Several Ways to View Cohens Actions in the Context of Carters Test - Research Paper Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
Summary
This paper examines whether Cohen’s actions in her essay pass the three-step test for integrity prescribed by Carter, and argues that in fact, by discerning that egg donation is wrong, and by acting on that discernment and making it known through her published piece…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER91% of users find it useful
Several Ways to View Cohens Actions in the Context of Carters Test
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "Several Ways to View Cohens Actions in the Context of Carters Test"

Download file to see previous pages Carter differentiates between honesty and integrity. One can say with little argument that Cohen was being honest, by writing about her thoughts in such a public way, about her experiences dealing with a couple who was looking for an egg donor for financial considerations, and to whose ad she responded. She was forthright in saying what she thought eventually of the whole thing. On the other hand, Carter says that integrity is more than just honesty. As embodied in his three steps, first there has to be discernment. Second, a person of integrity has to have the courage to act on what he or she has discerned. A person, for instance, may be against slavery, but unless that person also acts to end slavery or free slaves, then that person has no integrity, even if he or she professes with honesty that he or she is against slavery. There have to be the three elements or three steps present to be able to say that a person has integrity. Say Cohen is honest, and the article seems very honest, but that does not necessarily make Cohen a person of integrity by the standards of Carter (Carter; Cohen). So if Cohen was not a person of integrity for being honest about her thoughts and feelings about being an egg donor to a couple, then more must be done to examine whether in effect Cohen followed the three steps that Carter prescribed in his text on integrity. Looking at Cohen’s piece, one gets the sense that at the end she made a decision not be part of the whole thing. But then again towards the end, the decision was made for her too. ...Download file to see next pagesRead More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Several Ways to View Cohens Actions in the Context of Carters Test Research Paper”, n.d.)
Several Ways to View Cohens Actions in the Context of Carters Test Research Paper. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/literature/1663787-does-jessica-cohen-in-her-grade-a-the-market-for-a-yale-womans-eggs-meet-the-requirements-for-a-person-of-integrity-as-defined-by-stephen-l-carter-in-his-essay-the-rules-about-rules
(Several Ways to View Cohens Actions in the Context of Carters Test Research Paper)
Several Ways to View Cohens Actions in the Context of Carters Test Research Paper. https://studentshare.org/literature/1663787-does-jessica-cohen-in-her-grade-a-the-market-for-a-yale-womans-eggs-meet-the-requirements-for-a-person-of-integrity-as-defined-by-stephen-l-carter-in-his-essay-the-rules-about-rules.
“Several Ways to View Cohens Actions in the Context of Carters Test Research Paper”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/literature/1663787-does-jessica-cohen-in-her-grade-a-the-market-for-a-yale-womans-eggs-meet-the-requirements-for-a-person-of-integrity-as-defined-by-stephen-l-carter-in-his-essay-the-rules-about-rules.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Several Ways to View Cohens Actions in the Context of Carters Test

Tort actions

...?Week 3 Scenario The tort actions I see in this scenario are the tort of battery (an intentional tort), intentional infliction of emotional distress and the tort of negligence. The potential plaintiffs are Malik and Daniel, who are also the potential defendants in this scenario. I mention that both parties are defendants because there was negligence on behalf of Malik and intentional harm on behalf of Daniel. The elements that I found for each of the plaintiffs claims are as follows: If Malik had not accidentially spilled the beer on Ruben (Daniels son), Daniel would not have got fired from his job, being accused of giving alcohol to a minor. Also, if it were not for Malik following Daniel and his son to the parking lot...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

Forensic test

...B 11 C 21 C 31 A 41 D 2 D 12 B 22 E 32 D 42 D 3 C 13 C 23 B 33 B 43 B 4 D 14 A 24 C 34 C 44 D 5 D 15 E 25 A 35 A 45 A 6A 16 A 26 E 36 E 46 A 7 C 17 D 27 A 37 D 47 B 8 A 18 A 28 B 38 B 48 E 9 E 19 A 29 A 39 E 49 B 10 C 20 A 30 A 40 C 50 B Question one Characteristics of an ideal forensic test According to (Gunn, 2011) an ideal forensic test should be accurate because the results will be highly scrutinized in court therefore it cannot afford to be inaccurate. Accuracy also helps to avoid disputes. Another characteristic associated with an ideal forensic test is the sensitivity. Many forensic materials collected are usually small and minute and therefore a more sensitive...
3 Pages(750 words)Assignment

