Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Go to advanced search...

(managing human capital) Traditional performance appraisal methods and why it leads dysfunctional behaviour - Essay Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
One of the basic components of management in organisation is handling its basic resources such as money, materials, and manpower. The most crucial of which is assessing how the system is working as far as its "humanware" is concerned. This leads to the creation of the performance appraisal systems in every organisation, private or government, large or small.
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER98.6% of users find it useful
(managing human capital) Traditional performance appraisal methods and why it leads dysfunctional behaviour
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "(managing human capital) Traditional performance appraisal methods and why it leads dysfunctional behaviour"

Traditional appraisal techniques lead to dysfunctional behaviors Introduction One of the basic components of management in organisation is handling its basic resources such as money, materials, and manpower. The most crucial of which is assessing how the system is working as far as its "humanware" is concerned. This leads to the creation of the performance appraisal systems in every organisation, private or government, large or small.
Performance appraisal can be considered a 360 degree feedback on an employee's performance since it is being provided by the supervisor (main rater), co-employees (peer-rater), and external customers (client raters) to the employees concerned or from the employee concerned to the management referred as upward appraisals (Edwards and Ewen, 1996).
Performance appraisals are undertaken to assess the individual, a team, or an organisational unit's progress as far as its function is concerned. They can be based on personal assessment of the ratee based on a prepared rating scale depending on the systems preferred by the management. In the general context, performance evaluation is a good tool to reward and recognise outstanding performances and correct or counsel employees with poor accomplishments (US Department of the Interior, n. d)
Traditional appraisal techniques and its effects
Traditional methods of performance appraisal methods may differ in usability between private and public organisations. But they have similarities as far as the rating systems are concerned. Old systems use review processes in which the supervisor writes his ratings and opinions of the performance of a subordinate based on a form. In some organisations, the staff member is asked to fill out a self-review to share with the supervisor. In most cases, the appraisal reflects what the rater can remember and not a comprehensive evaluation. It is based on feelings and can be judgmental in nature (Dulewicz, 1989)
Considering that humans have emotions, traditional assessment techniques and even some present methods are mostly ceremonial rather than a thorough assessment of the personnel's output, efficiency, or effectiveness. Although there are several techniques that came out that really measures diligently the personnel outputs, majority of assessment tools do otherwise which could have led to dysfunctional behaviors.
Dysfunctional behaviors as a result of the traditional appraisal techniques are mostly found in government bureaucracy, and seldom found in private companies that strive for profit. Unwanted behaviors in the workplace as a result of traditional judgmental, personal assessment include insubordination, poor relations, criticism, and sometimes rebelliousness. In government bureaucracy a lenient performance system will lead to low quality and poor performance, discourages excellence, and promotes deliberate neglect of duties and responsibilities.
Although these negative cases are real in the workplace there are some situations that a serious implementation of these traditional systems and most of the modern systems may lead to better performance if the appraisal is linked to a reliable reward systems (Banister and Balkin, 1990) like promotion, monetary reward, and other forms of personal renumerations.
EDWARDS, M. R., and EWEN, A. J.. 1996. 360 Degree Feedback: The Powerful New Model for Employee Assessment & Performance Improvement. AMACOM
US Department of the Interior (n. d) Performance Appraisal Handbook (370 DM 430) A Guide for Managers/Supervisors and Employees.
BANNISTER, B.D. & BALKIN, D.B. 1990. Performance evaluation and compensation feedback messages: an integrated model, Journal of Occupational Psychology,
Vol 63, June, British Psychological Society.
DULEWICZ, V. 1989.Performance appraisal and counseling, in Herriot, P. ed. Assessment and selection in organizations: methods and practices for recruitment and appraisal. John Wiley & Sons, New York, pp645-649.
Redman, P., 2006. Good essay writing: a social sciences guide. 3rd ed.
London: Open University in assoc. with Sage.
Fishman, R., 2005. The rise and fall of suburbia. [e-book]. Chester: Castle Press.
Available at: / E-books [accessed 5 June 2005]
Boughton, J.M., 2002. The Bretton Woods proposal: an indepth look. Political Science Quarterly, 42 (6), p.564-78.
National electronic Library for Health. 2003. Can walking make you slimmer and healthier (Hitting the headlines article) [Online]. (Updated 16 Jan 2005) Available at: [accessed 10 April 2005]
Tesco Plc., 2002. Annual Report and financial statements 2002. [Online]. Tesco Plc.
Available at: f
[accessed 18 November 2005] Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
(“(managing human capital) Traditional performance appraisal methods and Essay”, n.d.)
Retrieved from
((managing Human Capital) Traditional Performance Appraisal Methods and Essay)
“(managing Human Capital) Traditional Performance Appraisal Methods and Essay”, n.d.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF (managing human capital) Traditional performance appraisal methods and why it leads dysfunctional behaviour

