StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Witnessing a Period of Workplace Harmony - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
The author of the paper "Witnessing a Period of Workplace Harmony" operates mainly based on question that can be stated as follows: To what extent does the number of strikes revealed in the UK suggest we are currently witnessing a period of workplace harmony?…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER97% of users find it useful
Witnessing a Period of Workplace Harmony
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Witnessing a Period of Workplace Harmony"

Coming to the phenomenon of worker strikes, although they disturb production schedules and affect the profitability of the industry, most instances of it does serve a legitimate purpose, namely that of team member representation.  In the scholarly article by John Godard, titled ‘What Has Happened to Strikes?’, we learn how worker strikes have gradually decreased in Britain.  But, while strikes per se have declined, this does not directly imply that worker satisfaction with management has correspondingly improved.  There are other factors at play that account for the decreased frequency of strikes, apart from improvements in levels of employee satisfaction.  The rest of this essay will elaborate on this point.

Strikes are an integral part of the discipline of Industrial Relations (of which Employee Relations is a part).  But the subsiding of frequency of strikes in the UK since the early 1990s meant that they have lost their prominence in Industrial Relations discourse.  For example, from their heyday between 1970 and 1990, when British industry witnessed more than a thousand days lost per thousand workers on three occasions, the figures have hovered close to zero since the last decade (2005 being the only exception). (Godard, 2011, p.285)  As a way of explaining this fall, scholar John Godard attempts to make a distinction between the terms ‘strike’ and ‘conflict’, stating that the latter is a general state of affairs while the former is a specific manifestation.  In his research article, Godard hypothesizes four plausible alternative avenues where “the conflict posited in Strikes has gone”.  These four hypotheses are:

“(i) it has been diverted into alternative forms of conflict; (ii) capitalism has effectively triumphed, reflecting a lessening of the stock of discontent or, at least, the will to act on it; (iii) conflict has only become more deeply embedded, manifest in general attitudes and behaviors, either within or outside the workplace, and not traditionally considered to reflect the sources of conflict; and (iv) conflict, particularly the collective manifestation of it, is not dead, but rather has simply become dormant.”  (Godard, 2011, p.288)

Drawing on Richard Hyman’s seminal 1972 publication Strikes, Godard seconds the view that ‘attempts to suppress specific manifestations...merely divert the conflict into other forms’.  This is especially a valid argument when one considers the rapid individualization of employment law in the UK and across the industrial world.  The rise in individual rights has, to an extent, made redundant the need for union representation.  Although data on alternative mediums of conflict is difficult to collate, the increase in Advisory, Conciliation and Arbitration Service (ACAS) filings in Britain (especially as these filings have escalated since the early 1990s), partially vindicates the Godard hypothesis.  Changes in the work environment (compelled by Britain’s shift from a manufacturing economy to a service economy) have also played a role. 

Whether or not the decline in strikes is proof of the triumph of capitalism is not clear.  Capitalist theories have always maintained that after peaking out, conflicts will plateau out due to the streamlining of the capitalist culture.  Moreover, as the capitalist economy has now turned into a predominantly services economy, the percentage of white-collar workers has increased tremendously.  There is some merit to the view that jobs in the ‘new economy’ offer greater scope for fulfilling one’s creative potential than the somewhat restricted and monotonous jobs of the ‘old economy.  This change was believed to have reduced conflict, and by extension, the necessity for strikes, since the early ‘90s.  Further, it is also true that discontent from white-collar workers is likely to show up as individual lawsuits as opposed to collective strikes. 

Human Resource Management as a field of practice has grown in sophistication over the years.  And companies with good management put in place robust mechanisms for employee grievance redress, which nip potential conflicts in the bud.  This could also be a contributing factor to the lessening number of registered strikes in the UK. 

Hence, in conclusion, while statistics clearly show a decline in the number of worker strikes in the last two decades, they do not necessarily indicate a corresponding decrease in ‘conflict’.  As John Godard, and prior to him Richard Hyman, perceptively state, Industrial Relations constantly witness conflict between the working and managing classes.  But due to the change in the nature of the economy, as well as comprehensive legislation to protect employee rights, the conflict manifests in alternative forms such as individual lawsuits.  The overall improvement in standards of living and work conditions has also alleviated conflicts to an extent.  And finally, the greater sophistication of HR practices has played a role in mitigating conflict.  In conclusion, while the drastic drop in strikes in the UK suggests improved employee relations, they do not imply a proportionate absence of conflict. 

Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“To What Extent Does the Number of Strikes Revealed in the UK Suggest Essay”, n.d.)
To What Extent Does the Number of Strikes Revealed in the UK Suggest Essay. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/management/1441079-to-what-extent-does-the-number-of-strikes-revealed
(To What Extent Does the Number of Strikes Revealed in the UK Suggest Essay)
To What Extent Does the Number of Strikes Revealed in the UK Suggest Essay. https://studentshare.org/management/1441079-to-what-extent-does-the-number-of-strikes-revealed.
“To What Extent Does the Number of Strikes Revealed in the UK Suggest Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/management/1441079-to-what-extent-does-the-number-of-strikes-revealed.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Witnessing a Period of Workplace Harmony

Increase Productivity and Safety at Night Shift

In this process of work one worker usually replaces another on the same work within a time period of 24 hours.... The paper 'Increase Productivity and Safety at Night Shift' has been made in order to consider the negative effects of night shift working and suggesting possible solutions for the problems....
44 Pages (11000 words) Research Paper

Clinical Supervision in Mental Care

This paper critically evaluates the role of clinical supervision as a governance strategy designed to support safe and effective mental health care.... Clinical supervision based on traditional, tested processes threatens new governance strategies and innovations.... ... ... ... The research investigates the methods that can be implemented to improve the quality of care for mental health patients and provide constant learning for their nurses....
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay

Identifying Training Needs For Higher Education Staff: A Case Study in an Academic Institution

Identifying Training Needs for Higher Education Staff: A Case Study in an Academic Institution CHAPTER I - INTRODUCTION 1.... Background of the Study Organizations around the world are experiencing extreme difficulties to remain competitive in this global business environment.... ... ... ... Irrespective of the industry or the nature of the organization, the situation is the same everywhere (Berge, Davis and Smith, 2002; Grossman and Salas, 2011)....
20 Pages (5000 words) Essay

Construction Industry

(2010) stated that dispute might arise due to the nature of the task being performed by the workers in the workplace and there are instances when suppliers or workers fail to comply with the compliances and mandatory quality norms.... (2010) stated that dispute might arise due to the nature of task being performed by the workers in the workplace and there are instances, when suppliers or workers fail to comply with the compliances and mandatory quality norms....
12 Pages (3000 words) Essay

Increae productivity and safety at night shift

The employees of the manufacturing sectors are under huge working pressure because of the type of the work they need to perform along with the shift patterns of their works.... Working in shifts though increases the productive capacity of the workers along with the increase in the.... ... ... The workers working in the night shifts in the manufacturing units are the ones facing the maximum problem in regards to their These problems affect the productivity of the workers working in the night shifts of the manufacturing firm....
40 Pages (10000 words) Research Paper

Moving from the Descriptive Effects of War to the Prescriptive Effects of War

The paper "Moving from the Descriptive Effects of War to the Prescriptive Effects of War" states that the soldiers' trauma, those of their families and the public at large may be different in nature.... However, there is no denying the fact that these traumas stem from a common source.... ... ... ...
14 Pages (3500 words) Essay

Trauma and Stressor Related Disorders

This research paper thoroughly explores the problem of Trauma and Stressor-Related Disorders, which are among the most common human disorders as the concepts of suffering, stress, and traumatic emotional and physical experience are inseparable from human life.... ... ... ... This paper talks about Trauma and Stressor-Related Disorders and states that, oddly enough, this direction of mental disorders still lacks accurate definitions and concrete symptoms....
9 Pages (2250 words) Research Paper

Workplace Discrimination

This coursework "workplace Discrimination" focuses on workplace discrimination and how an individual can protect his rights.... From this work, it is clear about religious discrimination in the workplace, accommodation for religious prayers, or rituals, dress code.... Under Title VII, workplace harassment on the basis of religion is also prohibited.... Due to the above factors, diversity in workplace in the U....
10 Pages (2500 words) Coursework
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us