StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Civilize Them With a Stick by Mary Crow Dog - Essay Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
Summary
Although the rationale behind Mary Crow Dog’s will to resistance is clear, what is entirely unclear is why a city educated comparatively wealthy white girl from New York would engage herself in such a type of resistance and revolution as the author indicated. This brief essay…
Download free paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER92.4% of users find it useful
Civilize Them With a Stick by Mary Crow Dog
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "Civilize Them With a Stick by Mary Crow Dog"

Dr. Hartnett Section/# Essay One Organizing Civil Disobedience Although the rationale behind Mary Crow Dog’s will to resistance is clear, what is entirely unclear is why a city educated comparatively wealthy white girl from New York would engage herself in such a type of resistance and revolution as the author indicated. This brief essay will attempt to disagree with the way in which the supposed “teacher” sought to engage the students in a type of Marxist Revolution that they were neither ready for nor fully understood the ramifications of. Although the revolution that the teacher inspired within the students, to include Mary Crow Dog, did not affect any type of violence, it nonetheless was based on revolutionary/Marxist movements that were sweeping the United States at that time that were based on violence and therefore the causation of such a movement was necessarily grounded in violent revolution.
Rather than advocating such a violent revolution and antagonizing influence among the student body, this author believes that a much more effective strategy for change could have drawn upon the influences of Dr. Martin Luther King and others who have advocated non-violence throughout history. It should be understood that the “hippie”, described to the reader as “Wise” did not actively advocate a violent solution to the repression that the students on the reservation faced; instead, she merely drew inspiration from movements such as the Black Panthers, Young Lords, and Weathermen.
Although advocating a sense of liberation and freedom from an overly repressive regime was no doubt needed and overdue, the fact of the matter was that holding such groups up to a repressed minority as exemplifiers of the best means to accomplish one’s goal is of course the very worst example that could be given (Mulloy 217). Although each of the groups that has been mentioned head its own reasons for defying the powers of the time, the means by which these groups accomplished their goals often relied on intimidation, violence, and coercion. As such, indoctrinating a group of young impressionable students with such hatred was shortsighted and foolish on her part.
Said Wise, “Black people are getting it on. Indians are getting it on in St. Paul and California. How about you? – Why don’t you put out an underground paper, mimeograph it, it’s easy tell it like it is. Let it all hang out” (Bird 307). Although the idea of freedom and the ability to express oneself regarding the issues that most severely affected the life of the girls and boys at the institute was useful, welcome and much needed, the fact of the matter is that this type of tacit support from an educator encouraged students so fully that they put out a paper that included quotes such as the following: “I put all my anger and venom into it. I called him a goddam wasicun son of a bitch. I wrote that he knew nothing about Indians and should go bac to where he came from, teaching white children whom he could relate to. I wrote that we know which priests slept with which nuns and that all they ever could think about was filling their bellies and buying a new car” (Bird 308). Although many of these items were no doubt true, such a vitriolic and hate-filled expression of feelings would have little effect in seeking to liberate the students; rather, it only served to invite a crack down from administration.
Such a short sighted approach by “Wise” showed that she truly was an idealistic city girl that knew and appreciated little of the struggles that those who lived and went to school on the reservation had to endure on a daily basis. Though the girls identified with her and appreciated the new way in which she approached topics regarding freedom and liberation, the fact of the matter was that neither the students nor the teacher had little if any experience in what it meant to resist and/or to go against the system. In this way, the naiveté of both the students and the teacher is exhibited in the fact that the obvious conclusion of the episode was not anticipated by the instructor that at first sought to instigate it.
Although the rationale behind the resistance is well understood and the authorities that sought to repress the girls and boys at the school were reprehensible, the approach that “Wise” advocated was entirely foolish. Although it helped to provide a powerful epiphany for Mary Crow Dog, the result of such a brash and brazen disregard for civility and dialogue is cringe-worthy. To her credit, “Wise” did not have the advantage of seeing the Black Panther and Weathermen movements for what they were: politically motivated hate groups that sought to widen the divide between peoples in order to advocate complete and total revolution to achieve their goals.
Works Cited
Bird, Mary. Lakota woman. New York, NY: HarperPerennial, 1991.
Mulloy, D. J. "New Panthers, Old Panthers And The Politics Of Black Nationalism In The United States." Patterns Of Prejudice 44.3 (2010): 217-238. Academic Search Complete. Web. 11 Nov. 2012. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Civilize Them With a Stick by Mary Crow Dog Essay”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/literature/1608194-civilize-them-with-a-stick-by-mary-crow-dog
(Civilize Them With a Stick by Mary Crow Dog Essay)
https://studentshare.org/literature/1608194-civilize-them-with-a-stick-by-mary-crow-dog.
“Civilize Them With a Stick by Mary Crow Dog Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/literature/1608194-civilize-them-with-a-stick-by-mary-crow-dog.
  • Cited: 2 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Civilize Them With a Stick by Mary Crow Dog