The performance appraisal methods

The performance appraisal methods
The performance appraisal methods are deemed as productive within organizations because these look to present the strengths of the employees and the work that they have manifested with the passage of time. It makes their work tasks cut out from the rest of their undertakings within the workplace environments and tells them where they have excelled as well as where they have gone wrong within the relevant scheme of things. This ensures that they remain steadfast as far as their work ideologies are concerned, and that all efforts and endeavors are geared to achieve big within the long term. The performance appraisal methods usually present the rewarding aspects related with the employees bu...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay


...? MANAGING HUMAN CAPITAL Table of Contents Executive Summary 4 Introduction 5 Analysis of Company background and current challenges/issues they are facing 6 Analysis- Literature Review 7 Process 12 Primary Research 12 Research Strategies- Quantitative and Qualitative Research 13 Data Collection Methods and Techniques 13 Data Analysis and Discussion on findings 14 Quantitative Analysis 14 Qualitative Analysis 19 Conclusion 19 Recommendations 20 Appendix 22 Questionnaire 22 Reference 25 Bibliography 28 Executive Summary The project begins with a brief introduction of Emirates the famous international airline based in Dubai. It is seen that the company has been known for its service quality towards customers, however, it has been confronting...
16 Pages(4000 words)Essay

Capital Appraisal

.... Newton would enjoy the royalty payments as a continuous source of revenue without having to invest heavily in fixed assets and working capital. The rental income from the manufacturing space will also continue and will enable Newton in making substantial profits. The expenditure of $5 million that Newton has already incurred in the past three years will be recovered in a span of 2.5 years which is not a very bad position since the project will have an expected life of 5 years. Keeping all the costs and benefits in consideration, it is recommended that Newton should chose option 3 to exploit the potential of the new product. Executive Summary This report is based on the important financial topic of Capital Appraisal...
6 Pages(1500 words)Research Paper

Managing Human Resources: Performance Appraisal

...Managing Human Resources: Performance Appraisal s Appraisal is essential for effective managing. TheConference Board study showed differences between the stated objectives of appraisals and the way they were actually used. These differences may have caused dissatisfaction. In the Work Planning and Review approach to appraisal, It will be emphasised that frequent performance discussions need to be undertaken. But performance discussions and salary actions will be dealt with at separate meetings. Appraisal will measure performance in achieving goals and plans and performance as a manager, that is, how well a person carries out key managerial activities. Traditional appraisal methods that attempt to measure personality traits have serious...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay

Capital Budgeting - Capital investment appraisal

...Capital Investment Appraisal a) Machine A Present Value Purchase Price (1570000) Working Capital (47000) Running cost (151671) Overhaul Cost (73494) Disposal Cost (51072) Labor Cost Saved 2823414 WC Released 21432 Net Present Value £ 951609 b) Report to the Managing Director:- After carefully combining all the information provided by salesmen and management accountant, I have performed an NPV analysis of the both proposed project’s cash flows. Results have shown that NPV of Machine B is 80% greater than NPV of machine A. So, Temple Ltd. should install Machine B for more effective automation process and to reduce its production costs and operate much more cheaply...
1 Pages(250 words)Speech or Presentation

Managing Human Capital Assignment

... on Employees’ Benefit Knowledge, Use, and Organizational Commitment. Journal of Business and Psychology, 20(1): 3-29, DOI: 10.1007/s10869-005-6981-1 Shih, K-H; Liu, Y-T; Jones, C; & Lin, B 2010 The indicators of human capital for financial institutions. Expert Systems with Applications. 37:1503-1509. Time Magazine 1955 “Management: The Scanlon Plan”. Time Magazine, 26 September 1955. Accessed 9 October 2010 from,9171,807657,00.html Waite, M.L. & Sites-Doe, S. 2001 Removing performance appraisal and merit pay in the name of quality: An empirical study of employees’ reactions. Journal of Quality Management, 5:187-206...
12 Pages(3000 words)Essay

