StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Dunkle v. State, 2006 Okla. Crim. 29, 139 P.3d 228, 2006 Okla. Crim. App. Lexis 29 (2006), - Assignment Example

Cite this document
Summary
The appellant Laura Dunkle was charged with first degree murder and sentenced to life term imprisonment without the possibility of parole in Oklahoma state court in 2004. Laura Dunkle’s fiancé at the time Gary Benton White was found dead by a gunshot to chest in front of…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER95.2% of users find it useful

Extract of sample "Dunkle v. State, 2006 Okla. Crim. 29, 139 P.3d 228, 2006 Okla. Crim. App. Lexis 29 (2006),"

Dunkle v. Dunkle v. 2006 Okla. Crim. 29, 139 P.3d 228, 2006 Okla. Crim. App. Lexis 29 (2006) Facts: The appellant Laura Dunkle was charged with first degree murder and sentenced to life term imprisonment without the possibility of parole in Oklahoma state court in 2004. Laura Dunkle’s fiancé at the time Gary Benton White was found dead by a gunshot to chest in front of Dunkle’s home. Dunkle had given numerous statements, which were not consistent, to the Corporal from the Sheriff’s office at the scene and then to O.S.B.

I special agent. Due to this she was suspected, then arrested and produced to the court. It was argued by the state prosecutors that Dunkle’s statements were not in accordance with the evidence at the scene and she had intentionally killed the victim. Character evidence was used in the court for the purpose of proving action and computer-generated crime scene re-enactments were used to persuade the jury that the state’s version were consistent with evidence at the scene and the defendant’s was not.

Based on this, Dunkle was convicted of first degree murder. Dunkle has now appealed for her sentence and conviction.Issue: The issue is whether, by using improper character evidence, the appellant was denied of a fair trial. It is to be seen if character evidence provided is relevant and admissible in the court of law. Another issue is whether the computer-generated re-enactments are actual images of the crime or a set of possibilities.Decision of the Court:Previously, the Court had convicted Dunkle of first degree murder, but the decision has now been reversed and the case has been remanded for a new trial.

It was found that there were reversible errors in admitting of computer-generated reconstructions and, irrelevant and inappropriate character evidence. Reasoning of the Court:The previous court had decided that the character evidence showcased and the evidence from computer-generated re-enactments were sufficient to prove that Dunkle had committed the crime and hence was convicted of first degree murder. But this court is of the opinion that evidence is insufficient to justify the decision. The court came to this conclusion as most of the arguments of the State were directed towards establishing that Dunkle had a bad character and a person who would kill someone but there was no attempt made to establish an apparent motive for the crime.

The majority of the character evidence presented was irrelevant to the murder charge. And with respect to computer-generated re-enactments, the evidence only proves that defendant’s version is not consistent with the evidence at the scene but in no way proves the claim of the state that the defendant killed the victim. There is no solid data to back the state’s version. Therefore, as the argument of the state does not go with legal reasoning, the court had decided to reverse the decision.

Citations to support judgment:Wilkett v. State, 1984 OK CR 16, PP10-12, 674 P.2d 573, 576Burks v. State, 1979 OK CR 10, P2, 594 P.2d 771, 772Harris v. State, 2000 OK CR 20, 13 P.3d 489Rule of Law:Character evidence can be used to convict a defendant only if it can directly prove that the defendant is guilty of charged offense. If not it is admissible for other purposes such as intent, opportunity, motive, etc but cannot be used to convict.Dissent:Lumpkin, Vice-Presiding Judge, felt that the Appellant was denied a fair trial by showcasing of improper character evidence.

They felt that character evidence was not admissible as it did not fall under any of the established exceptions. The defendant’s connection with witchcraft was over emphasised by the prosecution which distracted the jury’s attention from facts and laws upon which the case should have been decided.

Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Dunkle v. State, 2006 Okla. Crim. 29, 139 P.3d 228, 2006 Okla. Crim Assignment”, n.d.)
Dunkle v. State, 2006 Okla. Crim. 29, 139 P.3d 228, 2006 Okla. Crim Assignment. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/law/1592456-dunkle-v-state-2006-okla-crim-29-139-p3d-228-2006-okla-crim-app-lexis-29-2006
(Dunkle V. State, 2006 Okla. Crim. 29, 139 P.3d 228, 2006 Okla. Crim Assignment)
Dunkle V. State, 2006 Okla. Crim. 29, 139 P.3d 228, 2006 Okla. Crim Assignment. https://studentshare.org/law/1592456-dunkle-v-state-2006-okla-crim-29-139-p3d-228-2006-okla-crim-app-lexis-29-2006.
“Dunkle V. State, 2006 Okla. Crim. 29, 139 P.3d 228, 2006 Okla. Crim Assignment”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/law/1592456-dunkle-v-state-2006-okla-crim-29-139-p3d-228-2006-okla-crim-app-lexis-29-2006.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Dunkle v. State, 2006 Okla. Crim. 29, 139 P.3d 228, 2006 Okla. Crim. App. Lexis 29 (2006),

