StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Mary Jemison and Debbie Edwards Captivity in The Searches - Assignment Example

Cite this document
Summary
The paper "Mary Jemison and Debbie Edwards’ Captivity in The Searches" explains the captivity of women was a common practice in traditional Indian society. The kind of reception, stage of development, and treatment that one received as a captive influenced whether one will stay with the Indians…
Download free paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER95.2% of users find it useful
Mary Jemison and Debbie Edwards Captivity in The Searches
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Mary Jemison and Debbie Edwards Captivity in The Searches"

However, despite being abducted and living in the Indian community for several years, Debbie finally chose to reunite with her European family whereas Jemison willingly wanted to be fully absorbed by the Indians. Thesis; the kind of reception, acceptance, and treatment that a captive receives determines whether they will fully be assimilated or might return to their homeland whenever such an inordinate opportunity presents itself.

Jemison remained in India while Debbie went to Britain after being freed since the hospitality of Indians always inspired Jemison. Jemison confesses that Indian women were kind-natured, mild in their personalities, amiable, decent, and had treated her gently (Derounian-Stodola 129-132). In her narration, Jemison asserts that she was always treated as an Indian and felt comfortable being among the Indians than going back to Britain where she might not be accepted. She perceived herself as having been civilized and apparently different from Europeans who are likely to discriminate against her. Contrary, Debbie lives as Scar’s wife, and the turmoil, savagery, and tragedy in India trouble her. She is transformed into a Comanche. Despite this, she hardly finds happiness living in a warring community where she was once discriminated.

Jemison had a family of Indian children to take care of, unlike Debbie, who lived her life solitarily. Jemison had developed strong connections with Indian children and felt that it was her responsibility to stay in India and take care of the growing generation (Derounian-Stodola 164). She had acquainted herself with the Indian culture and felt part of it. While Debbie was also willing to stay, her cousin, Ethan, often averred that “Living with a Comanche ain’t living,” hence Debbie was forced to leave since her relatives hardly appreciated the Indian culture (John et al., N.p).
Moreover, in the narrative, India is portrayed as a cool place that invigorated Jemison to stay while in the film it is depicted as a belligerent state with little elegance. Jemison describes how the seasons unfolded and life was perfectly well in India (Derounian-Stodola 172). According to her, she was settled and provided with a home that portrays dashes of the improvisational subject succeeding the recital of catechism and solitary prayers. Debbie found herself in a chaotic environment and being young and childless, the option of leaving seemed best for her since she needed to join her family and enjoy the peace that was prevailing in the European homesteads. This is evident towards the end of the movie as she tells martin, “I remember, from always. At first I prayed to you: ‘Come and get me, take me home.’ You didn't come” (John et al., N.p). Evidently, Debbie was yearning to be with her people.

Considering the kind of vengeance and retaliation in India, Debbie chose to reunite with her family once freed. Scar, Debbie’s husband, was cruel and wanted to revenge for his two killed sons. “Two sons killed by white men. For each song, I take many... scalps”, portraying Scar as a tragic figure and psychologically damaged (John et al., N.p). Debbie was, apparently, considered a scalp. It was, therefore, prudent for her to leave. Jemison was considered as part of the Indian community that is portrayed as magnanimous. On several occasions, the Indians refer to Jemison as a sister, a factor that motivated her to live in India as a freed European woman. She was also old and had no resources to start life somewhere else knowing unambiguously that her relatives were slain when she was young.

