Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Go to advanced search...

Assignment #3 Petty v. Metropolitan Govt of Nashville & Davidson County - Research Paper Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
Metropolitan Government of Nashville & Davidson County, the issue is about if an employee is truthful about the reasons for his discharge from duties or service. The case also touched on the postponement in re-employing a returning Army reservist who had violated the…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER92.6% of users find it useful
Assignment #3 Petty v. Metropolitan Govt of Nashville & Davidson County
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "Assignment #3 Petty v. Metropolitan Govt of Nashville & Davidson County"

Management Number The Legal Issues in This Case In Petty v. Metropolitan Government of Nashville & Davidson County, the issue is about if an employee is truthful about the reasons for his discharge from duties or service. The case also touched on the postponement in re-employing a returning Army reservist who had violated the Uniformed Services Employment and Re-employment Rights Act (USERRA), even if the delay emanates from the employee’s dishonesty. All these happen in light of the fact that the US has taken several steps to ensure that employers do not discriminate against employees, when hiring, firing or promoting.
2. Explaining How the Reemployment Provisions of the USERRA Were Violated In This
As is specified by Mollica (2008), at the heart of this, the principal dispute in this case is whether or not Metro had violated USERRA, in its handling or treatment of Petty. Petty had left the department for active duty with the United States Army and sought redeployment with the department after the completion of his military service. There are four key functions that USERRA performs. These include: the guaranteeing returning veterans the right of re-employment after military service; preventing employers from discriminating against returning veterans, in relation to their military service; prescribing the position to which army veterans are entitled upon their return; and preventing employers from firing returning veterans arbitrarily, within a year of reemployment. In light of the four functions, it is right to state that USERRA exists to consolidate the rights of returning veterans who are seeking reemployment upon return from service.
However, even in light of the foregoing, Metro delayed re-hiring Petty by subjecting her through the entire return-to-work process. Secondly, Metro violated the reemployment provisions of USERRA by not according Petty the position he had been qualified for.
3. Explaining Why the Court Concludes That Petty Has a Claim for Discrimination under
The Court made a conclusion that Petty’s claim for discrimination under USERRA was legitimate and founded on truth because he had satisfied all the stipulations for the reinstatement. Again, the court continued that Petty’s petition for reemployment was made in a timely manner, and his discharge done honorably. In the USERRA lawsuit, Petty had cogently argued that the department had unlawfully delayed his reemployment and declined to restore him [Petty] to his patrol sergeant’s position. This was discriminatory against Petty, by virtue of his military service record. The argument by the department that it was merely observing uniform fitness for duty procedures which Nashville and the surrounding county did not suffice in the court.
Metro never conformed with the act’s requirement to immediately or quickly reinstate Petty to his former position. When Metro raised alleged dishonesty by Petty as a defense, the US Court of Appeal responded to Metro, by reminding Metro that USERRA allows any employer to terminate former servicemen for cause after redeployment. The Court of Appeal also reminded Metro that USERRA also does not allow any employer to use the same cause as a reason for totally not reinstating the individual. At the same time, as a way of complying with the Metro’s return-to-work process, Petty had signed an authorization that granted Metro unlimited access to his entire military and medical records which included, a complete DD-214.
4. Explaining What the Police Department Should Have Done Differently
It is a fact that the Police Department should have averted the aforementioned crisis by doing things in a better way. Particularly, the Police Department should have adhered by the dictates of USERRA to reemploy or reinstate Petty back to the office he had previously held. Petty had fulfilled all the felicity conditions that are needed for his reinstatement or reemployment. For instance, Petty had served the military and signed an authorization which granted Metro unfettered access to his entire military and medical records which included a complete DD-214. There was no factor indicating that Petty was unable to ably discharge the duties, roles and responsibilities pertinent to the office or job he had applied for.
Mollica, P. (2008). Petty v. Metro. Govt. of Nashville-Davidson County, No. 07-5649 (6th Cir. Aug. 18, 2008); Abner v. The Kansas City Southern Railway Co., No. 07-30674 (5th Cir. Aug. 14, 2008). Outten & Golden: Daily Developments in EEO Law. Retrieved on February 11, 2014, from: Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
(“Assignment #3 Petty v. Metropolitan Govt of Nashville & Davidson Research Paper”, n.d.)
Assignment #3 Petty v. Metropolitan Govt of Nashville & Davidson Research Paper. Retrieved from
(Assignment #3 Petty V. Metropolitan Govt of Nashville & Davidson Research Paper)
Assignment #3 Petty V. Metropolitan Govt of Nashville & Davidson Research Paper.
“Assignment #3 Petty V. Metropolitan Govt of Nashville & Davidson Research Paper”, n.d.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Assignment #3 Petty v. Metropolitan Govt of Nashville & Davidson County

Metropolitan Police and are they Racist

...this hypothesis is true or not. Analysis is made on the basis of a detailed discussion about the history of racism and its roots. It then looks into various incidents of racism that have taken place in history and Police’s involvement in them. Besides, it takes a closer look at the August riots and its various causes. In the end, a conclusion is presented that sums up the discussion and gives out some recommendations on the basis of it. TABLE OF CONTENTS EXECUTIVE SUMMARY 2 TABLE OF CONTENTS 3 INTRODUCTION 4 Research Background 4 Aims and Objectives of the research 4 Rationale for the selection of the research 5 Research Question 5 Hypothesis 6 Review of the Key References 6 Key references for this study include the...
14 Pages(3500 words)Assignment

