StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Is Andrew Obliged to Supply a 1,500 Computer to Betty, Colin and Edith - Coursework Example

Cite this document
Summary
The paper "Is Andrew Obliged to Supply a 1,500 Computer to Betty, Colin and Edith?" states that according to the facts, Colin called Andrew in the afternoon of 31st January to place an order but no one answered the phone because Andrew observes half-day on Wednesdays…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER91.5% of users find it useful
Is Andrew Obliged to Supply a 1,500 Computer to Betty, Colin and Edith
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Is Andrew Obliged to Supply a 1,500 Computer to Betty, Colin and Edith"

Business Law By Due The essential elements of a legally binding contract are offer, acceptance, consideration and an intention to create legal relations. A valid offer needs to be a clear statement that explains the terms on which a party is prepared to do business with another party. An offer is meant to clearly signify the intent of a party. Sometimes, statements made during negotiations or made just to invite an offer are mistaken as valid offers. Invitation to offer includes advertisements and tenders. These are not offers in the context of contract law and their acceptance does not lead to a formation of a contract. Offers can be general or specific. General offers are meant for general public and anyone who can fulfill the conditions of the offer can accept it. Specific offers are made to specific parties and can be accepted only by them. An offer can be revoked at any time before it is accepted. In the given case, Andrew circulated a flyer to local businesses which means that he made a general offer to all of them. Andrew made his offer in the beginning of the month of January. His advertisement stated that “any orders notified by the end of January will be met at the special discount price of £1,500”. Andrew found this offer to be too generous and decided to revoke it. He posted a letter of revocation to the same businesses on 20th of January. However, a revocation cannot be effective unless the offeree knows of it. In Dickenson v Dodds1, the defendant offered to sell property to the plaintiff. Before the plaintiff could reply, the defendant sold the property to a third party. A friend of the plaintiff told him that the house was sold. It was held that the offer was effectively revoked and was no longer open for acceptance because the plaintiff’s friend’s intimation was adequate notice and a reasonable person would have easily deemed the offer to have been revoked. In the given case, it is important to consider whether the acceptance was completed before the offer was revoked. Andrew communicated his revocation of offer through post on the 20th of January as against himself but the letter was not delivered before the 2nd of February. In Adams v Lindsell2, a famous rule called “Postal Rule” was established according to which the acceptance of an offer is complete when a letter of acceptance has been posted. However, this rule is not applicable on the communication of revocation of offer by post. In Stevenson, Jacques & Co v McLean3, the plaintiff was an iron merchant who purchased iron and sold it to third parties. The defendant, holder of warrants (titles) for quantities of iron, offered to sell iron to the plaintiff by telegram also stating that the offer would be open till Monday. The plaintiff asked the defendant for some additional information but the defendant did not respond and sold the warrants to another party on Monday. He sent a telegram to the plaintiff on the same day which said that the warrants were sold to another party. Before the telegram could reach the plaintiff, he sent a telegram to the plaintiff in which he accepted the defendant’s offer. Later, the plaintiff sued the defendant for non-delivery. It was held that the defendant was at liberty to revoke his offer at any time before its acceptance but it could not have been effective until it had actually reached the plaintiff. Since the plaintiff had accepted the offer before the notice of revocation of offer had reached him, the revocation was ineffective. In the given case, Andrew’s revocation of offer could not reach Betty, Colin and Edith before the 2nd of February. Also, his offer pertained only to the orders placed before the end of January. Therefore, by the application of Stevenson, Jacques & Co v McLean, Andrew’s revocation of offer is ineffective. The other important aspect of this case is whether the acceptance is effective. The acceptance of an offer needs to be a mirror image of the offer. It must reciprocate all the terms of the offer. If an offer requires some conditions to be fulfilled, the fulfillment of those conditions is necessary so that there is a valid acceptance. In Hyde v Wrench4, the defendant offered to sell his farm to the plaintiff for £1000. The plaintiff replied that he was willing to pay £950 for the same. The defendant refused to sell the farm at £950. Then the plaintiff asked to purchase the farm at £1000 but the defendant refused to sell. It was held that the subsequent acceptance by the plaintiff was ineffective and there was no contract because the counter-offer of purchasing the farm at £950 by the plaintiff had destroyed the original offer. Acceptance of an offer also needs to be communicated to the offeror. In Powell v Lee5, the plaintiff applied for a job as headmaster and the defendants, the school managers decided to appoint him. One of the managers acted out of his authority and told the plaintiff that he was appointed. The managers later decided to appoint somebody else. The plaintiff sued the defendants on the grounds that there was a breach of a contract to employ him and he had suffered damages in loss of salary. It was held that there was no contract between the parties involved because the communication of acceptance was not valid. In the given case, the offer by Andrew specifically requires that the orders are needed to be placed by the end of January. This means that if an order is placed in February, it would not be met at the special discount price of £1500. It has already been determined that Andrew’s revocation of offer is ineffective. The remaining question is whether the orders were placed in time by Betty, Colin and Edith. Betty According to the given case, Betty placed the order for a computer on the 30th of January. Andrew did not see Betty’s letter until the 1st of February. Betty communicated her acceptance of Andrew’s offer through a letter which is why Postal Rule would be applied in this case. Therefore, the acceptance of offer was complete at the time when Betty posted her letter to Andrew i.e. on 30th of January. As Betty has complied with the conditions of Andrew’s offer by placing her order by the end of January and Andrew’s revocation is nullified, Andrew is obliged to supply a £1500 computer to Betty. Colin According to the facts, Colin called Andrew in the afternoon of 31st January to place an order but no one answered the phone because Andrew observes half-day on Wednesdays. Colin sent an order by fax that was received subsequently on Andrew’s fax machine at 4pm. In Entores Ltd v Miles Far East Corporation6, a London-based trading company sent an offer by telex for the purchase of copper cathodes from a company based in Amsterdam which accepted the offer in the same mode. The contract was not fulfilled. It was held that the Postal Rule is not applicable in cases where Telex is used as the mode of communication. The acceptance is completed only when it is actually received by the offeror. Similar judgement can be seen in Brinkibon Ltd v Stahag Stahl7. In the given case, Colin’s acceptance of Andrew’s offer is completed on the 1st of February i.e. when Andrew actually saw Colin’s fax. This means that Colin did not place his order by the end of January and is not entitled to a computer at a discounted price. Therefore, Andrew is not obliged to send a £1500 computer to Colin. Edith Edith sent an e-mail order on the 31st January, at 20.14, which was only received by Andrew’s computer at 02:23am the following day. In the judgement of Entores Ltd v Miles Far East Corporation, Denning LJ stated that “the rule about instantaneous communications between the parties is different from the rule about the post. The contract is only complete when the acceptance is received by the offeror: and the contract is made at the place where the acceptance is received”8. Like Telex, email is also a mode of instantaneous communication which means that acceptance is complete only when it is actually received by the offeror. Andrew’s computer received the email when the date on the calendar was 1st of February. But importantly, Andrew himself saw the email in the morning of the 1st of February. Therefore, Edith’s acceptance of offer was not completed by the end of January. By the application of Entores Ltd v Miles Far East Corporation and Brinkibon Ltd v Stahag Stahl, Andrew is not obliged to send £1500 computer to Edith. References Adams v Lindsell [1818] EWHC KB J59 Brinkibon Ltd v Stahag Stahl [1983] 2 AC 34 Dickinson v Dodds [1876] 2 Ch D 463 Entores Ltd v Miles Far East Corporation [1955] EWCA Civ 3 Hyde v Wrench [1840] EWHC Ch J90 Powell v Lee [1908] 99 LT 284 Stevenson, Jaques & CO v McLean [1880] 5 QBD 346 Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Is Andrew obliged to supply a 1,500 computer to Betty, Colin and Edith Coursework”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/law/1609244-is-andrew-obliged-to-supply-a-1500-computer-to-betty-colin-and-edith
(Is Andrew Obliged to Supply a 1,500 Computer to Betty, Colin and Edith Coursework)
https://studentshare.org/law/1609244-is-andrew-obliged-to-supply-a-1500-computer-to-betty-colin-and-edith.
“Is Andrew Obliged to Supply a 1,500 Computer to Betty, Colin and Edith Coursework”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/law/1609244-is-andrew-obliged-to-supply-a-1500-computer-to-betty-colin-and-edith.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Is Andrew Obliged to Supply a 1,500 Computer to Betty, Colin and Edith

