StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

The Tempest Play - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
The paper "The Tempest Play" discusses that it is impossible to read the play for what it is, especially if the reader belongs to a postcolonial nation. When one’s history has been full of similar instances of imperialism, one cannot dismiss them in a cavalier fashion…
Download free paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER96% of users find it useful
The Tempest Play
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "The Tempest Play"

In "The Tempest" Shakespeare, William. Graff, Gerald and James Phelan, ed. Boston: Bedford/St. Martins. 2000.read pp.91 - 108. Then find a critical article pertaining to the play (you may use the library data base or the internet)and read that article. Discuss the internet article you read in relation to Graff and Phelan's debate between the Postcolonial Professor and the Traditionalist Professor. How does your internet article relate to this argument Then discuss what your own personal view in this debate is. Are you are postcolonialist or a traditionalist I am looking for a well-supported opinion, you know, critical thinking. Write a convincing argument. Literature has always had a dual function. For some, its primary function has been to entertain and amuse. For others, it is a source of information about the times we live in and those that preceded ours. It provides us with a historical context for certain events that we witness, it educates us and it sometimes informs our opinions about our world. It is exactly this duality in The Tempest that literary theorists have been grappling with for the past two decades. The Tempest has often been described as a magical play. It was first performed in the year 1611 and is considered Shakespeare's final play. It contains a mixture of everything required to create an instant success- Intrigue, conspiracy, betrayal and love. It also deals with certain issues that became apparent only during the early part of the 20th Century. In the debate under study in this essay, the English professor claims that, "it's a disservice to our students when we teachers use great literature as an excuse for our pet political agendas." However, in our day and age, it would be difficult to ignore the issues that a play like The Tempest explores. As the Comparative Literature professor puts it, the play 'practically reeks with political struggle in every scene' The play is a text about nascent colonization. This is evident from Prospero's treatment of Caliban and his usurpation of the latter's island. The theme of usurpation runs through the play. It is a vicious cycle. The dispossessed Prospero becomes the conqueror when he takes over Caliban's island. This is one of the central points of the debate between the two professors. While the English professor refuses to 'politicize' the play, the Comparative Literature professor views it as an instance of imperialism. The English professor's refusal to place the play in a postcolonial context seems cowardly. He claims that one must not impose 20th century concerns on the play. He believes 16th century audiences viewed the play only for what it is. They did not concern themselves with sub-texts within the play. While this may be true, we must remember that plays like The Tempest influenced 16th century attitudes and behaviors towards the natives of colonized countries to some extent. In the play, Caliban is the dispossessed native. Prospero manages to make Caliban submissive, first through education and then through force. It is a reflection of the history of almost every colonized nation. Colonization first began with the arrival of missionaries who came to evangelize the natives through religion and education. They were followed by their rulers who took over completely and denied the natives freedom in their own countries. In his essay, National and Colonial Education in Shakespeare's The Tempest, Allen Carey-Webb states that Prospero came to Caliban's island in the role of a teacher-colonizer. By educating Caliban, Prospero empowered him. Once the pupil began to understand, the master's intentions, he rebelled. By educating Caliban, Prospero allows him to think for himself. By teaching him language, Prospero allows Caliban to curse him in his own tongue and as a result of this Prospero has to subdue Caliban through force. According to Caliban, without his books Prospero would be just like him. To Caliban, the source of Prospero's power is in his books. Therefore as Carey-Webb puts it, "At stake in the struggle between Caliban and Prospero is ownership of books, the technology of power/magic and the implements of educational practice." Education is the means to gaining power and in the hands of Prospero it is a potent tool. He educates Caliban to think less of himself. By making Caliban believe in his own inferiority, Prospero has already triumphed over him. It is the first step towards absolutism. Prospero is the wisest and most manipulative individual on the island. He engineers events to suit his own needs. Education is central to Prospero's success. He has enough power to harness the forces of nature and unleash them as he wishes. Through his knowledge of magic, he manages to release Ariel from his captivity and make him is slave. It also seems like Prospero does not wish for others to be as knowledgeable as him. This becomes evident when he destroys his books at the end of the play, ostensibly to prevent them from falling into the wrong hands. The play also affirms various hierarchies. In the debate between the two professors, the English professor says Caliban deserved his punishment because he was trying to defy the Elizabethan concept of the Great Chain of Beings. He implies that Caliban must always be Prospero's inferior and must never fight back. Since Prospero is infinitely superior to Caliban, it is his right to demand his dukedom back from Antonio. It is in fact Prospero's prerogative to challenge Antonio. Yet Caliban is denied the same right. Any attempts on Caliban's part to win back his island will be futile because he simply cannot challenge Prospero's authority. As Carey-Webb puts it, "The final lesson of Caliban's education is an acceptance of the inevitable failure of revolt. In his last scene, Caliban appears in scraping submission to Prospero's authority." Caliban is a lowborn savage who must work and will be rewarded only according to Prospero's wishes. He is not allowed to fight back. He only gets his island back when Prospero leaves it at the end of the play. Until then he must work for Prospero. Hence we see that it is impossible to read the play for what it is, especially if the reader belongs to a postcolonial nation. When one's history has been full of similar instances of imperialism, one cannot dismiss them in a cavalier fashion. Perhaps the best we can do is to acknowledge the dual role of such texts. It would be utter folly on our part to not address issues that appear in them. They will only continue to appear in more blatant forms. It sounds ironic, but by neglecting to take notice we might end up encouraging future Kiplings, Conrads and maybe even Shakespeares. Sources: Carey-Webb,Allen. National and Colonial Education in Shakespeare's The Tempest. 1999. http://www.shu.ac.uk/emls/05-1/cwebtemp.html The Tempest. Shakespeare, William. Graff, Gerald and James Phelan, ed. Boston: Bedford/St. Martins. 2000. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“The Tempest Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 words”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/literature/1513054-the-tempest
(The Tempest Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words)
https://studentshare.org/literature/1513054-the-tempest.
“The Tempest Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/literature/1513054-the-tempest.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF The Tempest Play

