StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Shortfalls and Negative Issues of Jim Collins Good to Great - Book Report/Review Example

Cite this document
Summary
From the paper "Shortfalls and Negative Issues of Jim Collins’ Good to Great " it is clear that while Collins points out at some great qualities that a Level 5 leader should possess, he grossly fails to show the concrete steps that would assist in helping leaders to evolve into Level 5 executives…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER94.3% of users find it useful
Shortfalls and Negative Issues of Jim Collins Good to Great
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Shortfalls and Negative Issues of Jim Collins Good to Great"

Shortfalls and Negative Issues of Good to GreatJim Collins’ masterpiece “Good to Great” is certainly one of the most widely read book in the business world. Drawing from experiences of 11 companies, Collins belabors to explain some key principles that are essential to transforming a company from “Good” to “Great”. A random glimpse through the chapters of the book gives the reader a feeling of greatness even before practically rolling out the strategies suggested therein. In other words, the author skillfully uses his writing skills to create a feeling of possibility for every manager who desires to transform their companies into peak performance.

The reality on the ground, however, contradicts some of the author’s suggestion. In this critical review, I discuss the short falls and negative issues of “Good to Great”.To begin with, Collins’ tendency to generalize and apply his research outcomes on the universal platforms is somehow nonsensical. The study by itself is biased in the sense that Collins focused on just a few Fortune 500 companies. This study analyzed 11 companies that transited from good to great against 11 peer companies that failed to transit within the same period.

Judgment was made based on the increase in stock returns. The negative issue with this study is that it is limited to only a small section of the universe. A company listed in Fortune 500 companies is already an established, well branded, and relatively successful by nature. Assuming that start-up, or rather mid-sized company will follow the same trajectory as the companies used in the study is absolutely unrealistic. Companies at different levels of growth face various challenges that and limit the universal application of Collins suggestions.

Another shortfall of Collins’ book is that he fails to explain the reason why some of the companies he considered great had started underperforming even before his book was published. An analysis of most of the 11 companies 10 years after Collins’ research (2010) point at a rather sorry scenario where most of them are struggling to survive at peak performance. For instance, Abbott Laboratories has hardly experienced further growth stock, Circuit City became bankrupt, while Fannie Mae was placed under conservatorship.

This unfolding simply point to the fact that Collins’ opinion could have been valid only at that time period. In other words, as time progress and economic conditions vary, what could have worked at some period may lead to total failure when applied in another period. In this respect, the question that current readers of “Good to Great” book try to answer is why Collin’s Great companies are underperforming when they formed a perfect example at some past time. Did they deviate from strategies that gave them competitive advantage then?

While Collins points out at some great qualities that a Level 5 leader should possess, he grossly fails to show the concrete steps that would assist in helping leaders to evolve into Level 5 executives. This is attributed to the fact that the book only explains what such leaders are. The characteristics of a level five leader, whom Collins suggested has greatest chance of transiting their company to greatness, are almost unattainable. These qualities are of a perfect person who is not prone to any flaws.

Also, while a particular leadership style may be suitable for, let us say service industry, any effort to apply the same leadership style in a manufacturing industry may prove very fatal. The style of leadership employed majorly depends on the nature of the business as well as followers. Therefore, assuming that a particular leadership style is universally applicable is a fallacy. ReferenceCollins, J. C. (2001). Good to Great. New York, NY: Harperbusiness.

Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Shortfalls and Negative Issues of Jim Collins Good to Great Book Report/Review”, n.d.)
Shortfalls and Negative Issues of Jim Collins Good to Great Book Report/Review. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/management/1817215-good-to-great-book
(Shortfalls and Negative Issues of Jim Collins Good to Great Book Report/Review)
Shortfalls and Negative Issues of Jim Collins Good to Great Book Report/Review. https://studentshare.org/management/1817215-good-to-great-book.
“Shortfalls and Negative Issues of Jim Collins Good to Great Book Report/Review”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/management/1817215-good-to-great-book.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Shortfalls and Negative Issues of Jim Collins Good to Great

Negative Decisions Issues

A manager, who made a series of bad decisions that resulted in negative condition and huge losses for the whole company, was Nick Leeson.... What has started with an attempt to conceal employee's mistake, resulted in multiple attempts to hide his own mistakes in derivative market, and this deception together with many negative decisions led the bank to crash....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

The Issue of the Negative Externalities of the Profit Maximization Aim of the Big Corporations

It analyses the issue of the negative externalities of the profit maximization aim of the Big Corporations.... The Issue of the negative Externalities of the Profit Maximization Aim of the Big Corporations Michael Moore addresses the issue of the negative externalities of the profit maximization aim of the Big Corporations, specifically focusing on GM in this piece of work....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Issues with Chinese Made Goods - Toys, Food

The paper "issues with Chinese Made Goods - Toys, Food" discusses that the wheat gluten that was imported into America from China has been found responsible for the contamination of food products that killed a huge number of pets and dogs, during 2007.... The same include guarantee of high-quality products and services by the business enterprises, among other issues.... Accordingly, the issues related to the safety and dangers involved in using them are summarized, briefly, below: Presence of lead in Chinese toys Most of the Chinese products have an excessive amount of lead metal, which poses danger to the person handling such goods, particularly the children....
1 Pages (250 words) Essay

Schoolsville/Billy Collins

The poem Schoolsville by Billy collins describes some recognizable school experiences like the memories the persona has about the boy who always raised his hand in class and also the girl who signed papers with her lipstick.... The students do not go far from home after graduating, and they due: Schoolsville /Billy collins The poem Schoolsville by Billy collins describes some recognizable school experiences like the memories the persona has about the boy who always raised his hand in class and also the girl who signed papers with her lipstick....
1 Pages (250 words) Assignment

HR Performance Issues and Motivation

The author considers a real-life situation, of a sales executive (jim) who has been working at a leading MNC.... hellip; The author explains that jim had acquired his post graduation degree from the Harvard Business School with the 10th rank holder status, and subsequently he was hired by this MNC through a campus interview.... For the first three years, jim performed outstandingly and received the 'best performer of the year' award two times from the sales manager....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

The Woman in White by Wilkie Collins

Most of his writings focused on globally significant issues of gender, family and law.... Most of his writings focused on globally significant issues of gender, family and law.... In… The theme of the book is that irrespective of their education, social status, economic status or moral conduct, victimization of women is a common occurrence Wilkie Collin's The Woman in White Theme Analysis Wilkie collins is considered to be one of the first of sensation fiction novels....
1 Pages (250 words) Coursework

Poems Written by Billy Collins

t were the great car of English itself” he consoles himself that he can “speed off down the road, that will never lead to Rome, not even to Bologna.... … The paper "Any Three Poems Written By Billy collins" is an outstanding example of a literature essay.... Billy collins' poetry makes one smile.... The paper "Any Three Poems Written By Billy collins" is an outstanding example of a literature essay.... illy collins' poetry makes one smile....
1 Pages (250 words) Essay

On Turning Ten by Billy Collins

This essay is "On Turning Ten by Billy collins".... nbsp;On Turning Ten by Billy collins is a poem that represents a storyline that describes the issues someone might face as time goes.... The narrator and author perfectly make use of similes in the final sestets in the poem to represent that age changes whereas mentioning that “whenever someone falls in life while walking, it normally happens that they bleed from their knees or elbows” which is an attempt to deal with all the life issues that the author of the poem might have faced....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us