Differencies in substantive law and procedural law between common law and civil law - Essay Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
Common law originated from England in the eleventh century and spread to other countries (Nestorovska). Private law has been initiated in most countries because of the existence of common law…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER97.5% of users find it useful
Differencies in substantive law and procedural law between common law and civil law
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "Differencies in substantive law and procedural law between common law and civil law"

Task Introduction Civil laws trace their origin from the Roman law, and are majorly practiced in Europe. Common law originated from England in the eleventh century and spread to other countries (Nestorovska). Private law has been initiated in most countries because of the existence of common law. Substantive law refers to all laws that are under the section of public and private law, which include real properties and criminal laws (Beatty and Samuelson 12). Procedural laws are set of guidelines that determine the way a court rules and makes judgments. In this essay, the differences between common law, civil law, substantive law and procedural law are discussed.
Civil Law gives its priorities to the doctrines and especially on the reports of codifiers over jurisprudence. The Common Law conversely, gives its priorities to jurisprudence over the canon. To elaborate on the difference of priorities between civil and common law, examining the different roles of legislator in the countries that practice the law (Tetley). For example, French law allows separation of powers since the courts only apply ruling while legislature work is to legislate and make laws. The other difference is that common law canon’s functions is to differentiate cases that appear unsuited to civics, and at some point may criticizes judgments that are made in court that seem to be biased according ruling. The civil law doctrines function is to avoid confusion that might cause a wrong judgment according to legal literature. Therefore, it provides the right procedure for judging difficult cases.
Common law style of evaluating a case is different from the civil law style, since common law analyses cases that are similar in nature and extracts ruling from the previously set rules. The judge might add some rules and directions that do not exist to support the judgment made on the case. Civil law deals with legal principle that are firmly written to make decisions on certain cases (Tarr, 10). The judge comments on the history, the domain, and the application of the law accordingly without altering or adding some information. Therefore, the use and application of general mind is not allowed to be used in civil law to make judgments. Another difference is that civil law majors on the rights and compulsion to get the remedies of a case. It cannot make judgments without the use of legal doctrine that oversee the decision-making. On the contrary, common laws do not follow a set of guidelines or obligation to find a remedy to a case, but can add some knowledge of the law.
Substantive law characterizes the type of crime and how serious the crime is depending on the following reasons that might emerge; whether the suspect is has been involved in other criminal cases, whether they situation was a self defense or whether was a hate crime. Conversely, procedural law contains the rules, which assist the judge to make judgment according to the type of case at hand (Walston-Dunham, 153). It has the methods in which substantive law is structured and administered in the court.
Another difference is that substantive law has independent set of laws that it uses to determine the fate of a case while the procedural laws do not practice independent laws but have to adhere on the already set laws that are to be used without altering any information. The other difference between substantive and procedure law is that procedural describes the steps in which the court will follow and comply with when listening and making judgment. The substantive law defines how the handling of a case and the determination of judgment.
Common laws are different from civil laws in the following factors such as the remedies of the cases, the doctrine style, and the order of priority. Many countries practice either the substantive law or procedure law due to its historical background. The types of a law discussed help to solve various cases that are needed to be solved in a state.
Works Cited
Beatty, Jeffrey, and Samuelson, Susan. Legal Environment. Stamford: Cengage Learning. 2010.
Pg 12.
Nestorovska, Diana. Influences of Roman law and Civil Law on the Common
Law International Law / Internationales Recht. 2005. Pg 79. Web. October 18, 2011.
Available at:
Tarr, Alan. Judicial Process and Judicial Policymaking Stamford: Cengage Learning. 2009.
Pg 10.
Tetley, William, Mixed Jurisdictions: common law vs. civil law (codified and uncodified). Mc
Gill. 2004. Web. October 18, 2011.
Available at: Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
(“Differencies in substantive law and procedural law between common law Essay”, n.d.)
Differencies in substantive law and procedural law between common law Essay. Retrieved from
(Differencies in Substantive Law and Procedural Law Between Common Law Essay)
Differencies in Substantive Law and Procedural Law Between Common Law Essay.
“Differencies in Substantive Law and Procedural Law Between Common Law Essay”, n.d.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Differencies in substantive law and procedural law between common law and civil law

Common Law Lloyd v. Grace Smith & Co.28 wherein the solicitor was held for deceit by his managing clerk (Markesinis et al 2007). The courts used the test of sufficient consideration in respect of the liability of the employer for sexual assault torts by an employee. It is important to mention that both, the employer and the employee are held as join tortfeasors. 3-b Occupiers liability: The Occupier’s Liability Act 1957 and 1984 are different in application as the former applies to lawful visitors, while the latter applies to trespassers and those not covered under the former Act. In respect of the 1957 Act a common duty of care is owed to lawful visitors. It is not necessary...
15 Pages(3750 words)Essay