Shakespeare: Traditionsl Notion Of Sovereign Power in King Lear And The Tempest

In the tempest, Prospero and Caliban ruler-slave relationship is mutually considered just (McDonald, 2004).... Likewise, Prospero of the tempest is a grand magician who is very powerful, yet Caliban's presence elevates Shakespeare's style which salutes the groundlings that represented a major part of the Elizabethan theatre.... In the tempest, Prospero and Caliban ruler-slave relationship is mutually considered just (McDonald, 2004).... In the tempest, Prospero is a supervisor of his colony....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

The Tempest and Solibo Magnificent Comparative Literature

Colonialism: The island in the tempest inculcates numerous desires in nearly everyone who visits it.... Jambette and Diab-Anba-Feuilles twist his arms behind his back, slam him onto a chair, face under a lamp's incandescence” (Chamoiseau 139) The difference between the colonialism discussed in the tempest and that in Solibo Magnificent is that the former offers rule over land while the latter offers rule over public.... Slavery has been a common element both in the tempest and Solibo Magnificent, though the latter has mixed slavery with racism unlike the former....
3 Pages (750 words) Essay

Comaprisn between the two Tempests

the tempest was one of Shakespeare's last plays which was written in 1610 and it was to symbolize the ending of his career.... The author explains that the plot is built around a ruler, Prospero who is deposed, and the play Tempest is set on a far away island in the aftermath that the ship that had the King of Naples faced a storm that was extremely powerful and deathly and the people aboard were to leave the ship in order to survive.... Cesaire aimed to write the play about the ethnic situation in United States at that time....
7 Pages (1750 words) Essay

The Tempest vs Tempest

In the play A Tempest by Aime Cesaire is based upon the character of Caliban in Shakespeare's the tempest.... In the play A Tempest by Aime Cesaire is based upon the character of Caliban in Shakespeare's the tempest.... As Nixon (1987) notes, the post colonial movement, where colonization increasingly became discredited, as the intellectuals who have studied the matter seized upon the tempest as a way of protest and to frame the argument regarding colonization....
8 Pages (2000 words) Research Paper

Tempe General Plan 2040

Name: Lecturer: Course: Date: Tempe's Plan on Economic Vitality The general plan is used when refining the goals and vision into more exhaustive plans.... The General Plan is referred to when implementing requests for zoning, for decisions on economic development, for building permits, and when designing public amenities....
3 Pages (750 words) Assignment

Marina Warner and Mythological Stories

This essay "Marina Warner and Mythological Stories" is focused on the peculiarities of the writing style of Marina Warner.... As the text has it, she is a famous English novelist and critic, who has produced remarkable stories, novels on various topics including mythology, feminism, and culture.... ...
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Class Discussion 8

In The Tempest Play,.... In The Tempest Play, several participants are portrayed in a way that makes the story captivating.... With a clear understanding of this importance, William Shakespeare included emotions in most of the plays this actor-cum-play-writer did.... n a bid to ensure the readers or viewers follow a play or a story keenly, the use of emotions forms part of art.... With a clear understanding of this importance, William Shakespeare included emotions in most of the plays this actor-cum-play-writer did....
1 Pages (250 words) Coursework

Evaluation of General Plan for Tempe City

This essay "Evaluation of General Plan for Tempe City" evaluates the general plan 2040 with regards to Tempe City, Arizona State.... General strategic planning is a very essential element in each and every sector.... The main focus here is on the Circulation or the transportation sector such as the bicycle element, etc....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us