Jim Crow Laws

...? Research Project English 1101-220 Hox Spring Part Essay Jim Crow Laws Since time immemorial, social divisions have existed in the society. This may be based on gender, racial or ethnic inclinations and social class. Such divisions may exist subconsciously in the society, but sometimes, social subdivisions are rooted in the society to the extent that legislation regarding them is enacted. An example of such is the Jim Crow Laws. Jim Crow was the name of the racial social group system which existed mostly in the Southern and Border States in America between 1877 and mid 1960’s. These were laws formed against blacks in the society. Under Jim Crow Laws, African Americans were relegated to the state of second class citizens...
7 Pages(1750 words)Research Paper

Dog Training

...1 TO WHAT EXTENT MAY A DOG'S BEHAVIOUR BE TRAINED BEARING IN MIND THE STRENGTH OF THE ANIMAL'S OWN NATURAL INSTINCTS Introduction Time and time again, we read from newspapers that people leave inheritance to their dogs after their deaths. BBC News reported in 2007 that real estate magnate and hotelier Leona Helmsley left $12 million to her beloved dog Trouble, spurning her 2 grandchildren "for reasons which are known to them" and deeming her dog as worthy of inheriting instead. Helmsley's will also provided that the dog be buried alongside her upon its death (BBC News). Three other dogs belonging to Ken Kemper were bequeathed all his estate worth $800,000 consisting of a house and cash...
8 Pages(2000 words)Essay

My Dog

...Introduction: They say, ‘God condemns for life, by giving those a broken heart!’—Ask me, how to live with a broken heart. I am not a defeated lover, but a defeated dog lover. I loved my Labrador Retriever immensely. “Amicable and sociable, [my] Labrador Retriever is a playful companion and a calm house dog.” (Labrador….) Right from the day I acquired her, I was always seized with a feeling that why the lifespan of this breed of dogs should be 10-12 years only. I complain to God about His scheme of things that such a lovely pet should live only for 12 years. My dog was already 7 years old and I remain anxiety-filled, what would happen to her in the next few years? The very thought of losing my companion increased the palpitation of my...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay

The Big Stick by Roosevelt

...The Big Stick by Roosevelt “The Big Stick” was an administration directive initiated by Roosevelt between 1901 and 1909 (Morgan, 2004). Roosevelt believed in the dominance of the American people on both political and fiscal fronts. He built a massive navy with a view of displaying the Americans might to the world. He indicated that the US should safeguard her concerns in the world. Roosevelt was also an expert in international affairs. Although he championed for a stronger and more powerful navy, he understood the American limits in her involvement, in international conflicts (Morgan, 2004). He believed in a poise of power between the world’s powerful nations as he saw peace as a recipe for stronger fiscal growth and stability... Big Stick...
1 Pages(250 words)Article

Jim Crow

... American cities such as Nebraska, Illinois, North Carolina, and Oklahoma where African Americans were lynched. In Chicago, it is said that thirty people were lynched (Boskin 1976, 282). End of the Jim Crow The Jim Crow ended when Franklin Roosevelt assumed office in that he called for respect of rights by enforcing the bill of rights that aimed to preserve human dignity. This was followed by appointment of new Supreme Court judges who transformed the judicial system in America. These changes made it hard for discrimination to continue as those who were caught propagating hatred were convicted. Conclusion Under the Jim Crow, segregation was rampant in American society, which in turn affected them in that some of African Americans lost...
4 Pages(1000 words)Research Paper

Dog

.... Of course thus far this analysis has simply focused upon the key areas of difference and divergence that humans and dogs would have. However, the more important factor is if one were trapped in the body of a dog they would necessarily be highly interested in the way in which humans viewed them as living and worthy of life. Whereas many places around the world treat animals and dogs with a high degree of respect, this is very much not the case in many regions around the world. As such, the life of a dog in a region that does not value its life would be miserable and hardly worth living at all....
1 Pages(250 words)Essay

