StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Religion Myth and Magic in Fifth Business - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
The writer of this essay analyzes religion, myth, and magic in Fifth Business written by Robertson Davies. In line with its main character's self-identification as the fifth business, its hero and villain are defined by their rejection and embrace of myth…
Download free paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER93.8% of users find it useful
Religion Myth and Magic in Fifth Business
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Religion Myth and Magic in Fifth Business"

Religion, Myth and Magic in Fifth Business Given the brief of writing about religion and magic in Robertson Davies Fifth Business, it is hardly possible not to talk about myth also, since it is in myth that Davies is principally interested. In line with its main characters self-identification as fifth business, its hero and villain (Boy Stauton and Magnus Eisengrim, though it would be difficult to say which is which) are defined by their rejection and embrace of myth. Boy sinks entirely into the mythless religion of his boyhood, while Eisengrim recreates the world of myth through magic. The religious world that Dunstan grew up in was quite prescribed: We had five churches: the Anglican, poor but believed to have some mysterious social supremacy; the Presbyterian, solvent and thought—chiefly by itself—to be intellectual; the Methodist, insolvent and fervent; the Baptist, insolvent and saved; the Roman Catholic, mysterious to most of us, but clearly solvent. (12) No form of religion but Christianity existed for him, and everything outside of a narrow range of Protestantism was mysterious: even the Anglicans are at the limit. These churches play no role in what might be called a spiritual life of Deptford. Rather, they are concerned with the merely social relations of their members. This is why Dunstan estimates the wealth of each church: one of their chief importance is as a social marker for their members. Religion in Deptford is not something one believes, but something one does, like a job. Religion in Deptford is part of a daily routine that helps to regulate life, anything that varies form that routine is too much, like adultery compared to monogamy: "We had family prayers at home, a respectable salute to Providence before breakfast, enough for anybody. But he [sc. Baptist minister Amasa Dempster] was likely to drop on his knees at any time and pray with a fervour that seemed indecent" (41). The fact that Dempster prays outside the appointed schedule and for very personal ends is the enormity. Demspter makes this very clear to Dunstan when he catches him out in teaching Paul magic tricks and reading him the lives of the saints. To Demspter, the only use magic could have is theft, either through cheating at cards or pick-pocketing. Still worse, he considered the cult of the saints to be, not Christian, but "Papistry!" (43). He rejects the miracles and acts of heroic asceticism performed by the saints to be precisely the same kinds of cheats as card tricks, but in this case perpetrated by the devil for the stakes of human souls. This is very much in line with one modern understanding of magic as a term of competition between rival groups: what we have is religion we do miracles: what our enemies have is magic and they do magic tricks (Aune; Gager). Even before her miracles, Mary Dempster was Dunstans introduction to another kind of religious life. Mary was ostracized from the community and its religious ties, and tyrannized by her husbands religious fanaticism. But to her all of these external facts of her life were completely unreal. Instead, "She lived by a light that arose from within" (56). While still a child living in Deptford, Dunstan began to realize that the Biblical text and Christian liturgy were a category of myth. Of course he did not have the technical vocabulary to describe it as such, but simply began to put it in the same category as the Arabian Nights (44), a comparison he will revert to later in the novel (e.g. 77). He also realized that the essential similarity consisted of metaphor. The one atheist in the village interpreted everything in the Bible literally, making much of it risible. But Dusntan says , "I knew a metaphor when I heard one, and I liked metaphor better than reason" (58). As he might have phrased it his later years, he realized the metaphorical language of myth was the language spoken by the unconscious mind, so it ws the only form of expression that can have real meaning and resonance (77). Eisengrims magic show, the Soireé of Illusions is the opposite of Deptfords idea of religion. In that world magic was a cheat. And indeed the kinds of trickery used in stage magic has sometimes been used to stimulate religious belief (Poulsen). The ancient cult of the snake god Glykon was entirely based on its founders Alexander of Abonouteichos abilities as a ventriloquist and his talent at getting to know the contents of sealed letters (Fox 241-250), nothing different than the techniques Eisengrim used (e.g. 231, 244). More recently, the Spiritualist religion popular in the nineteenth century and with some transformations even today, presented a very traditional magic show (mentalism and escape artistry) only with the difference that the audience was expected to accept the illusions as real miracles (Houdini; Jackson). These deceptions succeed because they illustrate the mythical language of the unconscious (231). It is because Eisengrims show makes the same appeal that he becomes so spectacularly popular in distinction to magicians who debunk their own act with nervous laughter (230). Dunstan found the secret of Eisengrims and his own profession of a hagiogrpaher at the Shrine of Our Lady of Guadalupe. There the "Petitioners had no conception of art; to them a picture was a symbol of something else, and very readily the symbol became the reality. They were untouched by modern education" (227-28). Both men are essentially Romanticists, they cannot cease to be modern but they desperately want to communicate in the unconscious language of myth which modernity rejects because it cannot accept metaphor and rejects the literal meaning of myth (Abrams 182; Stillinger xvi-xvii). Rather than fakery, even when it is so palpably all trickery, Davies seems inclined to take magic as the operative language of myth. Dunstans own inner life, its growth and change, expresses itself in metaphorical mythical terms. That is why he becomes a hagiographer, because he finds the same myth expressed in that literature. He reads the lives of the saints in order to understand himself. Boy Stauton, on the other hand, finds this interest "queer" because he has no understanding of himself, he has retreated entirely into the formalist religion of Deptford which was the opposite of myth, and even further so that his second wedding "was neither a religious ceremony nor a merrymaking. It is best described as A Function" (274). And when he is suddenly brought to self-understanding through the mythical deception of Eisengrim, his life is destroyed (though the full details of that are not revealed until Worlds of Wonder). References Abrams, M. H. Natural Supernaturalism: Tradition and Revolution in Romantic Literature. New York: W. W. Norton, 1971. Aune, David E., "Magic in Early Christianity," Aufstieg und Niedergang der römischen Welt. Wolfgang Haase, ed. II.23.2 (1980): 1507-57 Davies, Robertson. Fifth Business. New York: Viking, 1970. Fox, Robin Lane. Pagans and Christians. New York: Alfred A. Knopf, 1987. Gager, John J., "Moses the Magician," Helios 21 (1994): 179-188. Houdini, Harry. A Magician among the Spirits. New York: Harper, 1924. Jackson, Herbert G. The Spirit Rappers. Garden City, N.Y.: Doubleday, 1972. Poulsen, Frederick, "Talking, Weeping and Bleeding Sculptures: A Chapter in the History of Religious Fraud," Acta Archaeologica 16 (1945): 178-195. Stillinger Jack ed. John Keats: The Complete Poems. Cambridge: Belknap, 1978. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Religion Myth and Magic in Fifth Business Essay”, n.d.)
Religion Myth and Magic in Fifth Business Essay. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/literature/1722140-fifth-business-essay-topic-to-be-chosen-by-writer-from-the-sheet-attached
(Religion Myth and Magic in Fifth Business Essay)
Religion Myth and Magic in Fifth Business Essay. https://studentshare.org/literature/1722140-fifth-business-essay-topic-to-be-chosen-by-writer-from-the-sheet-attached.
“Religion Myth and Magic in Fifth Business Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/literature/1722140-fifth-business-essay-topic-to-be-chosen-by-writer-from-the-sheet-attached.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Religion Myth and Magic in Fifth Business

