StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...

Collision Insurance Requirement and Traffic Safety Act in Gonzalez vs. Raich's case - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
This research presents collision insurance requirement and traffic safety act in Gonzalez vs. Raich's case. The US Supreme Court ruled that Congress had the mandate to regulate intrastate and non-economic if it formed part of the broader regulatory scheme…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER94.6% of users find it useful
Collision Insurance Requirement and Traffic Safety Act in Gonzalez vs. Raichs case
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Collision Insurance Requirement and Traffic Safety Act in Gonzalez vs. Raich's case"

Download file to see previous pages

This paper illustrates that the individual mandate will be a crucial part of the CIRTSA’s plan to reduce car accident costs. If individuals do not have to purchase insurance, then the companies offering the service cannot ensure others who are affected by accidents. It is possible to argue that, under the Commerce Clause, Congress can regulate those activities that will significantly impact on interstate commerce by contending that the motor insurance market is a significant player in the national US economy.

Therefore, uninsured drivers will use roads and fail to pay for the billions of dollars the sector is worth annually, shifting the costs to society and significantly impacting on interstate commerce. The US Supreme Court ruling in Gonzalez vs. Raich relied in part on Wickard v. Filburn, which can be, in this case, to hold that the refusal of many individuals to buy collision insurance would substantially impact on the market for collision insurance. This is because even if, the activity of the individual may not be considered commerce, Congress could still treat it as such because it exerts substantial effects interstate commerce economically, especially if many people lose their livelihoods, such as with Robert Doe.

A substantial number of Americans will require collision insurance at some point and, if they do not purchase insurance, they will be shifting their costs to other individuals. This law should be introduced as a regulation for how people pay for their likely collision insurance. Finally, if the Act is challenged in court, it can be argued that laws must be presumed constitutional if it is impossible to prove otherwise. Because Congress is entrusted by the Constitution with policy decisions, the courts should rarely interfere with its policies.

The second argument could come in if the Commerce Clause is found insufficient to support CIRTSA’s individual mandate. In this case, the mandate should be upheld as being within the powers of Congress to lay taxes and collect them.

...Download file to see next pages Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Collision Insurance Requirement and Traffic Safety Act in Gonzalez vs Essay”, n.d.)
Collision Insurance Requirement and Traffic Safety Act in Gonzalez vs Essay. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/law/1638607-public-health-law-please-not-exceed-750-words-to-write-the-memo-you-should-use-only-the-following-materials-files-i-gonna-attached
(Collision Insurance Requirement and Traffic Safety Act in Gonzalez Vs Essay)
Collision Insurance Requirement and Traffic Safety Act in Gonzalez Vs Essay. https://studentshare.org/law/1638607-public-health-law-please-not-exceed-750-words-to-write-the-memo-you-should-use-only-the-following-materials-files-i-gonna-attached.
“Collision Insurance Requirement and Traffic Safety Act in Gonzalez Vs Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/law/1638607-public-health-law-please-not-exceed-750-words-to-write-the-memo-you-should-use-only-the-following-materials-files-i-gonna-attached.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Collision Insurance Requirement and Traffic Safety Act in Gonzalez vs. Raich's case

The Requirements of the Credit Act

One of the ways in which the Act protects consumers is by laying down the form and contents which agreements are to be composed of, providing redressal procedures that must be adopted in case there is a default or a termination of the credit arrangement by either party and by disallowing extortionate credit bargains.... The paper 'The Requirements of the Credit act' focuses on the development of the credit phenomenon which is equivalent to money lending in that exorbitant rates of interest may be charged to consumers for the privilege of paying for services through the use of credit rather than cash....
7 Pages (1750 words) Case Study

Aircraft Safety and Human Factor

Humans can better understand and grasp the situation and act accordingly to sort out the risks.... In the essay “Aircraft safety and Human Factor” the author focuses on the departments of quality, safety, technical and maintenance to provide safer travel to the passengers of aircraft.... The equipment failure is a major hazard which needs to be mitigated to ensure safety.... Crew Resource Management in UAS Operations Crew Resource Management (CRM) is a function that ensures the safety, standards, and availability of trained professionals for UAS operations....
1 Pages (250 words) Case Study

Are traffic fatalities another consequence

They postulated potential negative effects of the spring break on traffic safety with knowledge gap I the area that they sought to bridge.... The results also call for awareness policies for safety precautions in the areas during the seasons in order to prevent traffic fatalities that increase during the season.... In the paper “Are traffic fatalities another consequence?... rdquo; the author analyzes French and Gumus's article, 'Are traffic fatalities another consequence?...
2 Pages (500 words) Case Study

Analysis of Insurance Case Study

In this case, Jessica should revise down expenses such as entertainment, clothing as well as groceries.... This means that he is covered by the time he retires but he needs to make sure that health and life insurance policies are covered since anything can happen.... Essentially, Jessica should prioritize life and insurance issues considering that her children are also under her custody....
2 Pages (500 words) Case Study

Aviation Human Factors

The implementation of Traffic Collision Avoidance System added a safety barrier in preventing mid-air collisions (Dumitrache, 2013).... Pilots are expected to respond to the RA immediately unless that action would jeopardize the safety of the flight.... It functions by tracking the airspace encircling one aircraft for other aircrafts that are free of air traffic control to avoid it traffic Collision Avoidance System traffic Collision Avoidance System I....
2 Pages (500 words) Case Study

Effectiveness of Systems Integrity Assurance Actions - Maxil Aerospace

In this case, despite the fact that Maxil has a team of capable programmers, their knowledge of the ADA and Assembler programming languages, which are utilized in the development of software in the aviation industry, was insufficient.... This report presents an analysis of the events leading to the accident; it not only indicates how the events contributed to the incident but also makes recommendations on how improvements can be made in the development of safety-critical systems at Maxil....
7 Pages (1750 words) Case Study

High Level of Risks and Safety Challenges while Crossing Streets

Therefore, it is crucial for planners and engineers, traffic safety and enforcement professionals, public health and injury prevention professionals, and decision-makers to be responsible for promoting pedestrian safety at the state or local level to plan, design and build safe walking and crossing networks.... The following paper 'High Level of Risks and safety Challenges while Crossing Streets' presents pedestrians who are legit users of the street facilities, and they should hence be able to have access to the facility safely and without unyielding delays....
6 Pages (1500 words) Case Study

Health and Safety Management at the University of Lancashire

The author of the paper "Health and safety Management at the University of Lancashire" will begin with the statement that workplace safety requirements for construction sites are usually stringent considering various risk factors that are continuously present in the worksite.... million individuals work in Britain's construction industry, Health and safety Executive (HSE), Britain's government agency for workplace health and safety, is apt to implement strict rules, regulations, and other legal boundaries that construction companies must conform to in order to operate within England's political domain (HSE 2009)....
8 Pages (2000 words) Case Study
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us