A comparative analysis of Shakespeares Hamlet and Mel Gibsons Portrayal - Essay Example

Summary
The character of Hamlet, both in Shakespeare's play and in Mel Gibson's portrayal in the film, is a youth beset by injustice and indecision.In adapting the play for cinema, certain liberties have been taken however, for better or worse. …
Download full paper
File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER94% of users find it useful
A comparative analysis of Shakespeares Hamlet and Mel Gibsons Portrayal
Preview
Download file to see previous pages The character of Hamlet, both in Shakespeare's play and in Mel Gibson's portrayal in the film, is a youth beset by injustice and indecision.In adapting the play for cinema, certain liberties have been taken however, for better or worse. The most obvious discrepancy is the age difference: for Hamlet to fit into his period role he could have ranged from the age of 13 to possibly as old as 21. Gibson, to be generous, is at least 28. On the other hand, Shakespeare's mention of rapier and dagger for the final duel is probably more Elizabethan in time, while the film attempts a more period placement by the use of single and two handed broadswords, as well as short swords for the two sword duel. Considering that both are the same character (for the sake of description they shall be referred to as Hamlet or Gibson), there are a number of differences between the play and the version directed by Franco Zeffirelli. The most obvious place to begin comparison would be to analyze the structure of both.In order to understand the scene rearrangement in the movie, one must first examine the original order of the play. It is vital to have a listing of the order and elements Shakespeare wrote in order to see the movie's purpose for leaving out certain elements and for shuffling others. In order to conserve space, one can focus the summary on the scenes most directly in conflict with the film. The opening act of the play involves the watch both discussing the history of Fortinbras and the deceased Hamlet, as well as witnessing the latter's ghost. The final scene of Act I has Hamlet receiving instructions from his father's ghost while his friends support him while keeping their distance from the spirit. Act II encompasses two scenes, the latter half of which follows a quick succession of events: the King and Queen welcome Rosencrantz and Guildenstern, an update on the activities of Fortinbras, Hamlet mocking Polonius and then greeting Rosencrantz and Guildenstern only to then berate their reasons for coming to Ellsinore, ending with Polonius announcing the arrival of the players. Act III scene one involves the King and Polonius receiving the report from Hamlet's friends, then testing Hamlet's madness by using Ophelia to bait him. Act VI is somewhat scattered, as the first three scenes all deal with Hamlet's murder of Polonius and subsequent departure for England. The fourth scene is the only meeting between Hamlet and Fortinbras; the next shows Ophelia's descent into madness and Laertes's return. Hamlet informs Horatio via a letter that he will be returning to Ellsinore in scene six, while the final scene involves the King and Laertes, having learned of Hamlet's return, plot his demise until they learn of Ophelia's death. The final act has but two divisions: the first at Ophelia's grave site and the latter at the duel, in which most of the major characters die, an English ambassador reports the death of Rosencrantz and Guildenstern, and Fortinbras appears to reclaim the lands his father lost. The evolution of the plot in this format serves to define a Hamlet tormented by indecision and grief, a character that can take action through events (such as through the players performance) but rarely initiates events himself he is pushed around more often than he chooses to push.
Just as Shakespearean theatre operates around the seven-element formula, so to do movies work around a cinematic formula. Yet, while there is always room for interpretation with plays, the leap of mediums to the big screen also involves the daunting task of editing a four-hour play to roughly two hours. The movie begins to bend the play's structure immediately in the first act. In lieu of the first scene of the play, the movie opens with the interment of the elder Hamlet, a scene in which Claudius, already wearing the crown over his dead brother's corpse, asks Gibson to look upon him as a father. While there is an edit done between this ...Download file to see next pagesRead more
HAVE A CHALLENGING ESSAY AND A TOUGH DEADLINE?
StudentShare Professional Writing Service is the right decision for you! Only from $14,99/page for a 100% unique and relevant paper. Enter your email, choose essay type and get your personal 20% discount
on on expert writing!
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“A comparative analysis of Shakespeares Hamlet and Mel Gibsons Essay”, n.d.)
A comparative analysis of Shakespeares Hamlet and Mel Gibsons Essay. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/literature/1506630-a-comparative-analysis-of-shakespeares-hamlet-and-mel-gibsons-portrayal
(A Comparative Analysis of Shakespeares Hamlet and Mel Gibsons Essay)
A Comparative Analysis of Shakespeares Hamlet and Mel Gibsons Essay. https://studentshare.org/literature/1506630-a-comparative-analysis-of-shakespeares-hamlet-and-mel-gibsons-portrayal.
“A Comparative Analysis of Shakespeares Hamlet and Mel Gibsons Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/literature/1506630-a-comparative-analysis-of-shakespeares-hamlet-and-mel-gibsons-portrayal.
  • Cited: 0 times
Click to create a comment or rate a document
WITH THIS DOCUMENT STUDENTS HAVE ALSO DOWNLOADED:

