StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...

Towards of Theory of Balanced Purges in Post-Conflict Reconstruction Efforts - Essay Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
Summary
History counsels that purges are a seemingly natural consequence of being on the losing side of a war. Leaders and supporters alike are at risk of being purged from political, administrative, and military positions within a country's governing hierarchy. It is significant to note, however, that not all purges are the same…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER96.9% of users find it useful
Towards of Theory of Balanced Purges in Post-Conflict Reconstruction Efforts
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "Towards of Theory of Balanced Purges in Post-Conflict Reconstruction Efforts"

Download file to see previous pages In Iraq, by contrast, Paul Bremer engaged in a much more systemic and pervasive program of purges. In addition, purges were in many ways based on ethnic and political affiliations. The consequences of these two purges, at least in the short run, could not be more different. Japan stabilized quickly, pursued post-conflict reconstruction in an orderly manner, and exists today as an economic powerhouse. The outlook for Iraq is far less hopeful. Stabilization has not only not occurred, but would seem to be impossible under current conditions. The nature of the purges in each case, and the conditions related to the purges, go a long way towards explaining success in Japan and failure in Iraq.
This essay will assert that deep purges of government, administrative, and military structures, if executed in accord with local conditions, can lead to stabilization in the short-run and prepare the country for an effective and an enduring reconstruction effort. To this end, this essay will discuss the risks and the rewards of the deep purge philosophy. Then more specifically, this essay will present a comparative analysis of deep purge strategies in Japan, Iraq, and Italy.
As a preliminary matter, there are a number of perceived rewards associated with the purging of officials and institutions in enemy combatant states. The first reward, and one which is perhaps more psychological than practical in the short term, is a sense of retribution and punishment. There is a need for ultimate accountability and the purging of top leaders symbolizes victory. Both Saddam Hussein and Mussolini were paraded before the world as obstacles to peaceful reconstruction in their respective countries. The Emperor of Japan, for reasons to be discussed below, escaped the retribution and punishment reward. In his place, MacArthur chose General Tojo. An additional reward is the opportunity to pursue a reconstruction model which is closely aligned with the governing philosophies of the victorious country or countries. From an administrative and a political point of view, in each of the three cases involved here, this involved the transformation of authoritarian regimes into democratically-oriented regimes. Human rights were emphasized, constitutions drafted and implemented, and administrative mechanisms established to grant access and influence to the victors. Finally, and significantly, there were economic rewards associated with deep purges. The old economic elite were pushed aside, stripped of their wealth, and reconstruction contracts allocated to business organizations of the victorious countries. In short, the perceived benefits of a deep purge were associated with the sweeping away of both real and perceived opposition to the pervasive post-conflict reconstruction of the defeated country in the image of the victorious countries.
There are, however, grave risks associated with the deep purging of a country's governing elite. Retribution for example, must be seen as balanced and just. MacArthur allowed Emperor Hirohito to preserve his dignity and thereby avoided potential uprisings against his administration of Japan. Paul Bremer's treatment of Saddam Hussein, on the other hand, was much less delicate. The deposed Iraqi leader was reported to have been hiding in a dirty hole in his underwear when captured. This public humiliation might certainly be ...Download file to see next pagesRead More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Towards of Theory of Balanced Purges in Post-Conflict Reconstruction Essay”, n.d.)
Towards of Theory of Balanced Purges in Post-Conflict Reconstruction Essay. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1501199-towards-of-theory-of-balanced-purges-in-post-conflict-reconstruction-efforts
(Towards of Theory of Balanced Purges in Post-Conflict Reconstruction Essay)
Towards of Theory of Balanced Purges in Post-Conflict Reconstruction Essay. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1501199-towards-of-theory-of-balanced-purges-in-post-conflict-reconstruction-efforts.
“Towards of Theory of Balanced Purges in Post-Conflict Reconstruction Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1501199-towards-of-theory-of-balanced-purges-in-post-conflict-reconstruction-efforts.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Towards of Theory of Balanced Purges in Post-Conflict Reconstruction Efforts

