The culture difference in influencing human resource management on multinational firm: comparison between China and Japan - Dissertation Example

Comments (1) Cite this document
Impact of Culture in transferring HRM policies of Japanese MNCs in Chinese subsidiaries ABSTRACT Globalization has broadened the mindsets of executives as they seek to extend the geographical reach of their firms. Liberalization of economies has provided greater opportunities to expand but also posed greater challenges…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER97.9% of users find it useful
The culture difference in influencing human resource management on multinational firm: comparison between China and Japan
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "The culture difference in influencing human resource management on multinational firm: comparison between China and Japan"

Download file to see previous pages Besides, the social and political changes also influence the cultural norms in a country which in turn impacts the labour market and policies. China has been the focus of expansion for many MNCs because of its vast geographical area and because of cheap labour. Japan has been operating in China since the mid-1990s but have not been able to transfer its HRM policies in China. With the motivation to evaluate the degree to which Japanese MNCs had to adapt the HR practices in local cultural environment in Chinese subsidiaries, this study was undertaken. Three objectives were set in Chapter and based on a qualitative study the objectives have been achieved. The study finds that factors that impact HR practices across cultures depends upon the push factors (from the home country) and the pull factors (of the host country). An MNC may attempt to control its subsidiaries and impose its own corporate culture, work values and HRM policies but the host country business environment may not be conducive to accept it. MNCs tend to demonstrate COO effect when they desire to transfer their HRM practices overseas but they are not always successful. The Japanese MNCs are known to exercise control and coordination mechanism through the use of expatriates in all its subsidiaries but despite this, they have been compelled to conform to local norms. The employment and training patterns in Japan too have not been emulated in China. The Japanese still believe in lifetime employment but the Chinese employment patterns have changed. The subsidiaries go by merit and do not give credence to the employment tenure or seniority. Another area where Japan has not been able to transfer its HRM policy is in the field of training where organizational behavior and work values are given importance, contrary to the situation prevalent in China. The Japanese MNCs have had to mostly accept the local norms and work values of the Chinese business environment. They have had to conform to local isomorphism. They have not succeeded in transfer of HRM practices through mission charters or through management education. They have been relying on the expat managers for control and coordination but they have not been able to impose their home country HRM policies on their subsidiaries in China. The study highlights the limitations and based on the limitations, areas for further research have been recommended. Table of Contents Chapter I Introduction 1.1 Background – Issues in International HRM 1 1.2 Rationale for the Study 2 1.3 Research Aims and Objectives 4 1.4 Scope of the Study 5 1.5 Structure of the study 5 Chapter II Literature Review 2.1 Chapter Overview 7 2.2 Definitions 7 2.3 Cultural Theories 8 2.4. Comparison of culture – China/Japan 14 2.5 HRM practice and the COO Effect 17 2.6 Role of Culture in shaping HRM practices of MNCs 18 Chapter III Methodology 3.1 Research Philosophy 22 3.2 Topic of the Research and Phenomenon 22 3.3 Choice of Method 23 3.4 Research Strategy 24 3.5 Data Collection 24 3.6 Justification for Secondary Data 24 3.7 Sources of Data 25 3.8 Data Analysis 26 3.9 Reliability and Validity 26 3.10 Ethical concerns 27 Chapter IV Findings and Discussions 4.1 Findings 28 4.2 Discussion 35 Chapter V Conclusion & Recommendations 5.1 Conclusion 40 5.2 Recommendation for MNCs seeking to expand 43 5.3 Limitations of the Study 43 5.4 Recommendation for ...Download file to see next pagesRead More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
(“The culture difference in influencing human resource management on Dissertation”, n.d.)
The culture difference in influencing human resource management on Dissertation. Retrieved from
(The Culture Difference in Influencing Human Resource Management on Dissertation)
The Culture Difference in Influencing Human Resource Management on Dissertation.
“The Culture Difference in Influencing Human Resource Management on Dissertation”, n.d.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (1)
Click to create a comment or rate a document
hwehner added comment 18 days ago
Student rated this paper as
Great paper! Used it to finish an assignment for a management course. It was easy as ABC, for the first time in my life.