Business Law - common law question

...? Business Law - Common Law Question Introduction Law is a tool to regulate the social as well as economic behavior of the society. It is a collection of rules as well as regulations for governing the society by social institution. Laws are formulated by the government or the legislative body of the country. It is formulated to provide peace as well as order to the society. Law is based on two principles which are order in the system as well as coercion which signifies that without enforcement there is no law. Violation or breach of law may lead to taking legal actions as well as steps against the...
12 Pages(3000 words)Essay

Substantive Law

...The accused (Movie) Substantive Law is the basic law in written form and that defines rights as well as duties, which includes crimes together with punishments (contract law, criminal law, tort law, law of wills, etc.) responsibilities and civil rights within civil law. Procedural law on the other hand provides the mechanism through which the enforcement of the duties and rights would be realized. The procedural law therefore comprises of rules to be adhered to by a court while hearing and determining...
3 Pages(750 words)Movie Review

Criminal Law / Civil Law

...? Criminal Law: USA v. Dr. Robert W. Stokes Criminal Law: USA v. Dr. Robert W. Stokes The case against Dr. Robert stokes According to Cornell University Law School, “Criminal law involves prosecution by the government of a person for an act that has been classified as a crime” (Cornell University Law School, 2010, Para 1). In a criminal case, the government, through a prosecutor, files the case and if individuals subject to the criminal case are found guilty, they are liable for incarceration, fine payment, or both. However, in civil cases, guilty parties are liable to pay for the damages and give up property, but they are not imprisoned...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay

Criminal Law / Civil Law

...? Criminal Law Civil Law Detailed account of the key facts surrounding the case Robert Ray Courtney, a former pharmacist, who owned and operated the Research Medical Tower Pharmacy in Kansas City, Missouri Robert Ray Courtney was born in Kansas in the year 1952 and was educated at Wichita High School. After high School he was admitted at Missouri-Kansas city high school where he studies pharmacy. After his education he established a pharmacy in Kansas City at Research Medical Towers. In addition Courtney was reported to be an active member of his Assembly of God church in the Kansas City where he used to fellowship as contribute substantial amount of money to support church mission. In...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay

Common law and Civil law

...or Spanish colonies. One of the contrasting differences between the common law and the civil law is that the former has a historical basis; they are a development of the custom. As such, they were in use even before they were put in writing, and people continued using them even after they became written laws (Dainow, 1967). In contrast, civil laws, as practiced by France and its former colonies, are a development of the Corpus Juris Civilis of Justinian, which is a part of the Roman law (Von Mehren, 2000). In line with this, civil...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay

Difference- Common law/Civil law

...Differences between Common Law and Civil Law Families Civil law and Common law are contrasted against each other and there primary differences lie within their application. Common law has been usually developed by custom, which normally began before any laws that were penned down. The Common law continued to be applied within the domains of the court after the written laws were brought in place. Civil law came out of the...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

Common Law

...on account of balance of donation he had promised give @ £ 4,000 per year for five years. The court held that money had been promised to be paid by him merely as a charity and not in exchange of some thing the donees had given him in return what is known as consideration in law. The position would have been different had Hudson executed a gift deed which could not be construed as a contract in any case. Thus, an offer is a proposal or promise by one person to another to enter into a contract, on certain terms and conditions, with an intention to bind himself when the person to whom promise is made announces his acceptance. The offer may be made to one person or to a set of people, or to the general...
8 Pages(2000 words)Essay

International Law as a Substantive Law

... International Law as a Substantive Law The present day outcome and existence of International law is the yield of centuries old journey it has undergone. The most evident development came about in the 20th century and more predominately after the Second World War when United Nations organization was established. Under the banner of United Nations organization, two centralized and powerful entities came into existence, namely General Assembly and Security Council. They were permitted to making decisions with regard to the political and global peace. Their decisions and their effective role has been time and again subjected to the criticism with regard to revamping and...
7 Pages(1750 words)Essay

Compare between criminal law and civil law demonstrate guilt. It allows one to demonstrate blame, "past a sensible uncertainty to an ethical sureness" and generally needed to get a consistent decision of the jury before a blameworthy decision may be rendered if even one legal hearer declines to vote liable, either the charged gets another trial ("hung jury") or charges are dropped( White and Edward 53). Criminal Law vs. Civil Law There are numerous differences between criminal and civil law. Criminal law is a body of rules and statutes that defines conduct prohibited by the government because it threatens and harms public safety and welfare...
8 Pages(2000 words)Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Essay on topic Differencies in substantive law and procedural law between common law and civil law for FREE!

Contact Us