Leadership and managing human capital

nagement and leadership styles to better interact with their subordinates and hence to improve employee productivity and organizational performance thereby. It must be noted that there is no single best leadership style that suits all leaders or organizations. Therefore, managers need to identify the leadership style that would fit them best in terms of their strengths and weaknesses and the nature of the organization. In order to evaluate the various roles and responsibilities of leaders and to assess the influence of leaders on the overall organizational performance, this paper will critically analyze six different scholarly articles talking about leadership models and managing human capital. In this paper, my personal leadershi...
10 Pages(2500 words)Essay

Managing Human Capital

...Managing Human Capital AFFILIATION: Table of Contents Table of Contents 2 Introduction 4 Criticalanalysis of the appraisal system 5 Evolution of the Performance Management System 8 Issues encountered by the organisations 12 Conclusion 15 References 18 Organisations in today’s competitive and dynamic business environment have realised the importance of developing an effective, loyal and competent workforce. When the company has a competitive edge in its workforce, then it is able to excel in its market and respond to the challenges in an effective manner. One of the important driver for creating such valuable assets is the performance appraisal process as it is the technique utilised for assessing the employee’s performance and identify...
15 Pages(3750 words)Essay

Problems of Human Activities

A lion’s share of the industrial, cultural and academic leadership is made up of the baby boomers. The baby boomers also have the highest median household income in the United States of America. An undue burden is being placed by these baby boomers on their children’s economy. They are in a state of denial regarding their aging and death and thereby they do not plan for their retirement. Since there is a too rapid decline in population the immigrants help in maintaining the fertility rate and population of the country. This too leads to a plethora of problems. These immigrants sometimes do not join the mainstream of their adopted country and live in groups following their own culture and customs instead of assimilating...
7 Pages(1750 words)Term Paper

An Evaluation of the Role That the Principles of Behaviour Therapy Have to Play in Clinical Hypnosis

Hamburg (2006) first used this combined effort to treat two patients who were scared of dying. He uses his paper to encourage clinicians to refrain from not using their knowledge at the introductory classes of hypnosis but to go into it deeper. Many therapists at that time were taking the bold step of combining behavior therapy with hypnosis (Chaves, 2006). One group used hypnosis for desensitization therapy (Kirsch et al, 1995). However, there was general disagreement about the manner of hypnosis being employed and the methods of mentalist constructs. Chaves who strongly believed in the treatment combination used it as a base for many of his therapeutic interventions (Chaves, 1997a as cited in Chaves, 2006). The hypnotic therapy...
8 Pages(2000 words)Article

Analysis of the Methods of 3 Research Papers about Child Abuse

Research ethics was maintained as the identity of the individuals participating was kept secret. As far as the validity of the study was concerned, the researchers attempted to use content validity in order to get an accurate response. The content validity focused on measuring off the ethnicities and gender percentages within the area and attempting to get a random sample of individuals via the phone. Their approach to random calling allowed for a significant random sample in the study. There were a few issues, however, with this type of approach. Those answering the phone sometimes were not always the desired individual, and not all of the desired people were surveyed. Different replacements did have to be used, and the attempt w...
6 Pages(1500 words)Literature review

Evaluation of Performance of a Bank Using Published Accounting Data

The performance of a bank is evaluated because of various reasons. The banks evaluate their performance to find out the outcomes of previous decisions of management. The bank regulators evaluate the performance of the banks to identify the banks, which are facing severe problems. Evaluation using the published data is also needed by shareholders to make decisions such as whether to buy or sell a share of banks. Furthermore, investment analysts advise their prospective investors regarding the selection of banks for making investments after performance evaluations of banks.

There are different ways, which have been used to evaluate the performance of the banks. When the performance is analysed through available published...
7 Pages(1750 words)Case Study

Using Computers to Teach Mathematics is Better than Traditional Methods

...Using computers to teach Mathematics is better than traditional methods Computer technology has changed the face of education, and is a useful tool in the teaching of other subjects as well with Mathematics being no exception. Various calculating devices have long been used in Mathematics, but the computer offers an even greater potential. Some teachers are reluctant to use computers, for example on the grounds that it is an expensive option and not every child has access to one at home, but its prevalence nowadays means that students should be given the opportunity to use computers in their Mathematics lessons. They have the advantage of being able to make complex calculations much quicker, demonstrate graphical visualisations, instilling...
7 Pages(1750 words)Case Study

