StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...

Towards of Theory of Balanced Purges in Post-Conflict Reconstruction Efforts - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
History counsels that purges are a seemingly natural consequence of being on the losing side of a war. Leaders and supporters alike are at risk of being purged from political, administrative, and military positions within a country's governing hierarchy. It is significant to note, however, that not all purges are the same…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER93.6% of users find it useful
Towards of Theory of Balanced Purges in Post-Conflict Reconstruction Efforts
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Towards of Theory of Balanced Purges in Post-Conflict Reconstruction Efforts"

Download file to see previous pages

In Iraq, by contrast, Paul Bremer engaged in a much more systemic and pervasive program of purges. In addition, purges were in many ways based on ethnic and political affiliations. The consequences of these two purges, at least in the short run, could not be more different. Japan stabilized quickly, pursued post-conflict reconstruction in an orderly manner, and exists today as an economic powerhouse. The outlook for Iraq is far less hopeful. Stabilization has not only not occurred, but would seem to be impossible under current conditions.

The nature of the purges in each case, and the conditions related to the purges, go a long way towards explaining success in Japan and failure in Iraq. This essay will assert that deep purges of government, administrative, and military structures, if executed in accord with local conditions, can lead to stabilization in the short-run and prepare the country for an effective and an enduring reconstruction effort. To this end, this essay will discuss the risks and the rewards of the deep purge philosophy.

Then more specifically, this essay will present a comparative analysis of deep purge strategies in Japan, Iraq, and Italy. As a preliminary matter, there are a number of perceived rewards associated with the purging of officials and institutions in enemy combatant states. The first reward, and one which is perhaps more psychological than practical in the short term, is a sense of retribution and punishment. There is a need for ultimate accountability and the purging of top leaders symbolizes victory.

Both Saddam Hussein and Mussolini were paraded before the world as obstacles to peaceful reconstruction in their respective countries. The Emperor of Japan, for reasons to be discussed below, escaped the retribution and punishment reward. In his place, MacArthur chose General Tojo. An additional reward is the opportunity to pursue a reconstruction model which is closely aligned with the governing philosophies of the victorious country or countries. From an administrative and a political point of view, in each of the three cases involved here, this involved the transformation of authoritarian regimes into democratically-oriented regimes.

Human rights were emphasized, constitutions drafted and implemented, and administrative mechanisms established to grant access and influence to the victors. Finally, and significantly, there were economic rewards associated with deep purges. The old economic elite were pushed aside, stripped of their wealth, and reconstruction contracts allocated to business organizations of the victorious countries. In short, the perceived benefits of a deep purge were associated with the sweeping away of both real and perceived opposition to the pervasive post-conflict reconstruction of the defeated country in the image of the victorious countries.

There are, however, grave risks associated with the deep purging of a country's governing elite. Retribution for example, must be seen as balanced and just. MacArthur allowed Emperor Hirohito to preserve his dignity and thereby avoided potential uprisings against his administration of Japan. Paul Bremer's treatment of Saddam Hussein, on the other hand, was much less delicate. The deposed Iraqi leader was reported to have been hiding in a dirty hole in his underwear when captured. This public humiliation might certainly be

...Download file to see next pages Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Towards of Theory of Balanced Purges in Post-Conflict Reconstruction Essay”, n.d.)
Towards of Theory of Balanced Purges in Post-Conflict Reconstruction Essay. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1501199-towards-of-theory-of-balanced-purges-in-post-conflict-reconstruction-efforts
(Towards of Theory of Balanced Purges in Post-Conflict Reconstruction Essay)
Towards of Theory of Balanced Purges in Post-Conflict Reconstruction Essay. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1501199-towards-of-theory-of-balanced-purges-in-post-conflict-reconstruction-efforts.
“Towards of Theory of Balanced Purges in Post-Conflict Reconstruction Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1501199-towards-of-theory-of-balanced-purges-in-post-conflict-reconstruction-efforts.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Towards of Theory of Balanced Purges in Post-Conflict Reconstruction Efforts

The Doctrine of Suggestion, Prestige and Imitation in Social Psychology

The paper "The Doctrine of Suggestion, Prestige and Imitation in Social Psychology" suggests that Freudian theory associates compliance as learned behaviour, which is acquired by the process of acculturation proceeding from infancy.... hellip; The theory and research related to Freud, Erickson, and other humanistic psychology schools build a systematic framework for understanding human behaviour compliance through the acculturation process in the family and social groups....
10 Pages (2500 words) Essay

UK Employers and Human Resource Management

Slowly but surely, the balance of power gradually tilted sharply towards the employers.... This essay stresses that labour has always been among the most important production inputs for firms, be they coming from the service or the manufacturing industry.... Indeed, the business environment as we know today has gone through tremendous leaps....
11 Pages (2750 words) Essay

Neorealism and European Integration

Neorealist Joseph Grieco (1995) argued that the successful negotiation of the Treaty on European Union (TEU, 1992) and Economic and Monetary Union (EMU) rebuked the neorealist theory that states hold international institutions in low esteem (Rosamond, 2000, p.... In this chapter I focus on the failure of neorealists to take account of contemporary alterations in EU integration and policy as well as the burgeoning role of social constructivism in this debate....
13 Pages (3250 words) Essay

NGOs and Conflict: Maintaining Peace

Charitable organizations have become an integral part of the world politically, economically, and health care wise as well.... Such organizations may be well-known, such as World Vision and United Way, but there are tens of thousands of organizations of which the public is generally unaware.... hellip; Sometimes, these organizations are funded by governments for the specific purpose of providing aid and relief to other countries....
30 Pages (7500 words) Essay

Highschool and American Government

As the discussion outlines representatives and Senators are under an obligation to such persons and corporations, because they provide significant contributions towards election expenditure.... This essay stresses that  legislators take several factors into account, before casting their vote in Congress....
13 Pages (3250 words) Essay

Personal Theory of Change

Within psychology the theory of change, and of growth has been widely studied, in order to assist people to led a healthy and adaptive life.... Shapiro (2005) states that a theory of change refers to the strategies, actions and processes an individual goes through to bring about change in their lives.... Theories of change propose that one of the main goals of therapy is help move the client from a maladaptive frame of mind, and to assist growth towards a more adaptive state (Hayes, 1996)....
12 Pages (3000 words) Essay

Project Management -Team Lifecycle and Conflict within the Team

Write a report reviewing and critically evaluating the performance of your team on that exercise.... you report should concentrate on how the team functioned rather than the… The essay focuses on experience and feedback from project management exercise.... the essay want to analysis our teamwork form five respects which are the teams Belbin profiles, the team lifecycle, According to results of Belbin profiles, each member is allocated within different teams by an adviser....
19 Pages (4750 words) Essay

Organizational Structures of the COY Company

The core value of the organizational structure is to ensure that activities like task allocation, coordination, and supervision get stirred towards achieving goals of an organization.... The move was sought to broaden the scope of the company.... It would have been advantageous for the company to go global and expand if the management would have been patient for a little longer....
8 Pages (2000 words) Coursework
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us