StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...

A Just War - Essay Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
Summary
This paper attempts to answer the question of whether or not the war in Iraq qualifies as a just war according to Catholic Doctrine. This paper will first examine what a just war is according to Catholic Doctrine and then apply the definition to the Iraq War to determine whether it is a just war.
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER93.9% of users find it useful
A Just War
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "A Just War"

Download file to see previous pages The power of modern means of destruction weighs very heavily in evaluating this condition.
These are the traditional elements enumerated in what is called the "just war" doctrine. The evaluation of these conditions for moral legitimacy belongs to the prudential judgment of those who have responsibility for the common good.
The first question the definition brings is who has "the responsibility for the common good" This is Catholic Doctrine so one would assume that the leadership of the Catholic Church is responsible for defining it for the Catholic community. The doctrine does put the responsibility on the leadership of the Catholic Church and that would be the Pope. But, the Catholic Church turns that responsibility back to the people when they ask the community to keep them informed (Catholic Answers). The Pope and the Church pass some of this responsibility to the members of the Church by educating the people of the church (using the Catechism).
The idea of condoning a war would seem to be in direct conflict with many of the scriptures and teachings of the Catholic Church and the Bible. ...
This gives the impression that when challenged one should not react in an aggressive manner (according to the Bible). This contradicts Catholic doctrine that allows for the evaluation of war as just or unjust. To condone war would mean acceptance, to some extent, of Catholic Doctrine over the writings of the Bible. In order to evaluate the Iraq war as just or unjust according to Catholic Doctrine (Catechism) the teachings of the Bible need to be set aside as not relevant. The Catholic Church is assumed to have evaluated it all for its congregation and given its rulings in its Catechism (like a judge interprets the law when making a ruling in a court case). Evaluating the Iraq War will be done assuming the Catholic Catechism is the law.
2. Just or Unjust War
The first part of the Catechism to be examined is this: "the damage inflicted by the aggressor on the nation or community of nations must be lasting, grave, and certain."(Catholic Catechism paragraph 2309).
This question challenges whether the Iraqi leadership (or the country itself) is expected to cause lasting, grave, and certain damage to the community of nations. During the first Gulf War it was evident that Iraq (the country) intended to take over Kuwait and cause great harm to Israel and any other country that was part of the coalition forces that liberated Kuwait. When the World Trade Center was bombed it was clear that it was an attack on the United Statesbut initially unclear who was responsible. The men who carried out the attacks on 9-11 were from the Middle East and were apparently funded by Osama Bin Laden. "Osama bin Laden Promises More Attacks on United States" (ABC News, ...Download file to see next pagesRead More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“A Just War Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 2000 words”, n.d.)
A Just War Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 2000 words. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1500462-a-just-war
(A Just War Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 2000 Words)
A Just War Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 2000 Words. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1500462-a-just-war.
“A Just War Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 2000 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1500462-a-just-war.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF A Just War

Just War Doctrine

...?Military and Civilian Perspectives on the Ethics of Intelligence Introduction The military is a unique and has its own way of going about its duties. This not withstanding, there is no denying the fact that the civilian populace form the majority of representation of any country and thus the driving force in determining societal norms and deeds. This means that the military cannot live and operate in isolation but then should have all its operations in the interest of the nigger society. One issue of such importance to society about the work and operations of the military is Just War. Content According to the BBC Ethics Guide (2011), “A war is only just if it is fought for a reason that is justified, and that carries sufficient moral...
1 Pages(250 words)Essay

Just War Theory

... in advance before strike. Orend defines a just war as an intentional, actual organized and armed attack between aggressors. Just war theory is based on two points of view; classic and contemporary just wars. Schall reports that theorists like the Father Webster and Mr. Cole insist that for a war to qualify as just, it must base on classic concept and should not involve evil actions like fighting the perceived innocent and noncombatant individuals. Father Webster and Mr. Cole believe that a justified war should transpire through certain criteria. The contemporary concept of just war permits armed attack under the claims of self-defense by a country. The contemporary concept of just war recognizes permission granted for coercion to be based...
5 Pages(1250 words)Essay

