) [and] strategic management accounting (SMA).” (Askarany, Smith and Yazdifar 54). However, few of these have been implemented and utilized to their full potential. The authors propose to find a reason for this.

ABC focuses on costs associated with activities, but also evaluates whether those activities add value, thus providing a means of understanding how to most effectively reduce costs. In addition to cost reduction benefits, applying ABC giv...
7 Pages(1750 words)Term Paper

Country Study: Mali

The territory of Mali has had a great history. We have been centers of the Ghana Empire, the Mali Empire, and the Songhai Empire for about six centuries. Thereafter, during the 17th and 18th centuries, several small states developed along the Niger basin, but they fell during the holy war waged by Muslim leader Al-Hajj Umar, whose kingdom extended from Timbuktu to headwaters of Niger and Senegal. His successor, Ahmadu was defeated by the French in 1860. (http://us-africa.tripod.com /mali.html)

As is well-known, we have had a turbulent past. We were a French colony for 80 years until we achieved independence. Now we are a multi-party democracy with Presidential form of Government. While the executive power rests with the...
6 Pages(1500 words)Case Study

Article Analysis of 11 Ways to Critique an Article by Mike Metcalfe

The systems for thinking perspective and T.O.P perspective styles have been chosen as this article needs to have an explicitly straight conclusion. Moreover, the ethical issues concerning the organization have also not been given adequate treatment in the article which makes it a one-sided communication on the part of the author. Also, certain other critical issues concerning the article involve lack of adequate clarification on the part of the author regarding various key issues such as what would be the resultant consequences in case of failure on the part of the employee / prospective employee to adhere to the rules and regulations governing the protection of privacy of the organizational data. Are there any legal obligations i...
11 Pages(2750 words)Assignment

Project Risk Assessment: Qualitative Versus Quantitative Approach

The risks may vary in terms of nature or scope according to the situation. So since the risk is so common in project management, a very important aspect of managing a project is analyzing all the possible risks that are associated with that particular project. It makes no sense of going on with a project and not giving a thought to the risks that could affect the success. Once these risks are analyzed, the project manager will have all the possible risks in front of him. He will know the degree of risk and also the benefits that the organization will get if the risk is taken. Therefore only after a risk analysis, the project manager is in a position to conclude whether or not it is worth taking the risk and going on with a certain...
6 Pages(1500 words)Assignment

A Comparative Study of the Origins of Ethical Thoughts

Do you know what they dug out? -- Wires! It proves that two thousand five hundred years ago, in the age of Pericles, the Greeks had telephones”. The Jew laughingly retorted: “Recently they were digging in Jerusalem. They dug out nothing. This proves that three thousand years ago when Solomon was the king of Judea, the Jews had the principle of wireless!”

ETHICS AND DIVERSE DEFENITIONS: One of the Dilemmas of the civilized human society was the fight between the soul and the flesh or rather the body and desires. The question is how to divert human energy in an intelligent, controlled way? Searching answers to this question one lands in the premise of ethics, personal as well as social. Ethics (English)...
11 Pages(2750 words)Case Study

Conflict Between Researh and Ethics on the Tuskegee Syphilis Study

...Opinion paper The Declaration of Helsinki by the WHO clearly s that in clinical trials involving humans the wellbeing of the should be of prime importance than the interest of science or society. This has been stated because at times in order to achieve the objectives of a study the investigators might overlook the welfare of the trial subjects thus jeopardizing their health in the process. According to ethical rules while comparing two treatment options the control group of the study must receive the best known treatment available while the study subjects are given a potential newer treatment. Only when there is no effective treatment available a placebo-controlled group can be used for the study. There have been several trials which have...
7 Pages(1750 words)Essay

The Epistemological Assumptions Schommer-Aikins and Hutters Study

The authors, however, have made several philosophical assumptions even before the actual study began. These assumptions have bearing on the entire research because they guided the studies thesis, the method of investigation and the way the researchers interpreted the collected data.
Referring to previous works, Schommer-Aikins and Hutter embarked on several bouts of theorizing regarding the nature of knowledge and how people learn about issues that they face every day. Citing the body of literature, for example, on epistemological beliefs, the authors assumed that "individuals’ beliefs about the nature of knowledge and learning are linked to their comprehension, metal comprehension, interpretation of information, and pe...
6 Pages(1500 words)Case Study
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Essay on topic Critique of a qualitative study for FREE!

Contact Us