Proposed amendment to county comprehensive plans

..., economic, and environmental benefits. (Puget Sound Regional Council, 2008, v) As such in its general principles it corresponds precisely with the goals of the Pierce County Code Title 19A – Comprehensive Plan, 2010. This document commences with the identification of thirteen goals. One of these is (E.) 'Economic Development', and another is (J.) “Protect the environment and enhance the state's high quality of life, including air and water quality, and the availability of water.” A range of the other objectives relate to social goals and quality of life issues. Clearly, therefore, the Vision 2040 document is congruent with Pierce County's broadest policy thrusts. Such is also the case...
6 Pages(1500 words)Assignment

Hearsay & Crawford v. Washington

...? Hearsay & Crawford v. Washington Hearsay & Crawford v. Washington As the sole trier of factsin a criminal trial, the jury is responsible the credibility of the witness and resolving testimony conflicts. As a result, jurors are given the opportunity to listen to impeachment evidence that may undermine the credibility of the witness. Thus, the big task is to determine if the evidence provided by the witness in a trial is truly credible or not. This brings in the concept of impeachment, which is an attack to determine the credibility of evidence given by the witness in a trial. There are several methods used for impeachment in a court of law and these include bias, character, inconsistent statement,...
3 Pages(750 words)Assignment

Determine the water resources in your hometown area (Canton, Ohio - Stark County)

..., incorporating all the perspectives, to address the issue of conservation of water. According to the US 2009 census, the estimated population of Canton-Massillon, Ohio Metropolitan statistical area is 408, 005 (US Census Bureau, 2009). Most of the urban population depends upon ground water for consumption and daily usage purposes. The area receives its water supply through 3 different ecological mechanisms, all of which are interconnected through a complex hydrologic and infiltration cycle. The major sources of water supply are: (1) Precipitation (2) Surface water resources (3) Ground water resources. We will briefly explain each one of them with particularly greater emphasis upon...
8 Pages(2000 words)Assignment

Marketing Plan: Harley Davidson Motorcycle

.... The model digs up and breaks the market into six factors, political, economical, social, technological, legal and environmental factors (Cheverton, 2005, p. 72). Analyzing all such factors provides the businesses the complete overview of the market they are moving in. For Harley Davidson here is the PESTLE analysis for the new UK market segment: Political UK is the most opened region for new businesses. Under the leadership of a liberal, democratic and public oriented Government, UK provides a great room to new businesses to expand into the region (EMM, 2012, p. 3). The political situation is quite stable as the region is owned by single authoritarian party the Conservative party. Hence, there is...
24 Pages(6000 words)Assignment

She v. Her

... al Affiliation Same Gender Sexual Harassment Introduction Sexual harassment is unwanted sexual approaches either verbally or physically. This behavior is considered sexual harassment when it obstructs another employee’s work performance by creating a threatening, unfriendly, or unpleasant work environment. (Black, 1997).The conduct doesnt have to be aimed at someone, for it to be unpleasant to them. Some forms of sexual harassment are evident, for example one person making coarse remarks to another, or touching an unsuitable part of another persons body. The essential thing to know is that what is perceived as harassment can differ from person to person. For example, when a gay employee who hits on another employee of the same... al...
1 Pages(250 words)Assignment

Earthquakes in the County of Utah

...Assignment education The life science research to be explored in this assignment is the frequent striking of earthquakes in the County of Utah. Utah is vulnerable to earthquakes due to its geological nature (Maupin,and Barber 2). Earthquakes occur in areas along faults or fractures where the crust of the earth is weak just like Utah. The county has endured this problem for a long period because it is difficult to predict when the area will be struck. Some people have vacated the county for safer places but individuals with no alternatives especially those with low income have remained under the risk because they cannot afford the expenses of vacating their families to safer places. The...
1 Pages(250 words)Assignment

State and local GOVT

... and Local Government al Affiliation and Local Government In the Discussion Forum and Local Governments file), comment on the following: "The greatest professional challenges for public merit personnel are at the local level."  Then, on separate days, comment on two other threads. The public personnel administration theory in the U.S. has undergone various changes in orientation over time. For instance, early in the history of U.S., the membership of a person to a particular class played a major role in terms of obtaining and retaining federal employment. However, this has changed overtime and today it has reached a time when issues of employment and retention of federal jobs are solely placed on merit. Public merit personnel... and Local...
2 Pages(500 words)Assignment

Who is the audience for Metropolitan Opera

...What’s target audience for Metropolitan Opera? The main target audience for the Metropolitan Opera has been composed of the older adults aged 65 and above making up 60% of the audience (Shugoll Report, 2009). In terms of gender, there is a balance as more people are likely to come as couples. However, currently the opera is targeting a much younger audience below the age of 35 and this has been successful following their diversification in products offered. As for the new Met Opera’s product known as “The Met: Live in HD” which transmits shows over HD signal, the audience comprises of mostly young a young audience below the age of 35. The research by Zamoyta (2011) confirms this as she describes the...
1 Pages(250 words)Assignment

Marbury V. Madison

...Marbury V. Madison Task The article discusses the rightfulness of the formation of the judicial review procedure that defines a borderline betweenthe executive and judiciary branches. The article seeks to explain this formation by discussing the petition by Marbury and justifying the decisions made. Task 2 The audiences targeted by the article are law specialists and any other citizens who are interested in understanding the USA law. Task 3 The writer argues that Marbury has a right to the commission since his appointment is signed by the president. The writers also say that the Supreme Court has a right to review the congress since they interpret the law and decide what the law is....
1 Pages(250 words)Assignment
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Research Paper on topic Assignment #3 Petty v. Metropolitan Govt of Nashville & Davidson County for FREE!

Contact Us