StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Answers to questions - Essay Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
Summary
[Claiming to be unable to perform her automobile assembly line job because she was disabled by carpal tunnel syndrome and related impairments, Ella Williams sued petitioner, Toyota Kentucky, her former employer, for failing to provide her with a reasonable accommodation as required by the American Disabilities Act (ADA)…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER95.6% of users find it useful
Answers to questions
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "Answers to questions"

TOYOTA MOTOR MANUFACTURING KENTUCKY, INC. V. WILLIAMS SUPREME COURT OF THE UNITED S, 534 US.184 (2002) [Claiming to be unable to perform her automobile assembly line job because she was disabled by carpal tunnel syndrome and related impairments, Ella Williams sued petitioner, Toyota Kentucky, her former employer, for failing to provide her with a reasonable accommodation as required by the American Disabilities Act (ADA). The district court granted petitioner summary judgment, holding that respondent's impairment did not qualify as a "disability" under the ADA because it had not "substantially limit[ed]" any "major life activity", and that there was no evidence that Ms. Williams had had a record of a substantially limiting impairment or was regarded as having such an impairment. The Sixth Circuit reversed, finding that the impairments substantially limited respondent in the major life activity of performing manual tasks. In order to demonstrate that she was so limited, said the court, Williams had to show that her manual disability involved a "class" of manual activities affecting the ability to perform tasks at work. She satisfied this test, according to the court, because her ailments prevented her from doing the tasks associated with certain types of manual jobs that require repetitive work with hands and arms extended at or above shoulder levels for extended periods of time. In reaching this conclusion, the court found that evidence that she could tend to her personal hygiene and carry out personal or household chores did not affect a determination that her impairments substantially limited her ability to perform the range of manual tasks associated with an assembly line job. The court granted her partial summary judgment on the issue of whether she was disabled under the ADA. The Supreme Court granted certiorari.]
Case Questions
1. Was it proper for the court of appeals to focus on Ms. William's inability to perform the tasks associated with her job in determining whether she was disabled under the ADA
2. Does the definition of "disability" under the ADA focus solely on the workplace and employment
3. What relevance do occupation-specific tasks have in the inquiry whether an employee is substantially limited in the major life activity of performing manual tasks so as to be disabled under the ADA
The Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) is grounded in the will to provide equal opportunity in employment, transportation, public accommodations, public services, and telecommunications for individual with disabilities. Any proceedings under the ADA must first determine whether the claimant is disabled as defined by the Act. According to the ADA, "an individual is considered to have a 'disability' if s/he has a physical or mental impairment that substantially limits one or more major life activities, has a record of such an impairment, or is regarded as having such an impairment" (page 2), with "major life activities" referring to "activities such as seeing, hearing, speaking, walking, breathing, performing manual tasks, learning, caring for oneself, and working".
Evidently, given the range of activities and spheres of the ADA definition, determining whether the claimant is disabled includes but is not limited to her ability to perform work-related tasks. There is thus no support in the Act for the Court of Appeals' idea that the question of whether an impairment constitutes a disability is to be answered only by analyzing the effect of the impairment in the workplace.
The Court's focus on Ms. William's inability to perform the tasks associated with her job in determining whether she was disabled under the ADA could be justified if the claimant could prove that she is a "qualified individual with a disability", which in turn would justify her suit against Toyota for the lack of provision of reasonable accommodation. This was not the case. Firstly, both Sutton and the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC) have established that a claimant would be required to show an inability to work in a "broad range of jobs," rather than a specific job. Not only did the Court erroneously focusing on one highly specialized manual job, the District Court also noted that at the time the respondent admitted that she was able to do the manual tasks required by her original two jobs in QCIO (Quality Control), further evidence that her alleged disability did not substantially limit her ability to perform work-related manual tasks.
Thirdly, when assessing the claimant's ability to perform the major life activity of manual tasks, the central inquiry must be the claimant's inability to perform the variety of tasks central to most people's daily lives, not those tasks associated with her specific job, in this case, "repetitive work with hands and arms extended at or above shoulder levels for extended periods of time". The court, therefore, should not have considered the respondent's inability to do such manual work as sufficient proof that she was substantially limited in performing manual tasks.
At the same time, the Court of Appeals appears to have disregarded the very type of evidence on which it should have focused. It treated as irrelevant "the fact the respondent can tend to her personal hygiene and carry out personal or household chores," and this even after her condition worsened, yet these are among the types of manual tasks of central importance to people's daily lives. While the respondent's deposition testimony indicates that her medical condition caused her to quit dancing, to occasionally seek help dressing, to reduce how often she plays with her children, gardens, and drive long distances, these changes in her life did not amount to such severe restrictions in the activities that are of central importance to most people's daily lives that they establish a manual task disability as a matter of law. On this record, it was therefore inappropriate for the Court of Appeals to grant partial summary judgment to the respondent on the issue of whether she was substantially limited in performing manual tasks, and its decision to do so must be reversed and remanded. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Answers to questions Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 words”, n.d.)
Answers to questions Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 words. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1502187-answers-to-questions
(Answers to Questions Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words)
Answers to Questions Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1502187-answers-to-questions.
“Answers to Questions Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1502187-answers-to-questions.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Answers to questions

