Nobody downloaded yet

Case Analysis: Her Majesty The Queen v. John Robin Sharpe - Assignment Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
Summary
The author of the paper analyzes such legal cases as Her Majesty The Queen v. John Robin Sharpe, Rudder v. Microsoft, Kanitz et al. v. Rogers Cable Inc, Spetch v. Netscape Communications Corp. The author examines the court’s ruling and expresses his/her opinion as to it…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER92% of users find it useful
Case Analysis: Her Majesty The Queen v. John Robin Sharpe
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "Case Analysis: Her Majesty The Queen v. John Robin Sharpe"

Download file to see previous pages In the case Her Majesty The Queen v. John Robin Sharpe, the defendant possessed a big collection of videos and photographs containing nude teenage boys involved in uncensored activities. Sharpe invoked the actions of the prosecutor as a violation of his right to freedom of expression, trying to prove the in-constitutionality of the Criminal Code provisions prohibiting possession of materials containing child pornography. Sharpe made an intensive attempt to refute the prosecutor’s arguments and to prove that he is not guilty of anything. The main legal issues that have arisen in this case regarded the following: a) is the possession of child pornography protected by the right to freedom of expression? b) are the provisions of the Criminal Code of Canada somehow infringing the liberties guaranteed by the Constitution?
2. Court’s ruling: The Court was forced to face and solve a constitutional challenge, aroused by a child pornography fan, which would have formed a powerful precedent in Canadian law. The Court agreed with the defendant in one thing: the prohibition of the Criminal Code provisions did represent a limitation of the freedom of expression. Nevertheless, this limitation was necessary for a country where morality is respected and protecting children is one of the main objectives of the whole society. However, the Court decided that possession of child pornography for exclusive personal usage does not harm the child directly, so it should not be outlawed. The charges against Sharpe were dropped, except the ones referring to the photographs. Sharpe was charged with the crimes of gross indecency (article 157 Criminal Code of Canada) and indecent assault against a minor boy (article 156 Criminal Code of Canada).
3. My opinion: I believe that ownership of child pornography for private usage should be also outlawed and declared as an exception to of the freedom of expression. ...Download file to see next pagesRead More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(Case Analysis: Her Majesty The Queen v. John Robin Sharpe Assignment, n.d.)
Case Analysis: Her Majesty The Queen v. John Robin Sharpe Assignment. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/law/1564043-leading-discussion
(Case Analysis: Her Majesty The Queen V. John Robin Sharpe Assignment)
Case Analysis: Her Majesty The Queen V. John Robin Sharpe Assignment. https://studentshare.org/law/1564043-leading-discussion.
“Case Analysis: Her Majesty The Queen V. John Robin Sharpe Assignment”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/law/1564043-leading-discussion.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Case Analysis: Her Majesty The Queen v. John Robin Sharpe

Robin Hood

...?Robin Hood Robin Hood and his band have one clear goal: to kill the Evil King and free the people of Nottingham/Sherwood Forest from oppression. Through a SWOT analysis it has been determined that there are numerous factors that support the success of the mission, but these may also pose issues in the short and long term. Strategically, the size of the group is problematic; however, the charismatic charm of the leader and his predisposition to reward the poor by stealing from the rich may compensate for this. New members are added on a regular basis, but there is a lack of screening, which allows for potential infiltration by enemy spies. While non-violent solutions may be the most...
1 Pages(250 words)Research Paper

Seigel v. Merrill Lynch Case Analysis

...Seigel v. Merrill Lynch Case Analysis Seigel v. Merrill Lynch Case Analysis Titus Rock Manickam Order No. 264221 23 December 2008 Seigel v. Merrill Lynch Case Analysis Introduction Merrill Lynch accidentally paid checks amounting to $143,000 to various casinos in Atlanta City, New Jersey, in spite of instructions from their client, Seigel, to stop payment against these checks. The payments were made to these casinos for the losses suffered by Seigel on account of gambling. Seigel dragged Merrill Lynch to court for the lapse. The court, however, ruled in favor of Merrill Lynch since the plaintiff was indebted to the casinos. Seigel owed the casinos monies for the losses incurred by him in gambling. Analysis... and...
2 Pages(500 words)Case Study

Jim Sharpe

...with the dynamics of the situation and keep increasing his learning curve. Before the finalization of a deal he should learn each and everything about the business he is buying. He should totally not rely on instincts solely but also use concrete facts to affirm his choice. After his deal he should first of all resolve those issues which are arising because of the labor union. He should embark upon a campaign to build relationship with his employees and customers. QUESTION # 2: Sharpe is falling short of the capital required to make the deal. Thus he is going for a leveraged buyout. The upside of this way of transacting is the availability of liquidity and flipping. However, the second benefit is cut by the original...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