In conclusion, the above explication candidly indicates that the kind of reception, acceptance, and treatment that a captive receives determines whether they will be willing to stay once freed. Jemison received a warm reception in the Indian community, a factor that made her develop the sense of belonging. After being freed, she felt that was deeply in adoration with the Indian community and opted to stay instead of leaving to Europe where she would wonder for long before regaining acceptance from her community. Debbie’s life in India was full of distrust. The warring Indian community coupled with her family’s patronization of Indians made her to leave India once she was freed. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(Compare one of the two Indian Captivity narratives, of either Mary Assignment, n.d.)
Compare one of the two Indian Captivity narratives, of either Mary Assignment. https://studentshare.org/literature/1867139-compare-one-of-the-two-indian-captivity-narratives-of-either-mary-rowlandson-or-mary-jemison-with-the-film-the-searches-by-john-wayne-why-did-mary-jemison-remain-with-the-indians-while-debbie-returned-to-european-settlement
(Compare One of the Two Indian Captivity Narratives, of Either Mary Assignment)
Compare One of the Two Indian Captivity Narratives, of Either Mary Assignment. https://studentshare.org/literature/1867139-compare-one-of-the-two-indian-captivity-narratives-of-either-mary-rowlandson-or-mary-jemison-with-the-film-the-searches-by-john-wayne-why-did-mary-jemison-remain-with-the-indians-while-debbie-returned-to-european-settlement.
“Compare One of the Two Indian Captivity Narratives, of Either Mary Assignment”. https://studentshare.org/literature/1867139-compare-one-of-the-two-indian-captivity-narratives-of-either-mary-rowlandson-or-mary-jemison-with-the-film-the-searches-by-john-wayne-why-did-mary-jemison-remain-with-the-indians-while-debbie-returned-to-european-settlement.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Mary Jemison and Debbie Edwards Captivity in The Searches

Various aspects of S&O management in the Atokowa Company

The main purpose of this following paper is to examine and present various aspects of S&O management in the Atokowa Company and give recommendations for improvement of the management operations in systems and operations segments.... ... ... ... The opening of the report consists of the background information of Atokowa advantage and systems and operations role and integration in Atokowa....
12 Pages (3000 words) Essay

Assimilation versus Acculturation

The combination of jemison and Rowlandson's experiences offers readers varied angles on how both captives view their Indian-American captors.... The combination of jemison and Rowlandson's experiences offers readers varied angles on how both captives view their Indian-American captors.... Although contrasting, jemison and Rowlandson offer unique tales of lives that were drastically altered by the Indian-American raids during their era.... Name Subject Professor Date Assimilation versus Acculturation mary jemison's narrative explores her acculturation to the Seneca tribe in the event of her captivity....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

The Biography of Mary Jemison

Soon after giving birth to their second child whom she named after her father ‘Thomas' who she missed very much, jemison and her husband Sheninjee started a trip to Sheninjee's motherland in New York along the Genesee River.... Instructor Date Introduction The biography of mary jemison depicts three cultures, namely, the colonial frontier, the mid-late 18th century culture of the Seneca, as well as that of industrial American republic, and takes the perspective of a woman ‘residing among adversaries....
3 Pages (750 words) Essay

Coastal Erosion on Essex Coast

Its gigantic size, its availability to support the variety of species, and its immense power has amazed many.... The ocean has shown its tranquillity and appeal to many, through vacationers coming to resorts near the ocean and various cruises.... However, it can ... ... ... ... ... lso be a tempest and powerful force that can threaten mankind....
12 Pages (3000 words) Essay

Role of Private Sector Organisations in Education

Private schools have been the best example of how different functions in different societies are fulfilled like in some countries private schools have principally been expressions of religious and other cultural identities.... It has been argued that in urban areas in England the market system of education and the associated processes of decomprehension mean that resources are flowing from those children with greatest need to those with least need children are rewarded largely in proportion to the skill and interest of their parents....
12 Pages (3000 words) Essay

Can Corporate Culture and Managment/Leadership Styles Inhibit/Promote Success in Mergers and Acquisitions

This essay talks that merger and acquisitions are routine news from which the business world sees more opportunities and symbiosis in their desire to add something to their existing assets and capabilities.... The reasons for such deals are diverse and the rational for their expectations.... ... ...
28 Pages (7000 words) Essay

The Life of Mary Jemison

mary jemison, the American frontierswoman, was born in a ship (this ship was going from Northern Ireland to America) to Thomas and Jane Jemison in 1743.... In 1823 mary jemison related her life story to James Seaver, a doctor who lived near her home in western New York.... Seaver's story of “the white woman of the Genessee,” as she became known, sold over 100,000 copies in 1824” (Captured By Indians: mary jemison Becomes an Indian).... This paper briefly explains opinions of mary jemison about native American culture and relationship between Native Americans and Anglo-Americans in the eighteenth century based on the autobiography of mary jemison written by James Seaver....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

Conflict Management in Businesses

.... ... ...
14 Pages (3500 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us