Critical Thinking. Answers to Questions in Medicine

...? Answers to Questions Q1. Critical Thinking Argue a case for having ALS skills (intubation, cannulation, cardiac drugs, etc withinParamedic scope of practice. (700 words) A paramedic is a healthcare professional experienced in handling emergency medical circumstances. Paramedics render higher levels of care for medical crisis and distress. Paramedics are people who have special medical training; though they are not doctors, they can perform many of the similar tasks (Bryan, 2003, p. 4). Bryan (2003) further illustrates that paramedics stop people from bleeding, keep broken bones from aggravation and aid people in breathing (p. 4). Moreover, when the situation deems it necessary, they can even facilitate delivery of babies (Bryan, 2003, p...
26 Pages(6500 words)Essay

Answers to questions

...? Environmental Studies The relationship among urban dwellers Urban areas are the center of money and developments. As such, people move to settle in the urban. People join various activities like, teaching, journalism, social work, politics, and other industrial activities with the view of improving their lives. This is due to efforts to reduce time and expenses in commuting and transportation while improving opportunities for these jobs, education, and housing. These developments are linked with many issues, some positive while others are negatives. The negative issues linked with the developments vary with the region. In Europe cities, the urban social world is a set of compartments in which most of the people in one... Environmental...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay

Answers to questions

...Topic: Approaches To Contemporary Psychology Introduction There are various different approaches to contemporary psychology and at the end psychologist settle for the seven major perspectives namely psychoanalytic, behaviorist, humanist, cognitive, neuroscientific/biopsychological, evolutionary, and socio-cultural.An approach is basically a perspective or view that involves particular assumptions based on certain beliefs regarding the behavior of humans, the study of some of their aspects and the research methods which are appropriate for undertaking the study. According to most psychologists none of the perspective is more correct than the other since each of the perspective brings out a different understanding of human behavior... Approaches...
2 Pages(500 words)Research Paper

Problematic Questions of Testamentary Document

...OPINION In the present case, the testamentary document, that is the will, merely s that the testator leaves $100000 to Tom; insofar as the question of bequeathing the money goes, it has been bequeathed absolutely and unconditionally to Tom. Where a person obtains an absolute conveyance for a particular purpose and then uses it for another purpose, the courts will interfere on grounds of fraud;1 but this restriction is not to be interpreted as being a bar on the power of the beneficiary to use the gift/ transfer property for any other purpose than what the donor may have intended without a specific agreement between the donor and the beneficiary to that effect. In fact, even in cases where the donee has expressed his intention to use...
8 Pages(2000 words)Case Study

Tort Law of the United Kingdom: 3 Problem Questions

Trespass on land, goods, and person is altogether the most common type of tort, but in all cases, the main concern is the allocation of responsibility for whatever losses are sustained. For anyone party to be held responsible for violation of the tort law, the claimant must establish that there is a duty of care and that there has been a breach of that duty to cause damage or loss to the claimant that needs to be compensated by an award of damages. There is a breach of the duty-of-care principle if the defendant is proven to have failed to do what a reasonable person will do in the situation presented.

Francesca was a chambermaid of good standing at Hulton hotel until a regular hotel guest stormed into the manager&rsquo...
8 Pages(2000 words)Case Study

Anwering Three Questions of Philosophy

Basically, where he drew a comparison between the two, was by equating their attempt to explain concepts and constructs therein, by the use of numbers (Pythagoras) and ideas (Plato).

Aristotle believed that these were comparable in the sense, that these were arrangements of convenience, wherein additions or subtractions in the notions could be contrived at a theoretical convenience, just so that a link could be established amongst the theoretical construct originally proposed by them. Aristotle believed that Plato advocated the notion that forms (ideas) cause both existence and generation. On the other hand, Aristotle felt that Pythagoras supported the idea that numbers try to explain the connotation of the universe and...
7 Pages(1750 words)Assignment

Biology Data-based Questions

Potassium or K and Calcium or Ca has shown greater Mean Residence Time in rainforest chaparral when compared to temperate forests whereas Phosphorus or P demonstrates maximum variance in Mean Residence Time.

