StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Nobody downloaded yet

Judges as Lawmakers: Harts Rule of Recognition - Essay Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
Summary
This essay "Judges as Lawmakers: Hart’s Rule of Recognition" analyzes Hart’s rule of recognition which allows flexibility of judicial interpretation within the framework of social rules.  …
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER93.4% of users find it useful
Judges as Lawmakers: Harts Rule of Recognition
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "Judges as Lawmakers: Harts Rule of Recognition"

Download file to see previous pages Kelsen is of the view that the ability of the law to use the threat of violence where necessary and impose its rules through its coercive nature is its most important aspect4. Therefore, under such a coercive framework, the scope for judicial interpretation may be seen to be limited, posing the question of whether true justice may be served through rigid adherence to rules laid down by the sovereign and through social norms. Hart fiercely opposes the predictive interpretation of law based upon its coercive aspect on the grounds that such interpretation “obscures the fact that, where rules exist, deviations from them are not merely grounds for a prediction that hostile reactions will follow.... but are also a reason or justification for such reaction and for applying the sanctions.”5
Raz emphasizes the social learning aspect of conforming to rules, applying a test of behavioral guidance to determine that a person could have come to accept the rules without actually deciding to do so, or questioning the original justification for the rule itself.6 According to Hart, a full-blown system of law must be equipped with more than mere rules, since these are only “concerned with the actions that individuals must or must not do”, while secondary meta-rules that have the primary rules as their subject matter help to “specify the way in which the primary rules may be conclusively ascertained, introduced, eliminated, varied, and the fact of their violation conclusively determined.”7 Thus, while primary rules spell out the obligations of the individual, secondary rules help courts to resolve disputes over the application and interpretation of those primary rules and may, therefore, be classified as rules of recognition. ...Download file to see next pagesRead More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(Judges as Lawmakers: Harts Rule of Recognition Essay, n.d.)
Judges as Lawmakers: Harts Rule of Recognition Essay. https://studentshare.org/law/1703649-2-is-it-a-telling-objection-to-harts-rule-of-recognition-that-it-places-legal-officials-in-the-position-of-conferring-the-status-of-lawmakers-upon-themselves
(Judges As Lawmakers: Harts Rule of Recognition Essay)
Judges As Lawmakers: Harts Rule of Recognition Essay. https://studentshare.org/law/1703649-2-is-it-a-telling-objection-to-harts-rule-of-recognition-that-it-places-legal-officials-in-the-position-of-conferring-the-status-of-lawmakers-upon-themselves.
“Judges As Lawmakers: Harts Rule of Recognition Essay”. https://studentshare.org/law/1703649-2-is-it-a-telling-objection-to-harts-rule-of-recognition-that-it-places-legal-officials-in-the-position-of-conferring-the-status-of-lawmakers-upon-themselves.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Judges as Lawmakers: Harts Rule of Recognition

Disciplining judges

...? Disciplining Judges Number Introduction That every in America has judicial uniqueness is a matter that is well underscored by states having their own jurisdiction, laws and legal procedures. The issue of disciplining judges is not an exception when it comes to legal procedures that may vary from one state to another. In the case of Michigan, the procedure of disciplining judges will have to be consistent with the Michigan Rules of Professional Conduct (MRPC) which was adopted and effected by the Michigan Supreme Court on October 1st, 1988. Alongside this, the principles disclosed in the Board of Law Examiners and the Code of Judicial Conduct are to be followed during this disciplinary process, as shall be seen forthwith. First, there has...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay

Revenue Recognition

...Affects of Revenue Recognition: 'An "assets and liabilities approach" is being used to address the issues rather than a "realization and earnings process approach." Under the assets and liabilities approach, changes in assets and liabilities that have occurred are analyzed to determine the source of those changes. For example, if an entity's assets increase, that increase must have resulted from one of the following corresponding changes: (1) a decrease in other assets, (2) an increase in liabilities, (3) an investment by owners, or (4) income (which includes revenues). In addition, assets obtained and liabilities incurred are measured at their fair values when they are obtained and incurred.' The revenues recognition under the Asset...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

Judges of colorado state

... The Judges of Colorado Introduction In Colorado, the in-office majority has constantly despoiled the privileges of Colorado voters. In 1992, Colorado voters approved a Taxpayer’s Bill of Rights modification to the state constitution. This amendment protected the right of voters to have a say on tax rises. However, in spite of the apparent language of the Constitution advocating that its preferred explanation shall sensibly hold back most the expansion of government, the Colorado Supreme Court did not endorse this segment of the state constitution (Arnold 1). Under the deception of abolishing tax credits or exemptions, the court, as part of the same ruling, introduced language allowing the legislature to raise more taxes. This is a tax...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

