StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

On First Looking Into Chapmans Homer - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
The paper "On First Looking Into Chapman’s Homer" highlights that there are doubts that whether Keats was able to visualize the world of literature as a place where rivalry was more important than romanticism. In Homer’s works, rivalry and violence can be seen. …
Download free paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER91.3% of users find it useful
On First Looking Into Chapmans Homer
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "On First Looking Into Chapmans Homer"

? Assignment Analysis of “On First Looking into Chapman’s Homer” by John Keats Introduction The poem “On First Looking into Chapman’s Homer” is a sonnet written by the British poet John Keats (33-34) in the year 1816. The poem was published in Leigh Hunt’s literary periodical The Examiner in the same year. The literary work has been widely acclaimed and it is also regarded as a classic. The sonnet is basically dedicated towards developing a reflective observation of the translation of Homer’s major works by George Chapman in 1614. For details regarding Chapman’s works on Homer, Richard H. Shepherd’s edited book The Works of George Chapman: Homer’s Iliad and Odyssey can be referred to. Analysis By analyzing the morphology of the poem, it can be categorized under the genre of Italian sonnet. It is typically divided into an octave and a sestet. The rhyme scheme is well-adjusted within the iambic pentameter format typical to English sonnets. However, a main drawback of the sonnet from this viewpoint is that not all of the staves contain exactly 12 syllables. Critics like Hunt have initially overlooked this drawback owing to the young age of the poet at the time of writing this poem. The poem can be critically analyzed from three major perspectives. Firstly, the biographic approach as taken by the critics like Hunt and Gittings must be considered. According to Hunt, the poem actually reflects the poet’s own ambition. Homer’s works are a secondary subject. But this secondary subject gives rise to a number of visuals so strong that the poet’s own ambitions cannot be detected very easily. In his essay “The Three Young Poets”, Hunt diagnoses Keats’s admiration for Chapman and Homer as a driving force behind developing the compulsion inside the young poet’s mind to do something phenomenal in the “realms of gold” (Keats, 33) of the literary world. Gittings also stresses on a similar scrutiny of the sonnet. In fact, Gittings has delved into a background analysis of the poem. At the time of writing this poem, young Keats was in the final stage of his apothecary education. This was the vital juncture of Keats’s life whereat he was supposed to decide about his career. He was around 21 years old then and could get ahead in life to become a reputed physician. But he appears to have changed his mind a little earlier and now he had decided to become a poet. At this stage, he was under the influence of friends like Charles Cowden Clarke who inspired him to become a poet. The poem, therefore, reveals young Keats’s fascination for grand literary works. And he particularly admired Chapman because without his wonderful translation, the young poet could hardly know about the Greek literary genius of Homer. (Gittings, 18-21) But there is a second opinion as well. No doubt that “On First Looking into Chapman’s Homer” is a reflective analysis of one poet regarding the works of another poet. Also, this happened through the aid of a powerful writer like George Chapman, whose legendary translation and literary inputs from English to Greek and vice versa remains unrivalled even today. This is clearly established when the poet writes “I heard Chapman speak out loud and bold” (Keats, 33-34). Yet, the literary resonance becomes more prominent. At this point once again, the morphological features of the poem must be analyzed with special reference to the usage of analogies. In the poem, Keats writes that the discovery of the charm of ancient Greek literature was rather like discovering a new planet altogether. Recently then, a new planet Uranus had been discovered by the European astronomers and Keats was relating that event with his reading of Chapman’s Homer. Another analogy has been very instrumental. In this analogy, the poet compares himself with Cortez. If one attempts to adjust this analogy in simple, plain English, then he or she must write that the poet was so astounded to have read Chapman’s translations of Homer’s works that he was feeling like Cortez “when with eagle eyes/ He star’d at the Pacific” (Keats, 34). And when had Cortez stared at the Pacific? Cortez might have stared at the Pacific when he was doing the grand task of Spanish conquest in the Americas! Experts of English literature like Strachan have emphasized on these structural superiorities of Keats’s sonnet, where the poet not only creates clever riddles but also presents unexpected but effective visuals. Nevertheless, by the end of the 20th century, a third perspective has started to germinate and mature rapidly. It is about the socio-political context of the sonnet. Definitely, there is an initial bamboozlement caste by comparing the act of reading a book with that of conquering a continent. But then the reader must ask that what is the real relevance of Cortez in this milieu? If the poet wants to compare the mirth of literary discoveries with that of exploring new continents, then why does he mention Cortez? In fact, Cortez did not discover the Pacific Ocean; that was done by Balboa (Otfinoski, 42). Then why does the poet write about Cortez instead of Balboa, if he intends to compare his discovery of Homer’s vast literary works with that of Pacific Ocean? This point can emerge as an epicenter of debate regarding Keats’s intentions behind writing the sonnet. Critics like Gittings and Roe have pointed out that friends like Clarke had made the poet aware of this discrepancy in the sonnet. And the poet did not change what he had written. Some scholars like Gittings and Strachan have tried to furnish morphological reasons behind this. They argue that Cortez was used instead of Balboa to adjust the number of syllables in the sentence. But this argument does not hold strong since discrepancies regarding the number of syllables are already present in the sonnet. For example, the line “He star’d at the Pacific – and all his men” (Keats, 34) has an extra syllable. Consequently, Roe suggests that Keats might have used the example of Cortez with some deep politico-societal implications. Possibly, the poet does not refer to discovery but conquest. And he attempts to make the reader aware of the imperial culture behind the Spanish Empire in Americas. Similarly, Homer’s works are also much about war, conquest, etc. typical to the Greek culture that looked at warfare and violence with a certain degree of esteem. Nevertheless, the question remains that why does the poet select violence, imperialism, etc. as the means of creating an analogy to glorify the task of reading a great work done centuries ago. So ultimately, Keats is found to be shuttling “metonymically between two ‘realms of gold’ – the New World and the ancient classical world of Homer’s poetry.” (Roe, 218) Conclusion There are doubts that whether Keats was able to visualize the world of literature as a place where rivalry was more important than romanticism (Gittings). In Homer’s works, rivalry and violence can be seen. Cortez’s activities too were cruel and violent. And in a world of increased rivalry and competition, art and literature too might become instruments of intellectual violence. However, if the poet was not conscious about these issues that are discernable in the beautiful sonnet he wrote, the quality of the work is rather hampered than enhanced. In spite of extra-ordinary visualizations, the sonnet has certain morphological discrepancies as well as inconsistencies regarding its multiplicity of meanings. Works Cited Chapman, George. The Works of George Chapman: Homer's Iliad and Odyssy. Richard H. Shepherd, 1885 ed. London: Chatto & Windus, 1614. Print. Gittings, Robert. Selected Poems and Letters of Keats. London: Heinemann, 1987. Print. Hunt, Leigh. "Three Young Poets." The Examiner. London: Leigh Hunt, 1816. 32-35. Print. Keats, John. "On First Looking into Chapman's Homer." The Examiner. London: Leigh Hunt, 1816. 33-34. Print. Otfinoski, Steven. Great Explorations: Vasco Nunez de Balboa. New York: Benchmark Books, 2005. Print. Roe, Nicholas. Keats and History. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1995. Print. Strachan, John R.. Routledge Literary Sourcebook on the Poems of John Keats. London and New York: Routledge, 2003. Print. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“John Keats Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 words”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/literature/1470001-john-keats
(John Keats Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words)
https://studentshare.org/literature/1470001-john-keats.
“John Keats Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/literature/1470001-john-keats.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF On First Looking Into Chapmans Homer