Views on Just War

...?Views on Just War Introduction The thought of war coming to one’s mind is always chaotic and bloody. Bravery is often manifested in war regardless of its purpose and goals, and that it happens for a variety of reasons. However, despite the violence associated with war, it is often argued that there is in fact, a just war or accepted ethically and by law due to its purpose and goals. This paper aims to examine whether or not there is an existence of a just war. The Nature of War Regan (1996, p.3) stated that war was natural part of life during the Greek times, and that they intensify “self- interest.” “Right reason” was also said to be one of the “Moral Norm of War” (Regan, 1996, p.10). There were a variety of reasons as to why war can...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay

Theories of Just War

...? Theories of Just War Number Number Teacher’s Due Theories of Just War The theories of just war are relevant in today’s society as well. War forms an integral, if undesirable, part of modern society. Every nation has an arsenal stocked with the deadliest of weapons, many of which may be able to wipe off mankind from the very face of the earth. It is widely agreed upon that a nuclear war, if it happens, would produce this result. The threat that stronger nations pose to the sovereignty of smaller nations is also one of the greatest problems that faces mankind at this point of time in history. For the purpose of acquiring resources and also for the age-old purpose of conversions, countries may turn loose aggression on countries that may...
8 Pages(2000 words)Essay

Terrorism and just war

...?Terror has been used all through the history of the civilization to establish identities, power and maintain structural and cultural realities of the societies. In this process of terrorizing what happens in turn is the distortion of the contradicting identities, power systems and structural and cultural realities. Theories relating to just war have always tried distinguish between the right and wrong in these power games. The terminological conclusions of this distinction are the terms ‘just war’ and ‘terrorism’. “Terrorism is the random killing of innocent people, in the hope of creating pervasive fear” (Walzer, 2006). Acts of terrorism involves arousing fright amongst the target population so as to push a particular political, social...
5 Pages(1250 words)Essay

Just War Theory Concept

...Introduction According to just war, specific war can be justified or ified as just if it meets certain conditions. Just war defines war as a warthat is really against military aggression or its threat. It also refers to intentional threat that is serious in nature. It is also defined in other words as a war that includes the intervention of human rights. It normally has to satisfy a proportionality norm. The gains of the just war have to exceed the costs incurred. Just war is actually an attempt to distinguish unjustifiable and justifiable uses of armed forces that are organized. This involves the issue of using armed forces when it is right to do so. Just war defines war as a situation where parties have to fight back basing on various...
7 Pages(1750 words)Case Study

World War II as a Just war

... groups: The Allies and the Axis. Germany, Japan and their allies formed the 'Axis' while US, Britain and its allies as the 'Allies'. This essay would validate this claim that the war fought by the 'Allies' was a just war, by describing the true nature and criteria required to name a war as a 'Just war'. The basis of the 'Just war' is the point that no matter what the circumstances become, the prospect of war certainly means death and slaughter but at a certain point war becomes inevitable. This could be seen since the wars in the olden times. Though the criteria differ in nature but the moral considerations of the war are the same. Under these conditions, a certain criteria should be met before waging any war to make that war a 'Just war...
6 Pages(1500 words)Essay

The Just War Theory

...uccess, and the end being proportional to the means used" (Moseley, 2009). One can clearly see that although these principles are commonly accepted, they are open for interpretation and extrapolation. They allow a certain amount of flexibility and do not provide a strict ethical framework, as the principles and the interpretations of them can be quite vague at times ("Catholic Just War", n.d). Possessing a just cause is the first principle and probably the most important one, and it is very intrinsic as it stems from the very definition of a just war. It is commonly held that initiating an act of aggression is an unjust thing, and gives the attacked party the right to defend itself and initiate a counter-strike. The latter will be...
6 Pages(1500 words)Term Paper