Macro and Micro Economics of the Country

Country Name Australia Brazil China Spain Zimbabwe 1998 21 364,21 4 980,99 820,86 15 126,43 522,11 1999 20 578,83 3 413,26 864,73 15 475,52 552,83 2000 21 708,04 3 696,15 949,18 14 413,79 534,79 2001 19 541,42 3 129,76 1 041,64 14 952,09 538,96 2002 20 100,99 2 812,33 1 135,45 16 611,71 503,03 2003 23 445,60 3 041,68 1 273,64 21 041,54 454,10 2004 30 375,83 3 609,88 1 490,38 24 468,75 460,84 2005 33 944,98 4 743,27 1 731,13 26 056,39 457,83 2006 35 986,07 5 793,40 2 069,34 28 024,75 434,48 2007 40 461,07 7 197,03 2 651,26 32 118,10 423,99 2008 49 232,97 8 628,95 3 413,59 34 977,39 354,63 2009 42 333,45 8 391,67 3 749,27 31 714,24 491,68 2010 51 628,60 10 992,94 4 433,36 29 956,16 591,29 2011 61 789,48 12 593,89 5 444,79 31 984,73 757,09 This table proposes the different picture....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

Valuation of Shares: TESCO plc

This report analyses the behavior of the stock in the past five years links it to the financial performance of the company and predicts the future trend that may emerge.... This report also analyses the value of the TESCO share as an instrument for investment in absolute terms.... nbsp;… TESCO is the largest grocery retailer in the UK....
12 Pages (3000 words) Term Paper

Barnsieydale Sales-Related Data for 2004 and 2005 Report

There are various ways of adding and counting data (Microsoft Corporation 2006), the most appropriate are a simple addition and addition with one or more criteria.... Peltier (2006) concludes that pie charts are good when you are showing the relative proportion of numbers that add up to a total, for a single series of data and when there are not too many wedges, particularly too many small ones....
8 Pages (2000 words) Research Paper

Interacting with Others as a Major Life Activity under the ADA

Title I of the ADA protects individuals with disabilities from discrimination in the employment context.... To be entitled to such protection a person must: (i) be employed by an entity covered by the ADA, (ii) be disabled within the meaning of the ADA, (iii) be otherwise qualified to perform the essential functions of her job, with or without reasonable accommodation, and (iv) have an adverse employment action taken against her on the basis of her disability....
9 Pages (2250 words) Essay

The Presumption of Innocence in English Law

In answering the above there needs to be a discussion on competence and compellability as well as the usage of similar fact evidence, hearsay evidence and the admissibility of any confession.... Within the realms of competence and compellability there will need to be an examination… One of the first observations that need to be made when considering the competence of a witness is the rules under the Youth Justice and Criminal Evidence Act 1999....
10 Pages (2500 words) Essay

Nokia Company from 2003-2008

The case study "Nokia Company from 2003-2008" states that The company's aim is to provide high-quality and innovative products and services that help the people to connect.... A majority of its products are sold through network operators, distributors, and its branded stores.... nbsp;… The paper shows that These stores are owned and managed by the retail partners of the company....
4 Pages (1000 words) Case Study

The Primary Purpose of the UK Housing Act 2004

The Halifax Building Society released the results of a research October 2006 which reflected that at least 300,000 dwellings were empty in England.... nbsp; This paper discusses the problems created by empty dwellings and how state and local government have met these challenges.... The problematic reasons were listed as vacancies as a result of “low demand for housing in the locality” lacking facilities, the undesirability of the property, its state of disrepair, not able to fund repairs, waiting for a market value to improve and lack of interest in the property....
51 Pages (12750 words) Research Paper

Measuring Allelolapathy in Plants

The inhibitory chemical is often released to the environment causing a negative effect on the growth and development of the neighboring plants (Gaudet, 2006).... This research paper "Measuring Allelolapathy in Plants" evaluates the possible effects of allelopathy of tree of heaven on a radish seed, as well as examines the possible effects of the acid rain upon and the effectiveness of the allelopathic chemicals that are secreted by the tree of heaven....
14 Pages (3500 words) Research Paper
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us