The Book Of Judges

... Task The Judges were the people God anointed to provide leadership for his people this can be found in judges 2:16 that says that God “rose up judges who saved them.” The Judges include Eli and Samuel. 2 The main cause of the sin in the book of Judges was the worship of the false gods that was due to the intermarriages of the Israelites with the Canaanites community. 3 The Judah’s conquest is an irony, Judges 17-21 contains plenty of comedy and irony comment, for instance, ‘in those days, there was no king in Israel: every man did that was right in his own eyes’. 4 The role of the women in Judges is to expose men to humiliation and defeat, because the powerless often have more power than the powerful because they are able to manipulate...
1 Pages(250 words)Research Paper

Different Sorts of harts

... Purpose of Charts The purpose of charts is to make the information easier for depiction, by adding charts in a presentation or a document so that the other party understands the situation easily and quickly as well. At first Pie chart was introduced but later different sorts of charts were introduced. By adding charts in the presentation, the product looks defined. There are several types of charts, Pie charts Bar charts Polar charts Are charts Stock charts etc Gantt Chats Gantt Chars are used mostly for the purpose of project management. Projects are scheduled and planned on a Gantt chart. Gantt chart is a horizontal bar chart by which the benchmarks could... ...
1 Pages(250 words)Essay

Electing Judges

... Electing Judges In partisan election method, those individuals that are running for the position of judge have their ballot papers which even indicate the political party they belong to (Segal 182). In this kind of elections that are various factors that may affect my voting decision. My voting decision will be impacted by identification with the party. This means that my voting decision will be dependent on how the party has performed in the past, this will impact will especially take place if a new face or novice judge is running for the elections. If the judge has already served before, my decision will dependant on how fairly the judge has been operating and whether or not he has previously based his decisions in compliance with my...
1 Pages(250 words)Essay

Judges Rule on the Basis of Law

... Judges Rule on the Basis of Law Introduction In the legal systems of any given state, judges play a very significant role. However, for the judges to work efficiently the independence of the legal system need to be upheld. This is because judges should make rulings as per the law but not the opinions of the public. Judges are also required to differ from pressures in existence if their ruling is to be regarded as fair. In any given case, pressure from either groups of people or individuals should not deter the judges from making their rulings according to the law (Reavley, 2002). However, there is an argument made that the government is a human affair. Contrary to the fact that the judge should rule in accordance to the law, critics...
11 Pages(2750 words)Case Study

Exercises for judges

... Exercises for “judges” Ann and Barnaby are best friends and on this particular day, Barnaby had gone to Ann’s house for a sleep over. Ann’s parents had travelled out of town and had suggested that Barnaby comes over to keep Ann company. The girls had a good time as they watched a series of movies that they loved and talked about fashion to boys. The only people who were aware they were all aloe were Barnaby’s parents. The girls were so engrossed with painting their nails that they did not hear the front door open. The one thing that jilted their attention was that the security alarm went off when the door was opened (Dressler 43). Ann rushed to the door and quickly put the alarm off. Little did she know that a man had entered their house...
1 Pages(250 words)Essay

Revenue Recognition

... standards that focus on revenue and construction contracts respectively. The standards are difficult to understand and application in a situation. They provide minimal guidance concerning revenue recognition used for multiple arrangements. FASB and IASB has set new accounting rules designed to assist converge global standards. The current and proposed standards will change how companies in the United States recognize their revenue on their financial and statements (http://www.fasb.org/intl/convergence_iasb.shtml). The proposed standards will have some different effects on various companies. The effects may include changes in the amount of deliverables of the contract. The standards will affect the manner in which revenue is allocated...
1 Pages(250 words)Assignment

Harts Primary and Secondary Rules

This paper tells that law is not always meant to be coercive and in many instances provides guidelines and powers for various types of human activity. Hart states that a good legal system should be governed by primary and secondary rules. A legal system can be considered to be complete only if both these sets of rules exist. Hart distinguishes between primitive and developed legal systems in this regard. A developed system will have both primary and secondary rules while a primitive one will only have primary rules. A primitive legal system will not be well organized and will have elements of uncertainty and inefficiency. It will also be static in nature. Primary rules directly provide the ways in which...

16 Pages(4000 words)Research Paper
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Essay on topic Judges as Lawmakers: Harts Rule of Recognition for FREE!

Contact Us