Crow Lake

... Crow Lake Crow Lake is a novel ed by Mary Lawson, and narrated by Kate Morrison, an adult womanliving in Crow Lake. At the tender age of seven, Kate and the siblings lost their parent in a tragic road accident leaving the family in a tough situation that threatens their dispersal and an end to the dream the parents had once had for their children of all getting through with their college education. An alternative is provided for each of the siblings to stay with their relatives, a suggestion that they reject based on intention by the sibling to remain together in their stay. This brings about another challenge, as they have to struggle in order to cater for the needs of the family. With the responsibility of taking care of the family...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

Lakota Woman Is About Mary Crow Dog Coming Into a Sense of Identity as a Lakota Woman

...Lakota Woman Is About Mary Crow Dog Coming Into a Sense of Identity as a Lakota Woman Mary Crow Dog is a woman in search of her real identify, in a world where the white dominance has threatened to stifle the cultural identity of the Lakota people, creating an identity crisis between embracing the Whiteman’s ways or to embrace her ancestral cultural identity (Brave and Erdoes, 49). The major cultural identity crisis emanates from the fact that Mary Crow Dog does not belong to any specific culture between the white and the Indian Lakota culture, having been born of an Indian mother and a white father. This being the case, she is undergoing a crisis of identifying with each of the culture, but the crisis is deepened even more by the fact...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay

Reality TV Shows - Keeping Them Real

The winner in Portugal has tried to commit suicide several times already. German Scientists say other contestants may be at risk form Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder, a condition sometimes developed after leaving the armed forces. The racist controversy around Big Brother contestants Shilpa Shetty and Jade Goody generated, 200 newspaper articles just in Britain, 1,200 English spoken language newspapers globally, 3,900 articles in other languages, 22,000 blog postings on the internet. (wiki.2007.BB.The UK)

From the bloody combats in The Coliseum in Rome, where 80,000 or so spectators watched executions and hunting spectacles, viewers have roared in support, booed in rejection and basically embraced whatever means of recre...
17 Pages(4250 words)Report

Problems in Australian Politics and How to Solve Them

Wages that include overtime allowances and travel allowances for the staff of Members of Parliament reveal a sudden increase just before the elections and this reveals that they are being utilized as a part of the election campaign (McLennan, 2004).

Estimating corruption is always difficult because people never reveal the facts of corruption that they are involved in. Politicizing public service often becomes a major problem and this reprehensible practice was introduced during the regime of the Labour party government and was continued by the Coalition government. Due to this, the public servants have slowly commenced to divest themselves of accountability towards parliament or to the code of conduct (McLennan, 2004).<...
6 Pages(1500 words)Assignment

Factors that Influence Tissue Response to Radiation and Evidential Explanations for Them

All biological matter contains inorganic and organic compounds dissolved or suspended in water. This is a protoplasm. The smallest structural and functional component of protoplasm that can exist freely in the cell (Suntharalingam et al, 2005, p. 485). It is just necessary to study the effects of radiation at the cellular level to truly understand the factors that affect biological tissues. Cells are of two types – somatic cells and germ cells. Of these somatic cells have three subtypes – stem cells (cells that generate other cells through differentiation), transit cells (cells that are in the state of being transformed from one type of cell to another) and mature cells (cells that are fully differentiated and are rela...
10 Pages(2500 words)Term Paper

An Overcorrection of Mary Magdalenes Biblical Role

A purely theological approach to DVC would be impossible since the claims the book makes takes issue with what has been supposedly left out of the bible. This essay will in no way attempt to question whether any non-canonical gospels should be considered; that sort of investigation should be left to historians.

As Brandon Gilvin states in Solving the Da Vinci Code Mystery, “It’s difficult to start a discussion on the creation of the bible from the Bible itself” (7). As the word of God is being questioned, it does us no good to turn to the Gnostic Gospels, the main sources of the claims of Mary Magdalene’s and Jesus’ marriage. In these texts, Mary Magdalene is the most mentioned person after...
11 Pages(2750 words)Essay

The Characters Tyler and Jack in Fight Club and Calvin and Hobbes the Philosophers and the Cartoon Characters Based Upon Them

...The Characters Tyler and Jack In Fight Club And Calvin and Hobbes (The Philosophers and the Cartoon Characters Based Upon Them): A Comparison Analysis of literature in a creative way requires some seriousness of thought. Here it will be attempted to link excerpts from the script Fight Club and the philosophies of John Calvin and Thomas Hobbes. 