Analysis of Wisconsin v Mitchell (1993) Case

...Case Brief: Wisconsin v Mitchell (1993) 113 S Ct 2194 Facts A white youth was made the target of an attack by black youths, on October 7, 1989. This attack was instigated by Todd Mitchell, a black youth. On the evening of this particular day, several black youth, including Mitchell, had gathered at an apartment in Wisconsin. These individuals discussed a scene from the motion picture ‘Mississippi Burning’, wherein a white man had beaten a black youth, while the latter was engaged in prayer[Wis93]. After their discussion, these black individuals emerged from the apartment and espied a white youth, walking on the opposite side of the street. Mitchell reminded the group about their discussion and...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay

Robin Hood Case

... they did not, then the King will get back to everyone and all these preparations would go in vain. References: 1) (2013, 04). Robin Hood* Case Study – Leadership. StudyMode.com. Retrieved 04, 2013, from http://www.studymode.com/essays/Robin-Hood-Case-Study-Leadership-1605324.html 2) (2005, 06). Swot Analysis. StudyMode.com. Retrieved 06, 2005, from http://www.studymode.com/essays/Swot-Analysis-61595.html... Robin was that, with increasing men in his band, it was becoming difficult for him to maintain the discipline. He was thinking of changing the way of his policies in order to maintain the order of his band. The best way to do it would be to stop confiscating the goods from the rich and rather imply a transit tax for each...
1 Pages(250 words)Case Study

She v. Her

...isn’t gay. Discussion In the video clip, two employees working in the same department, Cara who is gay hits on Alisha who isn’t gay. They are the same gender. This is illegal because Alisha is being forced to work in an offensive, intimidating, hostile, humiliating, and sexually offensive work environment. According to the law, same-sex sexual harassment is forbidden under state law in spite of the sexual orientation of the parties. In this scenario, Cara is hitting on Alisha and its making her comfortable. On one hand, the courts have to conclude that a victim need not say or do a particular thing to indicate unwelcomeness. But it’s kind of odd or unexpected because it is the same type of behavior that if it was...
1 Pages(250 words)Assignment

Robin Hood Case

...Robin Hood Case Study Analysis What are the goals and objectives of Robin Hood and his band? What is it that they are trying to accomplish? Robin Hood and his band objective is to pursue equality aggressively on behalf of the people of Sherwood. Fundamentally, the intention of the group is justice for all. This is their only goal and objective. 2) Create a basic organization chart for Robin Hood and The Merrymen. Write each person’s name and what they are responsible for doing. The current organizational structure for Robin Hood and his team of Merrymen is a functional structure where eachlieutenant is responsible for...
4 Pages(1000 words)Assignment

Robin hood case

...Best Option for Robin Hood Politically, it is the order of the day that if you have political support of those in power and the courts, then one becomes very powerful. Robin should therefore explore the option of gaining the confidence and support of the authorities and the political classes that can help him drive forth his agenda in a supportive and convincing manner. In this case, he will be able to fight the Sheriff using administrative means which might contribute a lot to his victory. Economically, Robin should seek for a strong economic support where he will be able to support his band both financially and in terms of food provision. As it is clear now, the band...
1 Pages(250 words)Case Study

Mckee v. Laurion Case Study Analysis

... Mckee v. Laurion Case Study Analysis Issue The issue in contention is whether Dennis Laurion comments in a website called rate your doctor was genuine in relation to Dr. Mckee comments about the defendant's father. When Dr Mckee goes to a private room to review Laurion's father following a discharge from Intensive Care Unit (ICU), he allegedly made three statements in the presence of the family members including Dennis Laurion. The first statement he allegedly made was that he said when he did not find the patient in ICU, he took time to find out whether he had been transferred on died. Secondly, he allegedly...
1 Pages(250 words)Case Study

FCC v. CBS Case Analysis

...to be an infrequent, fleeting expletive, in which case the FCC does not so much keep up the privilege to direct a periodic expletive. The legislature must show a convincing enthusiasm to manage sexually unequivocal material where minors are liable to view where through the slightest prohibitively implies accessibly. For this situation, there was a sexually unequivocal presentation amid the most recent few seconds of a live TV musical performance amid the CBS show of the Super Bowl. Despite the fact that the presentation itself is not an issue, the court here must figure out if such performance is viewed as a fleeting expletive such that a fine ought not to be maintained. During the year, 1978 case number...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Assignment on topic Case Analysis: Her Majesty The Queen v. John Robin Sharpe for FREE!

Contact Us