Post conflict establishments

...? Reorganizing Post-Conflict Establishments Insert Insert Grade Insert Reorganizing Post-Conflict Establishments Introduction The post-Cold War era has brought with it many challenges for the reconstruction of governments and other organizations around the world. Ottaway (2002) observes that in the past there was a definite way of building nations. This way through what he refers to as “blood and iron” molding of nations as opposed to the increasing need of nations today to be built upon the pedestals of peaceful agreements, international intervention and democratic elections. Historically, there were conquests and wars geared towards constructing territories that were subject to a supreme ruler. A good example is the Roman Empire...
10 Pages(2500 words)Essay

Sociocultural influences on conflict resolution and post-war reconstruction

... States election and especially the 2008 elections that pitted president Obama against senator McCain2. The nation has found itself in a reconstruction program in both Afghanistan and Iraq in the aftermath of its anti-terrorism missions in the said countries. Elsewhere, there have been various peace-building projects, national building programs, political mediations and other post war and conflict reconstruction programs that are being undertaken by international bodies like the United Nations and other regional or supranational agencies. However, such efforts have not always been smooth and have been met with a lot of challenges both of logistical and ideological nature. The ever-changing global environment that has meant that the approach...
15 Pages(3750 words)Research Paper

Reconstruction

...: “But those stubborn souls who persisted in their forward ways were flogged, mutilated, or even murdered.” He does however; describe these practices as “atrocious”. Norton feels that the emergence of the Ku Klux Klan provided the “deathblow” to reconstruction efforts. She describes in detail the various activities of the organization in their attempt to prevent Republicans from campaigning in the south and to discourage Blacks from voting or becoming involved in politics: “Nighttime harassment, whippings, beatings and murder became common, and terrorism dominated some counties and regions…” Conclusion Reconstruction has been a controversial subject for historians and there have been many different schools of thought that have evolved...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay

Structural Functional Theory & Conflict Theory

... is how people come together and form a community aimed at being a society. It focuses on the good actions that are essential for society. Functionalists mainly aim at the balance of a social system and stability. To summarize structural functional theory; it focuses on the community as a whole, as a team that is focused on promoting stability and balance. Conflict theory, on the other hand, describes society as a group that is not closely related together. It views society as a series of groups that contending to survive (Johnson, 2008). What characterizes society in conflictstheory is that society is built on the opposite of structural functional theory; that society has inequality characters. It is filled with differences instead...
1 Pages(250 words)Essay

Reconstruction

Reconstruction al Affiliation) According to Foner article, reconstruction was a success. The south attempted in changing but the freedmen burdened the changed. According to WEB Du Bois, he stated that reconstruction was complicated when the freed blacks and the freedmen were added. It is stated that the moral implications of the unsuccessful war with all the limitation in the social standards and quick discouragement and hatred was a situation that would make it hard under any criteria to come up with new civilization and new government. Additionally, the 4 million freemen and the situation are more complicated. The south solving the broken society made them freedmen look as burden that needs support. The people from the North for...
1 Pages(250 words)Essay

Conflict theory

...Conflict Theory Reflection Conflict Theory Reflection Conflict theories have played a significant role in the filed of sociology. The theories have been used to explain society existence and well-being. In fact, the underlying theme of conflict in these theories is seen as a way of social life and natural processes in the society. Conflict is also seen as a way of bringing change to the society. A reflection on conflict theories helps in understanding their application in society values. After reading the chapter on conflict theories, I have come to understand various theories. One of the theories that I have come to like is that of class conflict. The class conflict theory notes that the society has been dominated by class antagonism...
2 Pages(500 words)Assignment