The major link between the two will be demonstrated through the ethical and moral scruples of the cartoon Calvin and Hobbes, which will be described further in detail later on herein. The characters in Fight Club are supposed to mirror Calvin and Hobbes, and Calvin and Hobbes are supposed to mirror the philosophers John Calvin and Thomas Hobbes. 

 One of the more amusing scenes...
6 Pages(1500 words)Assignment

Mary Wollstonecraft on Education

Understanding that women are just as able as men in many capacities and some very important ways that she excels causes one to realize that no one should be able to take her rights away. It is the mother who gives protection for the initial nine months to the divine creative force of nature – regardless of whether the offspring is male or female. But what is prescribed in various secular and spiritual texts and what is practiced in society currently are contradictory. A female child is victimized during every step of her life, from the moment of birth, notwithstanding the fact that it is she who sacrifices at those stages. Women need to be the social, spiritual and legal equals of men. These were the arguments that Mary Woll...
10 Pages(2500 words)Assignment

Frankenstein by Mary Shelley

The captain provides him help and listens to his story of how his drive for getting what he wanted so badly brought him to face lethal consequences. Frankenstein kept on narrating all the happenings of his life to the captain; where he was born, how he was raised, what happened to his family and what happened to him after them. Also, the narration of how he formed the creature and now that creature is harming his family. There were many incidents taking place during the scientist’s absence after creating that monster, but when the scientist came back to life he noticed that the creature has been wreaking havoc to his family and has been hiding in woods and getting familiar with another family. The scientist came to find that...
8 Pages(2000 words)Book Report/Review

Why Does the Government Lock Public Parks when the Citizens Pay for them

...Why does the government lock public parks when the citizens pay for them? Public parks are a part of daily life. People pass through parks on their way to school and work. People go to parks to relax, run or walk their dogs. Public parks offer a great view in high-rise buildings. Travellers navigate with public parks as landmarks and travel routes. In the U.K., there are at least 27,000 thousand public parks that cover 143,000 hectares of land. These parks offer spaces for leisure, recreation, sports, entertainment and business. Some parks are open and very accessible while other parks are walled with gated entrances. Around 1.5 billion people visit these parks each year. With many people using parks, upkeep is necessary. The government...
8 Pages(2000 words)Literature review

Lakota Woman by Mary Crow Dog

Secondly, there was the harsh situation with alcohol and drugs among Lakota society that is why some males behaved themselves extraordinarily fighting with their own wives (p. 21, 25, 34) like it happened in Mary’s own family. Also, males were without jobs almost, so they could accept such deviant pattern of behavior, to get tired of life-fighting their own wives being out of consciousness in a deep over-drinking state.
Thirdly, Native Americans were living on their reservations without electricity and running water, without their native schools and gardens for children. According to Mary, here, in the reservation, you could afford nothing to yourself, and combining with white hostility around the reservation these factor...
7 Pages(1750 words)Book Report/Review

Gothic Romance: Mary Shelleys Frankenstein and Robert Louis Stevensons Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde

... Gothic Romance There are numerous genres in the writing community, one of the most popular ones being that of gothic romance. The books that are allotted under this have the elements of horror, romanticism as well as fiction in them; the plot is usually placed in a medieval setting. This style of literature was initially introduced during the eighteenth century and was soon followed by the release of many widely successful books in the following years such as Mary Shelley’s Frankenstein and Robert Louis Stevenson’s Dr Jekyll and Mr Hyde. Despite – or because of – there being a lack of the books concluding with a happy ending and the complexity displayed by the characters, they are greatly loved by the readers to this day. The villainous...
8 Pages(2000 words)Term Paper

Analysis of Frankenstein by Mary Shelley

... Lecturer Essay # Frankenstein by Mary Shelley Frankenstein is the most famous work by Mary Shelley, an English and dramatist. Shelley’s father, William Godwin, was a philosopher and historian while her mother, Mary Wollstonecraft was a philosopher and feminist. Although her mother died when she was less than two weeks old, Shelley was raised by his father who later married a neighbor Jane Clairmont (Pastore, ed., 10). Shelley was thus exposed to philosophers, historians and other great people at an early age. Shelley’s growth in the world of literature blossomed when she got married to Percy Bysshe, a poet (Pastore, ed., 11). Shelley and Percy traveled across several countries in Europe including France and Germany. Throughout this period...
6 Pages(1500 words)Literature review
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Essay on topic Civilize Them With a Stick by Mary Crow Dog for FREE!

Contact Us