The Historical and Psychological Characteristics of German Modernism

The Faust myth appears in German-language publications soon after Gutenberg invented the printing press in 1450, and some scholars have focused on a possible relation in identity between one of Gutenberg's business partners who may have been known as “Doctor Faust”.... Print and literacy are an integral aspect of the spread of Lutheranism and Protestantism, creating a reform movement that grew popularly in Northern Europe, while alchemical literature and fairy tales also circulate in this era in which the Faust myth is first found historically....
39 Pages (9750 words) Dissertation

Capitalism vs. Communism

Capitalism vs.... Communism Author's Name Institutional Affiliation Abstract This document covers the history of capitalism and communism from the ancient times.... It distinguishes the underlying concepts between capitalism and communism, where capitalism is driven by market forces to enable competition and control demand and supply, while communism emphasizes on communal ownership of resources....
10 Pages (2500 words) Essay

Personal Mythology in Fifth Business

This particular incident has turned him into being the "fifth business" for everyone else until he grows up.... Religion, myth, and magic are intertwined in Dunstan Ramsay's life, crucial for the completion of Ramsay as a person through the wonder they inspire.... om/fossilfreak/books/fifth.... om/fossilfreak/books/fifth.... om/fossilfreak/books/fifth.... magic is the escape of yore that Dunstan seeks and successfully rediscovers....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Gandhi's ethic of nonviolent civil disobedience

As for Osama, his belief was (is) that Islam is the only true religion, and Mohammed, the only Prophet, and all those who did not agree were infidels.... The Holocaust and more recently, the attacks on the World Trade Center may be considered as examples of an unfortunate inversion of sacred beliefs and moralities, that led to the attempted annihilation of two distinct groups of people and their cultures....
19 Pages (4750 words) Essay

The Five Most Common Market Myths

The outlook for business conditions is always changing, and so are the future earnings of a company" (Investopedia, 2008, pg.... myth Number Two is that the stock market is some type of fancy, executive club reserved for the wealthy and for brokers and that the average person cannot play, or at least cannot play very well.... he third market myth is that stocks that have risen high and fallen will rise again....
18 Pages (4500 words) Essay

Baptism in Fifth Business

In the paper “Baptism in fifth business” the author analyzes Robertson Davies' novel Fifth Business that concerns personal transformation.... hellip; Davies' use of baptism as a symbol is naturally based on a clear understanding of its history in religion....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

The Protestant Ethic and Spirit of Capitalism

nbsp; He relates religion and economy with each other.... nbsp; He relates religion and economy with each other in order to bring about capitalism in the West.... And this emphasis found its way into economic practices which set off secularization and the undermining of all types of religion.... Modern analysts point out how their studies of history during the early days of capitalism in the West have revealed the important role of religion, especially Protestantism in Capitalism....
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay

Women in World Religions

This assignment "Women in World Religions" presents the traditional concepts of women in religion that are considered equal to men.... nbsp; It shall consider why most classical and contemporary sociological theories of religion masked the experience of women.... Since most of the discussions on religion are based on elements of private and public, the discussions have become generalized, mostly relating to equality and power.... The first argument would consider the point that religion, piety, and purity serves to empower women....
24 Pages (6000 words) Assignment
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us