MORE SAMPLES OF TOPIC: "A comparative analysis of Shakespeares Hamlet and Mel Gibsons Portrayal"

Shakespeares Universal Appeal as Shown in Hamlet

...Shakespeare’s Universal Appeal as Shown in Hamlet Discussing Shakespeare is a continuous dealing with superlatives. The superlatives that apply tothis great writer not those that come cheaply, even in this day and age where adulation is cheap. There are countless instances when the adulation is well deserved. The strongest argument in favor of Shakespeare is his universal appeal. He is for all people, of all times. The reading public may be fickle, ungrateful, even cruel, but their loyalty to Shakespeare has not changed. Eternal relevance is a permanent quality of greatness. What gives rise to this perpetual and universal appeal? The first quality...
7 Pages(1750 words)Research Paper
Read More…

Comparative analysis

...………………………………………………….. D. Infrastructure development (Transportation facilities): Gold Coast and Sunshine Coast…... IV. Findings……………………………………………………………………………………….8 V. Conclusion……………………………………………………………………………………..9 VI. References……………………………………………………………………………………10 VII. Appendices………………………………………………………………………………….11 Comparative analysis I. Introduction Generally saying, behind every tourist hotspot, one can expect the rich history of planning and creativity of a few blessed minds. Worldwide, coastal areas, especially sea coasts with wide beaches attract millions of national and international tourists. As international tourism is blooming, the Gold Coast...
10 Pages(2500 words)Essay
Read More…

Comparative Analysis of William Shakespeares Hamlet in the film and text

...Comparative Analysis of William Shakespeare’s Hamlet in the film and text William Shakespeare’s Hamlet and the film version that stars Mel Gibson are somehow different in the aspect of the main character Hamlet that they emphasize. Although both the written and the film versions of Hamlet portray a likeable character because of his uncanny combination of intelligence and emotion, the film version portrays the rather more brutal and emotional side of Hamlet, yet both written and film versions seem to satisfy their own goals. In Act III, when...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay
Read More…

Comparative analysis

...Comparative Analysis Transcript analysis of non-model plants is the method through which many of the contemporary research in plants and various living matter uses to understand the various characteristics in these living products. The method is imperative because it ensures that there is specification of the particular product. An example is the fact that through transcript analysis, there is the assurance of identification of a specific epidermis. The epidermis of plants varies but it is imperative to understand that the normal or scientific microscope does not carry out effective work of determining the difference in plants of a similar species. Transcript...
10 Pages(2500 words)Assignment
Read More…

Analysis of Mel Gibsons The Passion of the Christ

... The Passion of the Christ The Passion of the Christ is a 2004 American drama movie directed by Mel Gibson and Jim Caviezel acting as starring. It shows passion of Jesus with reference to the Gospel of Mathew, Luke, mark and John. The movie primarily covers the last 12 hours of the life of Jesus. It starts from the Agony in the Garden of Gethsemane, the grievance and insomnia of the Virgin Mary, and finally ends with a succinct depiction of Jesus’ resurrection (The Passion of the Christ). There are also many flashbacks of biblical scenes of Jesus’ early life with Mary; his mother, Jesus’ Sermon on the Mount, Jesus’ teaching the Apostle as well as the Last Supper. The movie has been controversial since its release (Bock 1). Some... )....
2 Pages(500 words)Essay
Read More…

Comparative Analysis

...Comparative analysis Children of the Sea” by Edwidge Danticat and “Big Mamas Funeral” by Gabriel Garcia Marquez) Course name University Date Comparative analysis (“Children of the Sea” by Edwidge Danticat and “Big Mamas Funeral” by Gabriel Garcia Marquez) Contemporary literature does not stop to astonish the readers of any circle and mentality. The diversity of genres and variety of techniques impress entirely. Modern reader has a chance to choose such piece of literary art that he/she likes and appreciate. There is a tendency in postmodern culture to deem that everything has already written and done. People cannot create anything new; still we observe a wide multiplicity of literary works that affect reader’s minds and perception...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay
Read More…
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Essay on topic A comparative analysis of Shakespeares Hamlet and Mel Gibsons Portrayal for FREE!

Contact Us