Several topics

...on the one side, and the feminist leaders including Cady Stanton, Susan Anthony and others, struggles of whom paved the way towards obtaining several rights for women on the principles of equality. The Seneca Falls Convention of July 1848 was the first step taken in this direction in order to unite the women against the oppression and injustices being exercised on them by male stratum. The convention demanded complete security from their sexual exploitation, physical tortures and abuses of all kinds being practiced against them by males. The convention encouraged further demonstrations during second half of twentieth century. As a result, women also obtained the right to cast votes in America in 1928....
9 Pages(2250 words)Essay

T-Test and Chi-Test

...T-Test and Chi-Test Unit 3 In the T-Test, the first hypothesis is expected that the mean of tenures between 1 and 2 will be similar. But a found out its different and that difference is very significant. In which in this kind of Test we determine the difference or the varying relationship to each other. The total number of compromising group 1 is equal to N1=120. The mean is equal to 1.47 while the variance is equal to 0.4989. While: The total number of members in group 2 is N2=186. The mean is equal to 1.67 while the variance is equal to 0.649. Therefore in the given hypothesis the only inference that can only be made suggests is that the difference between the two...
2 Pages(500 words)Assignment

Unreliable test

...Answer each of the following Questions, each should be about 2 page response. One Source Per Questions if possible should be used Can an unreliable test be valid Why or why not A reliable test estimates the consistency of the measurement conducted. Reliability means how the results are measured and if they are found the same way each time they are gathered. Validity is the measure of accuracy. It is the determination of whatever method used is consistently giving accurate results. This is more important because if the results are not correct then there is no reason to use them. They will not offer an appropriate conclusion. There are cases where unreliable tests can be...
5 Pages(1250 words)Essay

Statistical Test

...Statistical Test This section was used to perform preliminary statistical test on the data that were collected from who patronize the school cafeteria on their desire to be served with specific soft drinks and how they would be able to determine that the specific drink they demanded was what they were served with. The data were collected based on the hypothesis that the only way to determine the true brand of a product is through taste and not just by looking at the appearance of the product. The assertion was made against the backdrop that there could be imitation of packaging. This section shall therefore deal with the organization, summarization, display, consideration and above all...
2 Pages(500 words)Assignment

DRVVT test

...DRVVT test Lab Report Questions Immunological method for measuring lupus anticoagulants Activated Partial Thromboplastin Time (aPTT) is an immunological method for measuring lupus anticoagulants. In this method, reagents consisting of a platelet phospholipid, an activator, and calcium are added to a sample containing platelet poor plasma and then the time taken to form a clot is recorded. The aPTT is usually the duration it takes from when calcium is added to the formation of a clot. The nature of antibody is an Antiphospholipid antibody. 2. Lack of positive antibodies in sample C The absence of positive antibodies in sample C means that lupus anticoagulants were not present in the blood thus blood clotting could not...
2 Pages(500 words)Lab Report

Several topics

...adjacent to the Chinese border are Russian by race, though share several commonalities with the Chinese and hence ethnically are Chinese. Moreover, the Jews could be Asian and European by race, though their ethnicity would remain Jewish or Israelite forever. 2. Marxist perspective vehemently condemns the exploitation of the haves-not at the hands of the haves. It is partly because of the social, political and economic domination the haves maintain over the downtrodden groups and communities that they start exploiting them in one way or the other. Since the proletariat i.e. laborers work from dawn to dusk in agricultural fields and industrial units, they must obtain their respective share in income and...
6 Pages(1500 words)Essay

SEVERAL TOPICS

...on the human pheromones. This is because men produce testosterone while the women will produce estrogen thus the hypothalamus in the brain will have to react in a different way from the ordinary scents. Since the neurons will be active during sexual activity for the gay men then the possibility of reacting to different scents will be low since for men, it will be the same “testosterone” making it to share the same thing which will not double life (Nicholas 21). On the other hand, when the hypothalamus of the women and the scents related to men is activated, it will make it possible to double life simply because of the odor of the different partner. The article is primarily concerned with acceptance of different types...
2 Pages(500 words)Coursework

Health Care: Several Processes With Several Specialists

... Acute Care facilities seems to be the most important of all the others. The facilities cannot be avoided when the others can take place without much dependence (Roe, 2005). The facilities offer the short term health care when one is from an injury and the facilities are able to prevent further injury to the person (Roe, 2005). When the acute care is done the person is able to recover from the condition without further complications. The facilities also become more important since they involve several processes with several specialists (Roe, 2005). Karen Wavra Acute facilities are able to accomplish all the missions and the operations that are required by the injured since the acute care offered... ...
1 Pages(250 words)Assignment
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Research Paper on topic Several Ways to View Cohens Actions in the Context of Carters Test for FREE!

Contact Us