Conflict Theory

...CRIMINOLOGICAL THEORY No: CRIMINOLOGICAL THEORY Explain Conflict Theory. How can this theory be used to explain white-collar crime? How does Conflict Theory differ fundamentally from the Chicago School? After reading Chapter 5 of Kozol’s Fire in the Ashes, use conflict theory; explain how the social and political environment may have influenced Alice Washington’s life. How might her well-being and care have been different had she come from a middle or upper class background? Conflict theory can be described as people in a society are distributed in groups based on social order and this social order is governed and enforced by those having power. The power is not in the hands of individuals, but groups. Every individual living in a society...
4 Pages(1000 words)Assignment

Reconstruction

... Topic 2 Factors That Led To the Rise of Big Business in the Years after the Civil War Introduction The American Civil War occurred between 1861 and 1865, which was fueled by slavery in the southern territories that were also known as the Confederate States of America. Other causes of secession included sectionalism, state rights, and protectionism among others (Roland 1861). The war led to the destruction of infrastructure in the South and the death of more than 600,000 soldiers. After its halt, there was the need for reconstruction in the states due to the economic, social, and political damages (Roland 1865). The stop of the war led to the rise of big businesses in the United Stated and mostly in the war-torn states. The rise...
6 Pages(1500 words)Essay

Post disaster shelter reconstruction

Research has shown that sustainable post-disaster shelter reconstruction is crucial in strengthening resilience and provides full and equitable benefit (Ganapati & Ganapati, 2009 p.57). The principle of sustainable post-disaster shelter reconstruction requires that such reconstruction should meet the needs of the present generation without compromising the capacity of the coming generations to meet their needs (Ahmed, 2011 p.159).
There are certain challenges hinder sustainability in post-disaster shelter reconstruction and they include: massive displacement crisis, extensive physical destruction and limited accessible land. Effective shelter reconstruction in urban setting must therefore balance between all interests includin...
12 Pages(3000 words)Coursework

Bandura's Philosophy Theory

His memories are an accumulation of yesterdays. In yesterday's are written his dealings to others and to himself. He finds life more meaningful in the lives of others. His reason for living is to serve others because he learns more of himself by dealing, relating with and loving others. Hence his motto in life is: “Do to others what he wants others to do to him.”

Bandura’s theory confirms the reality of the experience. A man needs mirroring of others to tell him whether what he is doing is fine or not. The wife is the best critic of the husband and vice versa. This is what makes marriage a wonderful ground for discovery for the two is made into one yet uniqueness of each is still there.

Band...
7 Pages(1750 words)Coursework

Police and Society: Post 9/11

The paper then takes note of a number of initiatives that have attempted to combine local policing with intelligence work. This shift from crime-prevention to counter-terrorism has had a profound effect upon these local law enforcement divisions; lack of proper funding has also undermined these projects, leaving local officers with the ability to prevent terrorists, but either lacking in resources or risking becoming dependant upon intelligence divisions. The paper will then turn to a consideration of two local communities, Dearborn, Michigan, and Las Vegas, Nevada, that have been involved in these initiatives, and considers the impact of counter-terrorism policing upon the wider local law enforcement of the region.

By...
12 Pages(3000 words)Case Study

International Trade Theory

 Further to this, it is also believed that international trade can bring substantial economic welfare to the countries however still most of the countries do not view it as a favorable thing. Despite having a very promising and bright outlook, international trade has been largely viewed with suspension and it is because of this that governments impose barriers to restrict international trade. There can be many reasons behind this act of imposing restrictions or blocking international trade however there are also benefits on the other side too.

International trade has driven the attention of many of the brilliant minds in economics therefore the origins of the economic theory on international trade owe much to the c...
6 Pages(1500 words)Case Study

Social Theory in a Globalizing Age

A comparison between the followers of social theories and the followers of natural sciences (physics and chemistry) revealed that unlike followers of natural sciences social theorists don’t use any techniques to show the exact knowledge or skill. Instead, they prove their work or idea by suggesting a possible way of explaining the facts or arguments usually called hypotheses (Lemert, 2004).
By hypotheses, social theorists cannot easily prove their argument at a time but they require time to prove it. Social theorists are normally criticized for using the hypotheses. Deconstructionists or postmodernists, rigidly critical theorists, disagree with the criticism by mentioning that any research methodology is not 100% pure a...
10 Pages(2500 words)Assignment