In general, plant productivity and Mean Residence Time are such that one increases whilst the other decreases. In subarctic regions, there is low plant productivity and greater Mean Residence Time.

In tropical forests, the mean residence time of nutrients is influenced by higher temperatures than in subarctic forests. Therefore, there is a vast difference in the MRT of nutrients pertaining to the tropical rainforest and the subarctic forest.

Nuclear fission weapons tests in 1961 released radioa...
10 Pages(2500 words)Assignment

Communitarian and Cosmopolitan Approaches to Questions of Justice

Cosmopolitan/Communitarian divide relates to a dispute on whether or not the state or the species stand in for the limit of human society. In Campbell’s distinguished definition, he explained justice as “like the pre-original, anarchic relation to the other, and akin to the undecidable. It represents the domain of the impossible and the unrepresentable that lies outside and beyond the limit of the possible and the representable.” (1994, p. 472)

In general, there are two contrasting positions in understanding international justice and intervention. In its universal sense, the two perspectives can be distinguished as a particularist and universalist. One perceives in a state-centric manner while the othe...
7 Pages(1750 words)Literature review

Way in Which the Courts Approach Questions as to the Formation of Contracts

...English law, having committed itself to a rather technical and schematic doctrine of contract, in application takes a practical approach, often at the cost of forcing the facts to fit uneasily into the marked slots of offer, acceptance and consideration.’ New Zealand Shipping Co v Satterthwaite & Co [1975] AC 154, 167, per Lord Wilberforce. To what extent do you agree with Lord Wilberforce’s analysis of the way in which the courts approach questions as to the formation of contracts? Give your reasons. In order to be able to comment on Lord Wilberforce’s analysis it is necessary to discuss the facts of the case in question. The case of New Zealand Shipping Co v Sattherthwaite [1975]1 concerned the right of the defendant to terminate...
6 Pages(1500 words)Essay

5 Questions re: The AmericanTradition in Literature by George and Barbara Perkins

... 11/17 American Literature The different works of the Native Americans show several similarities and differences to other culturesand peoples, creating a universal thought process in other forms. When reading the pieces of literature, it can be seen that the similarities are defined as the religious or spiritual processes, as well as human nature that is widely accepted as a popular concept. However, the differences are reliant on the cultural affiliations and traditions which are created among the different cultures, specifically which define a sense of uniqueness among those practicing this tradition. An example of the similarities can be read in stories such as At the Time of the White Dawn. The main example is one... 11/17 American...
10 Pages(2500 words)Assignment

Short Answers for Plant Diversity Botany Class

...Q1. Describe the plant cell wall, including its location, composition, origin, function and other important aspects. (http micro.magnet.fsu.edu/cells/plants/images/plantcell.jpg) Answer: Cell wall is the most important characteristic feature of the plant cell. It is important for maintaining the appropriate shape of the plant cell and hence of the plant. It is present outside the plasma membrane of the plant cell. It provides rigidity to the plant cell. It enables the plant to stand tall and also allows the leaves to get sunlight. These are the two essential features of the plant and cell wall plays the important role to carry out these functions. It prevents the plasma membrane from rupturing when the cell is placed in the hypotonic...
9 Pages(2250 words)Assignment

The Assessment Plan, Education Questions, Checklist on Communication

... the candidate follow the two witness’s teaching inspection? 3 Did the candidate respond to the instructor’s inquiries in an appropriate manner? 4 Did the candidate take part in a one hour education task? 5 Did the candidate follow a 60 minutes radio presentation on teaching skills? Tool C: Questionnaire on communication. No QUESTIONAnswer 1 What are the resources required by a teacher? 2 What are the traits of a responsible teacher? 3 What are the characteristics of an objective of a lesson? 4 What are the major components of a lesson plan? 5 How can a teacher handle misbehaviour in his class? These tools and the assessment plan were selected because they are suitable in assessing the skills of the candidates because...
7 Pages(1750 words)Assignment

50 Questions from Book Titled The Happiest Refugee by Anh Do

...The happiest refugee Prologue Questions Directions: Write the answers to the following questions in complete sentences Why does Anh call Dad a hypocrite? He believes his dad is a hypocrite because he says him and his mother are happy because he married the right woman yet he left them and their mother he was still young thirteen years. 2. What does Anh actually end up doing when he meets Dad? What are his feelings? He engages in a conversation with his dad, laughs and feigns enjoyment. Although he keeps wondering if he should head butt his dad or not, wonders who the woman that opens the door is, if the baby is his kid and what a shitty place his dad lives in. He is feeling confused inside and seething with anger and hatred and violence...
9 Pages(2250 words)Assignment
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Essay on topic Answers to questions for FREE!

Contact Us