Just War Theory

...Just War Theory (JWT) is, essentially, a theory of moral obligations of armies in wartime, and therefore rests upon the assumption that militaries and states are equivalent to moral agents. Because morality is a prescribed set of conduct governing the rules of individual interactions within a social context, JWT applies the same kind of prescriptions and values to states and militaries that it does to individuals within their respective communities. Thus, in the world community, it is expected that when two entities go to war with each other, they will follow a set of ethical standards laid down within JWT. However, two problems arise when trying to justify the use of JWT in shaping the United States and allies’ strategies in Afghanistan...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

Just War/Military Ethics

...Just War Just War Just war in the criteria by which nations lawfully and ethically qualify war to be a correct of action for particular reasons. The theory of just war dates back to the works of early Greek and Roman philosophers, Aristotle and Cicero who brought about the discussion on justifiable reasons to take life or go to war with proper rules of conduct. the idea have deep roots in the religious doctrines of Abrahamic origin (Islam, Judaism and Christianity) which tries to harmonize the fact that killing is sin but at some cases it may be purposeful to take human life (Walzer, 2008). . This paper seek to harmonize the different principles that qualifies a war to be just. Just war as a theory have open boundaries of interpretation...
2 Pages(500 words)Assignment

English Literature - the Post-War Fiction

And, one of the written forms through which the author will reflect all his/ her ‘events influenced thought process’, is the fiction. So, from early centuries, fictions have been a great medium to imprint one’s life as well as to see and read one’s life. And, Writers from the United Kingdom also wrote events influenced fictions as a variation to plays. And this paper will analyze the event of World Wars and its impact, as an aspect of modernism, and then demonstrate its use in the modernist writing, “The Happy Autumn Fields” written by the Irish born English author, Elizabeth Bowen.

Among an assortment of events of the 20th century, the two World Wars only impacted the people en masse...
12 Pages(3000 words)Term Paper

Afghanistan War and the Export of Heroin

Afghanistan seemed to be big in the United State’s national security policy in the 1980s. The Soviet Union attacked and invaded Afghanistan in 1979, this war turned into an unwinnable guerrilla war. Thus, the strategic policy of America considered Afghanistan as a battleground where the Soviet military machine possibly will be badly defeated and to America, it was a time to arouse domestic dissatisfaction by means of a conflict that could extremely unpopular as well as expensive. The pictures of Afghans that were shown in America in the 1980s depicted them as brave and courageous people, who were fighting to get back their sovereignty from the clutches of the Soviet bear. The rebels of Afghanistan, the mujahideen, were thoug...
9 Pages(2250 words)Assignment

The United Kingdom and World War I

It had shown its ability to survive a war and remained a powerful nation of the world (Hardie, Graham, and Kofman).
Almost all the nations in Europe had suffered economically due to the First World War. Most of the European nations were subjected to economic burdens imposed by the war. After the end of the war, the European governments had to make rehabilitation efforts, in respect of the cities destroyed in the war. In addition, they had to provide medical facilities to the soldiers who had been wounded in the war. These governments had to pay pensions to the soldiers, widows, and relatives of the dead soldiers. Moreover, they had to repay the public and foreign debts, and the interest on such debts. These constituted the ad...
6 Pages(1500 words)Assignment

Comparison of the Cold War International System to the Current International System

An example is that of the Korean War (1950-53) which is said to transform the nature of the Cold War, while its initial impact was to solidify the division of the world into political, military, and economic spheres. Take Germany for instance where imperialism was a victim challenged by the historians for the destruction of the German Government along with its supporters used to conduct (Keylor, 2001, p. 44). That indicates economic expansion and territorial acquisition has always been a problem promoted since the First World War. Even in the 1920s, it was fashionable to declare the German empire on the threshold of the ‘Great War’ (Keylor, 2001, p. 44).