Contemporary American Catholic Homiletic Theory and Practice

...Overview of Contemporary American Catholic Homiletic Theory and Practice Luke 4:16-21 The foundation moment in Christian preaching is written in Luke4:16-21, when Jesus went into the synagogue in Nazareth and stood up to read the scroll of the prophet Isaiah “and he begun by saying to them, ‘today this scripture is fulfilled in your hearing’”. (Luke 4:21) Upon the ripening of time, Jesus stood at that moment as the prophetic speaker proclaiming God’s scriptural Word, declaring the fulfillment of the prophecy in Isaiah in his person. He spoke in revelation of the fulfillment of written words to a congregation, laying down the foundation of Christian preaching that has since been the basic implement in the sustenance and propagation...
6 Pages(1500 words)Case Study

Free Cash Flows Theory

These are not hard and fast rules in determining the capital structure which should best affect a firms value. These theories lay down the benefits and the costs when a firm chooses what it sees as an adequate mix to maximise the shareholders value.

One of the implications where this research can lead include the possibility of the effectiveness in maximising shareholder value by employing two or more theories in capital structure decisions. Because these theories are more conditional by nature, probing which combinations when used for capital structure decisions are more effective in arriving at the goal of maximising firm value can be another subject for further research.
The role of capital structure in increasi...
11 Pages(2750 words)Case Study

Conflict Resolution in Organisations

The bakery organization failed to resolve the matter but eventually secured the services of a third party that helped separate one of the parties from the factory. As it has been pointed, the intimate relationship at the workplace was doing the company no harm until the unification came under strain (The Breakup at the Bakery, N. d). Intimate relationships aside, professional associations between workers can similarly develop into conflicts. That highlights the actuality that the workplace is stalled with an array of conflicting challenges. For a group to succeed, it must satisfactorily control conflicts within it. As the bakery case points, the management must have failed in moving swiftly to contain the situation and this was af...
7 Pages(1750 words)Assignment

Self Assessment: Conflict Management Style

...Please indicate Self Assessment: Conflict Management Style The assessment on conflict management that I took suggests that I am the type of person who tends to cooperate and work with people to achieve a desirable outcome. It suggests that when I am faced with a conflicting situation, although I listen and consider other viewpoints included in the discussion, I carefully evaluate and analyse every detail in accordance to my own. It depicts that I welcome other ideas or arguments but not easily swayed by them for I tend to make my point be heard and accepted as well, creating a really interesting discussion that in turn promotes a win-win situation. Furthermore, the assessment also indicated that second to collaborating attitude, I also...
7 Pages(1750 words)Essay

Management Theory and Practice in the Early Childhood Education Industry

...Management Theory and Practice in the early childhood education industry This Report applies management theory into practice in the early childhood industry, especially in the context of women leaders. Management issues play a significant role in the academic sector, because early childhood professionals need higher levels of motivation in order to avoid burnout . As pointed out in a study by Osgood and Halsall (2007) where they carried out research to examine the position of women in leadership or management positions, a “glass ceiling” exists for women in the academic setting, which could significantly impair motivation. Since many of the individuals employed in the early education sector are women, addressing this issue is even more...
6 Pages(1500 words)Coursework

Conflict Between Researh and Ethics on the Tuskegee Syphilis Study

The Declaration of Helsinki by the WHO clearly states that in clinical trials involving humans the wellbeing of the subject should be of prime importance than the interest of science or society. This has been stated because at times in order to achieve the objectives of a study the investigators might overlook the welfare of the trial subjects thus jeopardizing their health in the process. According to ethical rules while comparing two treatment options the control group of the study must receive the best-known treatment available while the study subjects are given a potential newer treatment. Only when there is no effective treatment available a placebo-controlled group can be used for the study. There have been several trials th...
7 Pages(1750 words)Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Essay on topic Towards of Theory of Balanced Purges in Post-Conflict Reconstruction Efforts for FREE!

Contact Us