Sole Trader Startup Business Strategy

Consistency is key to business success hence the need to get suppliers who have the capacity to supply the shop according to the growing demand.... 3,500 Renovations and decorations: ?... 1,500 Total set up cost:?... The purpose of the present assignment is to develop a comprehensive business proposal for a stationery shop....
10 Pages (2500 words) Assignment

GLOBAL LOGISTICS AND SUPPLY CHAIN MANAGEMENT

Arguably, Economic order quantity is a model used in enabling companies making the optimal quantities of stock; notably, the quantity amounts is recorded as the ordering and holding cost and are minimized.... In simple terms, companies use EOQ model in minimizing costs that are.... ... ... Therefore, EOQ can be defined as the model used in calculating the optimal quantity that can be produced or purchased to reduce the cost of processing purchase and carrying inventory. ...
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Supply and Demand II

Use the following table showing the relationship between quantity demanded, quantity supplied, and price in the market for Movie Tickets to answer questions 3a-b:Table 1 : Price, Quantity Demanded (Qd), Quantity Supplied (Qs) of Movie Tickets PQdQs£105030 124535 144040 163545 183050Draw the market supply and demand curves for Movie Tickets from the information provided in the table.... Use Figure 2 to answer questions 5a-d:Figure 2: Demand and supply with Subsidya....
2 Pages (500 words) Assignment

Andrei Rublev's The Holy Trinity

In exploring the evolution of the artwork in Russia, the essay focuses on the work of one of the iconic painters, called andrew Rublev.... The first section is an analysis of the biography of andrew Rublev.... Olsufiev describes andrew Rublev as one of the iconic painters in the Russian History.... Information on andrew's biography is very scanty.... According to the Russian Orthodox Church andrew was first mention as a painter when under the apprenticeship of Theophanes the Greek....
9 Pages (2250 words) Research Paper

Supply Chain Management: Crown PLC

The focus of this paper 'supply Chain Management: Crown PLC' is on Crown PLC which is planning to open a Distribution Center in Australia.... nformation technology is bound to play an important role in supply Chain Management.... The fast exchange of information makes it easier to communicate any matters/problems that would previously hamper/delay the supply chain in days.... Speed, reliability, and accountability in terms of service deliveries define the success and competitive advantage of companies in which the leading trading firms strategically manage time in their supply chains (Kosteck, 1996)....
15 Pages (3750 words) Case Study

The Repair and Supply of Computer Parts in the Computer Galore Company

The reporter states that the computer Galore Company deals with the repair and supply of computer parts.... computer Galore complement the computer retail business by offering repair service after the computer's warranty coverage has elapsed.... computer Galore will engage in the selling of computer parts and software and is also engaged in the customization, upgrade, repair, virus removal and hard disk data recovery of computers (Du et al, 2008)....
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay

Computer Programming Techniques

The author of the paper "computer Programming Techniques" concerns a clear outline to the users of the program on technical problems solved, variables, and constants that they deal with, the guidelines recommend when carrying out the designing program tests, modern engineering practice description.... The current is computed from the division of the supply voltage (V) and the complex impendence (Z)....
6 Pages (1500 words) Assignment

Supply Chain Management in the Computer Industry

This paper "Supply Chain Management in the computer Industry" uncovered how the efficient use of supply chain management results in a company having the potential to secure additional market share by end-product price savings generated by internal cost reductions.... The computer industry is a prime example regarding the use of supply chain management.... The other characteristics of the computer industry are that models change almost yearly (Purdue University, 2018)....
10 Pages (2500 words) Coursework
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us