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF The culture difference in influencing human resource management on multinational firm: comparison between China and Japan

Differences between Japan and China

...? Differences between Japan and China Differences between Japan and China Capitalism is prevailing in Japan which allows consumers more freedom in their savings and expenditure whereas in China communism or socialism is prevailing which reduces the freedom of consumers in their savings and expenditure. Japan is a democratic country which gives huge respect to human rights, freedom of thoughts, liberties etc. On the other hand China is a communist country which gives less respect to human right issues....
1 Pages(250 words)Essay

Comparison and contrast between business systems in Japan and China

..., this study seeks to compare and contrast business systems applied in Japan and China, with a focus on understanding the factors behind their similarities and/or differences. Comparison between business systems in Japan and China There is a great similarity between the Chinese and the Japanese business systems. The business systems for these countries are centered on cultural values, where delivering value to the people is the key for business systems in both countries (Liao, 2009 p15). Both countries have the collectivist business culture, where there is a great deal of...
9 Pages(2250 words)Essay

Multinational Human Resource Management

...diverse personal issues10. This results due to a different context of institutional regulations and cultural aspects where companies operate. Companies employ conceptual framework that emphasizes on HR management practices and the main issue related to adaptation of diverse policies at the national context. For instance, China is one of the countries that face varied issues in an attempt of using western managerial approach especially in recruiting are training employees with suitable or professional qualifications. This contributes to varied challenges; thus making multinational corporations operating in China difficult to meet their...
7 Pages(1750 words)Essay

Human Resource Management of eBay in China

...? Human Resource Management of eBay in China EXECUTIVE SUMMARY The unexpected performance of eBay in the online C2C market of China raised many questions regarding the decisions taken by the corporation in the geographical region. With a promising entrance into the market boosted by eBay’s acquisition of local online shopping giant EachNet in 2003, the corporation initially boasted of a staggering 72.4% market share of the Chinese e-shopping arena that was reduced to a mere 7.7% by 2007 as Alibaba’s competing venture captured 84.9% of the market. eBay’s failure in China is attributable to its rigid and product-centered approach...
10 Pages(2500 words)Essay

Human Resource Management in China. Performance Appraisal

...of revenue generation for a company in both, negative and positive, sense however another important effect of employees’ performance is on the stature of organization by which the public image or market image of the organization can become better or worst. Another important impact of the performance of workforce is that the organizational behavior and organizational culture is directly associated with the human resource of specific organization (Varma et al., 2008). This direct association of employee performance with organizational culture results into the manipulation in the built in culture which, sometimes, does not concord with the code of...
7 Pages(1750 words)Dissertation

A Comparison of Business Systems Between Japan and China

...should be driven to join a winning team and sustain these victories. Japanese workers and managers are coerced to work long hours and, unlike China, are promoted to make rapid advancements up the proverbial corporate ladder. Therefore, it should be recognised that the main difference between Japan and China, though both masculine driven, is that Japan prides itself in maintaining a very liberal and Westernised human resources system that feeds the culturally-driven competitive nature of employees. Furthermore, in Japanese business systems, employees and...
7 Pages(1750 words)Essay

North American Culture and Multinational Firm Advertising

...the local culture. The study conducted by Chang of multinational firms and localization in China showed that multinational firms from differing industries have differing growths (Figure 2.0). This figure supports those consumption rates of the types products vary from one industry to another (30-31). Figure 2.0 Industry Growths of MNEs in China from 1998 to 2009 To address this challenge, standardization or localization has to be taken into consideration (Sotomayor 139). Nevertheless, when the target market is from a similar cultural background, say for instance, A...
7 Pages(1750 words)Research Paper

Human Resource Management in China

...links and connections in Chinese culture also plays an important role in HRM. These personal connections affected every aspect of the human resource management in organizations operating in China. They can affect who is being hired to who will be given the new project. They can also have a positive effect on the organization if harnessed. Good personal relationships between managers and subordinates can create more effective communication in the firm and better results can be achieved. These connections can also help to manage the complex relation with the entities outside the...
13 Pages(3250 words)Essay

War between China and Japan

...and the common man. (Vincent Canby). The films Bethune and Inn of Six Happiness are not exactly an account involving China and Japan, although Bethune was occupied by Germany during the First World War (Bethune), and Inn of Six Happiness poignantly recounts the life of a poor, nondescript English woman who goes to live in China as a missionary at her own expense and fulfils her ambition by saving the lives of local children from the Japanese invaders. (The Inn of the Sixth Happiness). 5. Conclusion The scholarly account of the events of war between China and Japan and its interpretation and portrayal in the form of fiction through books...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay

The Firm and Strategic Human Resource Management

...and human capital” (188). In contrast, the best practice model supports a universal approach “arguing that all firms will be better off if they identify and adopt ‘best practice’ in the way they manage people” (186). The findings on best practice approach state that those elements found to be most desirable to employees (employment security, selective hiring, self-managed teams, high pay based on performance, extensive training, among others) are not consistently cost effective in general. There is always the need to assess and incorporate factors such as economic, social, and political which affect and influence HR practices in employment among...
6 Pages(1500 words)Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Dissertation on topic The culture difference in influencing human resource management on multinational firm: comparison between China and Japan for FREE!

Contact Us