Europe in the global context remained tense and divide...
8 Pages(2000 words)Article

Analysis of Mark Twains The War Prayer

As a satirist and journalist, Mark Twain wrote some of the most influential works in American literary history. His work has influenced the stereotype of American life. Within his words are the images that typify the 19th-century experience with the whitewashed fences, the steamboats on the Mississippi, and the raft on the river, rolling lazily along on a hot summer day. However, within this writing one can find a deeper truth about the greater American experience of all its inhabitants. While creating a warm and charming atmosphere, Twain commented on racial discrimination and the false ‘superiority’ that the policies of the American government. 

As it is popularly known in this time, the name Mark Twa...
12 Pages(3000 words)Book Report/Review

Roles of the African American Soldiers in the Korean War

In 1950, nearly eight percent of the total military force standing in Korea was comprised of African-American servicemen, equally approximately one hundred thousand individuals willing to fight and possibly die for their country. The country which finally gave these men this opportunity, at this time, was undergoing radical change at home and abroad in wartime. As African-Americans sought and acquired more social and economic freedom, and the consequent political power, military officials realized the underutilization of Black soldiers. As a result, the Korean War marks for the first time a major role granted to African-Americans to contribute in a significant fashion to the military endeavors of the United States.
That which...
7 Pages(1750 words)Essay

Culture's Portrayal of the Vietnam War - A Criticism Misdirected

Most of the popular culture images were highly critical of the war and painted the US forces as brutal intruders into an otherwise peaceful and innocent jungle scene. From the viewpoint of the popular culture, its images and art, everybody had a scene to play and everybody got it wrong. The lowly buck private was no less responsible than the Commander in Chief, and the Pentagon shared equal guilt with the Military-Industrial Complex. Was the criticism legitimate? From the viewpoint of the actors, agents, and citizens that filled these roles, the medias criticism of the war and their grim portrayal of the times, was an exaggerated stretch of reality that forever tarnished the reputation of an entire generation.

It was ea...
7 Pages(1750 words)Assignment

The Origins of the Second World War

The accord at present is that it was Hitler's resolve to change the basis of European society that took the war to Europe in 1939. It was not essentially the war he was planning for; the facts propose that Hitler was intending to set up Germany for a huge conflict with Russia in the early 1940s. However, indisputably it was a war forced by his persistent pursuit of strategies that stood on race and on space (Henig, 1997).

The Second World War was originated due to the Fascist attack and the failure of democratic powers to prevent this assault. There seem to be a number of reasons for the Second World War to occur. German rearmament started after Hitler left 1932-34 Geneva Disarmament Conference, declaring that as the po...
7 Pages(1750 words)Article

Intelligence and the War on Drugs

When the Ronald Reagan Administration initiated its famous War on Drugs program in the 1980s with the catchy slogan “Just Say No”, the focus of the program was not exclusively Mexico. At that time, different pockets of Latin America posed threats of varying degrees, including Columbia and Brazil. But due to its proximity to the United States, and the increase in demand for cocaine and marijuana, Mexico has emerged as the greatest threat in recent decades. Compounding the problem of drug trafficking is the internal political chaos in Mexico. The Mexican governments of past and present have tried various methods and tactics for bringing the drug cartels under control but to no avail. It is a reflection of the governments...
7 Pages(1750 words)Assignment

The Geography of War and Peace

... rallying occurred in the Iraq-US war. In the same way, just as Huntington purports the dominance of the Western civilization over others in terms of their superior military power, international dominion and economic stability have made it an enviable power for the rest of the world. The author argues that the Western nations such as United States, Britain, France and Germany have developed better close international relations as they are united by the same Western civilizations and this cannot be seen among the non-Western civilizations. As a result, just as Huntington pointed out, the civilization conflict in the future is most likely to be the west versus the rest where the Islam civilization will prove to be another competent rival...
10 Pages(2500 words)Assignment
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Essay on topic A Just War for FREE!

Contact Us