Universal Declaration of Human Rights

...Hello, I have read this and thinks it’s perfect I have slight amendments which are highlighted in red. thanks Universal Declaration of Human Rights Introduction Human rights are defined as, the basic standards by which we can identify and measure inequality and fairness. These rights are specified in the Universal Declaration of Human Rights.1 The United Nations adopted the Universal Declaration of Human Rights (UDHR) on the 10th of December 1948. It consists of a number of civil, cultural, economic, political, and social rights. Although, it is not legally binding, it provides an authoritative interpretation of several articles of the UN Charter; and the latter is binding on the member states of the United Nations.2 There are several...
8 Pages(2000 words)Case Study

Capital Asset Pricing Model and Recent Developments

It is the most essential aspect of any venture. The important considerations that finance has within it, is that of profit and loss. The business as a whole or a person as an individual always strives to earn a profit. To earn a profit, one has to undertake uncertainties that are known as risks. Therefore, profit is also known as the reward for incurring risks.
In the present world of today, the capital market has come up as a viable investment opportunity for individuals all across the globe. People invest their hard money only with the expectation to earn profit or return. The stocks of various companies that are traded in the capital market are also known as capital assets. Prior to investing in any of the stock or capital...
7 Pages(1750 words)Assignment

Real Cost of Capital

Also, other academics criticize the models' failure to incorporate other determinants of risks such as firm size, book-to-market ratio, etc. then the plain correlation of the risk of the assets to the market. Despite these criticisms, many practitioners in the corporate world still use CAPM for capital budgeting. These issues are probed in this paper.
CAPM or the capital asset pricing model has been a tool in modern finance that has been extensively used for capital budgeting. The capital asset pricing model is useful in estimating the required return on an equity stock of a company (Perold 2004). Under the principle of finance that rational investors will require higher returns to compensate them when they undertake projects...
8 Pages(2000 words)Assignment

Alternative Methods of Accounting

Accounting has always been a self-regulated profession. After the 2nd half of the 20th-century changes in accounting occurred due to the influence of private organizations such as the FASB.  In the United States, accountants followed the generally accepted accounting principles (GAAP) to guide their everyday work. Accounting is a discipline that is very strict in its ways and does not welcome change well. In the aftermath of the Enron and WorldCom scandal, the government had to force change with the creation of the Sarbanes Oxley Act of 2002 due to a lack of trust in financial information. 

The efficient market hypothesis states that securities are typically in equilibrium and that they are fairly priced in th...
8 Pages(2000 words)Article

What to Consider in Structure-Conduct-Performance Model

The best possible outcome for SA is when it plays L while SS plays U and the best possible outcome for SS is when it plays L, and the other plays U. These outcomes (L, U) and (U, L) are difficult to achieve. This is because these strategies are not dominant for both. There is an incentive for one player to deviate.
If the prices are decided every week then the strategy would change in terms of the components. For the repeated games, the Nash equilibriums of all the sub-games are the same as the equilibrium of each one-shot game. The number of components in the strategy would increase because of the repetition of the game (both would still play L, L) however the pay off associated with the game would be increase by times of th...
6 Pages(1500 words)Essay

Managing Human Capital

.... Amidst uncertainties and to avoid confusion managers may tend to overpay the workers in which case the workers may likely withdraw effort (Belfield and Marsden, 2003). Example Companies such as Nokia have actually experienced reduced performance over time as people realize that goals are achievable and hence a positive appraisal assured (Nikols, 2007). Involving employees in the appraisal process my to some extent increase acceptance but the bias control mechanism cannot be eliminated due to the human element involved (Davis & Landa, 1999). Multiple appraisals from different managers, is one method of eliminating manager-bias but if ratings from different managers differ, it could again impact the overall appraisal (Lewis, 1998...
12 Pages(3000 words)Assignment

Managing Teacher Appraisal and Performance

Radicals strictly as a benchmark to key decision-making processes at the school are wrong, as it denied the institution an opportunity to fully enjoy the benefits of staff appraisals. The following argument evidently projects the benefits of conducting regular staff appraisals at the learning institution. Staff appraisals are important in every learning institution as they enable the administration to ensure that the teachers perform their duties and responsibilities effectively. On the other hand, staff appraisals also ensure that teachers give their best while in the classroom in order to guarantee maximum output through the excellent performance of their students. Under normal circumstances, staff appraisals take place on a per...
9 Pages(2250 words)Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Essay on topic (managing human capital) Traditional performance appraisal methods and why it leads dysfunctional behaviour for FREE!

Contact Us