StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Murray & Co Entered into a Contract with Annabel Constructions Ltd - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
From the paper "Murray & Co Entered into a Contract with Annabel Constructions Ltd" it is clear that it is important to distinguish a valid offer from an invitation to offer. An invitation to offer is a statement that invites a person to a negotiation which may end up in the formation of a contract…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER94.4% of users find it useful
Murray & Co Entered into a Contract with Annabel Constructions Ltd
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Murray & Co Entered into a Contract with Annabel Constructions Ltd"

The acceptance of an invitation to offer does not create an agreement. The acceptance of this invitation means that the addressee makes an offer that, when accepted by the address or, becomes an agreement (Adams, 2012).

Acceptance of an offer must be communicated to the offeror and must be absolute. A qualified acceptance is not a valid acceptance. Both parties must agree to the same thing in the same sense i.e. there must be consensus ad idem. A qualified acceptance is a counteroffer that immediately terminates the original offer. However, when the counteroffer is accepted by the original offeror, an agreement is created. The agreement should have consideration for both parties. There must be a benefit and a detriment to both parties. There are a few exceptions to this rule like in agreements involving gifts. Generally, consideration is an essential element of a valid agreement. An agreement becomes a contract when it is legally enforceable by law. This is why it is extremely important that the parties involved have an intention to create legal relations. Otherwise, the agreement would just be a social one and would be unable to be enforced through courts if there is a breach by any party (Adams, 2012).

Murray & Co. entered into a contract with Annabel Constructions Ltd. They were required to supply and fit double-glazed windows. They were desperate to get the contract which is why they were under-quoted and ended up having major financial difficulties during the fulfillment of their duties. Further, there were no penalty clauses in their contract which is why Murray & Co. decided to exit the contract and communicated their inability to deliver the windows to Annabel Constructions Ltd. This decision really put Annabel Ltd. in a spot as they depended on Murray & Co. to honour a contract of their own which did have a penalty clause. Looking to minimize their costs, Annabel Smith, the CEO of Annabel Constructions Ltd, offered an additional amount of £20000 to Murray & Co. to fulfil their promise as agreed. Murray & Co. managed to perform their duty but Annabel refused to pay the extra £20000.

As discussed above, consideration is a very essential element of a legally binding contract. Consideration also has to be valid in that it has to have its counterpart. In Stilk v Myrick, it was held that where a promise of additional payment is made for carrying out a pre-existing duty, the consideration is not valid. It is because the consideration for the duty has already been provided by the previous contract. Under this case, Murray & Co. are not entitled to claim the extra £20000 because they have only completed the duty the consideration for which was provided by their original contract with Annabel.

However, the solution provided by Stilk is very old and it was modified by Williams v Roffey Bros & Nicholls (Contractors) Ltd (Abbott & Pendlebury, 2013). In this case, the courts held that where "factual benefits" are given from one to another party, there is a valid consideration. The given scenario is very similar to this case. In this case, the defendants, being building contractors, had entered into an agreement with a housing association to refurbish a block of 27 flats. The contract had a clause for liquidated damages if it was not completed on time. The contract demanded some carpentry work for which the defendants engaged the claimant for an agreed price of £20,000. The claimant realized after 6 months of commencing the work that the price was too low and the work could not have been done at this price. He communicated this fact to the defendants who agreed to pay an additional £575 per flat. However, he only received £500 which was insufficient for him to complete the work.

The defendants hired another carpenter to complete the contract and refused to pay the claimant the further sums promised. They maintained that the claimant had not provided any consideration for the additional benefit. It was held that the claimant was providing a benefit to the defendants by helping them in avoiding the penalty clause. Similarly, in the given case, Murray & Co. has performed a pre-existing duty but they are also helping Annabel Constructions Ltd. in avoiding a penalty amounting to £100 per day of delay to all the buyers who experienced a delay in getting possession of their apartment.

This means that Annabel’s defense on the grounds that Murray & Co. have performed a pre-existing duty, and they have not provided any consideration for the additional £20000 would be rejected by the courts. The courts would honour the arrangement under which Murray & Co. promised to deliver on time for an additional £20000. In return, Annabel receives the factual benefit of avoiding the penalty under a separate contract which may have been up to £100000 if the work was not completed on time. Hence, Murray & Co. are entitled to the additional £20000 as promised by Annabel Constructions Ltd.

Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Assessment Requirements Annabel Constructions Ltd. are engaged in the Essay”, n.d.)
Assessment Requirements Annabel Constructions Ltd. are engaged in the Essay. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/law/1645085-assessment-requirements-annabel-constructions-ltd-are-engaged-in-the-business-of-building-residential-flats-at-present-the-company-has-just-completed-a-construction-project-comprising-of-100-apartments-all-of-which-were-fully-booked-at-the-start-of-th
(Assessment Requirements Annabel Constructions Ltd. Are Engaged in the Essay)
Assessment Requirements Annabel Constructions Ltd. Are Engaged in the Essay. https://studentshare.org/law/1645085-assessment-requirements-annabel-constructions-ltd-are-engaged-in-the-business-of-building-residential-flats-at-present-the-company-has-just-completed-a-construction-project-comprising-of-100-apartments-all-of-which-were-fully-booked-at-the-start-of-th.
“Assessment Requirements Annabel Constructions Ltd. Are Engaged in the Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/law/1645085-assessment-requirements-annabel-constructions-ltd-are-engaged-in-the-business-of-building-residential-flats-at-present-the-company-has-just-completed-a-construction-project-comprising-of-100-apartments-all-of-which-were-fully-booked-at-the-start-of-th.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Murray & Co Entered into a Contract with Annabel Constructions Ltd

Advice and Recommendations for WWD

Breach of a contract attracts compensation under liquidated damages.... Advice and Recommendations for WWD Before taking into account the reasons of parting ways by the offeror and the offered, we have to peruse the contents of contract and subsequent betrayals.... For the offeror and the offered, it is important to understand the difference of bilateral and unilateral contracts to ink an effective contract....   Accordingly, if an acceptance takes place, binding contract is constituted....
9 Pages (2250 words) Essay

Construction Management and Contract Law

There is a need to have a defined contract with the architect for the deliverables that is expected off him.... In order to understand and to clearly ensure that either of the parties have understood the complexities involved it is essential that a contract is drawn.... Every contract has its own complexity in the agenda.... The contract under current consideration much more so and has its own complexities.... Most of the contract agreements not just specify the terms of the agreement legally, but also specify other formats that become day-to-day reporting formats and for metrics of the project and its progress....
19 Pages (4750 words) Essay

Business contract Law

only made a contract with Murray & Co.... arties to a contract must be competent and authorized to enter into a contract, and therefore, not all individuals are fully free to enter into a valid contract.... nnabel constructions ltd.... The consent of each of the parties in a contract must be genuine in the sense that they must agree to the same thing, in the same sense and at the sense time (Gillies, 2006: p143).... A promise differentiates from a contract in the sense that a valid contract creates an obligation to the parties and is enforceable in the court of law, whereas a promise without any consideration creates no legal obligation to be enforced in a court of laws (Kelly et....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Key Elements of a Binding Contract

nnabel constructions ltd.... Murray the completed the work within the original schedule but annabel constructions refused to pay the additional £ 20000 as had been agreed between the parties.... a contract must satisfy specific elements in order to bind parties to it.... Another essential element of a contract is acceptance of the offer and this must be consistent with terms of offer and within a reasonable period.... Parties to a contract must also have legal contractual capacity such as majority age, sound mind, and freedom from intoxicants....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Comparison and Contrast of the Poems For Annie and Annabel Lee Written by Edgar Allen Poe

The author compares and contrasts two poems "For Annie" and "annabel Lee" by Poe and states that are similar in the manner in which they address the loss of their beloved one.... However, the name Annie has been shortened in the poem For Annie, and it remains annabel in the poem annabel Lee.... annabel Lee is the last poem Edgar Poe wrote before his death.... That is confirmed by the several time the author refers to annabel as an oval portrait....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Construction Contracts: Freedom of Contract

The basic aim of the paper 'Construction Contracts: Freedom of contract' is for defining the business terms and conditions of the agreement.... In this regard, the parties to a construction contract are constrained by this basic aim of business contract drafting so that they are not free to incorporate.... The author states that as result freedom of contract is not an absolute right to the extent that parties are only at liberty to agree to terms and conditions that are lawful and consistent with the law of contract, construction law, and practices....
14 Pages (3500 words) Dissertation

Construction Contract

In the paper, the construction contract in question between GPD, the employer and CCL, is governed by the standard form of contract JCT 98.... of JCT 98 requires the contractor to carry out and complete the works undertaken strictly as mentioned in the documents of the contract.... According to the research findings, it can, therefore, be said that during the period of work in progress, the architect finds that cladding materials used are of an inferior quality not in compliance with specifications of the designs and contract documents....
15 Pages (3750 words) Case Study

Construction Contracts in Context

The author state that the employer's act or omission to act can cause a delay in the execution of the contract.... Adjudication especially meant for construction contract has been purposely provided for as a stop-gap arrangement for relief to the aggrieved party so that, if necessary, the adjudication order can be challenged.... Adjudication especially meant for construction contract has been purposely provided for as a stop gap arrangement for relief to the aggrieved party so that, if necessary, the adjudication order can be challenged....
14 Pages (3500 words) Assignment
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us