Health Care Provider Faith and Diversity

An essay "Health Care Provider Faith and Diversity" claims that healthcare providers must understand that there are many different ways that people see healthcare.... A healthcare provider cannot assume that an individual will understand Western medicine, or will comply with what the doctors want....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

Research Project Handout

Name: Course: Tutor: Date: Research Project Handout Introduction Most Americans say publicly freedom, but do not all denote an equivalent issue.... ? For some the word freedom may connote that each man do as he or she pleases, in addition to the creation of his or her labor, while for others freedom implies doing what they feel pleases with others (Foner “What is Freedom?...
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Propaganda and British Cinema

ritish film descended from French Lumiere brothers in 1892 and their first show was in 1896.... he first moving picture was in 1889.... he first English sound tape was produced in 1929 by Hitchcock .... Propaganda is a type of a message setting whose target is serving a specific scheme....
10 Pages (2500 words) Essay

Street Homelessness Research

When people first become homeless for different reasons, they are more likely to seek help from relatives or friends.... The paper "Street Homelessness Research" underlines that while there is homeless youth from different ethnic backgrounds which makes them have different needs, what unites them is their inexperience in life, youthful age, and inability to work in respectable jobs in order to improve their circumstances....
8 Pages (2000 words) Literature review

Classical Tradition

One finds this interest reflected in many of his poems, including “on first looking into Chapman's Homer” and “Ode on a Grecian Urn”, among others.... The elation that Keats felt on the discovery of.... ... ... Being one of the earliest poets from the middle classes, Keats came to know of such works not through schooling but as an auto-didact....
4 Pages (1000 words) Term Paper

How an Individual Felt After Discovering a Book

eats' poem, "on first looking into Chapman's Homer" has one particular element in common with the story "The Search Engine"—both describe how an individual felt after discovering a book.... How does Keats' response to finding Chapman's homer resemble Corliss's response to finding Harlan Atwater?... The difference between Corliss finding Harlan Atwater's book and Keat's response when he found 'Chapman's homer' is the content they stumbled upon....
1 Pages (250 words) Assignment

How Technology Conditioned the Nature and Extent of Banking after the Second World War

The paper "How Technology Conditioned the Nature and Extent of Banking after the Second World War" is a great example of an essay on technology.... Technological development has brought tremendous changes in different economic sectors.... It has led to increased production and profitability to those people who have embraced the changes....
9 Pages (2250 words) Essay

Living and Working Conditions in the East End in 1888

The fact that she was murdered on the road shows that she had been looking for a potential buyer so as to get income.... The paper "Living and Working Conditions in the East End in 1888" is a great example of a case study on social science.... Jack the Ripper is an acronym given to a serial killer who existed around the year 1888 in Whitechapel, east of London....
10 Pages (2500 words) Case Study
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us